Elections

Charter schools moratorium sparks sparring at Democratic gubernatorial primary debate

Democratic gubernatorial candidates John Wisniewski, Phil Murphy, Jim Johnson and Ray Lesniak. Credits: Pool Photo
Gubernatorial candidates Phil Murphy and Jim Johnson in an exchange during a debate at NJTV studio in Newark. Credits: Pool Photo
Gubernatorial candidates John Wisniewski and Phil Murphy in a debate at NJTV studio in Newark. Credits: Pool Photo

The question of whether there should be a moratorium on charter schools sparked heated discussion among the four major New Jersey Democratic gubernatorial primary candidates gathered at a television debate in the studio of NJTV in downtown Newark on Thursday night, putting a direct spotlight on a critical educational issue in the state's largest city. 

While the candidates were led through a series of back-and-forth exchanges by NJTV's chief political correspondent Michael Aron on a range of policy issues that included the pension system, transportation, health care and property taxes, Assemblyman John Wisniewski (D-Sayreville) opened the door to a candidate exchange about the issue when he mentioned the concept of a moratorium on charter schools as part of a discussion on the state's public school funding formula.

Wisniewski expressed his desire for a moratorium on charter schools and noted that the flow of funds toward charter schools further hurts the efforts of a state public school system that is already underfunded. 

Sign Up for E-News

At a meeting of the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People (NAACP) in October, Murphy, a voting NAACP board member, expressed reservations before the organization approved a resolution calling for a moratorium on charter school growth, trying to temporarily put a break on the vote, as reported by TAPintoNewark. 

Murphy tried to open a discussion about the controversial resolution that has bitterly divided the African-American community in Newark and across the nation. But the other NAACP board members were not in a mood for dialogue and pushed forward with the resolution, one of 47 adopted by the organization during the meeting.

All of the other three Democratic gubernatorial primary candidates present at Thursday's debate, including Wisniewski, Senator Ray Lesniak (D-Elizabeth) and Montclair attorney Jim Johnson, have stated that they are for a moratorium on charter schools. 

Aron pressed Murphy on the issue, asking him directly if he supported a moratorium on charter schools.

"This is a complicated one. This is hard," Murphy said while sitting under the lights at the NJTV studio in Newark's Gateway Center, the stage exposed to the viewing public behind glass. "I've never been a heck-no charter guy, but the way [funding] has been done under [Republican Gov. Chris] Christie is extremely troubling. So I had said let's call a time out and get some rules of the road in place here. We over-label this discussion. I want to be the guy that supports schools that are working. But there are very troubling governance issues, funding issues and demographic issues."

Wisniewski then interjected, asking if Murphy was for a moratorium or not.

Murphy answered that he voted against the NAACP call for a moratorium because he felt that it was "implying that federal money would have been cut off the next day, and kids would have been thrown out of school. And I'm not for that."

Johnson initially expressed confusion as to why Murphy brought up the NAACP board debate, then took a moment to clarify his position on a charter school moratorium. 

"I've called for a pause...but the other thing we need to be concerned about is that there are districts in which there is a choice between funding for charter schools and funding for traditional public schools," Johnson said. "We need to support our public schools but also take advantage of the knowledge and learning experience from charter schools." 

After the debate, which was co-sponsored by NJ Spotlight, Wisniewski continued to criticize Murphy's answer during the debate on the issue of a charter school moratorium. 

"He was multiple choice, like he was taking the PARCC test and filling in a couple of the boxes at the same time," Wisniewski told TAPintoNewark. "He's inexperienced, doesn't understand New Jersey policy or politics, and he was all over the place." 

Murphy countered by further clarifying his position on the charter school moratorium. 

"I absolutely stand for a timeout on charter schools. I was trying to make a point on what is the definition of a moratorium," Murphy told TAPintoNewark. "[The NAACP] definition was to cut federal money from schools, close schools tomorrow, and throw kids on the street. I'm not going to sign up for that."

Murphy received the endorsement of the New Jersey Education Association (NJEA), which supported a charter school moratorium in New Jersey. 

When asked how this endorsement affects his stance on a charter school moratorium, Murphy said that it did not. 

"My view has not changed. In fact, [the NJEA] is probably organized in about 12 or fifteen charters. This is not the black-and-white issue that people make it out to be. It's also a different dynamic in Newark than it is in Montclair. As I mentioned, we're way over-labelling this."

TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Be Interested In

Sign Up for E-News

New Providence

Obituaries

Frank Bottone died on Nov. 9, 2017, in the hospice unit of St. Barnabas Hospital, following a ...
Read more

Service of Comfort

November 20, 2017

As we make our way to the celebration of Christ's birth, the world fills our days with shopping and tinsel and cheerful songs floating over the radio.

Amid the hurry and the excitement of these weeks, do you need a place to spend a bit of time in quiet reflection?  Do you find that, because of circumstances in your life, it is difficult to feel as “merry” as the season ...

Stop in and Browse at TMC's Boutique in New Providence for Gifts and Accessories

NEW PROVIDENCE, NJ - TMC's Boutique is your little shop with a twist that has brought something big to downtown New Providence, showcasing the work of 20 local artists.

TMC's Boutique is participating in the Holiday Festival on Friday, Nov. 24 with attractions throughout Downtown New Providence along with the traditional Christmas Walk and Santa Visit . Visit ...

