NUTLEY, NJ - The Nutley Police Department reports that an 18-year-old Nutley man has been arrested and charged in connection with breaking into multiple vehicles in the township. The resident is also charged with stealing one vehicle.

Keith McNei Jr. made headlines earlier this week as the "Shirtless, Masked Bandit" after being captured on surveillance video entering vehicles while wearing a surgical mask. An accomplice was also seen in some video footage.

According Public Safety Alphonse Petracco and Chief Thomas Strumolo, police responded to Hay Ave and Villa Place early Sunday morning where six cars had been entered and numerous items stolen. At that time, it was reported that he also had a stolen Infinity G35 on Villa Place.

Sign Up for Nutley Newsletter
Our newsletter delivers the local news that you can trust.

Police arrested McNei Jr. of Nutley and charged him with six counts of burglary, one count of auto theft and one count of conspiracy. McNei was also found to be wanted by Florence Township Police for auto theft. Officers of that department took custody of him in the evening of Tuesday July 21 after Nutley charges were filed.

Detective Lt. Antony Montanari of the Nutley Police Department reported that police  recovered the stolen vehicle in Passaic. Charges against McNei’s accomplice are imminent.

Chief Strumolo said, "the department has a very high percentage of arrests related to motor vehicle burglaries. Typically, one or two actors are responsible for several burglaries. He said this year alone we have had nineteen people arrested or charged with crimes committed in Nutley, and each of these arrests had multiple vehicles involved."

Police Director Alphonse Petracco commended the Officers and Detectives that were able to identify the actor so quickly. He said that entry into unlocked motor vehicles is something many towns are experiencing. Nutley residents have been reminded to lock their doors, but often neglect to do so, which makes incidents like this continue to occur.

Related article: Shirtless, Masked Bandit Target Unlocked Vehicles in Nutley

Home cameras have played a critical role in identifying thieves in Nutley. In 2019, a Ring unit capured the "droopy pants bandit" who was later identified, arrested and charged.  Droopy Pants Bandit Makes Off With Packages From Nutley Home


For more police news, read the Police and Fire section of TAPinto Nutley. Every week, we also publish the complete, unedited Nutley Police Department Blotter. 

Since 2016,  has been the only locally owned news organization serving the Township of Nutley, and is a member of the New Jersey Press Association. The Nutley Board of Commissioners first named the township's 'Official Electronic News Source'  in 2019.

Stay informed, sign up for our FREE daily eNews. Like us on Facebook, follow us on Twitter @TAPintoNutley  and Instagram @TAPintoNutley  Questions? Email us at