Religions and Spirituality

ISBR Mosque Plan Approved at Special Planning Board Meeting on Tuesday

bb20a87851fd16a694c3_IMG_5707.JPG
Revised plans for a 4,250-square-foot mosque in Liberty Corner was approved at a special Planning Board meeting on Tues., Aug. 8, at Ridge High School. Credits: By Linda Sadlouskos
bb20a87851fd16a694c3_IMG_5707.JPG

BERNARDS TWP., NJ - Planning Board members and Mayor Carolyn Gaziano voted for site plan approval for a proposed 4,250-square-foot mosque on Church Street in Liberty Corner Village on Tuesday at a court-mandated special hearing that was held in the aftermath of Bernards Township's legal settlement agreement with the Islamic Society of Basking Ridge,

The Planning Board's approval of the revised plan - reversing an earlier denial of the ISBR's mosque application by the Planning Board in December 2015 - is subject to further approvals from the Somerset County Planning Board and from Bernards Township Sewerage Authority for a sewer line extension.

ISBR Attorney Robert Raymar said that the project is still a few months away from final approvals and the drawing up of actual construction plans. But, he said of Tuesday's approval by the Bernards Planning Board, "This obviously is a step forward."

Sign Up for E-News

The 6-0 vote to approve the plan followed a brief public hearing at which former members of the Planning Board and other members of the public - including Jeffrey Plaza, who presided over the Planning Board during most of more than three years of hearings on the mosque proposal - offered critiques of the ISBR's revised site plan and the procedure, and even integrity, of Tuesday night's hearing.

A key change in the site plan for the proposed mosque was the reduction of required parking spaces from 107 to 50 on the four-plus acre lot at 124 Church St.

The settlement, approved in late May by a majority of the Bernards Township Committee and the Planning Board, required that change and also a payment of $3.25 million from Bernards Township to pay the ISBR for a combination of damages and legal costs. The settlement with the ISBR is published on the township website, Tuesday's "Whispering Woods" hearing was another outcome of the settlement.

The number of parking spaces had been set early in hearings on the mosque that began in 2012, when experts testified that attendees at worship services at the mosque were more likely to arrive alone or in pairs directly from their jobs. The rule of thumb for church parking is that an average of three attendees will arrive in each vehicle for religious services.

A federal judge ruled that some of the land use issues that were the Planning Board's basis for denial were as a result of the additional parking requirement. Lawsuits were filed by both the ISBR and US Department of Justice in federal court in 2016 alleging that the Planning Board's rejection was based on religious discrimination rather than land use laws.

At Tuesday's hearing, the revised plans submitted by the ISBR's experts showed 50 parking spaces, with 14 additional parking spots, if needed, on unpaved ground.

Gaziano, as a voting member of the Planning Board, said she believed that the Planning Board's original decision to reject the ISBR application was based on legitimate land use issues regarding a plan with 107 parking spaces. A plan with only 50 parking spaces addressed many of those issues, she said.

The three professionals that reviewed the revised site plans and documents submitted by the ISBR prior to Tuesday's hearing said they were in compliance with the settlement requirements.

But some of the speakers on Tuesday spoke against the process of the board's interpretaton of the Whispering Woods hearing.

"A Whispering Woods hearing gives residents an opportunity to comment on a settlement [proposal]," said resident Cody Smith. "You already approved a settlement," Smith told the Planning Board.

Kevin Orr, another speaker who is an attorney as well as a former Planning Board member, said he agreed with Smith.

"I believe the integrity of the process remains flawed," Orr said.

'Done Deal'

"It was a done deal before it even started," Orr said of Tuesday's hearing.

Plaza argued that the way the settlement agreement was stated, granting the lifting of personal liability for the Planning Board members as well Township Committee members who approved the settlement agreemeent, presented an inherent conflict of interest for four voting members of the Planning Board.

Raymar countered that the lawsuit only named members of the Planning Board in their professional, not personal, capacities. The township officials were not sued as individuals, he added.

