New Providence Borough Council Votes to "Squeeze" Out Mayor; Sets New Rules for Committee Representation

Council President Robert Munoz and Councilman Michael Gennaro discussed the necessity of a resolution changing council member representation at borough boards and committees at its Feb. 12 meeting. Credits: Bobbie Peer
Mayor Al Morgan, clearly unpleased with the resolution. Credits: Bobbie Peer
Sunil Abrol, chair of the Diversity Committee, announced his disappointment of this resolution that would essentially "squeeze" the Mayor out of attending committee meetings. Credits: Bobbie Peer

NEW PROVIDENCE, NJ – The New Providence Borough Council approved a resolution Monday to have up to three-council-member representation at borough boards and committees. In accordance with the Sunshine Law, the change effectively excludes the mayor from attending the meeting if three council members are present.

Council President Robert Munoz, Councilmen Dr. Robert Robinson, Jim Madden, Michael Gennaro and Councilwoman Nadine Geoffroy voted in favor and Councilman Gary Kapner abstained from the vote.

According to Mayor Al Morgan, the representation should include the mayor as an ex-officio member of a committee or board since the mayor represents the executive form of the government while the council acts as the legislative body. The mayor of New Providence has been an ex-officio member of boards and committees since 1899, Morgan said.  

Sign Up for E-News

Munoz explained that New Jersey has 12 different forms of municipal government. New Providence is representative of “a weak mayor” governing body format, where the mayor only votes as a tiebreaker.

Morgan, clearly not happy with the resolution, suggested the proposal be presented to voters as a referendum question. Morgan said that he likes to listen to board or committee members, advisers and the public in order to make “an educated decision” on a given issue. Munoz noted that the mayor gets to know the issues once the liaison reports them to the council. Morgan vowed to make a commitment that he will continue to voice his opinions on borough issues despite not being allowed to attend meetings.

During the public comment session several residents expressed their disappointment that the mayor will not be able to attend their meeting as they preferred the two council members and a mayor be in attendance at all board and committee functions.  Among those who spoke were the Chairman of the Diversity Committee Sunil Abrol and former Councilman Armand Galluccio. Borough resident Peggy McHugh Hagen, who described herself as a Democrat who didn’t even vote for any of the sitting council members or the mayor, asked the council to explain “why” the change is necessary.

"I wonder myself, as a committee chair, why I need three council representatives on a Diversity Committee meeting-- but the mayor, himself, is excluded. I am very very disappointed to hear that is the likely outcome," said Abrol.  

Munoz said that the resolution doesn’t hinder the mayor's ability to talk with people, attend mayors' meetings or go to the diversity event, he can still do all of that. "What I am proposing here will not effect that or take that duty away from him." In answering Hagen's question, he said he agrees that the Mayor can not stay if three council members attend committee meetings. He continued to answer Hagen's question, by saying that there is a reason for this decision. "Any decision this council makes, is not done 'willy nilly'. We have a reason for every single decision that we make -- and there is a reason for this one.  As for a referendum, we do not put out a referendum on issues that effect the way the council conducts its business. If the issue effects the town as a whole, then that we may consider putting out a referendum. -- But, for the way the council handles its business, that is handled by the council." 

Councilman Michael Gennaro said unfortunately there is “another side” to the story and noted that the council is in full compliance with the law with regard to the committee representation decision. 

He said that it is clearly within the power of the council  to dictate how this meeting proceeds and it is clearly within the power of this council to dictate what committees are created as a creation of council. "Everyone of these committees are created by council and supported by council. It is certainly within the council power to dictate what members of council or governing body including the mayor participate in those committees. In the terms of how those committees are governed, we discussed at the last meeting, it's within our power to do that," he said. 

Gennaro explained that the council members have received a number of complaints from borough employees and from the administrator [Doug Marvin] regarding undue influence being brought upon those employees by the mayor and by a relative of the mayor instructing them on how to conduct business for the town, about how to conduct what they were doing in certain town events and how they structure those events. "Those employees came to us with complaints that they were feeling harassed. Doug Marvin can talk to you about this --."  Gennaro did not provide further explanation of the complaints. TAPinto New Providence reached out to Borough Administrator Doug Marvin for further explanation of the harassment claims per Gennaro's suggestion. At time of publishing, Marvin had not responded. 

Gennaro further said, "We had situations where the mayor and relatives of the mayor were scheduling events in a vacuum. -- We also had a situation, incredibly enough, where the mayor's wife took it upon herself to incur an expense on the borough by ordering banners" for a Diversity Committee event without proper authorization. “As a council, we would be irresponsible if we allowed this stuff to continue," he said.

"These decisions are based purely on the interest of the community and based purely on the interest of our employees. If this council doesn't protect its employees from harassment, how on earth can those people be expected to continue to serve this community. Furthermore, some of those people have threatened litigation against this community. We can't allow this to happen," said Gennaro.  

Gennaro said that he had a conversation, as did a number of the council people with this mayor, asking for the behavior to stop and he promised that it would -- it didn't stop.

Morgan and Gennaro squabbled about a "heated argument" they had "behind closed doors."  

Borough Administrator Doug Marvin further noted that when borough employees receive instructions from others than himself it creates “confusion”. He noted that some phone calls regarding community events have gone directly to department heads. “The council needs to know what these events are,” he said and added that the purchasing processes have to be followed. He pointed out that “it is important to have a good working relationship with the governing body,” however, that has not always been the case.

