Rutgers University

Men Heard More this Presidential Election, RU Says

NEW BRUNSWICK, NJ - Since women make up more than half of the population, comprise 53 percent of the electorate, and for the first time in history a woman is at the top of a major political party’s presidential ticket, you might think that the female political perspective would be a large part of this season’s nonstop cable news coverage.

But you’d be wrong. Men outnumber women significantly in cable news political punditry, according to research being conducted by The Eagleton Institute’s Center for American Women in Politics at Rutgers. The center is working with Gender Avenger, an advocacy website that encourages people to identify areas where women have been left out.

“At this point, there is no excuse for not including women, but it’s happening,” said CAWP Director Debbie Walsh. ”We have heard this too many times. They want women but they just can’t find them.  It doesn’t hold up.”

Sign Up for E-News

CAWP is leading Gender Avenger’s “Who Talks?” research initiative and providing a weekly tally and analysis of the gender balance on the top-rated morning and nightly cable news shows – Morning Joe (MSNBC), Fox and Friends (FOX), New Day (CNN), Rachel Maddow (MSNBC), The Kelly File (FOX) and Anderson Cooper 360 (CNN). Gender Avenger’s other partner on the project is the Women’s Media Center, a non-profit progressive women's media organization founded by well-known feminists including Jane Fonda and Gloria Steinem.

The Rutgers CAWP research study began in March and will continue until a week after the presidential election on Tuesday, November 8.  After that, the information will be analyzed to determine how often the bookers, producers and hosts on cable news shows are seeking the female perspective.

Overall, it doesn’t look too promising, according to CAWP’s research. While Anderson Cooper on CNN and Rachel Maddow on MSNBC have broken the 50 percent mark when it comes to featuring female pundits, the rest are well below with FOX News Network’s The Kelly File and Fox and Friends scoring the lowest with only 15 percent of women panelists for The Kelly File and 19 percent for Fox and Friends.

“Many people watch the news without focusing on who is providing the analysis,” said Walsh.  “But when they are confronted with the numbers I think they will realize that there is a serious disparity and hopefully will take action.”

Chelsea Hill, a research assistant at CAWP, spends six hours each day tracking the gender of the political pundits on these cable news shows by tuning in, listening to podcasts or reading transcripts.

“With all this information, I’d be really good at a cocktail party or really bad, depending on your perspective,” said Hill, a 26-year-old millennial who took on the job after receiving her graduate degree in women and gender studies from the Graduate School at Rutgers-New Brunswick.

In collecting the data, Hill does not look at the content of what the men and women on the panels are saying but rather at how many women are actually included on the panels, in how many segments and for how long.  Researchers are only interested in segments that revolve around the presidential election. Anything else being discussed gets fast forwarded, Hill said.

Gina Glantz, co-founder of Gender Avenger and campaign manager for former Sen. Bill Bradley’s presidential run in 2000, wants to bring attention to the times when women are excluded or underrepresented. And not just on cable television.

Her mission to create an online advocacy organization was spawned in 2012 when Harvard University Kennedy School’s post-election forum featured all white men. “It was a stunning omission especially four years after Americans elected the first black president and four years after Hillary Clinton spoke about making cracks in the glass ceiling,” Glantz said.

Gender Avenger has launched efforts to expose gender imbalance including at conferences, in “top” lists and at cultural events. When Esquire magazine’s list of “The 80 Books Every Man Should Read,” included only one female author, the community responded through social media and the publication responded by publishing a balanced list of “Books Everyone Should Read”.

Before the 2016 primary season Glantz noticed that more often than not it was all male panels discussing issues affecting women. “They were dismissive of Trump’s misogynistic comments and consumed with whether Hillary Clinton did enough smiling,” Glantz said.  “I knew in order to change the make-up of analysts – and the conversations on cable – I needed facts, not just impressions.”

"This is why Gender Avenger thought it was so important to partner with CAWP to get real data from scientific research that could be taken to the networks, she said. “Whether it is Trump or Clinton, this presidency and his or her administration need to be seen through the eyes of women who represent 50 percent of the population and, as important, 53 percent of the electorate.”

TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Be Interested In

Sign Up for E-News

New Brunswick

The Jaffe Briefing - November 17, 2017

** The Jaffe Briefing is over the river and through the woods for Thanksgiving, returning Monday, November 27 ** 

OUR TAKE ON THE NEWS IN NEW JERSEY

WASHINGTON, DC - Rep. Tom MacArthur has the distinction of being the only member of New Jersey's congressional delegation to support $1.5 trillion in tax cuts for businesses and individuals.  MacArthur was also ...

Upcoming Events

Carousel_image_7759d7c64e060bcdb430_kidscritters

Fri, December 1, 11:00 AM

New Jersey Audubon - Plainsboro Preserve, Plainsboro

Kids and Critters Preschool Program

Green Health & Wellness Home & Garden

Carousel_image_004bcde9c7ad5b932818_kidscritters

Fri, December 1, 11:00 AM

New Jersey Audubon - Plainsboro Preserve, Plainsboro

Kids and Critters Preschool Program

Green Health & Wellness Home & Garden

Carousel_image_ea6fbb85d79ad9a094b8_kidscritters

Fri, December 1, 11:00 AM

New Jersey Audubon - Plainsboro Preserve, Plainsboro

Kids and Critters Preschool Program

Green Health & Wellness Home & Garden

Rutgers Leaders to Join Governor-Elect Murphy’s Transition2018 Team

November 22, 2017

More than 20 leaders at Rutgers University, including Rutgers University–New Brunswick Chancellor Deba Dutta, will join Governor-elect Philip D. Murphy’s Transition2018 committees to undertake policy analysis and recommendations on a host of state issues and new initiatives as the new gubernatorial administration prepares to take office.

The committees, comprised of policy experts ...

Grad students pushing for university response on Congress tax bill

NEW BRUNSWICK, NJ - Rutgers ​University ​graduate students are pushing the university president for assurance that he’d advocate for them against a potential tax-hike by Congress, which ​many argue ​could hit graduate students particularly hard.

The House of Representatives plan, which passed last week, would turn the tuition remission for graduate and teaching assistants into a ...

Rutgers president addresses controversial bias incidents, says they're protected by ​First ​Amendment

NEW BRUNSWICK, NJ - Rutgers President Robert Barchi stood by his affirmation ​of​ the First Amendment, saying those ​protections ​extend to ​the recent rash of ​anti-Semitism on campus.

At the November 16 student government town hall, Barchi​ noted the protections to incidents such as the anti-Semitic posts allegedly shared on the Facebook of a food science professor, the ...

South Brunswick: Phone Syncing Leads To Car Thieves Arrest (WITH VIDEO)

November 14, 2017

SOUTH BRUNSWICK, NJ – Syncing your phone to a stolen car will likely lead police straight to your doorstep.

That’s the lesson learned by three Somerset County juveniles this week.

Police charged the three with theft, receiving stolen property and eluding a police officer after they led police on a brief chase Nov. 6.

According to police, the incident started at 5:30 p.m. when ...

OPINION

Middlesex County Democratic Chairman Kevin McCabe Endorses Senator Menendez for Re-election

November 18, 2017

METUCHEN, NJ – Middlesex County Democratic Chairman Kevin McCabe endorsed Senator Bob Menendez for re-election, citing the senator’s longtime commitment to fighting on behalf of New Jersey’s families in Washington.

            “Senator Menendez has dedicated his career to working for the interests of ...

Four Rutgers Professors Named Fellows of AAAS

November 22, 2017

NEW BRUNSWICK, NJ - Four Rutgers University professors have been named fellows of the American Association for the Advancement of Science (AAAS), an honor bestowed by their peers for scientifically or socially distinguished efforts to advance human knowledge.

The honorees, representing Rutgers University–New Brunswick and Rutgers Biomedical and Health ...

Column - Ramen Nagomi Part II: Tim, Sabastian, and Our Interview Continued

November 6, 2017

Note: This is a column by food writer Devin Healey. Manager Tim Wong and Chef Owner Sabastian Karyadi were so gracious with their time and in-depth with their responses that this story on New Brunswick’s favorite noodle shop will run in two parts. This is part two, but you can find part one here.

I recently took some time to get to know Ramen Nagomi’s General Manager Tim Wong and ...