Business & Finance

Apartment Complex Proposed for GI Auto Site in Pine Brook

Jeffrey Otteau and John Inglesino Credits: Melissa Benno
Avalon Bay rendering Credits: Courtesy of The Architectural Team
Potential Avalon Bay site plan rendering Credits: Courtesy of Boswell Engineering
Potential Avalon Bay courtyard plan rendering Credits: Courtesy of The Architectural Team
Proposed site Credits: Courtesy of Morris County GIS Dat

MONTVILLE, NJ – The Montville Township Zoning Board of Adjustments has heard testimony at three public hearings regarding an application to build 349 non-age-restricted rental units on the former site of GI Auto Salvage in the Pine Brook section of town.

During the Dec. 7, 2016 meeting, attorney John Inglesino began testimony by stating Avalon Bay Communities, LLC, has purchased the property at 85 Bloomfield Avenue. The site was a junkyard for 50 years and has soil contamination, he said, according to the minutes of the meeting published by the township. Age-restricted housing is a permitted use for the site, but the applicant is proposing non-age restricted units, thus requiring the hearings. If the use variance is approved, Avalon Bay will file site plans in the future, meaning, no formal drawings of the proposed building and facilities exist. However, the company is proposing 36 studio apartments, 124 one-bedroom apartments, 156 two-bedroom apartments, and 33 three-bedroom apartments, according to the minutes from the Feb. 1, 2017 zoning board meeting. The rents would be approximately $1,600 for the studios, ranging to $3,000 for the three-bedroom, according to March 16 meeting testimony.

Avalon Bay’s professional engineer and civil engineer, Kevin Boswell, then provided a background on the site, stating that a Lowes Home Improvement store had been approved for the site in 2008, but Lowes had canceled the project. The site has been in the process of being cleaned up, and that clean-up is ongoing, according to the minutes. Parking of cars, then storage of wooden pallets and mats have been allowed on the site.

Sign Up for E-News

The proposed footprint of the project is “significantly smaller than the previously approved Lowes project,” Boswell testified, per the minutes. The area to be redeveloped for Lowes was 18 acres, whereas the current proposal is for 14 acres. The apartment building footprint is 143,000 square feet, whereas the Lowes building was proposed at 217,000. Avalon Bay’s professional engineer, Jeff Morris, testified that this would be a residential building wrapped around a four-story parking garage, according to the minutes. The site could be accessed from Bloomfield Avenue but with no exit back onto Bloomfield, whereas access from Route 46 would be both entrance and exit, making Route 46 the primary access.

Architect Ed Bradford also testified for Avalon Bay, stating that there would be residential wings with six landscaped courtyards, according to the board’s minutes. Originally a height variance was applied for, 52 feet where 48 are allowed, but this was later withdrawn. The building would be four stories.

“The primary goal is to achieve a design for the building that has a very strong residential scale,” Bradford is attributed as stating at the hearing. The building is proposed to include dormers and balconies, while the facilities include a pool, fitness center and club room comprising 7,500 square feet of amenities. There will be 353 spaces in the garage and 328 spaces around the site, Jeff Morris, Professional Engineer, testified for Avalon Bay. Inglesino stated that the company will meet the 20% affordable units requirement, according to the minutes.

At the Feb. 1, 2017 meeting, Scott Fishbone, Vice President of Avalon Bay Communities, testified that each garage is fully enclosed, with a separate garage door for each resident. Each apartment would have a full-sized washer and dryer and individual climate controls, the minutes attribute Fishbone as stating.

Traffic Engineer Gary Ascolese testified for Avalon Bay that he had reviewed the ingress and egress to the site, and found them to be “safe and efficient access,” according to the minutes from the meeting.

“Most uses permitted in the B-6 zone would have higher trip generations than this apartment proposal,” Ascolese is attributed as saying. “The network of streets can handle this project.”

However, when the board asked questions of the professionals, emergency vehicle access seemed to be an issue.

