Education

Newton Superintendent Joins with 13 Other Districts, Towns in School Funding Suit

d4fc999b73fb4cb8e1e6_IMG_7158.JPG
Newton Superintendent Dr. Kennedy Greene addressed the group gathered in the state house in Trenton on Friday Credits: Jennifer Dericks
23601299bdd676482281_IMG_7165.JPG
Newton Board of Education President Stella Dunn, Vice President Jessica Egner, member Anthony Neggers II Credits: Jennifer Dericks
f6e91bfdaf704be46dd0_IMG_7171.JPG
Newton Mayor Wayne Levante Credits: Jennifer Dericks
eda410bae57748770f12_IMG_7173.JPG
Attorney Allan Dzwilewski Credits: Jennifer Dericks
edf4af4b41cb4391fb87_IMG_7178.JPG
Kingsway Regional School District Superintendent Dr. James Levander Credits: Jennifer Dericks
18ba7262d3550a9a3ba1_IMG_7181.JPG
James Muller Kingsway Regional School District Board President Credits: Jennifer Dericks
c00314dc4cd58ca5d247_IMG_7187.JPG
Newton representatives Dr. Kennedy Greene, Jessica Egner, Anthony Neggers II, Wayne Levante. Not pictured, Newton Town Manager Thomas S. Russo Jr. Credits: Jennifer Dericks
d4fc999b73fb4cb8e1e6_IMG_7158.JPG

TRENTON, NJ – Newton Superintendent Dr. Kennedy Greene was joined by superintendents, board of education members and concerned citizens in Room 103 at the State House in Trenton on Friday afternoon, to announce the filing of litigation regarding school funding.

Approximately 50 people crowded into the room.  Greene was joined by Newton Board of Education President Stella Dunn, Vice President Jessica Egner and Anthony Neggers II.  Newton Town Manager Thomas S. Russo Jr. and Mayor Wayne Levante were also present for the discussion.

Greene said ten school districts and four municipalities were currently part of the suit, along with “30 individuals who have stepped up and been named in this litigation.”  Greene also said they are “open to amending the petition to add more parties” as they are identified.

Sign Up for E-News

In his opening remarks Greene said he was “pleased a sitting superintendent and educator, Lamont Repollet of Asbury Park was chosen to be the commissioner of education.”

School “funding is neither a minor problem nor a simple one,” Greene said.  The actual size of the funding shortfall is close to $2 billion; “under funding of $1.3 billion in state aid according to School Funding Reform Act or SFRA which affects two in three districts of all geography and income levels.”

Another part of the state aid “problem is $670 million of aid outside SFRA called ‘Adjustment Aid’ used to keep some districts at 2008 funding levels; 'overaiding' 38 districts” regardless of the changes in student populations and other demographics according to Greene.

Greene said the litigation is not asking to have full funding under SFRA rather it is seeking to have the aid budgeted by the legislature to be distributed more fairly.  Local taxpayers have to pick up the tab for under funded districts. 

This has led to a downwardly spiraling budgeting problem from which districts see no relief. Without the necessary aid, districts rely on property tax levy.  The levy is capped at two percent.  Add to that increased student populations and the problem escalates each year. 

Several of the districts party to the litigation have seen increases in their student populations yet their aid remains flat, essentially creating budget shortfalls each year. There are few options.  With much of the budget dictated by statue or contract, staff gets cut and capital budgets are depleted.

“The funding is wildly unjust and won’t go away with wishful thinking,” Greene said. He said the litigation is to take action, seeking “significant steps toward fair and sustainable funding.”

The second prong of the school funding problem is over taxing or municipalities called on to pay more than their “fair share.”  This is not a totally subjective concept.  The state has a formula for determining fair share. 

Newton tax payers are taxed at 48 percent or $4 million over fair share according to the state calculation.  “Nearly one third of the districts in the state are not paying their ‘fair share’,” Greene said.  Some districts are receiving more than 100 percent above the SFRA aid, some even at levels of 200, 300 and 500 percent of the formula according to Greene.

