Letters to the Editor

Panel of Experts Say Charter Schools Adversely Impact Public Education

43c11ea7def534e7a034_IMG_0209.jpg
Credits: Cindy C. A. Pereira
92d188ac48013c86214b_IMG_0219.jpg
4346e4e2743d8becb632_IMG_0210.jpg
Credits: Cindy C. A. Pereira
2dca36c0c04c81adf3b7_IMG_0212.jpg
Credits: Cindy C. A. Pereira
b5040a53c522ea283728_IMG_0213.jpg
Credits: Cindy C. A. Pereira
7a67f4620b70101114f7_IMG_0214.jpg
Credits: Cindy C. A. Pereira
8c78fb9389c5f447ed69_IMG_0215.jpg
61f4c11a8d05ec139564_IMG_0216.jpg
Credits: Cindy C. A. Pereira
90b651173c824dc25d0d_IMG_0217.jpg
5ed0800eb1a38f5d35c7_IMG_0218.jpg
Credits: Cindy C. A. Pereira
ea7b49a124a9f177148b_IMG_0219.jpg
66732ff36716286b4869_IMG_0220.jpg
2eb200595a41ce8c4578_IMG_0221.jpg
Credits: Cindy C. A. Pereira
7e3673f38a2d57abcce6_IMG_0222.jpg
Credits: Cindy C. A. Pereira
d247ae8df6ca2303c629_IMG_2782.jpg
351aaa362d5da44e0bf8_IMG_0221.jpg
2c8ef725f48788dad227_IMG_2786.jpg
Credits: Cindy C. A. Pereira
f00353b4788dfe6821f5_IMG_0223.jpg
43c11ea7def534e7a034_IMG_0209.jpg

MONTCLAIR, NJ - What impact does charter school education have on public school districts? A panel of experts gathered in Montclair on Saturday to discuss.

Moderated by Michelle Fine, co-author of “Charter Schools and the Corporate Makeover of Public Education,” the panel of experts included Darcie Cimarusti, President, Highland Park BOE; Liz Mulholland, also known as blogger “Mother Crusader “; Sharon Smith, former Special Education teacher and advocate, Parents Unified for Local School Education (PULSE); and Mark Weber, Teacher, Researcher, blogger known as “Jersey Jazzman,” joined to discuss the impact charter schools have on public education.

Among the large number of attendees were Montclair Mayor Robert Jackson, Councilman Sean Spiller, Gayle Shepard, president of the Montclair Education Association, Anne Mernin who is VP of the Montclair Board of Education, former Montclair school board member David Cummings, Al Pelham of the Montclair NAACP, Newark native actor John Amos, and education activist and Paterson teacher Stan Karp.

Sign Up for E-News

Citizens representing Roxbury, Montclair, Bloomfield, Newark, Clifton, Maplewood, South Orange, Morristown, and more, joined on a beautiful May afternoon to sit indoors and attend the presentation.

In a nutshell, most of the viewpoints expressed pointed toward charter schools being not only detrimental to the public school system, but also not serving of the children in most need, as well as a resource drain and a promoter of segregation. Many of the allegations were backed by research presented in a slide presentation by Mark Weber.

Some background was given on how charters began with the intent to promote education for families whose needs were not being served, and initially involved parents and teachers. However, what may have started as a social justice issue eventually got taken over by what panelists coined as 'corporate mandates', making this a for-profit endeavor that they felt does not necessarily serve the public needs.

Cimarusti started by pointing out how Arne Duncan, who was U.S. Secretary of Education from 2009-2016, provided grants and how Chris Christie has played a significant role in moving his charter agenda forward, as evidenced in his State of the State speech. One of Cimarusti’s strong suggestions was to persist in demanding transparency.

She said, “Go back to Senator Nia Gill” referring to Sen. Nia Gill (D-Essex) who filed the request under the Open Public Records Act (OPRA). Cimarusti said often times the state department is deciding approval or denial of charter applications without community involvement. She also warned that neighboring districts can be impacted and should be included in conversations since many times a charter will reach out to families form neighboring towns, further drawing on resources without offering a reciprocal benefit.

Weber provided slides that painted a not so favorable accountability picture of the charter scenario. His research depicted how special needs students can fall into 12 categories that correspond to needed levels of care. Charters tend to take students with a lower cost special need, and leave ones with higher cost needs to the district. However, they receive the same amount of money for a special need student.

He demonstrated through numbers that certain charters “take more white students…fewer special education students…” and when he showed a linear regression adjusting for student characteristics, the data suggested that the charter schools, on many occasions were still not providing higher educational outcomes.