Raymar also noted that the board's vote to approve the plan is subject to appeal.

[Information added] Other township residents said that some of the concerns raised during the original hearings, including a fire safety plan, a traffic flow plan for drop off of people entering the building, and stormwater management, have still not been resolved in the revised application.

Some speakers criticized the use of a fence to shield the proposed facility from a neighboring property, and said the neighbors will need to look at a 6-foot high fence.

Raymar said that the issues had been addressed in the new application documents, which had been subject to review by the township professionals. For example, he said the township fire official had reviewed the fire safety plan, and had recommended one small change, which he said was followed.

Thomas Quinn, the professional engineer for the Planning Board, noted that the township professionals had been "given a tight framework through which to review" the revised documents for the mosque projet.

Loretta Quick, the immediate neighbor of the mosque property, told the Planning Board she was afraid to say what she wanted for fear of violating the federal court order. She said the ISBR had "previously harassed and intimidated me" during the legal proceedings, and had pursued a court subpoena even seeking her personal email.

Another neighbor of project, Joseph Abbate of Somerville Road, had been a vocal critic of the project during the original hearings, but at Tuesday's hearing then asked only if street parking could be restricted near the intersection with Somerville Road. Afterward, he addressed the mosque representatives at the meeting by offering a "Welcome to the neighborhood."

 

 

 

 

TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Be Interested In

Sign Up for E-News

North Plainfield/Green Brook/Watchung

Thousands Expected for Sourland Music Festival

June 20, 2018

HILLSBOROUGH, NJ – The Sourland Music Festival will be held Saturday, June 23 from 3-10 p.m. at the Hillsborough Golf & Country Club at 146 Wertsville Road, rain or shine, to benefit the Sourland Conservancy.

Discounted advance-sale tickets are available online only, Children under 12 are admitted free.

“We’ve got a really powerful lineup of the region’s most ...

Third-annual Juneteenth Parade and Heritage Festival in New Brunswick this Weekend

NEW BRUNSWICK, NJ - The Vulcan Pioneers of New Brunswick, comprising the city's Black Fire Fighters Association, will host the Juneteenth Parade on Saturday, June 16 to commemorate the Emancipation Proclamation.

Juneteenth celebrations are held across the country to mark the announcement of the abolition of slavery in Texas in June 1865. That state was one of the last locations to learn of ...

Manutti Marina in Belmar: Top Choice for Boating, Fishing and All-Around Family Fun

BELMAR, NJ — It’s no secret that Belmar Manutti Marina ranks among the best boating destinations along the Atlantic coast.

Tucked along the eastern shoreline of the idyllic Shark River — just a five-minute trip by boat to the ocean — the state-of-the-art marina is a top choice among boaters looking to stay for the season, enjoy a vacation or spend the weekend.

In ...

Manutti Marina in Belmar: Top Choice for Boating, Fishing and All-Around Family Fun

June 12, 2018

BELMAR, NJ — It’s no secret that Belmar Manutti Marina ranks among the best boating destinations along the Atlantic coast.

Tucked along the eastern shoreline of the idyllic Shark River — just a five-minute trip by boat to the ocean — the state-of-the-art marina is a top choice among boaters looking to stay for the season, enjoy a vacation or spend the weekend.

In ...

Summer Camp Programs for Children and Teens Announced By Environmental Education Center

June 18, 2018

BERNARDS TWP., NJ – Each summer, the Environmental Education Center (EEC) in Basking Ridge holds programs that let children and teens explore nature for summer activities that both entertaining and an opportunity to learn about the environment.

The programs are organized and led by the EEC's staff of naturalists.

The EEC is a Somerset County facility located at 190 Lord ...

Get Empowered to Help Prevent Suicide

June 8, 2018

Dear Editor:

Over the past week social media and the news have been filled with stories and articles encouraging people to seek help if they’re in emotional distress. There have been countless articles about the need to break the silence around the topic of mental health and suicide, and I am encouraged by the support people are extending to others.

