Newton Education Association Demands Answers About Contract Negotiations

Teachers from Merriam, Halsted, & the High School attended the Board of Education meeting Tuesday, October 20. Credits: Danielle Francisco
The Newton Education Association stood outside the Board of Education office before the meeting on Tuesday, October 20. Credits: Danielle Francisco
Members of the NEA stood in front of the Board of Education office waiting to hear what the board had to say about the questions that were asked in regards to contract negotiations. Credits: Danielle Francisco
Not all the members that were present, which was approximately 70, could fit inside the Board of Education office, other members of the NEA listened from outside the windows Credits: Danielle Francisco
Yvonne LaForge, a teacher at Newton High School, commented on some of the facts that the members were given by the board. Credits: Danielle Francisco
Jean Perrier, a teacher and also the Vice President of the Newton Education Association spoke about the dedication of the teachers. Credits: Danielle Francisco
Steve Runske, a teacher at Newton High School answered the famous question that teachers get asked, "If pay is so low, then why do you stay?" Credits: Danielle Francisco
Board of Education's responses to the NEA members questions Credits: Danielle Francisco
Fact sheet created by the Board of Education for the NEA members  Credits: Danielle Francisco

NEWTON, NJ - Teachers and members of the Newton Education Association gathered outside the Board of Education office Tuesday night in hopes of getting answers to their questions about their contract negotiations.

On Sunday, Oct. 11, the NEA published an ad in the New Jersey Herald regarding the ongoing contract negotiations between the Newton Board of Education and the members of the NEA association.

In an open letter published by the NEA on their website, there were many questions about salaries. One in particular was why the superintendent received a higher salary and higher bonuses than the teachers in the district.

Sign Up for E-News

Others included questions that asked why teachers got paid the lowest salary when the students in our district have the second highest SAT scores of any school district in Sussex County. Newton teachers have the lowest starting salary in the county and the second lowest average salary in the county.

When last they met on Sept. 30, the union, comprised of about 250 members from Merriam, Halsted and Newton High School, asked for a mediator to become involved in the contract negotiation process. While a mediator had not been named as of Monday, the Board of Education tried to answer some of the questions the NEA presented to them at the meeting on Tuesday.

The NEA’s questions and the Board of Education’s responses are as follows:

  1. Why did Newton’s superintendent receive bonuses for accomplishments that are part of the job of being a superintendent in the first place? 
    1. This would be a great question to ask the Governor and former Commissioner of Education who put salary cap and merit goal regulations in place against the objections of the New Jersey School Boards Association.  They resulted in an eight percent cut to our superintendent’s pensionable salary and all merit goals have been approved by the Department of Education.  Advocacy from other groups to repeal the regulations would be greatly appreciated. 
  2. Why did Newton’s business administrator receive a $10,194 raise for this year? 
    1. The actual raise was $2,784. The remaining salary difference from last year was not an additional increase: it was due to rolling existing longevity ($5,250), travel ($1,200) and communications ($960) stipends into the base and eliminating them from the contract.  Rolling longevity into the salary base has been proposed to the Association during the past two contract negotiations and was rejected each time.
  3. Why does the Board Secretary who makes $141,967 a year have a full time assistant who makes $80,631? 
    1. The Board Secretary is also the School Business Administrator with a job description that goes above what the typical person in that role handles. She saves the district well beyond the cost of an assistant … expenses that would otherwise be directed to various leadership, managerial, and contracted services.
  4. Why does our Business Administrator pay a private bus company $380 instead of paying a district employee $75 or our district bus driver $90 in overtime?
    1.  The central office regularly hires district employees to drive buses.  Occasionally, there are no district employees qualified, willing, or available to drive.
  5. Why have the Newton administrators received an average increase of over $4,500 each year over the last three years? 
    1. The average annual salary increase for the six administrators who stayed in the same role from 2011-12 to 2014-15 was $2,293.
  6. Why did the Board of Education pay more money for a lawyer to negotiate with district secretaries than they did for the total raise for all the secretaries? 
    1. The total raise for secretaries from 2014-2017 if all remain in their positions will be $46,080.  The cost for the negotiations attorney was $10,499 and only became necessary in response to the Association’s decision to bring their own representative to the table.
  7. Why is the Board spending the money to go to court to fight a decision when an arbitrator already ruled against them? 
    1. Actually, the arbitrator ruled in favor of the Board on the secretarial grievance on overtime pay. Their Association chose to file legal action to pursue it further.
  8. Why do Newton teachers have the lowest starting salary, second lowest average salary, and lowest dollar increase over the past three years in the county? 
    1. Salary guides are recommended by the Association, so they could have suggested a higher starting salary.  Average salaries are determined largely by years of experience, so a less experienced staff typically has a lower average salary.  39% of Association members have been here less than 5 years. Salary comparisons presented by the Association included only 9 of the 25 districts in the county...why?  A more reasonable comparison would be with similar districts around the state, not just wealthier communities in Sussex County.