At the December meeting, Board Member Kurt Dinkelmeyer asked about emergency vehicle access and Inglesino replied, according to the minutes, that that would be handled at the site plan stage of the project, since at this time only use variance is being applied for. However, Board Attorney Bruce Ackerman stated that safety is a factor in the board’s determination. Board Professional Engineer Paul Ferriero stated his concerns that emergency vehicles would have to take a “long detour to access the site in case of an emergency,” according to the minutes. Inglesino replied that the proposed building “meets RSIS standards and are not required to improve a bridge that is owned by the county,” the minutes state. RSIS stands for Residential Site Improvement Standards and are statewide standards for improvements to residential developments.

“Safety is a legitimate concern for emergency services when you are arguing that the site is particularly suitable to [residential] use,” Ackerman replied, according to the minutes.

When Dinkelmeyer asked about emergency vehicle access later in the meeting, Inglesino replied “Avalon Bay will not restrict the route the emergency vehicles [use to] access the site,” and that they can access it in “any way they require,” according to the minutes.

“It is up to the emergency services to decide how to access the site,” Inglesino stated, per the minutes.

At the March 16, 2017 meeting, Jeffrey Otteau of The Otteau Group, testified regarding the economic viability of age-restricted housing, which is what the site is zoned for, among other uses. His company performed a demographic study of age-restricted vs. non-age-restricted housing in Montville and surrounding communities.

Otteau said that the state of New Jersey is “underperforming,” lacking in job creation, and has the highest rate of mortgage delinquencies and foreclosures. Home prices are 17% below their peak, he said, all of which have a significant impact on the real estate market. One such factor, he said, is that New Jersey has one of the highest migration rates in the country, meaning, many households are moving out of the state.

“In Montville, you’re experiencing an accelerated decline in the 45-54 years of age bracket, which is significant to age-restricted housing, because it is the target demographic,” Otteau said. “The banking community is not willing to finance age-restricted projects.”

Further, age-restricted apartments have lower rents, which are not economically viable to build, he said.

All-age, or non-age-restricted developments, have a booming rental market, Otteau said. The vacancy rate is low, and rents increase from year to year. These apartments would be “geared to higher income households, making at least $90,000,” he said.

With rents ranging from $1,600 to $3,000 for a three-bedroom, Otteau said, a family would be able to afford a $500,000 home, and would not be interested in an apartment, he said. He called the tenant community in similar Avalon Bay developments “overwhelmingly childless.”

“Families with children will opt out,” Otteau said.

When Chairman James Marinello asked about the effect on the school system, Otteau stated the “effect would approach zero.”

The apartments would typically be inhabited by higher income renters in their 30s or older-age empty nesters, according to Otteau. They would have “significant income to spend at local businesses” because they would have no lawns to mow or other maintenance issues to take their time, he said.

When the public portion of the hearing commenced, residents stated concerns with the impact on the school system. Otteau responded that the occupancy demographics of typical Avalon Bay communities are very different from apartment complexes such as Rachel Gardens, because Rachel Gardens is larger, and the rents are about $1,000 lower at Rachel Gardens.

Testimony on this proposal will continue at the May 3 Zoning Board meeting.


TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Be Interested In

Sign Up for E-News


Upcoming Events


Tue, March 20, 4:00 PM

Montville Township Public Library, Montville

Library Teen Lecture: Jimmy Wong, Actor/Musician

Arts & Entertainment


Tue, March 20, 7:30 PM

Montville Township Municipal Building , Montville

Montville Board of Education meeting



Wed, March 21, 8:30 AM

Montville Township Municipal Building, Montville

Economic Development Committee Meeting


A Letter of Appreciation for the Montville Township Police Department

March 9, 2018

I wanted to give a very special Thank You to all the men and women of the Montville Twp. Police force. Your efforts and determination to assist the public during these back to back storms was and continues to be nothing short of incredible.

Officers have worked countless hours running call to call or providing stationary protective details. You have spent countless hours away from your ...

Town Egg Hunt to be Held

March 19, 2018

MONTVILLE, NJ – The Montville Township Recreation Department announces its annual egg hunt, at the Montville Township Community Park on the artificial turf field, on Sunday, March 25 at 1:00 p.m.

This event is for preschool aged children through the third grade. There will be special eggs that contain a note for prizes. A petting zoo, face painter and balloon sculptor will be also ...