Dunn said Newton had recently lost a referendum to replace the 100+ year old middle school by a margin of 80 percent.  “The state’s decision to 'underaid' puts an undue burden on taxpayers,” Dunn said.  That is a big reason why the referendum failed, she explained.

The board members said they were waiting to see what the 2018 aid numbers would be before discussion how to handle the facility problem in Newton.

When Levante told the room that in addition to the aid issue, “35 percent of the properties were tax exempt [in Newton],” there was a gasp from others in the room.  “That also hurts.  We are sending too much money to the former Abbott Districts, then you see the SDA [School Development Authority] building palaces in those [formerly Abbott] cities when Newton can’t muster up the money to put an addition on a 60-year-old building.

“Districts that have seen reduced enrollment and still get more than 100 percent state aid need to consolidate or get less aid.  There is enough money in the state, it’s just not allocated correctly,” Levante said.

Attorney Allen Dzwilewski of Schwartz Edelstein Law Group announced the “petition had been filed and served,” to a round of cheers from the assembled.   

“The points are clear.  The numbers speak for themselves,” Dzwilewski said.  He used the department of education’s own data to get a way from a long hearing process he explained.  “That way the Commissioner or Administrative Law Judge will have all of the material right in front of them.”

Dzwilewski said the underpinnings of their petition was that the “current appropriation was unreasonable, capricious and not equitable.”  The state has established guidelines and requirements school districts must use in providing a Thorough and Efficient Education.  He said it also requires funding to be “equitable, equal and predictable. Further [current state aid] does not follow legislation or administrative code requirements.”

Dr. James Lavender, Superintendent of Kingsway Regional School District in Gloucester County spoke, reiterating the attorney’s thoughts. “The funding shall be for equal benefit for all people in the state,” Lavender said.  “Instead it’s arbitrary and capricious creating haves and have nots.  The have nots are here in this room.”

Kingsway district has seen tremendous growth; 1600 additional students since 2008. James Muller President of the East Greenwich Township Kingsway Board of Education said they were the fastest growing district in the country for five years but their aid remains flat.  Teachers have 180 students on the roster and 35 in a class.

Lavender said their district is currently understaffed by 46. 

President of the Chesterfield School District Board of Education Jignesh Shah said their kindergarten to six district has grown from 280 to 760 yet their funding has remained flat.  Shah said, “At 11 percent of SFRA we are the lowest funded district in the state.  We should be getting $4 million but receive $419,000.” 

Shah said he looked forward to having something done to provide 'T and E.'  Their budget is $600,000 “in the red” this year and they anticipate laying off seven staff members.

Lavender was wearing several hats at the meeting; superintendent, taxpayer and parent.  “I’m tired of seeing nearby districts have what we can’t, what my children don’t.  Kingsway only receives 40 percent of SFRA, missing $10 million in aid.  We are over taxed and have had two failed referendum.  Taxpayers don’t want to pay another nickel.”

Lavender and Dunn were not the only districts in the suit where referendums have failed.  Middlesex School District in Middlesex County, also named in the suit, had a referendum fail by a 7:1 ratio.  Dr. Linda Madison, Superintendent of Middlesex School District said they have two schools more than 100 years old. 

“The high school was built in 1958 and the science labs have never been updated,” Madison said.  “We are struggling to provide sufficient facilities.”  The district does not have their own athletic fields and were looking to make repairs, upgrades and addition to the buildings with the referendum funding. 

Representatives from Fair Funding Action group were at the meeting.  Andrea Katz and Jennifer Cavallaro-Fromm have been lobbying legislators since 2012.  Cavallaro-Fromm and her husband Thomas Fromm, Mayor of Swedesboro are named on the petition. 

They had successfully lobbied Governor Christie to get “super growth appropriations.”

“We will keep working,” Katz said.  “Now 65 percent of the districts are talking to each other.”  

Muller said, “Our residents have been tapped out.  This can’t continue year after year.  My kids are no less important than the kids whose district gets 140 percent funding or more.”

