Law & Justice

Jury Still Weighing Whether New Brunswick Man Killed College Student

Timothy Puskas enters the courtroom on Friday, Jan. 6.

NEW BRUNSWICK, NJ — The jury in the murder trial of Timothy Puskas, who is accused of killing college student Billy McCaw almost three years ago, is now in its fifth day of deliberations.

It’s unclear if the jury will render a verdict today, or if a decision will come next week.

McCaw was found beaten to death on the morning of Feb. 15, 2014, in a snow-covered backyard off Hartwell Street in New Brunswick. The slaying of the 22-year-old former Rutgers student shocked the university community and ignited a month-long police investigation that resulted in murder and weapons charges against Puskas.

Sign Up for E-News

Puskas, who has pleaded not guilty, lived on nearby Plum Street at the time of the murder. The defense has claimed his roommates set him up because they feared he would inform the police of a burglary ring with which they were involved.

The prosecution, on the other hand, has claimed Puskas bludgeoned McCaw to death in a fit of rage, following a divorce and thefts from his bank account.

So far, the trial has spanned seven days of jury selection, 29 days of testimony and five days of jury deliberations, Middlesex County Assistant Prosecutor Bina Desai said this morning in court.

Both sides delivered their arguments in mid-November. Since then, dozens of witnesses have taken the stand.

State Superior Court Judge Dennis Nieves, who presides over the case, has expressed concern for the lengthy nature of the trial. Last Friday, for instance, jurors were still listening to closing arguments after 5 p.m.

McCaw’s family, some of whom live in Tennessee, have stayed in New Jersey, making their presence known in the courtroom throughout the trial.

Jurors today listened intently today as the court replayed testimony from a city cop and the recording of a phone call between Puskas and a friend. Some jurors leaned forward, squinting their eyes as if deeply concentrating, as they re-watched security camera footage that the prosecution claimed shows McCaw’s movements shortly before his death.

Both the prosecution and the defense have described the camera footage and the phone call as major pieces of evidence in the case.

Attorney Joseph Mazraani, who represents Puskas, said earlier today that he believed some jurors have grown frustrated.

Puskas is currently serving time after pleading guilty in 2015 to vehicular homicide after hitting a man on a bicycle in 2012 and leaving the scene.

TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Be Interested In

Sign Up for E-News

New Brunswick

The Jaffe Briefing - May 23, 2018

The Jaffe Briefing will not publish from Thursday through Monday. A great Memorial Day to all!


SEASIDE HEIGHTS - Sex can be an almost-religious experience, but it seems a bit excessive to copulate under a statue of the Virgin Mary in a Catholic church's outdoor prayer garden. Yet, that's where ...

The Jaffe Briefing - May 22, 2018

The Jaffe Briefing will not publish from Thursday through Monday. A great Memorial Day to all!

MANVILLE - If marijuana becomes legal in New Jersey, here's another town where you won't be able to buy it: Manville. The mayor and council unanimously voted to prohibit any sale of weed - recreational and medicinal - within Manville's borders. The ...

The Jaffe Briefing - May 21, 2018

The Jaffe Briefing will not publish from Thursday through Monday. A great Memorial Day to all!

STATEWIDE - Should public school students be allowed to attend schools in other towns? That's the big, controversial question in a lawsuit filed against the state that looks to end what some consider to be the worst school segregation in the nation. The ...

The Jaffe Briefing - May 18, 2018


IN COURT - Sounds like a cheesy thing to do, but the NJ Turnpike Authority has gone to court for years trying to stop a pizzeria chain whose logo is suspiciously similar to our beloved Garden State Parkway sign. Sure, nobody wants drivers searching for an on-ramp to end ...

The Jaffe Briefing - May 17, 2018


MOUNTAINSIDE - Oh, where to begin describing this 46-page lawsuit against two Mountainside cops? A detective sergeant placing his testicles on co-workers' food. And throwing poop-smeared toilet tissue at them. And defecating in someone's boots. And taunting with a dildo dubbed "Big Blue" he liked to wave in cops' faces, as he chased ...

The Jaffe Briefing - May 16, 2018


ATLANTIC CITY - Happy days are here again, as the state's once gasping gaming resort is expecting sports betting will rake in $150 million to $175 million a year in new, glorious profits - courtesy of your pals on the U.S. Supreme Court. Moreover, ecstatic Stockton University officials believe, this recharged gambling mecca will bring in a whole new ...

Rutgers Athletics Signs Dyehard Fan Supply to New Multi-Year Agreement

May 21, 2018

NEW BRUNSWICK, NJ -  Rutgers Athletics has selected Dyehard Fan Supply, an event and retail merchandise marketing and e-commerce company, as the official merchandising partner for the Scarlet Knights in a new multi-year agreement.Dyehard will handle game day and event merchandising for Rutgers Athletics.

“We’re excited to expand gameday merchandising options and elevate ...

Newark man given 22-year sentence for kidnapping, sexual asault of Rutgers student

NEW BRUNSWICK, NJ - A Newark man was sentenced Friday to 22 years in prison for the 2016 kidnapping and sexual assault of a Rutgers University student on the school campus in New Brunswick.

Michael Knight, 40, of Newark must serve at least 85 percent of his sentence before he is eligible for parole, Middlesex County Prosecutor Andrew Carey said in a statement today.

Superior Court Judge ...

Rutgers center battles noise pollution nationwide

NEW BRUNSWICK, NJ  - Eric Zwerling got a call this week from a man was living next to a fitness center, complaining he repeatedly heard the loud thud heavy free weights and medicine balls hit the floor.

The man was recovering from having a pace maker in his chest and wondering of the impact of the noise from the gym.

“I’ve received thousands of calls,” said Zwerling, ...

Police Investigate Rabbit "Tale"

May 11, 2018

SOUTH PLAINFIELD, NJ – Local cops are investigating an incident of ‘theft by deception’ involving the Plainfield Animal Hospital. 

According to the incident report filed by Officer Justin Melanson and obtained by TAPinto, residents of South Plainfield took their pet rabbit to the Park Avenue animal hospital on April 4 to be euthanized due to advanced ...


Here's How to Help Protect Young Athletes from Injury: Let Them Play Multiple Sports

May 1, 2018

Dear TAPInto New Brunswick:

One of the responsibilities that parents take most seriously is protecting their children from injury, whether it is buckling seat belts in a car or wearing a helmet while riding a bike. And when their kids become teenagers and want to participate in sports or other activities, parents do everything they can to keep their sons and daughters from getting ...

"Itʼs Time for New Leadership" Say Middlesex County Republicans

May 22, 2018

MIDDLESEX COUNTY, NJ  - On Tuesday, June 12th, elected county committee members of the Middlesex County Republican Organization will have a choice on who will be their next County Chair and party executive board.

Sharon D. Hubberman, former Middlesex County Freeholder Candidate, and current Perth Amboy Republican Chair has announced she will accept her nomination for the ...