On the World Scene

He Said, She Said, and the Truth

We spend so much time teaching our children not to bully one another and not to gossip, but all too often adults don’t practice what they preach, especially given the often toxic and viral nature of social media.

Given the series of events last week regarding a disputed story involving the Somers girls and Yorktown boys lacrosse players, it seems that Somers school administrators were bullied into making premature statements.

Many people are so quick to judge—and to judge publicly—without any deference to due process and the concept of “innocent until proven guilty,” which are the hallmarks of our justice system.

Sign Up for E-News

The impetus was an anonymous letter claiming that the Somers girls lacrosse players had been using the Yorktown boys locker room and were in various states of being undressed when members of the boys team deliberately came in and began taunting them, with one or more boys suggesting that the boys get undressed as well.

While this letter went viral on social media, our editor began receiving letters demanding that we publish this story.

If true, surely the alleged victims deserved to have their story told. However, the only problem with this entire story was that it was he said/she said, and we don’t publish stories based on anonymous accusations. The only exception to this rule would be if the person revealed their identity to us, was credible, and their motive for remaining hidden was fear of retaliation.

The only other exception would be if school officials began publicly talking about the matter, which is what happened last week when Somers administrators released a statement siding with the Somers girls lacrosse players. At that point, we had an obligation to publish something.

On Tuesday of last week, Somers Superintendent Dr. Raymond Blanch issued a statement saying that members of the Yorktown team engaged in harassing and intimidating behavior. But by Thursday, Blanch walked back his initial statement, saying he did not intend to implicate the entire Yorktown team, that the boys team entered the locker room unaware that the girls were in there, and that there was no evidence of sexual harassment.

When I spoke with a couple of Somers parents who were totally unaware of the alleged incident and were never notified by the anonymous writers before the letter went viral, they told me that their daughters didn’t know what the hubbub was all about, and their daughters didn’t witness the worst actions described in the anonymous letter even though they were present in the locker room. The parents also said their daughters had, in fact, witnessed typical banter expected of any opposing team and were not at all intimidated by it.

In addition, my sources describe a heated exchange this past Monday afternoon at a meeting with the Somers parents.

“Everything is he said, she said,” one of my sources said, describing the meeting. “I cannot confirm any version of events and neither can anyone else.” 

So, what explains the anonymous letter in light of the Somers administration walking back their statement and in light of the mitigating statements made by my own sources?

There is a saying that there are three sides to every story: his side, her side and the truth. With this story, I think the truth is that with a couple dozen girls in the locker room, there were a couple dozen different perceptions of events. That’s human nature. Clearly, a few girls felt very uncomfortable by what happened, regardless of the boys’ intentions, and other girls may have perceived things differently, and even positively, according to a source.

The anonymous letter writer and a couple of other parents were understandably protective of their daughters and they sent out a letter claiming to represent everyone. As a father of a girl myself, I could understand if several other parents jumped on the bandwagon out of concern for their daughters.

The social media mob shared the anonymous letter and accepted it as fact. Had the letter remained something directed toward administrators, we might have gotten a thorough—and private—investigation. But the viral nature of the letter on social media put pressure on the school district to make a statement too quickly.

In one of the letters sent out to parents, the person wrote, “We owe it to our girls,” and I’m sympathetic to that statement. But part of protecting our girls is preventing a frenzy. We also owe it to our boys to not convict them in the media and to not assume they are sexual predators. Just as there were different perceptions among the girls, the boys certainly perceived things through their own individual lenses. In reality, the solution is not to place a scarlet letter on the boys, but to ensure this type of encounter never happens again. 

In the movie “Doubt,” a priest described gossip as tearing a hole in a pillow, letting the feathers out, and then attempting to gather all of them back. An impossible task.

The victims of this viral story surely are the majority of the boys who didn’t engage with the girls in the way described in the letter as well as the girls who don’t feel represented by the anonymous accusations or are embarrassed by the media attention. The horse is out of the barn, but hopefully this column will help clean up some of the mess.

Editor's Note:  On the World Scene is a column written by Brett Freeman, publisher of Halston Media, franchisee/publisher of TAPinto Mahopac, North Salem, Somers, and Yorktown.

The opinions expressed herein are the writer's alone, and do not reflect the opinions of TAPinto.net or anyone who works for TAPinto.net. TAPinto.net is not responsible for the accuracy of any of the information supplied by the writer.

TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Like

Sign Up for E-News

North Salem

The Crisis in America

America has reached a crisis involving the leadership of our nation, which I believe can only be solved by the resignation of Donald J.  Trump as president of the United States. This would avert the possible impeachment of Donald Trump for alleged high crimes and misdemeanors against the United States.

Why am I asking President Trump to resign the office to which he has been legally ...

The Waning of Free Speech

Until the last few years, there was what seemed to be an untouchable status quo in the United States that everyone was entitled to free speech, even if the person was a bigot and their speech was hateful. We had the First Amendment standing behind this protection. When word came, decades ago, that Nazis were planning a march on Skokie, Ill., home of many Jewish Holocaust survivors, this ...

Beer Here!

Anybody who’s ever stepped foot inside a sports stadium knows this clarion call: “Beer here!”

When it comes to suds, I was the teetotaler of my frat house (AEPi Syracuse, for those into Greek culture). Notwithstanding, my given name being a homophone for the modestly alcoholic beverage (you know, Bruce…brews), in my early adulthood, beer and I were not exactly ...

Something Smells Fishy Here

We’ve had our fair share of goldfish. Most of them were won at a local fairs and carnivals so I could understand if they may not have been the healthiest fish in the world. However, I’ve had friends who’ve had pet goldfish like mine that lasted for a dozen years (the fish, not the friends), so maybe it’s not the fish… maybe it’s us.

Either way, we ...

Re-casting Politics 'Madmen' and 'Blind'

August 23, 2017

Alvin Lobell, in his letter to the editor of Aug.10, attempts to give us food for thought, but unfortunately it provided little to no nourishment.

In the lofty words of Shakespeare’s “King Lear,” Mr. Lobell fashions himself to be the arbiter of who are the “madmen” and who are the “blind.” The only problem is that the facts fail to support his ...

North Salem Man Allegedly Stabs Woman With Kitchen Knife

August 10, 2017

NORTH SALEM, N.Y.--Miguel A. Morales, 58, of North Salem, was arrested Aug. 6 for second-degree assault following a domestic dispute during which he allegedly stabbed a woman.

State Police were dispatched to a domestic incident on Sugar Hill Road after receiving a 911 call at approximately 5:27 p.m.

Neighbors said they saw a woman being removed from the house on a stretcher, and a shirtless ...