He suggested the communities ask themselves, “What are you getting for the price?” In many examples presented, it seemed there was actually no justification for having a charter school. One such example was Red Bank, NJ.

In recent weeks in Montclair, after NJ Commisioner of Education David Hespe approved an application for a charter school last month, the decision was met with rebuke from Interim Schools Superintendent Ronald Bolandi and the Montclair Board of Education. In addition, parents who have expressed their dissatisfaction with the decision for a charter school to open in Montclair have been encouraged to write letters the Hespe.

Liz Mulholland likewise painted a very grim picture of how the charters affected schools in Hoboken. She specifically referenced HoLa (The Hoboken Dual Language Charter School). She stated some comparative 2010 demographics such as their 11% free lunch, and 0.05% special education at the charter, versus 69% free lunch and 17% special education for the public system.

She quoted the superintendent’s letter that said, “It’s hard to believe 40 years after a civil rights movement, I would be writing about the need to integrate the public schools. The charter school populations do not reflect the overall diversity and immediate intervention is needed from the NJTO.”

Finally, Sharon Smith President of Parents United spoke of the Newark experience. She referenced how Newark schools squandered Mark Zuckerberg's $100 million donation. She spoke of Newark’s large African American and Latino community and said the government allowed a "destructive policy" into the city as a test to use the prototype in Newark to implement in other cities.

She said, “Most of the money (Zuckerberg’s) went to the charter schools and a small percentage went to the public school but only for innovative work, which was code for TFA teachers and other things like that. Some of the money went toward the teacher’s union.”

Smith told the audience that after the first charter schools were announced, a complaint was filed with the office of civil rights.

According to Smith, high needs students were collocated and ultimately homeless children couldn’t find a way to get to schools at remote locations. It was suggested the parents carpool, which showed a complete disconnect from the community, who did not have cars. Smith referenced white privilege, discriminatory practices, and said a second complaint was filed also with the Justice Department.

In Smith’s opinion the One Newark plan was destroying the community because special needs students were not receiving needed services, the academic transition from one school to another was not working well not only on transportation but she added that this was happening also on many other levels.

Tap into Montclair spoke to an audience member named Jennifer who said she attends many related events. As a teacher in Jersey City she said, “We see a lot of nonsense going on. Kids are losing out in the public schools. Problems aren’t being addressed. The public is made to feel we need a new school.” 

When asked if charter schools could help improve instruction and close the education gap she commented, “The thing with the charter schools is they weed out kids, and basically only take ones who test in.”

The opinions expressed herein are the writer's alone, and do not reflect the opinions of TAPinto.net or anyone who works for TAPinto.net. TAPinto.net is not responsible for the accuracy of any of the information supplied by the writer. Click here to submit a Letter to the Editor.

TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Be Interested In

Sign Up for E-News

Morristown

AtlantiCast

AtlantiCast: Episode 15

On this week’s AtlantiCast, learn some important tips for controlling and avoiding diabetes from an Atlantic Health System expert, see how Atlantic Health is advancing cutting-edge research, hear what’s being done to keep health care environmentally friendly and much more!

 

Reserve Your Spot: Morris County Historical Tours Begin This Summer

May 16, 2018

MORRISTOWN, NJ - Community members are invited to “Discover Morris County” through the summer walking tour and lecture series  The Morris County Tourism Bureau invites everyone to experience the rich history that Morris County has to offer with a knowledgeable guide. Summer programs will be held over nine successive Saturday mornings during June, July and August.  ...

National Public Gardens Day at Morristown's Macculloch Hall; Sat. May 12

MORRISTOWN, NJ - Macculloch Hall is inviting the community to National Public Gardens Day on Saturday May 12 from 10am - 1pm.

Visitors can enjoy the gardens as well as family activities, presentations, art, scavenger hunts, and stories. The event is free and open to the public.

Inquiries can be directed to Cynthia Winslow at cwinslow@maccullochhall.org

 

 

Morristown Welcomes Sandy Hook Ride on Washington

Team 26 will ride from Newtown, CT to Washington D.C. to raise awareness of gun violence, stopping in Morristown for a welcome rally

MORRISTOWN -- A 400-mile bicycle ride that will begin in Newtown, CT and will continue toward the steps of the U.S. Capitol will arrive to a welcome rally in front of Morristown’s Town Hall on Saturday, May 5 at 5 p.m. The ride is being conducted by Team ...

