Real Estate

Court Ruling Cripples Effort in Hillsborough to Save Doris Duke Mansion from Demolition

9be04eccb9a0b6f3c352_hillspixdorisdukeestatepostcard1.jpg
Vintage postcard shows the Duke estate as it appeared in 1915
c6161b737d9dd635a291_hillspixDORISsign.jpg
DORIS - Destruction of Mansion is Senseless - was organized in July, 2015 by residents opposed to the demolition.
93510dd66e50107fc3a3_sompixdorisdukedavidbrook__1_.JPG
Hillsborough resident and attorney David Brook has been leading the fight to save the Duke estate from demolition. Credits: Rod Hirsch
9be04eccb9a0b6f3c352_hillspixdorisdukeestatepostcard1.jpg

SOMERVILLE, NJ – A ruling handed down by Superior Court Judge Yolanda Ciccone Friday effectively derails efforts by a Hillsborough grass roots organization to save the Doris Duke estate from demolition.

DORIS – Demolition of Residence is Senseless – has been waging a non-stop battle with the Dukes Farm Foundation, Doris Duke Charitable Foundation, Hillsborough Township and the township’s Historic Preservation Commission since July, when the foundation first applied for a demolition permit to knock down the 67,000 square-foot mansion.

David Brook, the outspoken attorney representing DORIS, expects to file an appeal in the Appellate Division early next week.

Sign Up for E-News

However, that may be too late.

“Duke can do whatever they want now,” Brook said just hours after receiving the court decision. “They have the demolition permit. If the equipment is there, they can go out there tonight and start knocking it down.

“I would like to believe the system is set up to correct errors,” Brook said, “but I think the system failed.”

Brook, along with William J. Willard, the attorney for Hillsborough Township, and Jeffrey T. LaRosa, attorney for the Duke Farms Foundation spent one hour in Ciccone’s courtroom Feb. 26.

DORIS was hoping that Ciccone would overturn some of the actions taken by the HPC, and return their appeal to the township board for reconsideration.

“The Court finds that the Township neither abused its discretion, nor deprived Plaintiffs of due process,” Ciccone wrote in her seven-page opinion.

At one time, the Duke mansion was the centerpiece of the estate, which spreads across 2,700 acres fronting on Route 206 South. Doris Duke inherited the property and her father’s tobacco fortune after a bitter custody battle with her mother. James Buchanan Duke died in 1925.

Duke remodeled the mansion, adding substantial square footage to the building. She died in 1993. It has not been occupied since 2008 and has fallen into disrepair.

LaRosa told Ciccone the foundation estimates it would cost upwards of $20M to restore the mansion and that the building does not conform to the overall mission of the foundation, which continues to transform the property into an ecological preserve and nature education center. More than 500,000 visitors come to Duke Farms annually.

The mansion has been stripped of all significant architectural elements, including fountains, fireplace mantels, panels made from exotic woods, chandeliers, sconces and other fixtures; all were sold at auction.

LaRosa has also argued that the mansion’s historic significance was compromised by the alterations and additions made to the original structure over the years.

Brook maintains the mansion does belong on the National Registry of Historic Places, and has referred to a voluminous application completed by Duke in 1986 - but never submitted to the agency - seeking historic status for the estate and surrounding property.

DORIS has offered testimony and filed documents at several HPC meetings in September and October that faulted procedures, claimed violation of open public meeting laws and questioned the credibility of testimony from an expert witness used by the commission to make its determination.

The HPC voted 6-1 to approve the demolition permit.

DORIS repeated accusations at the Feb. 26 hearing before Ciccone that the process was flawed and that the actions taken by the HPC were “arbitrary and capricious.”

However, Ciccone did not find fault with the board’s decision granting the demolition permit, or the process leading to that determination.

“HTHPC had adequate basis in fact and opinion to approve the demolition and acted in conformity with the appropriate law when approving DFF’s application. It would be inappropriate for the Court to substitute its own judgment of the evidence for the judgment of local citizens with an intimate knowledge of the community’s interest in preserving historic sites.”

“Disturbing, disturbing, disturbing,” Brook said. “This is an erroneous decision.”

Other highlights from Ciccone’s ruling:

“Plaintiffs contend that the Commission hearings and the Commission’s conclusions were predetermined. Plaintiffs allege that there was no effort on the part of this Commission to attempt in any fashion to honestly and with due consideration take in information and make a decision based on the record and conduct a proper application of the record to the requirements in the Municipal Ordinance.

“Plaintiffs’ allegations lack support in the form of proofs. Plaintiffs have produced no evidence that indicates that the hearing process was a ‘sham proceeding’ driven by ‘politics and money,’ “

The Court finds that the Township neither abused its discretion, nor deprived Plaintiffs of due process.”

“This is so discouraging,” Brook said. Everyone put their heart and soul into it. We’re all so discouraged.”  

TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Be Interested In

Sign Up for E-News

Piscataway

TapInto Welcomes Letters to the Editor, Guidelines for Submission Listed

PISCATAWAY, NJ - Letters to the Editor are a time-honored tradition in the newspaper industry and now that so much of news has moved online, the letters explaining a personal point of view have moved with it.