Approximately 70 teachers attended the meeting.  Nearly all wore yellow question mark pins and held large yellow question mark signs in the front of the Board of Education building. “The question mark is like our theme or our symbol,” said a teacher who wished to remain unnamed. “We have a lot of questions and so we want some answers.”

During the public portion of the meeting, teachers were given the opportunity to share their opinions. Members of the NEA that spoke included, NEA Vice President Jean Perrier, Steve Runske, Karen Mazur, Kate Adam, Yvonne LaForge, Andy Iliff and Wendy Whipple. Comments were also made by Karen Kitchell. Jake Mull, NEA President, was not present at the meeting due to a previous teaching commitment according to teachers present.

Perrier said, “Education should not be about saving money, but spending money wisely.” She continued, “Our staff makes certain that no students fall through the cracks and our students work harder than they ever thought they possibly could. We help our students develop pride- Newton pride and to be respectful. Many people always ask us ‘Why stay in Newton?’ We stay because we believe, we work and we live, in this community and we believe in the students in our district. This is where you should invest your money- we are an investment. You have a dedicated staff in front of you that works extremely hard, beyond the capacity, even though we bring home less pay than we did years ago. By refusing to reasonably negotiate with the NEA you are failing to recognize our unparalleled dedication to the children of this community.”

Runske touched upon that same question that so many people ask teachers, “Why do you stay? I can’t speak for everyone else. I can only speak for myself but I stay because I love and respect my colleagues and because I love the children I teach. They are my life, they are my reason for getting up in the morning and I love this community.”

LaForge commented on the response of the board that the NEA should talk to their Governor about why the superintendent is receiving his bonuses. She made the board aware that every one of her colleagues has received eight, 13, 14, and some even higher of a percentage decrease in salary over the last three years. “I am currently making six thousand less per year than I was three years ago.”

Superintendent Dr. Greene responded. “If we’re talking about employee benefit contributions, I am making those contributions also.”  Laforge countered with the fact that she does not receive a bonus to make up for it.  

Iliff and Whipple had similar questions in regards to the information that was provided by the board. “Median and average are two very different words,” said Iliff, “From a mathematical standpoint I can tell you they are very different, because that is what I do.” It seemed that when compiling data, the board gathered information on the “average salary” for a teacher instead of the “median salary” of a teacher.

Whipple questioned the response the Board of Education gave for why Newton teachers have the lowest starting salary in the county.  The board responded that “a more reasonable comparison would be with similar districts around the state, not just wealthier communities (Sparta) in Sussex County.”

Whipple countered saying, “Every teacher that is working in Sussex County has the same cost of living as one another.”

A community member, Kitchell, spoke about the contract. “You have to give it to get it. The board and the NEA need to come together.” said Kitchell. 

The contract talks began last December.  The current contract is due to expire on June 30. If there is no new agreement prior to that the teachers will be working under the terms and conditions of the current contract until an agreement is reached.  At that time, any increase in pay or change to benefits are retroactive.   

TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Be Interested In

Sign Up for E-News


Sparta Man Arrested on Phoned in Tip to Police

February 25, 2018

SPARTA, NJ – A Sparta man was arrested following a tip called into police about a possible drunk driver leaving the Sparta Theatre Center.  On February 17 around midnight Sparta Police Officer Thomas Snyder found the truck that had been reported, police report.

Snyder, joined by Cpl. Rubino, Police Officer Lippencott and Police Officer Porter, stopped the Ford pickup truck on ...