Often, the death by suicide by ...

Obituaries

South Plainfield, NJ – Margaret (Pascazio) Butfiloski, 99, passed away peacefully on June 2, ...
Read more

Upcoming Events

Mon, June 25, 9:00 AM

Terrill Road Baptist Chruch, Scotch Plains

Terrill Road Baptist Church

WHRHS Athletics: Watchung Hills Names New Athletic Director

June 19, 2018

WARREN, NJ - The Watchung Hills Board of Education announced a new Director of Athletics at its meeting on Tuesday night to replace Chris Van Vliet who has resigned. WHRHS world language teacher, Dan Root was unanimously approved as the WHRHS Director of Athletics effective July 1.

“I’m excited to work with newly appointed athletic director Mr. Root,” said WHRHS head football ...

A Path Forward for Watchung Schools Set for June 25

 

WATCHUNG, NJ - A Path Forward for Watchung Schools, a listening forum for Watchung parents, residents, and teachers to communicate to make Watchung Schools great, has been set for Monday, June 25. 

 

Watchung has three leadership positions open: Superintendent, Principal of Bayberry School, and Chief Administrator. The listening forum will be hosted and moderated by ...

WHRHS Athletics: 30 Watchung Hills Student Athletes Commit to Play College Sports

WARREN, NJ - Some 30 student athletes from the Watchung Hills Regional High School (WHRHS) Class of 2018 gathered  in the WHRHS Media Center for one last Warrior team photo before reporting to their intended respective colleges or universities in the fall.

Columbia, Yale and Princeton, Stevens, Rensselaer and M.I.T. are among some 27 other Division I, II, or III colleges ...

North Plainfield Board of Education Recognizes Student Athletes

NORTH PLAINFIELD, NJ - The North Plainfield Board of Education had the opportunity to celebrate the victories of the district's distinguished student athletes at the last Board of Education meeting.  Brandon Smith, Daniel Duncan, Trevor Sullivan, and Edgardo Villafane represented the Boys' Indoor Track Team.  The team was victorious as the New Jersey North II, Group II ...

Watchung’s Rizzi Ties Record at Rotary Track and Field Meet, North Plainfield Middle School Dominates in Awards Tally

PLAINFIELD, NJ - With an overcast sky and pleasantly cool temperatures, young student athletes from area middle schools and one elementary school gathered for the 91st Annual Rotary Track and Field Meet, held June 6 at the Hub Stine Athletic Complex in Plainfield.

Vincent Rizzi, holder of the Meet high jump records for boys ages 12 and 13, tried valiantly to best the 14 year old boys’ ...

North Plainfield Board of Education Recognizes 2018 Teachers of the Year

 

NORTH PLAINFIELD, NJ - North Plainfield School District's Teachers  of the Year were recognized at the Board of Education meeting on June 5, at West End School.  The evening began at 7:00 pm with a performance by the High School Jazz Band.  Opening remarks, made by  Human Resources Director, Phyllis Prestamo and Acting Superintendent ...

Thousands Expected for Sourland Music Festival

June 20, 2018

HILLSBOROUGH, NJ – The Sourland Music Festival will be held Saturday, June 23 from 3-10 p.m. at the Hillsborough Golf & Country Club at 146 Wertsville Road, rain or shine, to benefit the Sourland Conservancy.

Discounted advance-sale tickets are available online only, Children under 12 are admitted free.

“We’ve got a really powerful lineup of the region’s most ...

SCBP Biz Fest 2018 Draws Record Crowd

SOMERSET, NJ - More than 500 people attended Biz Fest 2018, Somerset County's ‘hyper-local’ trade show and networking event, on Thursday at the Imperia.

The Somerset County Business Partnership (SCBP) organized the event.  SCBP Vice President of Business Services Chris Edwards said that this year's Biz Fest was a huge success. 

"This has been ...