Butterfly Bonanza Flies to Pyramid Mountain; June 9

May 21, 2018

MORRISTOWN, NJ. On Saturday, June 9, from 12 noon to 4 p.m., celebrate the beauty and importance of New Jersey’s butterflies and other pollinators at the annual Butterfly Bonanza at Pyramid Mountain Natural Historic Area in Montville Township.

Butterfly Bonanza is packed with excitement, entertainment, and education for all ages. Enjoy a guided ‘Bug Safari’ tour of ...

4 Day Sale at The Depot

4 Day Sale going on now through Sunday at The Depot Gift & Home. The more you spend, the more you save!

980 Mt Kemble Avenue (Rt 202)

Morristown NJ 07960

The Civil War Invades Historic Speedwell in Morristown

MORRISTOWN, NJ - Cannons, muskets and bayonets! See and hear all these and more at the Civil War Weekend, Saturday June 9 and Sunday June 10 at Historic Speedwell in Morristown.

Visitors will be able to visit the battlefields of the American Civil War during this two day event. The weekend showcases the daily lives of soldiers. Visitors will witness musket, artillery, and bayonet drills as ...

Superheros to the Rescue! Over 900 Runners Run the 2018 Superhero Half Marathon

May 21, 2018

MORRIS TOWNSHIP, NJ -  Who is the strongest superhero? There has been some debate on the internet as to who the strongest superheros are. According to CBR.com, it is Sentry (3rd),  Thor (2nd) and The Hulk (1st) who top their list. However, it might just be the 900 runners that were strong enough to participate in the 2018 Superhero Half Marathon on Sunday May 20 at Ginty Field in ...

10-Year Old Boy Battling Cancer Receives Generous Donation From Randolph Hockey Family

RANDOLPH, NJ- While the inter-town hockey battles on the ice between Randolph and Roxbury are fierce at every age level, when it comes to real life battles off the ice there is no hesitation to offer help to their neighbor.

Such is the case with a recent gesture of unity and support from the Randolph Varsity hockey team, when they came together to deliver good wishes and ...

Peter Toth to Perform a Free Piano Recital at the Morristown Historical Park; Sunday May 20

MORRISTOWN, NJ - The community is invited to Washington's Headquarters Museum on Sunday May 20 to enjoy a piano recital featuring Hungarian pianist Peter Toth.

The free piano recital will take place at 1pm at the national Historical Park's Washington Headquarters Museum; 30 Washington Place.

Toth will play the park's 1873 Steinway Grand piano that will ...

The Kootz at Macculloch Hall Historical Museum

May 15, 2018

MORRISTOWN, NJ - Stop by the Macculloch Hall Historical Museum to hear The Kootz perform a medley of blues, pop, and rock from the 60s-90s on July 1 from 2-3pm.

Break out the picnic blanket or beach chairs and join us in our historic garden Sundays at 2:00 pm for a selection of music and poetry.

$10 per adult, FREE for members!

Rain or shine. In the case of inclement ...

Three Bloomfield Teens Are Missing, Police Seek Community Assistance to Locate Them

BLOOMFIELD, NJ - The Bloomfield Police Department is asking for the public's assistance to locate three teenagers who went missing this week. One of the parents reports that a large sum of money is missing suggesting the three may have fled the state. 

16-year-old Ulises Yance and 15-year-old Alex Lopez were last seen Fridaymornin, and 16-year-old Alexa Arenas was last seen ...

In London Town - NJFO Season Finale

On Saturday May 19 and Sunday May 20, the New Jersey Festival Orchestra, under the baton of David Wroe, presents a magnificent 35th anniversary season finale celebration of music linked in some way to England and its great city of London.

The concert opens with Sir Edward Elgar’s exhilarating Introduction and Allegro for Strings, a work composed in 1905 to enable the string section ...

Parents of Dangled Roxbury Kid File Lawsuit Warning

May 20, 2018

ROXBURY, NJ - The parents of a 6-year-old special needs student who, according to authorities, was hung upside down and shaken by a frustrated teacher's aide in March, filed a notice of tort claim today, the first volley of a forthcoming lawsuit.

The notice says the Landing couple intend to sue the aide, the Roxbury school board, a number of school  administrators and ...

Bayonne Bridge New York-Bound Lanes to Close Monday Night

May 21, 2018

BAYONNE, NJ – Emergency construction work on the Bayonne Bridge will force the closing of all New York-bound lanes on Monday night.

Lanes on the bridge will close at 9 p.m. on Monday and remain vacant until 5 a.m. Tuesday, the Port Authority of New York and New Jersey said in a statement.

