Paterson Top Stories

Hodges and Irving Face Removal From School Board Over Fingerprinting Deadline



PATERSON, NJ – Two city school board members – Jonathan Hodges and Christopher Irving – are among 185 around New Jersey who the state education department says must leave their positions for not having their background checks completed.

Both Paterson school commissioners say they have signed up for the fingerprinting and background checks and are simply awaiting appointments to get the work done. The state, however, says that is not good enough.

Sign Up for E-News

“These members were contacted and failed to comply,’’ said a statement issued by Department of Education spokeswoman Allison Kobus. “Because they have failed to comply with the background check law, they have been notified that they are ineligible to serve and must immediately vacate their position.’’

The education department's enforcement of the law has created confusion and controversy statewide.

Hodges said he’s received no official word that he’s being removed from the board – just calls from reporters telling him his name is on the state’s list. The recent letter he received from the state simply urged school board members to comply with the background check law, Hodges said. He didn’t view the letter as a problem.

“I have complied,’’ said Hodges. “I’m trying to get the state to figure out where they made this screw-up.

Hodges said officials at Paterson Public Schools as well as at the state school board association have told him that he simply needed to take the first step by signing up for the background checks before January to comply with the law. Irving said he was told the same thing

In late December, asked the education department exactly what board members needed to do in order to comply with the new law. “Board members have to start the process for background checks by the Dec. 31st date,’’ said Kobus in an email. “You’ll need to reference the law for details regarding disqualification.’’ 

Since the bill was signed into law at the end of May 2011, three notifications were sent to school boards and chief school administrators, in July, October and early December, according to Kobus’ statement.

Hodges has said he registered for the background check on December 30 and has his fingerprinting scheduled for February 20. Irving said he signed up for the background check on December 22 and had a January 3 appointment to get the fingerprinting done. But then, Irving said, a conflict with work emerged, so he rescheduled the fingerprinting for the third week of January.

The state, however,  is providing an opportunity for board members to be back in their positions soon enough. Under state law, the 21 county superintendents of schools have the authority to pick people to fill the seats that become open because of the background check law, Kobus said.

“The person who is not in compliance and therefore removed from the board by receipt of the ineligibility letter could be appointed to fill the vacancy,’’ according to Kobus’ statement. “However as a new appointment, that person would have to abide by the law which dictates that new appointees must comply with the criminal history background check in 30 days. The person who was deemed ineligible is not given statutory preference over other candidates.’’

The number of New Jersey school board members and charter school trustees in danger of losing their seats as a result of the background check law could grow higher than 185. The education department said some filled out the forms incorrectly, while others have not yet paid the requisite fees. As a result, the records of their background check have not yet been released to the education department, the state said.

“Our office is still reviewing these cases and the information will be released once the issues are resolved,’’ said Kobus.

The education department did not say whether any New Jersey school board members have been removed because they failed their background checks.

It was not clear yesterday whether Passaic County Superintendent of Schools planned to appoint Hodges and Irving back onto the Paterson Board of Education.

Paterson Public Schools spokeswoman Terry Corallo said there had been a “communication issue that we’re trying to get resolved.’’ As of Thursday afternoon, the school district had received no official word from Trenton on Hodges’ and Irving’s status, she said.

For Hodges, the prospect of being disqualified from the school board over the background checks is particularly upsetting because he had considering not going through with the fingerprinting because he saw it as an infringement of his privacy. He called the law “capricious and arbitrary” because he said there are no known cases of school board members with criminal records who have harmed students.

“I reluctantly went through this unjust and unnecessary system,’’ he said.

TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Be Interested In

Sign Up for E-News


Assemblyman Benjie Wimberly Seeks Input on State Budget

April 17, 2018

Dear Editor:

As one of only 12 members on the New Jersey General Assembly’s Budget Committee, I am in the unique position to question New Jersey’s commissioners, those charged with leading our state's various departments, on the specifics of the FY 19 budget that Governor Murphy has proposed. As you may know, this budget must be passed by June 30, 2018.

From education to ...

Newark Mayor Ras Baraka Shares Secret of Newark’s Success in Paterson

April 18, 2018

PATERSON, NJ- With new construction dotting its neighborhoods, control of the schools back in local hands, and a spot on the list of finalists to land Amazon’s proposed second headquarters, Newark is a city on the rise.

It is with the state’s largest city’s upward trajectory in mind, and contemplation of their own city’s future, that several prominent Paterson leaders ...

Paterson Music Project Joins New Jersey’s Newest Youth Ensemble to Perform Bernstein Classic

April 18, 2018

“Somewhere…there’s a place for us.”  So goes one of the most beautiful songs Leonard Bernstein ever wrote—part of the legendary musical West Side Story.

On Sunday, April 22nd, children of a unique New Jersey music education alliance will perform the song on the stage of the New Jersey Performing Arts Center to open a New Jersey Symphony Orchestra ...

Organizations Team Up to Make Prom Dreams Come True

April 5, 2018

On March 29 the Paterson Great Falls Rotary ClubTAPinto hosted their annual prom dress giveaway. This year they joined with several other groups, making the event bigger than ever. TAPinto Paterson reader, and Great Falls Rotary Club Director, Debra Flower shared this piece abut how the event started, what it’s become, and where it’s going.

Paterson Great Falls Rotary Club ...