Football: Goodstein Resigns as New Providence Head Coach


NEW PROVIDENCE, NJ – First-year varsity football head coach Mitch Goodstein submitted his letter of resignation last Thursday to superintendent Dave Miceli.

According to an email sent to several football families that included the resignation letter, Goodstein cited his “diminished authority" as head football coach for his main reason to resign.

“The district has the right to hire and fire who they wish and that is their prerogative,” Goodstein said. “I also have the right to express my feelings to the administration and not stand for being micro managed. With the above statement being said, I resign effective immediately as head football coach of the New Providence Pioneers."  

Sign Up for E-News

At the center of Goodstein’s resignation is his inability to hire certain assistant coaches to his staff. According to a New Providence football parent, assistant coaches Bob Romeo and Mike Kuchar were not returning to their positions next year, leaving two openings on the 2017 coaching staff.

The source said Goodstein attempted to fill the two open positions with coaches from outside the district, but those hirings were met with criticism from district administrators because “he did not go through the proper channels of Board hiring procedures.”

Goodstein said in his resignation letter that he should have the authority to hire coaches that “benefit the greater well-being of the program.”

“These men were not in a position to take over the program, just to add input and expertise when needed,” Goodstein said of the potential new assistants. “I am the one that asked these men to come on staff and it was my decision to do so. I need not worry what the perception is on the outside, my only concerned is what their abilities are as coaches. Regardless of their age.”

Goodstein also accuses the district’s administration of forcing certain personnel decisions on him, while also keeping other district employees “on pins and needles and have them fear that if they question authority, they will be terminated.”

Goodstein said he felt “second guessed” by members of the district’s administration, despite his long-standing relationship with the program as a fan, player and coach dating back to the 1970s.

“I have seen all the ups and downs of the program and I currently see where it is headed,” Goodstein said. “There is no one more dedicated and has a passion for New Providence football than myself. I took this position to lead and revive this program because I did not like the direction that is was going. I did what I thought was best for the program.”

New Providence athletic director Rocco Constantino offered no comment on Goodstein’s resignation when reached through a text message on Monday night.

Messages sent to Goodstein’s district email account were returned with a “failure to deliver” message.

Goodstein was hired last February in replace of former head coach Joe Carollo who parted ways with the department in January 2016. The Pioneers went 1-9 in Goodstein’s only year as head coach, missing the state tournament for the first time since Frank Bottone was the head coach.

According to several sources, the search for New Providence’s fifth varsity football coach in program history has already started, with an internal job posting to current members of the district staff. Former head coach and current assistant Art Cattano has been named the interim head coach. Cattano will oversee player registrations for this season until a permanent coach has been hired.

Check back in with TAPinto New Providence for more information on this story throughout the coming weeks.

TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Be Interested In

Sign Up for E-News

New Providence

Local Top Cops, Government Officials Helping 'March for Meals' Program

March 19, 2018

SUMMIT, NJ - Elected and Law Enforcement officials along with volunteers are joining SAGE Eldercare this month as it participates in the 16th annual March for Meals – a month-long, nationwide partnership of local community organizations, businesses, government officials and caring individuals, who come together to ensure that homebound and ...

New Providence Coach Joins Hoops Clinic Mar. 25 to Benefit Family of Jenna Sullivan

SUMMIT, NJ - By all accounts, Jennifer 'Jenna' Sullivan lived an amazing life. Tragically, that life was far too short, as Sullivan passed away December 19, 2017, at the age of 45.

Sullivan lost a hard-fought battle with cancer and left behind an amazing legacy of her love of life and her caring for everyone she met. She was a leader in everything she ...

Union County Students to 'March for Our Lives' Saturday in Union

UNION, NJ – Students from all over Union County will be walking from Burnet Middle School to Town Hall on Saturday morning, March 24, in an anti-gun violence march.

Led by steering committee chairman Colin Sumner, the march, which has the support of Senator Joseph Cryan, Moms Demand Action, Union County Chapter, and the Union County Freeholders, is not aimed at taking away guns, but ...

2018 Gov. Livingston Highlander Softball Clinic Set for March 19

Come join and learn from the 2017 Union County Softball Champion Gov. Livingston coaches and varsity players on Monday, March 19, 2018 from 6:30 to 8 p.m.

Activities will include the following fastpitch softball skills:

Batting Techniques
Throwing Mechanics
Base Running

Who: Children grades 1-7 of any skill level or ability

Where: Gov. Livingston High School, 175 ...