According to the press release, emergency work is needed to repair drainage grate on the ...

Living longer is in your control

Research published this week in the journal Circulation, reported findings of a 34 year study on over 100,000 people found five modifiable lifestyle     
 behaviors associated with a 14 year longer life expectancy in women and a 12 year long life expectancy in men at age 50. The health behaviors related to longer life included never smoking, eating a healthy diet, ...

Find Your Dream Home During Our DOUBLE Open House Weekend!

The forecast for this weekend is rain, rain, and more rain---so why not spend your time touring your new home?  Team Nest Builder offers 2 wonderful Open Houses this weekend, PLUS a new listing for you to check out via video tour!

27 Hilltop Trail, Sparta

Step into your own fairytale with this Lake Mohawk, storybook-sweet 3-bedroom, 1.5-bathroom gem! Gather in front of the rustic ...

The Great Alone by Kristin Hannah (St. Martin's Press, 2018)

            What is the “final frontier” on the Earth's surface? Many people would say Alaska, the 49th state, which was added to the United States fifty years ago. Once one has traveled to that remote land, it is impossible to forget the magnificence of the terrain and beasts. Floating by ship in Glacier Bay, surrounded by ...

'Turning Off the Morning News' brings comic twist

‘Turning Off the Morning News’ tackles today’s issues with a comic twist

By Liz Keill

PRINCETON, N J – Despite the late night comics, no one quite captures the insanity of the political/social status world like Christopher Durang.

His latest play, “Turning off the Morning News” hit the ground running.  John Pankow as Jimmy addresses the audience, ...

SURVIVING A STROKE: Quick Medical Response Gives Mom Her Life Back

Carotid artery dissection. It’s one of the most common causes of stroke in younger adults.

And while you might not associate the word “stroke” with younger patients, the condition – if not treated immediately – could lead to paralysis and even death.

Lindsey Singh can attest to the importance of immediacy. The 31-year-old mother of two from Flanders experienced ...

Letter to the Editor: Gum Litter and what YOU can do about it

May 14, 2018

Gum is non-biodegradable, meaning it doesn't’t break down ever….

Today, the unlikely problem surfaces. The average person chews 275 sticks of gum per year. With the amount of people in daily society, it’s no mystery why chewing gum is the second most littered item after cigarette butts.  Did you know that gum is banned in Singapore?

In addition to littering human ...

Guest Column: May is Skin Cancer Awareness Month

May 9, 2018

With warmer weather and sunny skies on the horizon, it is important to remember that skin cancer is the most common form of cancer in the United States. Skin cancer can greatly affect quality of life, and it can be disfiguring and even deadly. There are approximately 5.4 million cases of skin cancer diagnosed annually. Luckily, Skin Cancer Awareness Month provides a great time  to educate ...

Congressional Candidate Tony Ghee Candidate Statement

May 20, 2018

With the retirement of longtime Congressman Rodney Frelinghuysen, the good people of Morris, Essex, Sussex and Passaic Counties will elect a new representative this November. It also means that our Republican Party has a choice to make, as well.

Do we nominate a career politician in an age when most people don’t trust their government or the people serving, or do we seize this ...

Choose Brian Bergen for Assembly

My name is Brian Bergen. I am a West Point graduate, former Army Officer, combat Veteran, dedicated family man, small business owner and active community volunteer.

I am extremely excited for the opportunity to launch a campaign for NJ State Assembly in LD25. I have been humbled by the outpouring of support I have received thus far. My goal is to unite the party behind me in June 2019 and lead ...

Warrants, DWI and Narcotics Top This Week Police Blotter

May 14, 2018

4/23: ARREST FOR NARCOTICS: Officers were dispatched to the Mahlon Dickerson Reservation in Jefferson Township on a report of a noise complaint. An investigation led to Rebecca L. Schank-Smith, age 22, of Bloomingdale, and Delia A. Gutierrez, age 23, of Lincoln Park, to be charged with Possession of a Controlled Dangerous Substance. They were both released with a court date pending.

4/23: ...

GFWC Woman's Club Denvilee Rockaway Area Places Flags on Veterans' Graves

May 20, 2018

GFWC Woman's Club of Denville-Rockaway Area Helps Honor Veteran's with Flags for Memorial Day

On a very rainy Saturday, May 19, fifteen members of the GFWC Woman's Club of Denville- Rockaway Area, along with local Cub Scouts, citizens, and Veterans helped Phyllis and Jim Vialard, board members of the Memorial Association of Rockaway, Marcella, and Denville, place flags on ...