Upcoming Events


Tue, February 27, 6:30 PM

Sparta United Methodist Church, Sparta

Girl Scout STEAM Program

Arts & Entertainment Education


Fri, March 2, 7:00 PM

Wallkill Valley Regional High School, Hamburg

The Drowsy Chaperone

Arts & Entertainment


Sat, March 3, 7:00 PM

Wallkill Valley Regional High School, Hamburg

The Drowsy Chaperone

Arts & Entertainment


AtlantiCast: Episode 12

On this week’s episode of AtlantiCast, decade of excellence makes headlines, as Atlantic Health’s place on Fortune Magazine’s 100 Best Companies to Work For List leads off the newest episode of AtlantiCast. Also on this week’s show, check out the newest “hybrid” operating room at Morristown Medical Center and find out how Atlantic Health is helping local ...

Sparta Boy Scout Troop 150 Honors New Eagles

February 19, 2018

SPARTA, NJ - On Sunday, January 21, 2018 Scouts, parents and friends of Boy Scout Troop 150, along with members of the Sparta community, gathered at Shepherd of the Hills Lutheran Church to celebrate the eight of the Troop’s newest Eagle Scouts.  Buddy Al-Aydi, Tyler Holden, Andreas Oleinyk, Ben Schultz, Erich Schwarzrock, Quinn Van Es, Zach Van Es and Chris Zachok attained the ...

Height during childhood associated with increased stroke risk in adulthood

Researchers in Denmark studied the health records of more than 300,000 people born between 1930 and 1989 and found that those who were shorter than average height between ages 7 and 13 had a greater risk of stroke as adults. The results of this study were published in the February 15, 2018 issue of the journal Stroke.


Journal ...

Don't Miss This OPEN HOUSE Saturday for a 3BR Parsippany Trophy Home

Treat yourself to this newly-priced trophy home in majestic Puddingstone Estates in Parsippany, NJ!   See the details here or stop by the OPEN HOUSE on February 24th, 1 to 3 pm. If you can't make it, call Team Nest Builder's Lynn Garafola at 973-222-3777 for a private tour. 

You must experience this beautiful home to believe it!  It's ...

Where Does YOUR School District Rank in Safety?

Family safety remains paramount when it comes to choosing a new home and community in New Jersey, so Team Nest Builder wants to help you know where top local school districts rank., which specializes in all different types of consumer rankings, provided a list of the safest school districts in the United States and New Jersey. Below find a list of the 200 safest school ...

Top 5 Reasons to Hire a Real Estate Professional When Buying or Selling in NJ

Team Nest Builder knows that whether you are buying or selling a New Jersey home it can be quite the adventure, which is why you need an experienced real estate professional to guide you on the path to achieving your ultimate goal. But in this world of instant gratification and internet searches, many sellers think that they can ‘For Sale by Owner’ or ...

Does Marriage or Mortgage Come First?

According to the National Association of REALTORS most recent Profile of Home Buyers & Sellers, married couples once again dominated the first-time homebuyer statistics in 2017 at 57% of all buyers. Team Nest Builder knows it's no surprise that having two incomes to save for down payments and contribute to monthly housing costs makes buying a home more ...

Sussex County Board of Chosen Freeholders February 14 2018 Meeting Video

NEWTON, NJ - Sussex County Board of Chosen Freeholders February 14 2018 Meeting Video 



AtlantiCast: Episode 12

On this week’s episode of AtlantiCast, decade of excellence makes headlines, as Atlantic Health’s place on Fortune Magazine’s 100 Best Companies to Work For List leads off the newest episode of AtlantiCast. Also on this week’s show, check out the newest “hybrid” operating room at Morristown Medical Center and find out how Atlantic Health is helping local ...

Gottheimer Meets with Constituents at Andover “Cup of Joe with Josh” Town Hall

February 24, 2018

ANDOVER, N.J. – Yesterday, Congressman Josh Gottheimer (NJ-5) met individually with tables of constituents at his “Cup of Joe with Josh” Town Hall at the Andover Diner. Gottheimer has held these “Cup of Joe with Josh” events regularly across North Jersey to hear directly from the people he serves. Gottheimer and constituents discussed the work he is doing to cut ...

Paterson's Poet Laureate

February 13, 2018

PATERSON, NJ- The City of Paterson has given birth to famous athletes, business leaders, actors, and now, a poet laureate.

Born and raised in Paterson, Talena Lachelle Queen told TAPinto Paterson that she has been writing since she was five-years old, and, as she grew older, realized that when it came to pursuing studies and a career in writing, she “didn’t have a choice.” ...