Petitioners in the suit:
Boards of Education – Newton Middlesex, Little Ferry, Kingsway Regional, Jamesburg, Chesterfield Township, Emerson, Wallington, Swedesboro-Woolwich,

Municipalities- Town of Newton, Woolwich Township, East Greenwich Township, Borough of Swedesboro

Individuals – Benjamin Egner, Charles Fantasia, Michael Larsen, Alex Majewski, Dina Morris, Wayne Levante, E. Kevin Elvidge, Helen LeFrois, Daniel Flynn, Sandra Lee Diglio, Claribel Cortes, Gloria Gonzalez, Jennifer Nisonoff, Margaret Hallion, Belinda Blazic, James Mueller, James Lavender, Jennifer Cavallaro-Fromm, Thomas Fromm, Lorraine Flaherty, Dave Flaherty, George Weeks, Diane Hale, Jeff Hale, Michele Blair, Mia Randazzo, Michelle VanDiehl, Jaclyn Dopke, Lauren Ibbotson, Natalie Matthias and Dale Archer. 

The respondent is Kimberley Harrington, current New Jersey Commissioner of Education

 

TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Be Interested In

Sign Up for E-News

Newton

Newton Police: Car Crash Ends with Drug Arrest

June 20, 2018

NEWTON, NJ—A Stillwater woman is facing drug charges after crashing her car into a telephone pole on Monday, June 18 police said.

Newton police officers responded to a report of an accident around 9:16 a.m. near Tuscany Bistro on Route 206 .  The driver Samantha Benson, 30, was distracted after dropping a lit cigarette, causing her to crash, police report.

When Sgt Michael Monaco ...

Upcoming Events

Thu, June 21, 2:00 PM

Van Kirk Homestead Museum, Sparta

Summer Afternoon Garden Soiree

Home & Garden

Sat, June 23, 10:00 AM

CASA of Morris and Sussex Counties, Morristown

CASA Information Session

Sun, June 24, 1:00 PM

Van Kirk Homestead Museum, Sparta

Life Along the Wallkil River

Education

Carousel_image_dc175377b12fc03a60a8_toni4

Sun, July 8, 1:00 PM

Van Kirk Homestead Museum, Sparta

Sussex County Views: The Art of Toni Chaplin

Arts & Entertainment

Tue, July 17, 6:00 PM

CASA of Morris and Sussex Counties, Morristown

CASA Information Session

Education Giving Back Law & Justice

Carousel_image_42776b9cbb4ed47ca5de_paintbrush-pallet-

Mon, July 23, 10:00 AM

Sparta Public Library, Sparta

Watercolor Workshop

Arts & Entertainment

Carousel_image_2cec67206897437ad29b_sparta_historical_society

Sun, August 26, 1:00 PM

Van Kirk Homestead Museum, Sparta

Sussex County Views: The Art of Toni Chaplin

Arts & Entertainment

Sparta High School Students Visited by Modern Day Hero

June 16, 2018

SPARTA. NJ — The students in Andrew Lowery’s Heroes and Heroines senior English class had a special visitor last week. Gillian Lichota from iRise Above Breast Cancer foundation met with Lowery’s students and students from Kate Brennan’s Women’s Studies class as well as Emily Scott’s AP Government in Politics students.

The story of how Lichota came to be in ...

The Power of Positive Engagement

June 17, 2018

To the Editor:

I wanted to share this letter from Laurie Beacham, Media Director for NJ 11th for Change, about the notable increase in voter turnout and citizens deciding to run in the recent primary election:

"The 11th Congressional District has a lot to be proud of. In the June 5th primaries, voter turnout climbed from almost 33,000 in 2014 to over 86,000. Democratic ...

Again, Oroho, Space and Wirths Get It Wrong

On Wednesday, June 13th, a series of gun violence prevention bills were signed into law by Governor Murphy. These bills will strengthen our already strong gun laws in New Jersey and none of these new laws infringe on anyone’s right to keep and bear arms.   

Unfortunately, Senator Oroho and Assemblymen, Space and Wirths our Legislative District 24 representatives voted NO to a ...

