Football: Goodstein Resigns as New Providence Head Coach


NEW PROVIDENCE, NJ – First-year varsity football head coach Mitch Goodstein submitted his letter of resignation last Thursday to superintendent Dave Miceli.

According to an email sent to several football families that included the resignation letter, Goodstein cited his “diminished authority" as head football coach for his main reason to resign.

“The district has the right to hire and fire who they wish and that is their prerogative,” Goodstein said. “I also have the right to express my feelings to the administration and not stand for being micro managed. With the above statement being said, I resign effective immediately as head football coach of the New Providence Pioneers."  

Sign Up for E-News

At the center of Goodstein’s resignation is his inability to hire certain assistant coaches to his staff. According to a New Providence football parent, assistant coaches Bob Romeo and Mike Kuchar were not returning to their positions next year, leaving two openings on the 2017 coaching staff.

The source said Goodstein attempted to fill the two open positions with coaches from outside the district, but those hirings were met with criticism from district administrators because “he did not go through the proper channels of Board hiring procedures.”

Goodstein said in his resignation letter that he should have the authority to hire coaches that “benefit the greater well-being of the program.”

“These men were not in a position to take over the program, just to add input and expertise when needed,” Goodstein said of the potential new assistants. “I am the one that asked these men to come on staff and it was my decision to do so. I need not worry what the perception is on the outside, my only concerned is what their abilities are as coaches. Regardless of their age.”

Goodstein also accuses the district’s administration of forcing certain personnel decisions on him, while also keeping other district employees “on pins and needles and have them fear that if they question authority, they will be terminated.”

Goodstein said he felt “second guessed” by members of the district’s administration, despite his long-standing relationship with the program as a fan, player and coach dating back to the 1970s.

“I have seen all the ups and downs of the program and I currently see where it is headed,” Goodstein said. “There is no one more dedicated and has a passion for New Providence football than myself. I took this position to lead and revive this program because I did not like the direction that is was going. I did what I thought was best for the program.”

New Providence athletic director Rocco Constantino offered no comment on Goodstein’s resignation when reached through a text message on Monday night.

Messages sent to Goodstein’s district email account were returned with a “failure to deliver” message.

Goodstein was hired last February in replace of former head coach Joe Carollo who parted ways with the department in January 2016. The Pioneers went 1-9 in Goodstein’s only year as head coach, missing the state tournament for the first time since Frank Bottone was the head coach.

According to several sources, the search for New Providence’s fifth varsity football coach in program history has already started, with an internal job posting to current members of the district staff. Former head coach and current assistant Art Cattano has been named the interim head coach. Cattano will oversee player registrations for this season until a permanent coach has been hired.

Check back in with TAPinto New Providence for more information on this story throughout the coming weeks.

TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Be Interested In

Sign Up for E-News

New Providence

Berkeley Heights PAL Runners Take Titles and Record At USATF Jr. Olympics T&F State Championship

June 24, 2018

PLAINFIELD, NJ – The highly anticipated USATF Jr. Olympics T&F State Championship meet brought the best of the best of New Jersey to Hub Stine Stadium in Plainfield for a two day event, Saturday, June 9 and Sunday, June 10. Top three earn medals and top six competitors in each event advance to the USATF Region 2 Junior Olympic Championships on July 12-15 at the College of New Jersey ...

Shakespeare in the Park Returns to Union County, Sunday, July 8

The Union County Board of Chosen Freeholders is pleased to announce the return of Shakespeare in the Park this summer. The first performance will be presented on Sunday, July 8 at 7:00 p.m. at the Raymond Wood Bauer Promenade in Linden.

The Shrew Mechanicals Troupe from The Shakespeare Theatre of New jersey will present an hour long performance of “Powerful Trouble,” a stirring ...

Imagine Hosts Annual Breakfast Fundraiser

Nearly 350 guests attended Imagine’s 7th annual breakfast fundraiser, Seasons of Hope, on June 6th, 2018 at Shackamaxon Country Club in Scotch Plains.  “We especially want to thank our breakfast sponsors -- our platinum sponsor Merck, our bronze sponsors ConnectOne Bank and Northfield Bank, the volunteers and donors that contributed to the breakfast” said Imagine Board ...

Video: Union County Celebrates Pride Month with CommUNITY PRIDE Day Picnic

June 19, 2018

RAHWAY, NJ - Parents, children, friends, and all family members came out on Saturday afternoon to Rahway River Park for the Union County CommUNITY PRIDE Day Picnic.

The family-friendly celebration hosted by the Union County Board of Chosen Freeholders, was a day of fun activities of arts and crafts, family lawn games, inflatable bounce houses, playground fun and more, along with music by the ...

Scotch Plains Mayor Al Smith Attends Gun Safety Bills Signing Ceremony with Gov. Murphy in Trenton

June 14, 2018

TRENTON, NJ -- Mayor Al Smith attended a gun safety package bill signing ceremony at the Richard J. Hughes Justice Complex in Trenton on Wednesday with Governor Phil Murphy. Mayor Smith joined a bipartisan group of local and state elected officials, as well as members of Moms Demand Action of Union County, at the event. 

“As a leader in Sandy Hook Promise, I was happy to accept the ...

Sleep out at Covenant House

June 18, 2018

I can enjoy the same movies over and over like it were the first time to see them.  My kids roll their eyes at this.  Well, many unimaginable things happen as you become a certain age, and you tend to learn to accept those things graciously as gift.   But I remember the movie “The Blind Side.”  Until I saw that movie, I didn’t know homeless children ...

Upcoming Events


Mon, June 25

Summit YMCA, Summit

June 2018 College Tour



Mon, June 25, 7:00 AM

Summit YMCA, Summit

Pet Supply Drive at the Summit YMCA to Benefit ...

Giving Back


Mon, June 25, 8:00 AM

Providence Health & Fitness, New Providence

Barre Intensity

Health & Wellness

Mon, June 25, 9:00 AM


Kids' Critter Camp



Mon, June 25, 9:00 AM

The Connection, Summit

Summer Camp begins at The Connection

Arts & Entertainment


Mon, June 25, 9:15 AM

Providence Health and Fitness, New Providence

Aroma Flow Vinyasa

Health & Wellness

What's Hot and What's Not

Summer is a great time to take a step back, sip a cool beverage, and take a look at what’s going on in the world of college admissions.  Departments use the summer to evaluate how their year went and plan on any changes they want to make for the fall.  Did they over-enroll? Under-enroll?  What application materials were useful to them?  Which were redundant or time ...