Mount Carmel Breakfast with the Easter Bunny, Sunday, March 25

BERKELEY HEIGHTS, NJ - Mount Carmel Society is hosting a Breakfast with the Easter Bunny on Sunday, March 25 from 8 a.m. to 1 p.m. at 56 River Road in Berkeley Heights with an Easter Egg Hunt at 11 a.m. (weather permitting).

The all you can eat buffet includes pancakes, eggs, bacon, sausage, bagels, donuts and muffins and a cash bar will serve Mimosas and Bloody ...

Register for Breakfast with the Easter Bunny at Mt. Carmel Hall in Berkeley Heights

BERKELEY HEIGHTS, NJ - Come out and enjoy Breakfast Buffet with the Easter Bunny on Sunday, March 25 from 8 a.m. to 1 p.m. at Mt. Carmel Hall at 56 River Road in Berkeley Heights.

Children can have their picture taken with the Easter Bunny and receive a special gift from the Easter Bunny.

The buffet includes all you can eat pancakes, eggs, bacon, sausage, donuts, muffins, coffee, ...

Thank You From Mayor Al Morgan

March 16, 2018

This past week will certainly be remembered by us all for a very, very long time. Thank you hardly seems sufficient, but it is the very least we can express in appreciation for all the incredible acts of kindness, generosity, selflessness, and volunteerism our community received this past week during and after the storm.

Thank you to all of our residents for their patience, understanding, and ...

NPHS Student's Response to After School Walk-out Plan at NPHS

A group of students file into a science classroom amid a nervous din of chatter, the air is electric with excitement and nervousness. This small group of approximately 30 students are a studious bunch, largely members of the sophomore class with squeaky clean administrative histories. They are currently preparing to defy authority and stand up for what they believe in, even though they had been ...

A New Day for 529 Plans: Federal Tax Reforms Lead to New Possibilities for These Education Savings Accounts

March 8, 2018

Do you have a 529 college savings plan? Have you thought about opening a 529 plan account? If the answer to either question is “yes,” you should know about two major changes that broaden the possibilities for 529 plans. They may give your family some new options. You may be able to pay K-12 tuition with 529 plan funds.

The legislation ...

Avon Loses Its Last ‘Grand’ Hotel to the Claw of an Excavator

March 17, 2018

AVON-BY-THE-SEA, NJ — In less than two days, an Avon-by-the-Sea landmark that stood for 130 years was reduced to a huge pile of rubble. The Norwood Inn no longer stands on the corner of Norwood and Second Avenues — the last of the stately hotels that once graced the streets of Avon.

As onlookers gathered around the demolition site on March 15 and March 16, an excavator clawed its ...

Upcoming Events


Tue, March 20, 8:00 AM

Providence Health and Fitness, New Providence

Pilates Abs and Arms

Health & Wellness


Tue, March 20, 9:15 AM

Providence Health and FItness, New Providence

Essential Hatha Yoga

Health & Wellness


Tue, March 20, 10:30 AM

Providence Health and Fitness, New Providence

Essential Hatha Yoga

Health & Wellness


Tue, March 20, 5:30 PM

Providence Health and Fitness, New Providence

Barre Intensity

Health & Wellness


Tue, March 20, 6:30 PM

Providence Health and Fitness, New Providence


Health & Wellness


Tue, March 20, 7:30 PM

Providence Health and Fitness, New Providence

Yoga 101

Health & Wellness

You Want a Check for How Much!

 My first admissions gig was working for a small liberal arts college with a pretty hefty price tag.  Picture me at a college fair: name tag in place, pile of brochures ready to go.  An eager family would walk up and we’d start a conversation.  One of the first questions I’d get from parents was about cost and the moment that $50,000-plus figure left my mouth I ...

New Providence Annual Paca Club St. Patrick's Day Extravaganza

Mayor Al Morgan with Paca Club President Armand Galluccio don the green at the annual St. Patrick's Day Extravaganza on Saturday night at the Paca Club in New Providence.

The William Paca Club is a social and civic club, originally formed during the Great Depression by a group of residents of New Providence. In 1943, the club officially received a certificate ...

New Providence OEM Opened Storm Shelter and Warmed Hearts

The New Providence Office of Emergency Management opened its shelter at 5:30 PM on Wednesday, March 7, 2018, their first guest being a stranded motorist.  The storm left ¾ of New Providence without power. The shelter cared for over 325 people over the course of 6 days. 

The Shelter provided, heat, wifi, electricity, food and a safe place to sleep. One ...