Online Auction of Coolers Donated By McLain Ward Benefits Omega Horse Rescue

Coolers awarded to McLain Ward’s top horses over the years are being auctioned off online to benefit Omega Horse Rescue Fund.

The Silver Oak Jumper Tournament is organizing the auctions through it website.

An auction that ended on Nov. 15 and included the American Invitational championship cooler awarded to Sapphire in 2008, raised $2,300.

Sapphire earned two Olympic medals before ...

Concord Singers Winter Concert, "Myth and Mystery" Saturday, December 9

The Concord Singers, will present its winter concert, “Myth and Mystery”, on Saturday, December 9 at 7:00 PM at Calvary Episcopal Church, 31 Woodland Ave., Summit, New Jersey.

Join us for an inspiring mix of traditional, contemporary and sacred music of the season by composers and arrangers as varied as Benjamin Britten, Gabriel Faure, Clifton Noble Jr., David Eddleman, Samuel ...

Mingle & Jingle in Celebration of the Holidays

Opera at Florham continues to celebrate its 35th Anniversary season with its Holiday Program “Mingle and Jingle” at Lenfell Hall, The Mansion, Fairleigh Dickinson University in Madison, New Jersey on Sunday December 3rd at 2 pm.

This year the Chorus of Fairleigh Dickinson University, Madison, will join Opera at Florham’s singers: Theron Cromer, tenor, and Daniela Di Pasquale, ...

Tickets Now Available for Center for Hope’s 22nd Annual Super Bowl Raffle

SCOTCH PLAINS, NJ – The Center for Hope Hospice & Palliative Care has rolled out its popular annual Father Charles Hudson Super Bowl Raffle. This is the 22nd year that the non-profit organization is raffling off two tickets to the Super Bowl as the first prize. This year’s game will be played in Minneapolis; the grand prize winner will also receive a flight voucher worth $500 ...

The 2017 Houdaille Quarry Walk, Sunday in Springfield: Get on the Other Side of the Fence

November 17, 2017

SPRINGFIELD, NJ - The Houdaille Quarry, often called the “Grand Canyon of Union County”, and normally closed to the public, will be open on Sunday, November 19 from 1:00 p.m. to 3 p.m. for Fall Foliage walks sponsored by the Springfield Environmental Commission.

This is a rare chance to get to go on the other side of the fence and see the Quarry, which is an ecologically unique ...

Volunteers Assemble 1,500 Care Packages for US Troops Deployed Overseas

November 11, 2017

MANVILLE, NJ – More than 500 volunteers, young and old, helped Operation Shoebox New Jersey assemble 1,500 personal care packages during the XIII annual Military Appreciation packing event held in conjunction with Veterans Day.

The event was held on Saturday, Nov. 4, at the Manville VFW, 600 Washington Ave.

It took only two hours to build the boxes, pack the bags, assemble the boxes, ...

Sustained, Severe Cuts Equal Setbacks at NJ Department of Environmental Protection

November 8, 2017

Long-term budget and staff cuts have severely impacted the ability of the New Jersey Department of Environmental Protection (DEP) to carry out critical work to protect New Jersey’s environment and residents. This has serious implications for wildlife, public health and our economy. DEP is charged with managing and protecting the State’s environment and natural resources.

This ...

Parting Advice from Four Decades on the Front Lines of Local News

November 11, 2017

In February 1978 I walked into the office of The Rahway News-Record and Clark Patriot to begin what I thought was to be a short-term job stepping stone. 

Instead, it turned out to be a nearly 40-year odyssey in local journalism—including the last eight—overwhelmingly great—years with The Alternative Press (TapInto.Net).

I have decided it is time to spend more time in ...

To the residents of New Providence

To the residents of New Providence,

It is with sincere appreciation and pride that we graciously accept the honor of serving you as members of the Borough Council.  We would also like to acknowledge and thank Jamie Baer Peterson and Keith Doll. 

We will continue to work hard for everyone, keeping in mind our common goal of improving this wonderful town.  We optimistically ...

Upcoming Events

Carousel_image_7f6c107703df2d416aa6_barre_intesity

Mon, November 20, 8:00 AM

Providence Health and Fitness, New Providence

Barre Intensity

Health & Wellness

Carousel_image_3ef53449738f06d2e4c0_yoga___oils2

Mon, November 20, 9:15 AM

Providence Health and Fitness, New Providence

Aroma Flow Vinyasa

Health & Wellness

Carousel_image_a4801a3d56342db1596a_pilates_reformer

Mon, November 20, 10:00 AM

Providence Health and Fitness, New Providence

Pilates Reformer

Health & Wellness

Carousel_image_107da84439934a15516b_woman_yogi

Mon, November 20, 11:00 AM

Providence Health and Fitness, New Providence

Hatha Yoga Flow

Health & Wellness

Carousel_image_c64d737a46240c5e09c6_lean_technique_woman

Mon, November 20, 5:30 PM

Providence Health and Fitness, New Providence

Lean Technique with Kathy

Health & Wellness

Carousel_image_4ca4b046b48f94f03540_unnamed_4

Mon, November 20, 7:00 PM

Providence Health and Fitness, New Providence

Vinyasa Flow with Karen

Health & Wellness

I Reported It Myself!

Each year there seems to be more schools relying on self-reported test scores and transcripts on their applications.  While they may, in the long run, streamline the application process I’ve seen them cause a good amount of stress during this already stressful process.  Should an optional test score self-report be filled in?  How do I know whether to mark my class as a ...