Montville Twp Library to Clear Out Books, Reference as Part of 3-Year Plan

March 16, 2018

MONTVILLE, NJ – The Montville Township Public Library Board of Trustees met with consultants Alan and Leslie Burger of Library Development Solutions March 5 to further develop the library’s three-year strategic plan, which has been in the works for about eight months.

Library administration had conducted a questionnaire and three focus groups with residents, and the board held a ...

Montville's Woodmont School Celebrates "Read Across America"

March 18, 2018

MONTVILLE, NJ – District administrators, dignitaries and moms gathered at Woodmont Elementary School March 1 for the 20th anniversary Read Across America event, during which the adults read books to the students and talked about their love of books, the importance of reading, and their occupations.

The National Education Association initiative centers around the birthday of beloved ...

Floating Classroom Will Help Roxbury Kids Embrace 'Their' Lake Hopatcong

March 17, 2018

ROXBURY, NJ – There are plenty of kids living in Roxbury who’ve never been on Lake Hopatcong, says lake buff Marty Kane. He’s even confident many don’t realize their town borders the big lake.

That’s one of the reasons Kane, chairman of the Lake Hopatcong Foundation Board of Trustees, is bubbling with excitement about the upcoming launch of the ...

New Jersey Athlete Leads 2018 U.S. Paralympic Sled Hockey Team to First Victory

March 13, 2018

PYEYONG CHANG, SOUTH KOREA - Josh Pauls, of Green Brook, is the team captain and defenseman on the U.S. National Sled Hockey Team competing in the 2018  Paralympic Winter Games in Pyeyong Chang. The  United States defeated Japan, 10 - 0 in the preliminary round on Saturday and faces the Czech Republic on Sunday at 11 p.m. ET (NBCSN, live ...

Town Egg Hunt to be Held

March 19, 2018

MONTVILLE, NJ – The Montville Township Recreation Department announces its annual egg hunt, at the Montville Township Community Park on the artificial turf field, on Sunday, March 25 at 1:00 p.m.

This event is for preschool aged children through the third grade. There will be special eggs that contain a note for prizes. A petting zoo, face painter and balloon sculptor will be also ...


Ten Ways to Be Productive on a Snow Day

March 7, 2018

Another Nor’Easter has smacked us in the face today.  After so many of us lost power for what seemed to be an eternity, it’s a good time to make up for lost productivity and work on the famous Stephen Covey Quadrant 2 Activities.  What are they you may ask?  Those are the activities that are Important, yet not urgent (well some of them can be).  In other ...

Century 21 Open Houses this Weekend

MONTVILLE, NJ - Following are Century 21 Open Houses this weekend: 

Saturday, March 17 from 1 - 4 p.m.

Brownstones at Fairfield, Stonybrook Circle (Using GPS - Enter 66 Two Bridges Road)

Sunday, March 18 from 1 - 4 p.m.

Brownstones at Fairfield, Stonybrook Circle (Using GPS - Enter 66 Two Bridges Road)
8 Summit Drive, Bld #10, North ...

Century 21 The Crossing Open Houses this Weekend

MONTVILLE, NJ - Following are Century 21 Open Houses this weekend:

Saturday, Feb. 24 from 1 - 4 p.m.

Brownstones at Fairfield, Stonybrook Circle (Using GPS - Enter 66 Two Bridges Road)

Sunday, Feb. 25 from 1 - 4 p.m. 

Brownstones at Fairfield, Stonybrook Circle (Using GPS - Enter 66 Two Bridges Road)
8 Summit Drive, Bld #10, North Caldwell



AtlantiCast: Episode 13

On this episode of AtlantiCast, new clinical studies in the fields of cardiology and immunotherapy, national and statewide recognitions for Atlantic Health System medical centers and the inaugural AtlantiCast Collab Challenge!


Overparenting: What Is It and Why Do We Do It?

Overparenting.  It’s the new buzzword for helicopter parenting, enabling and micromanaging.  I did them all. I’m happy to say that I’ve (mostly) grown out of it.  The truth is that there are still moments when I have the urge to step in and take over.  It’s normal to feel that way; however, I know I’ve made progress when I feel the urge and ...

Pet Corner