"We have processes, and we have policies for example that prohibit individual members of council to meeting with employees," said Marvin. This is due to years ago there was an incident that resulted in litigation -- while neither the current mayor or council members were involved, he reminded everyone, "because of the influence you have, you had an effect on employees, you all do, just by the virtue of your elected position," said Marvin. 

Without mentioning names, Morgan said, "You want to bang me for being accountable, for expecting certain things from some people, then so be it, accuse me of that." 

Councilwoman Nadine Geoffroy offered more conciliatory words after the at times contested dialogue between Morgan and Gennaro. Geoffroy explained that the wording of the resolution allows the council to decide on a two or three council member representation and the council can vote whether to allow the mayor to attend meetings as the ex-officio member along with two council representatives depending on the given committee. The resolution “comes out sounding worse than it is,” she said.

Editor's Note: Bobbie Peer contributed to the reporting.

TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Be Interested In

Sign Up for E-News

New Providence

Center for Hope Hospice Starts 2018 with $10,000 Donation from RSI Bank

February 18, 2018

SCOTCH PLAINS, NJ – RSI Bank, headquartered in Rahway, has been a long-time supporter of the Center for Hope Hospice, which offers hospice and palliative care in its two residences, in patients’ homes and other healthcare settings.

A generous donation from the bank has helped the Center start the year with $10,000 more in its Charitable Care Program, which enables those ...

Third Annual Rockin' For Autism Music Festival

All-day festival benefiting Autism New Jersey will feature local bands, food trucks, vendors, a merchant raffle, bake sale, obstacle course and lots of family fun! Join us for a day of great music, food, fun -- and help us raise funds and awareness for a great cause.

The event will take place from 11 a.m. to 6 p.m., Saturday. April 14, in LaGrande Park. 200 LaGrande Ave., ...

Register Now to Save! Berkeley Heights Community Pool at the YMCA Early Bird Registration until February 28

With summer just around the corner, it will be hard not to look out the window and dream of warmer days and cool, crystal clear pools that are ready for swimming and splashing. With the Berkeley Heights Community Pool at the YMCA early bird registration currently open, signing up sooner will save money and give you something to look forward to once the summer sun hits! Since 1964, the Berkeley ...

Moms Demand Action for Gun Sense Will Meet on Tues, Feb. 20, at LaGrande Park Building

FANWOOD, NJ -- Following the mass shooting in Florida this week, the Union County Chapter of Moms Demand Action for Gun Sense will meet on Tuesday, Feb. 20, at 7:00 p.m. at the LaGrande Park Building  in Fanwood.

"Every life cut short by gun violence -- that somehow becomes a statistic -- is tucked away in our hearts, never to be lost," wrote Patti ...

New Jersey Youth Symphony Announces Bring A Buddy Week March 4-8

NEW PROVIDENCE—New Jersey Youth Symphony (NJYS) invites young musicians in grades 3-11 to attend open rehearsals for Bring A Buddy Week, March 4-8 at 570 Central Avenue in New Providence. Participating students will observe the first half of a rehearsal. Students can visit any ensemble based on their grade and experience level. Students who do not have a friend in an ensemble can still ...

Letter to NP Mayor and Council

February 17, 2018

I am writing to express my dismay at the New Providence Council’s actions at its February 12th meeting. The council voted to allow up to three council members (up from 2) to attend committee meetings. Because of Sunshine Laws no more than three can attend a meeting.  In my opion, the objective was to squeeze-out Mayor Morgan from committee meetings.  Without going into ...

Letter to New Providence Borough Council

Dear Council Member-

I attended the Borough Council meeting on Feb 12, 2018.  I brought my 2 young children to this meeting to see democracy in action in our new hometown but I was left speechless. 

It was an obvious display of overreach by the Borough Council.  It absolutely makes no sense at all that the Council wants Three Council Members to attend every Volunteer ...

Chatham Borough Police Chief Crosson has Retired; Captain Gibbons is Acting Commander

February 12, 2018

CHATHAM, NJ - Phil Crosson Jr., who has been a member of the Chatham Borough Police Department since 1992, retired from his position as the police chief on Feb. 1.

"It came on pretty quickly," Crosson said when reached by phone on Sunday. "I was on vacation for six weeks and I bought a business. I came back for one day and retired."

According to Crosson, ...

‘Reefer Madness’ Comes to Chatham Borough Council; Cannabis Advocates Make Pitch for Chatham Marijuana Shop

February 14, 2018

CHATHAM, NJ - A group of pro-cannabis activists came to the Borough of Chatham Council meeting on Monday night and used the public commentary portion of the meeting to ask the council to support a marijuana dispensary in town.

The advocates, who say they have attended more than 80 town meetings to inform about the benefits of medical cannabis, mentioned the 1936 movie "Reefer ...

Upcoming Events

Sun, February 18

Scherman Hoffman Wildlife Sanctuary, Bernardsville

NJ Audubon: Volunteer Art Show!

Arts & Entertainment Green


Sun, February 18, 9:30 AM

New Providence

Tai Chi Chaun

Health & Wellness


Sun, February 18, 11:00 AM

Providence Health and Fitness, New Providence

Zumba meets Bolly DaZz

Health & Wellness


Sun, February 18, 3:00 PM

Lawton C. Johnson Middle School , Summit

New Jersey Intergenerational Orchestra Free ...

Arts & Entertainment

Sun, February 18, 7:00 PM

Villagers Theatre, Somerset

Hairspray Auditions

Arts & Entertainment

Mon, February 19

Scherman Hoffman Wildlife Sanctuary, Bernardsville

NJ Audubon: Volunteer Art Show!

Arts & Entertainment Green