Overtime Hearbreak: North Salem Falls to Pleasantville

Tiger Amy Fetterolf looks to get off a shot. Credits: Deena Bell

NORTH SALEM, N.Y.— After working all the way back from a 10-goal deficit in the second half to force overtime, North Salem was on the verge of capping off a comeback for the ages.

No. 3-seeded Pleasantville, however, had other ideas.

Grace Capko’s goal in OT gave the host Panthers a 16-15 win over the sixth-seeded Tigers in the Section 1 Class D girls lacrosse quarterfinals on Friday, May 18.

Sign Up for E-News

Curran sparked the North Salem comeback charge with seven goals and an assist. Teammate Lydia Werlau had three goals and an assist.

“We had to want it,” Curran said of how they got back in the game. “We knew that was our game and we weren’t going to let them take it that easily. We all stepped up and played with grit. We had to play one goal at a time and focus on each possession until we caught up.”

Amy Fetterolf and Jane Fetterolf tallied two goals apiece. Kelly McCarthy netted one goal while Jessica Reiner made eight saves in the cage.

The Panthers jumped out to a 9-2 halftime lead.

“Pleasantville got their lead early on by winning the draws and scoring off of fast breaks over and over again,” Curran said.

A day earlier, North Salem easily disposed of visiting Blind Brook 18-3 in the opening round.

“We knew we were the stronger team but we had to go out on the field ready to play,” Curran said. “We were very successful on winning the draws, then our offense worked together to get assisted goals by sending cutters through the eight (meter).”

Werlau led the way with six goals and an assist. Jane Fetterolf (2G, 4A), Amy Fetterolf (2G, 2A), Curran (2G, 8 draw controls), Kelly McCarthy (2G, 1A), Jenny Murphy (1G, 1A) Colleen McCarthy (1G) and Jenna Shaughnessy helped stuff the stat sheet.

boys lax: irvington 9, north salem 7

Jake Lanyi had three goals and two assists in No. 10-seeded North Salem’s 9-7 loss to No. 7 Irvington in the Section 1 Class D opening round on May 19.

TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Be Interested In

Sign Up for E-News

North Salem

More than just a book store

What consistently rates 4.9 to 5.0 on the major customer review sites? What business is both destination and resource, a tradition, a haven, valued, endangered and has something for everyone, at every age? 
Hands down, it is your local independent bookstore. They have faced challenges (think “When Harry Met Sally”) and still do (um, Amazon), but those that remain have carved out ...

My Perfect Summer Weekend

I’m so excited to be preparing for a summer jam-packed with diversions! Memorial Day weekend is my official kick-off, but this year the week leading up to the holiday really set the tone for what I’m sure will be a season of adventure. So, while I’m busy planning my routes and exploring new places, I’ll just highlight what I did and where I went and hopefully your ...

Easy as PIE

Lately I’ve been fascinated by a new flavor of pie: psychologically informed environments (PIE). 
This “enabling environment” concept originally appeared as a kind of operational framework for therapeutic communities such as homeless resettlement and social services. I’ll spare you the footnotes and scholarly citations and just sum it up in lay terms: We are affected ...