Update: Police Break Up Fight Involving 40-50 People at Bridgewater Commons Mall

June 15, 2018

BRIDGEWATER, NJ — No injuries have been reported in an incident that shut down Bridgewater Commons Mall Thursday evening after a fight involving a crowd of 40-50 people.

Police are still investigating unconfirmed reports of shots being fired, according to the Somerset County Prosecutor's Office.

The mall is closed for the evening as the investigation continues.

Somerset County ...

2 Morristown Residents Help Take 1,500 Car Trips off NJ Roadways During Annual Bike to Work Challenge

CEDAR KNOLLS, NJ - Morristown residents Christopher Buck and Rebecca Karger were among the 150 commuters who embraced a more sustainable commute by trading in their car keys for pedals during TransOptions' annual Bike to Work Challenge.

Buck logged 832 miles and Karger recorded 38 trips during the month. Overall, participants took 1,379 trips, and ...

Why Buying a Home is Better Than Renting

People often ask if now is a good time to buy a home in New Jersey, but nobody ever asks whether or not it’s a good time to rent. Regardless, Team Nest Builder wants to make certain that everyone understands that now is NOT a good time to rent.

The Census Bureau recently released their 2018 first quarter median rent numbers. This graph from their report shows rent increases from 1988 ...

5 Fab Father's Day Happenings in Sussex & Morris Counties

Father’s Day hits this Sunday--what do YOU have planned? Team Nest Builder offers a slew of Father’s Day fun in Morris and Sussex County. Read on and surprise Dad with cool activities! (Be sure to check if registration is required prior to showing up!)

Alstede Farms' Father's Day Brunch – Chester

From 9am-noon, take a scenic hayride to a brunch buffet that offers ...

Don't Miss Sunday's OPEN HOUSE for 4BR Sparta Mountain Beauty

Perched handsomely on an acre in the beautiful SpartaMountain community, 28 Waters Edgeoffers a 4BR 2.5 Bathroom home with space and style. Come see for yourself this Sunday, June 17th, from 1-3pm at our OPEN HOUSE!

Located in the prestigious Sparta Mountain Reserve, this large, beautiful center hall colonial with open floor plan has a nice, level play yard with direct ...

Days on The Housing Market Drops to New Low

According to recently released data from the National Association of Realtors (NAR), the median number of days that a home spent on the market hit a new low of 26 days in April, as 57% of homes remained on the market for under a month.

NAR’s Chief Economist, Lawrence Yun, opined,

“What is available for sale is going under contract at a rapid pace. Since NAR began tracking this ...

June 13 Sussex County Board of Chosen Freeholders meeting

NEWTON, NJ - The June 13 Sussex County Board of Chosen Freeholders meeting video.

 

Pass It Along Triathlon

Tri-something new this July and sign up for the Pass It Along Triathlon!

The 9th annual Pass It Along Triathlon will take place on Saturday, July 28, 2018, at the Lake Mohawk Country Club. This triathlon features two USAT-certified courses - Olympic and Sprint. This triathlon has become a Sparta tradition and everyone is welcome to attend to cheer on athletes and be a part of the ...

Summer Hockey Programs at Skylands: 3v3, U8 and Beginner Hockey Camp

June 19, 2018

Skylands U8 Cross Ice Challenge League

Skylands Cross Ice Challenge League is an intermediate league for kids ages 8 and under. Emphasis on fun, skill progression, and player development, it de-emphasizes stressful, high-pressure, game scenarios and ultra-competitive play. It's focus is more on individual skating, player skills & puck touches
One practice per week ...

Update: Police Break Up Fight Involving 40-50 People at Bridgewater Commons Mall

June 15, 2018

BRIDGEWATER, NJ — No injuries have been reported in an incident that shut down Bridgewater Commons Mall Thursday evening after a fight involving a crowd of 40-50 people.

Police are still investigating unconfirmed reports of shots being fired, according to the Somerset County Prosecutor's Office.

The mall is closed for the evening as the investigation continues.

Somerset County ...