Paterson Top Stories

Cops vs. City Council: A Shootout Looms Over Overtime

4f343aebe7fcb1bc582b_copcar.jpg
4f343aebe7fcb1bc582b_copcar.jpg
PATERSON, NJ – The City Council and Paterson’s police officers appear to be on a collision course.
 
On Wednesday, an attorney representing Paterson’s two police unions filed legal papers seeking to quash the city council’s subpoena for nine officers to testify in the flood overtime hearings.
In response, Council Finance Chairman Kenneth Morris on Wednesday night suggested to his colleagues that they not approve any overtime for any city police officers until the nine officers show up for the flood inquiry.
 
“If they’re not willing to come forward, how can we verify that overtime?’’ Morris said. “To me, that calls into question all overtime.’’
 

“We’re not going to engage in a public do-and-pony show,’’ said Charles Sciarra, attorney for the Paterson Policemen’s Benevolent Association locals that representing rank-and-file and superior police officers.
 
Michael DeMarco, the special counsel representing the city council in the hearings, said he received word on Wednesday that the unions were seeking to quash the subpoenas. He also said the unions have indicated they previously registered their opposition to the subpoenas in October. But DeMarco said he has not yet seen that correspondence.
 
The City Council already has refused to pay $209,000 in overtime for city employees for the two weeks after the first wave of flood checks were issued on the grounds that the administration has not provided documentation to verify the time. That action already has prompted the police and fire unions, whose members would receive the bulk of the money, to file contract grievances.
 
In regard to the overtime hearings, Sciarra said the unions maintain that police officers are governed by “different statutory and regulatory provisions’’ which allow them not to appear at the city council inquiry. The unions’ motion likely will be decided upon in January, he said.
 
“That’s not remotely to suggest that there’s a concern about the content of the police officers’ testimony if they were to testify,’’ Sciarra said.
 
The nine officers who were called are:
·   Lt. Patrick Papagni, who collected $5,350 in net overtime in the first round of flood overtime checks. During his testimony, Wittig said Papagni was one of two people who collected overtime forms from rank-and-file officers during the flooding.
·   Sgt. Kelley Hemmings, who collected $7,002 in net overtime in the first round of flood overtime checks. His was the largest check issued by the city. City documents show Hemmings put in for 18 hours of overtime on six consecutive days.
·   Officer Antonio Blasucci, who collected $6,306 in net overtime in the first round of flood overtime checks.
·   Sgt. Alex Popov, who collected $6,253 in net overtime in the first round of flood overtime checks. Popov, a former lieutenant demoted during the city’s spring budget cuts, runs the police department’s disaster operations, Wittig said. The chief said Popov also handled officers’ overtime submissions, along with Papagni.
·   Sgt. Manuel Hernandez, who collected $5,882 in net overtime in the first round of flood overtime checks.
·   Sgt. Lazzaro Mazza, who collected $5,740 in net overtime in the first round of flood overtime checks.
·   Sgt. Christopher Straub, who collected $5,142 in net overtime in the first round of flood overtime checks.
·   Deputy Police Chief William Fraher, who received no overtime during the flood, as stipulated in the union contract.
·   Deputy Police Chief Danny Nichols, who received no overtime during the flood, as stipulated in the union contract.
 
The city council has threatened to file contempt of court charges against the officers, but that decision will wait until after the union’s court order seeking to quash the subpoenas is resolved.
 
Two other employees who previously had not appeared at the hearings in response to the city council’s subpoenas showed up for the first time Wednesday night. Health Officer Trevor Weigle gave about 35 minutes of testimony, while Deputy Fire Chief Kevin Hancock was in attendance but not asked to testify.
 
The council has concluded its inquiry on overtime paid to the mayor and his Cabinet, and plans to issue its findings next month. But the council also plans to conduct additional hearings on overtime procedures in the police, fire and health departments.
 
Sciarra said the police unions are not contesting the city council right to conduct its inquiry, but simply maintain their members are covered by different provisions. Sciarra said that if there were any questions about the officers’ overtime, the issue should be referred either to an outside law enforcement agency to the Paterson Police Department’s Internal Affairs Division.
 
“This is a procedural issue,’’ Sciarra said.
 
Councilman William McKoy, chairman of the public safety committee, said he found the unions’ attempt to quash the subpoenas “intriguing.’’ McKoy pointed out that Police Chief James Wittig has been regularly complying with the subpoena and has testified in the proceedings.
 
“I find it strange to see that lower level officers have found this caveat to thwart the investigation or review of this council,’’ McKoy said.
 
McKoy also took note of the fact that Fraher and Nichols would not show up and pointed out that the two of them were lead candidates to replace Wittig when he soon retires. Their absence, McKoy, is something the council should remember when it votes on Wittig’s successor.
 

 

TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Be Interested In

Sign Up for E-News

Paterson

City Council Candidate to Voters: Let Your Voice Be Heard

February 20, 2018

Dear Editor:

It is very important for the citizens of Paterson to participate in local city-wide elections because elected officials can help determine the economic, educational and social well-being of entire communities. For example, two very important tasks of city council members include making laws and allocating money.

Elected officials are the gatekeepers for millions of dollars in ...

Dreams for Service Dog for Autistic Montville Resident Become Reality

February 22, 2018

MONTVILLE, NJ - Faith Stanley, a Towaco resident and a single mother of four boys, sought help for her youngest son, Joey, who is almost three years old and diagnosed with autism. Amazingly enough, Faith found the help she needed!

Due to the generosity and help of so many people, Faith has managed to reach her goal of raising ...

Paterson Hosts Statewide Event as National El Sistema Leader

February 22, 2018

PATERSON—On March 10, nearly 300 students from seven New Jersey immersive ensemble music learning programs will converge in Paterson for the 4th annual Fiddlefest and Falala Festival. A day of music making and a celebration of culture and community for both the students and their families, the festival features the Paterson-based program Paterson Music Project (PMP), in addition to the New ...

How to Talk with Kids About the Florida Shooting

February 15, 2018

The tragedy of the Florida school shooting is devastating, leaving 17 killed and 15 injured. Our children can easily identify with what occurred yesterday. It will be the topic of conversation today in schools everywhere. School administrators are doing all they can to provide support and guidance. The shootings affect children, teachers, and school personnel. The school shooting ...