Government

Non Age-Restricted Apartments Denied for Pine Brook

Zoning Board Member Kurt Dinkelmeyer ©2017 TAPinto Montville Credits: Melissa Benno
Board of Ed Member Mike Palma asks questions of Ron Ladell, far left ©2017 TAPinto Montville Credits: Melissa Benno
Board of Ed Member David Modrak asks questions of Ron Ladell, front ©2017 TAPinto Montville Credits: Melissa Benno
Ron Ladell and John Inglesino for Avalon Bay, John Szabo and Paul Ferriero for Montville Twp ©2017 TAPinto Montville Credits: Melissa Benno
Zoning Board Chair James Marinello, Atty Bruce Ackerman, Board Member Kurt Dinkeolmeyer ©2017 TAPinto Montville Credits: Melissa Benno

MONTVILLE, NJ – The Montville Township Zoning Board of Adjustments voted unanimously to reject an application by Avalon Bay LLC to receive a variance to build 349 non age-restricted rental units in Pine Brook on what is commonly referred to as the GI Auto Salvage Yard.

Board Member Kurt Dinkelmeyer said witnesses and testimony had not indicated positive or negative criteria to warrant the variance. He also said that the 2010 Master Plan had indicated age-restricted use for the land.

“We have not heard evidence that this property is particularly suitable for this use and not for other uses,” Dinkelmeyer said.

Sign Up for E-News

He then introduced a motion to reject the application, which was seconded and voted on, resulting in the rejection.

The Township Committee had explored redevelopment designation for the land in 2014, because Avalon Bay had asked the township for permission to build 408 non age-restricted rental units and townhouses. The township contracted with Burgis Associates, but after Burgis said he was favorable to multi-family development for the land, the township did not pursue the redevelopment designation. It was a point of contention throughout the five hearings what the township’s lack of follow-up on the report meant. Attorney for Avalon Bay John Inglesino emphasized it did not mean rejection of the idea, whereas at the May 3 hearing, Professional Planner for the township John Szabo of Burgis Associates implied it had been.

Senior Vice President for Avalon Bay Ron Ladell testified that .084 school-age children would be generated by the 349 rental units, and since there is no site plan for the proposed development, there is no exact breakdown of the number of bedrooms per unit (one-bedroom vs. two). He said that Avalon Bay units typically charge a higher rent than a property such as Rachel Gardens even though Avalon Bay units are smaller, so comparing the two properties would not be appropriate.

Avalon Bay is an intervener in the affordable housing litigation that Montville Township is undergoing, explained in this article: affordable. Inglesino stressed in his closing argument that by granting the age restriction variance, Montville could apply the affordable housing units that would result from this development towards the allotment that would be required of the township.

Inglesino also said in his closing that site-plan issues would be worked out during the site plan phase of the application, and this phase of the application was merely to gain variance for the age restriction. He said that testimony had been given that there is no market for age-restricted housing. He again cited the Burgis report which was favorable toward the proposed 2014 non age-restricted Avalon Bay proposed development, and said no testimony from anyone, including Szabo has denied those findings, “nor has the governing body ‘rejected’ this proposal. Not acting is not a rejection.” He also said that Szabo sent a June 29, 2017 memo and “seemed to suggest” that approving the application would be “planning by variance,” meaning, surreptitiously changing the Master Plan. Inglesino called this “absolutely ridiculous.”

Public questions and testimony was negative toward the application and focused on traffic, strain on the school system, and fires that the Avalon Bay properties have experienced. Ladell said the fires mentioned were over a 17-year period. Inglesino stressed that making a decision based on fiscal implications to the school system is illegal.

To read about the May 3 hearing click May 3

To read about the March 16 hearing click March 16

TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Like

Sign Up for E-News

Montville

Upcoming Events

Carousel_image_e66b942483c30e7e9040_img_5972

Thu, August 24, 7:30 PM

Montville Township Municipal Building, Montville

Planning Board Meeting Cancelled

Government

Carousel_image_f8f6772bdd489612cba9_img_0283

Fri, September 1

Montville Senior House, Montville

Blood Drive

Giving Back

Carousel_image_8a05ed9e1458d6aa68ae_img_8465a

Tue, September 5, 7:45 PM

Municipal Building, Montville

Montville Township Board of Education Meeting

Education

Carousel_image_2f5e22fedbc0839027fd_township_logo

Tue, September 12, 8:00 PM

Municipal Building, Montville

Montville Township Committee Meeting

Government

Carousel_image_8a05ed9e1458d6aa68ae_img_8465a

Tue, September 19, 7:45 PM

Municipal Building, Montville

Montville Township Board of Education Meeting

Education

Montville Township Public Library to Hold Focus Groups

August 11, 2017

Dear Montville Library Patrons:

The library wants to hear from you!

The Board of Trustees and library staff are working with Library Development Solutions, a consulting firm, to develop new strategic and technology plans for the library. These plans will serve as blueprints for service enhancements and improvements for the next several years, and will set the course for our future. Our goal ...

Lazar Living Lessons Series: Eugenie Mukeshimana, Rwandan Survivor

August 12, 2017

MONTVILLE, NJ - When discussing the value of the Living Lessons presentations at Lazar Middle School this past spring, eighth grader Katie DeAngelis said it well, “When you are at an all-time low, there is always hope.”

And hope was the theme of many, if not all, of the 50 speakers who spoke at the event.

The Living Lessons program: Voices, Visions and Values ...

Four Police Officers Among 12 Carbon Monoxide Victims in Mount Olive

August 15, 2017

MOUNT OLIVE, NJ - Twelve people, including four police officers, were rushed to hospitals on Monday after becoming victims of carbon monoxide poisoning at a house in Flanders, according to a fire officials.

The incident took place at a house at 3 Fennimore Court, said Flanders Firefighter Doug Fenichel, a public relations specialist, in a statement. He said Roxbury firefighters were among a ...

Before Trump Broke Up Biz Council, Johnson & Johnson CEO Resigned

August 16, 2017

NEW BRUNSWICK, NJ — The head of Johnson & Johnson decided to step down from President Donald Trump's Manufacturing Council today, prior to its disbandment, according to the company.

Alex Gorsky, chairman and CEO of the New Brunswick-based Johnson & Johnson, announced his exit in a statement, following reports published yesterday, Aug. 15., which said he planned to remain ...

The Masterwork Chorus Announces Fall Auditions in Chatham

August 23, 2017

The Masterwork Chorus holds fall 2017 auditions by appointment on Wednesday evenings, September 13 and 20, at Chatham United Methodist Church (CUMC), 460 Main Street, Chatham.

Openings are available in all voice parts, but tenors and basses are especially encouraged to join.  Contact Don MacGowan at (973) 479-4020 or membership@masterwork.org. Other arrangements may be made if ...

Columns

Open Houses on Sunday by Century 21 The Crossing

MONTVILLE, NJ - Following are open houses by Century 21 The Crossing on Sunday, Aug. 13:

804 Route 202, Towaco from 1 - 4 p.m.
25 Hillcrest Road, Towaco from 1 - 4 p.m.
25 High Mountain Drive, Montville from 1 - 4 p.m.

 

Pet Corner