While many of our letters come during election time, TapInto invites letters year round. The main rules are to include a full name, phone number, email and snail mail address. TapInto ...

To Our Current and Future Representatives

July 17, 2018

To Our Current and Future Representatives - Wherever They May Be:

We can never forget we are a nation of immigrants. 

We cannot fall prey to fear, ignorance and anger when we  have been historically driven by freedom and justice. 

We must have the courage and will to fight hate, bigotry and prejudice. 

We must not wake up to what we hoped was a bad dream and ...

New Brunswick Battles Hunger with Largest Food Pantry Network in County

July 17, 2018

NEW BRUNSWICK, NJ - The Rev. Douglas Shepler became pastor of New Brunswick's Second Reformed in April 2008 and by October had a food pantry running that quickly attracted people in need, including Rutgers University students.

“We had graduate students coming to us and they had a choice of paying their rent or paying for food,” Shepler said. However, those students ...

Obituaries

Hillsborough, NJ - Gina (Francoisa) Salamon, 90, died Monday, July 9, 2018 at Bridgeway Care Center ...
Read more
Piscataway – Michael John Doherty, 73, passed away Saturday June 16, 2018 in Las Vegas, ...
Read more

New Outlook Pioneers hosts 18th Music in the Park at Milt Campbell Field

July 15, 2018

Plainfield, NJ - On Thursday, August 2, 2018 at 5PM Sponsored by: The City of Plainfield (including the Cultural & Heritage and Human Relations Commissions), Mayor Adrian Mapp and the Union County Board of Chosen Freeholders; along with CO-SPONSORS: New Outlook Pioneers, Mr. Plainfield (Robert Graham),TD+Partners -A Community Impact Development Firm, and Re/Max Select, Sandra L.

Cruising with Autism on the Seas

This is a event that includes the partnership and collaboration of Cruise Planners, Autism Friendly Escapes and WallynZavy's Autistic Kids Can Do!. WallynZavy's Autistic Kids Can Do is a non-profit 5013c, organization that supports families that have autistic and special needs children through advocacy, social play dates, resources, workshops, community support, seminars and family ...

Piscataway Library Accepting Diaper Donations Now Through July 31st

The Piscataway Public Library is helping the Central Jersey Diaper Bank collect diaper donations through the month of July. 

New or open packs of disposable baby diapers (all sizes) and wipes are needed.

Look for the blue bins at either Kennedy or Westergard to donate!

RU Ready for Rutgers Football? Tickets on Sale Next Week

NEW BRUNSWICK, NJ - There's a lot of promotions planned this fall as part of the Rutgers football season.

Single game tickets go on sale Thursday, July 12, with seven home games. There's matchups against Big Ten East opponents Michigan and Penn State, and a first-time cross divisional meeting with Northwestern.

If football is not your thing, there's plenty ...

Upcoming Events

Wed, July 18, 7:30 PM

Chatham United Methodist Church, Chatham

Masterwork’s Summer Sing Four to Feature Brahms

Arts & Entertainment

Sat, July 21, 10:00 AM

NJ Convention and Exposition Center, Edison

82nd Annual Garden State Cat Show & Expo

Giving Back Other

Sun, July 22, 10:00 AM

NJ Convention and Exposition Center, Edison

82nd Annual Garden State Cat Show & Expo

Giving Back Other

Sun, July 22, 11:00 AM

Columbia Park Senior Center, Dunellen

Bus Trip to SOPAC's Hunchback of Notre Dame ...

Arts & Entertainment

Mon, July 23, 10:00 AM

NJ Convention and Exposition Center, Edison

82nd Annual Garden State Cat Show & Expo

Giving Back Other

Residents Taking Action Against White Supremacist Fliers Found Around Bridgewater, Bedminster, Other Local Areas

July 17, 2018

BRIDGEWATER, NJ - Residents of Bridgewater, Somerville, Morristown and surrounding communities are mobilizing for action after they found posters around town promoting Identity Evropa, which the Anti-Defamation League (ADL) has labeled a white supremacist group.

According to Bridgewater resident Stacey Friedlander, a member of the “Not In Our Town – Bridgewater/Raritan” ...

Big Changes in Store for New Jersey’s Employers and Employees

July 15, 2018

Big changes are in store for New Jersey’s workplaces, with dramatic legislation aimed at improving conditions for New Jersey’s workers. These changes include the enactment of New Jersey’s Equal Pay Act, a new law to help the unemployed, and passage of New Jersey’s Paid Sick Leave Act. Most likely one or all these laws will impact you or someone in your family.

New ...

Extra Time

It was close to 70 minutes into the match and I had to go to the bathroom.  Badly.

As fans watching the World Cup know too well, bathroom breaks are a serious dilemma, especially for those who don’t have a TV in the loo.  This biological necessity is exasperated by beer, which during World Cup matches also fuels a strong propensity to throw chairs and instigate riots.