Newton High School’s Mock Trial Team Recognized at Board of Education Meeting

Credits: Danielle Francisco
Credits: Danielle Francisco
Credits: Danielle Francisco
Credits: Danielle Francisco
Credits: Danielle Francisco
Credits: Danielle Francisco
Credits: Danielle Francisco
Credits: Danielle Francisco
Credits: Danielle Francisco

NEWTON, NJ—On Tuesday, March 28, Newton’s Board of Education held their regular bi-monthly meeting, but their meeting was anything but regular.

On the agenda were two presentations that took place in the Newton High School Library; Enthusiastic Readers Recognition and Newton High School’s Mock Trial Team.

Along with the Newton board, which included President Stella Dunn, Vice President Jessica Egner, Business Administrator Donna Snyder, and Superintendent Dr. Ken Greene, parents, teachers and families of those being recognized, filled the audience.

Sign Up for E-News

“We have the pleasure tonight of hosting and recognizing the Newton High School Mock Trial team, who have achieved something that no group has done in this school’s history," Greene said “and that is competing in the county championships. They did an outstanding job and had an amazing season.”

The team, which was comprised of 10 students- six witnesses and four attorneys, gave the board and the public a brief overview of exactly what they had to do throughout their season as well as what being on the team meant to them.

The six team members who spoke at the meeting were:

  • Payton Collander
  • Michael Burke
  • Carter Boyd
  • Lisa Qarmout
  • Sarah Blake
  • Sean Tracy

Mock trial is “an annual competition that allows high school students from all across the nation to come together annually to practice law by participating in a simulated trial,” explained Collander.

The season, which begins in October, starts with an introduction to the case.  They then divide the jobs and positions on the teams between plaintiff and defense. This was the first year that Newton’s team held auditions.

Burke, a senior, completed his second year on the team, this year as an attorney on the defense side.

“As an attorney, my co-counsel and I had to look through all the facts and evidence of the case and then figure out a strategy to prove that the defendant was not liable of defamation,” Burke said. “We had to prepare openings, closings, directs and crosses for every single witness that we had and all of these would undergo countless revisions before the trial.”

Boyd also a senior, experienced his first year on Mock Trial as the co-defendant in the case.

“I joined Mock Trial because I’m very loud, outgoing and a little argumentative, so this was the perfect activity for me,” said Boyd. “But I do want to be a defense attorney when I get older and so I chose to be the witness so I could get into the heads of the people I will be defending…without actually having to be on trial.”

Those on the team that were the witnesses had to memorize countless lines and interpret a two page document known as an affidavit, so that when they were being interrogated by an adversary, they could respond to how they thought their “character” as Boyd put it, would respond.

Qarmout, a senior, has been on the Mock Trial team for two years now. While Mock trial deals mostly in the law surrounding the case, Qarmout pointed out how the members must view the problem in the case from both sides in order to defend the argument at hand.

“Even when you don’t necessarily believe it is right, you learn how to think critically and be flexible," Qarmout said. "Mock Trial demands that you learn how to use evidence to justify your case and that skill is important for effective writing. Presenting and winning a case requires good public speaking, which is a skill that builds confidence.”

Sarah Blake, who has been on the team for the past three years, experienced the side of a witness twice and an attorney once.  Blake explained how the team had three important people who helped them throughout their season.

“Our team would not have gone to the lengths and heights that we have gone without the help of Mrs. DaSilva, Mrs. Coffey and our attorney coach Mr. Lundquist," Blake said. "Since they are both history teachers they offered a unique insight to the ins and outs of the cases. It was great to have our attorney coach come in and help us out with the legal jargon and such as well.”

Last to speak was Sean Tracy, who has been on Mock Trial for the past two years. Last year he was the defense attorney, but this year he was in the role of the co-defendant in the case.

“The 2016-2017 Mock Trial season was extremely successful for our team,” Tracy said. “It is only the third time that a Newton Mock Trial team had reached the county semi-final round.

This year the plaintiff team went against the reigning champions, High Point, while the defense went against Kittatinny in the first round. Once the plaintiff team beat Wallkill they moved into the finals to once again compete against High point.

The finals competition took place in Newton old County Court House instead of the new one, which according to Tracy was “very intimidating to us because we were used to the court rooms in the new courthouse.”

After a 40 minute discussion to determine the winners in the finals, High Point took the win against Newton.

“We didn’t just learn about law during Mock trial. We learned how to be better writers and all became better orators, and we really became close friends along the way,” Burke said.

Collander ended the presentation by giving the board and the public a little insight as to why the students do Mock Trial.

“Being an attorney, let alone participating in Mock Trial itself, was single-handedly the best decision and a highlight in my high school career.”

TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Be Interested In

Sign Up for E-News


Sparta Police: Green Light Means DWI Charges

June 23, 2018

SPARTA, NJ – A Stockholm resident is facing drunk driving charges when she did not go when a traffic light turned green.  On June 16 around 1:15 a.m. Police Officers Thomas Snyder and Jonathan Poon stopped Christina Sacerdote, 52, police report.

When the officers spoke with the driver they determined she had been driving her white Mazda under the influence of alcohol.  ...

Upcoming Events


Sun, July 8, 1:00 PM

Van Kirk Homestead Museum, Sparta

Sussex County Views: The Art of Toni Chaplin

Arts & Entertainment

Tue, July 17, 6:00 PM

CASA of Morris and Sussex Counties, Morristown

CASA Information Session

Education Giving Back Law & Justice


Mon, July 23, 10:00 AM

Sparta Public Library, Sparta

Watercolor Workshop

Arts & Entertainment


Sun, August 26, 1:00 PM

Van Kirk Homestead Museum, Sparta

Sussex County Views: The Art of Toni Chaplin

Arts & Entertainment


Sat, October 13, 9:00 AM

Saint Kateri Parish, Sparta

Saint Kateri Craft and Vendor Fair

Arts & Entertainment

Sparta High School Students Visited by Modern Day Hero

June 16, 2018

SPARTA. NJ — The students in Andrew Lowery’s Heroes and Heroines senior English class had a special visitor last week. Gillian Lichota from iRise Above Breast Cancer foundation met with Lowery’s students and students from Kate Brennan’s Women’s Studies class as well as Emily Scott’s AP Government in Politics students.

The story of how Lichota came to be in ...

The Power of Positive Engagement

June 17, 2018

To the Editor:

I wanted to share this letter from Laurie Beacham, Media Director for NJ 11th for Change, about the notable increase in voter turnout and citizens deciding to run in the recent primary election:

"The 11th Congressional District has a lot to be proud of. In the June 5th primaries, voter turnout climbed from almost 33,000 in 2014 to over 86,000. Democratic ...

Again, Oroho, Space and Wirths Get It Wrong

On Wednesday, June 13th, a series of gun violence prevention bills were signed into law by Governor Murphy. These bills will strengthen our already strong gun laws in New Jersey and none of these new laws infringe on anyone’s right to keep and bear arms.   

Unfortunately, Senator Oroho and Assemblymen, Space and Wirths our Legislative District 24 representatives voted NO to a ...

Update: Police Break Up Fight Involving 40-50 People at Bridgewater Commons Mall

June 15, 2018

BRIDGEWATER, NJ — No injuries have been reported in an incident that shut down Bridgewater Commons Mall Thursday evening after a fight involving a crowd of 40-50 people.

Police are still investigating unconfirmed reports of shots being fired, according to the Somerset County Prosecutor's Office.

The mall is closed for the evening as the investigation continues.

Somerset County ...

5 Home-Related To-Do’s Before Leaving On Vacation

With school out and the summer sun shining down, thoughts turn to summer vacation trips.  Team Nest Builder offers these 5 home-related tips to follow to avoid everything from minor inconveniences to major headaches upon your return:

Pause Your Post & Paper

Piled up mail and newspapers act like a “rob me” sign!  Avoid tipping off strangers to your absence by ...

Why Buying a Home is Better Than Renting

People often ask if now is a good time to buy a home in New Jersey, but nobody ever asks whether or not it’s a good time to rent. Regardless, Team Nest Builder wants to make certain that everyone understands that now is NOT a good time to rent.

The Census Bureau recently released their 2018 first quarter median rent numbers. This graph from their report shows rent increases from 1988 ...

5 Fab Father's Day Happenings in Sussex & Morris Counties

Father’s Day hits this Sunday--what do YOU have planned? Team Nest Builder offers a slew of Father’s Day fun in Morris and Sussex County. Read on and surprise Dad with cool activities! (Be sure to check if registration is required prior to showing up!)

Alstede Farms' Father's Day Brunch – Chester

From 9am-noon, take a scenic hayride to a brunch buffet that offers ...

Don't Miss Sunday's OPEN HOUSE for 4BR Sparta Mountain Beauty

Perched handsomely on an acre in the beautiful SpartaMountain community, 28 Waters Edgeoffers a 4BR 2.5 Bathroom home with space and style. Come see for yourself this Sunday, June 17th, from 1-3pm at our OPEN HOUSE!

Located in the prestigious Sparta Mountain Reserve, this large, beautiful center hall colonial with open floor plan has a nice, level play yard with direct ...

Days on The Housing Market Drops to New Low

According to recently released data from the National Association of Realtors (NAR), the median number of days that a home spent on the market hit a new low of 26 days in April, as 57% of homes remained on the market for under a month.

NAR’s Chief Economist, Lawrence Yun, opined,

“What is available for sale is going under contract at a rapid pace. Since NAR began tracking this ...

June 13 Sussex County Board of Chosen Freeholders meeting

NEWTON, NJ - The June 13 Sussex County Board of Chosen Freeholders meeting video.


Pass It Along Triathlon

Tri-something new this July and sign up for the Pass It Along Triathlon!

The 9th annual Pass It Along Triathlon will take place on Saturday, July 28, 2018, at the Lake Mohawk Country Club. This triathlon features two USAT-certified courses - Olympic and Sprint. This triathlon has become a Sparta tradition and everyone is welcome to attend to cheer on athletes and be a part of the ...


AtlantiCast Episode 17

On this week’s AtlantiCast, it’s National Men’s Health Month, so check out important health tips for you or the men in your life, learn about groundbreaking research into breast cancer treatment that could mean an end to chemotherapy for some patients, meet a local sports hero who’s living his baseball dreams thanks to Goryeb Children’s Hospital and much ...

Sparta UMC Thrift Shop Half Price Sale

June 24, 2018

The Thrift Shop of the Sparta United Methodist Church, 71 Sparta Avenue, is holding a HALF-PRICE SALE from Wednesday, JULY 11TH through Saturday, JULY  14TH.  Most items in the shop will be half price.  All proceeds support local, national, and global charities.  Shop Hours:  Wednesday and Saturday, 10 a.m. to 2 p.m.; Thursday and Friday, 1 p.m.

Update: Police Break Up Fight Involving 40-50 People at Bridgewater Commons Mall

June 15, 2018

BRIDGEWATER, NJ — No injuries have been reported in an incident that shut down Bridgewater Commons Mall Thursday evening after a fight involving a crowd of 40-50 people.

Police are still investigating unconfirmed reports of shots being fired, according to the Somerset County Prosecutor's Office.

The mall is closed for the evening as the investigation continues.

Somerset County ...