Middlesex County News

Jury To Decide If New Brunswick Man Murdered a College Student

Timothy Puskas enters the courtroom on Friday, Jan. 6.

NEW BRUNSWICK, NJ - A jury is deciding whether a city man beat and left for dead Billy McCaw, a 22-year-old college student, on a cold, snowy weekend three years ago in a New Brunswick backyard.

Timothy Puskas, who lived a block from the Hartwell Street property where McCaw was found on Feb. 15, 2014 after being bludgeoned to death, has pleaded not guilty to murdering the Kean University student.

Both the defense and the prosecution presented closing arguments on Friday, painting vastly-different pictures of what happened the night of the slaying and during the subsequent police investigation.

Sign Up for E-News

“There is not a hair. There is not a fiber. There is not a drop of blood,” defense attorney Joseph Mazraani said. “There is nothing connecting Tim to the crime scene, nothing connecting Tim to this victim.”

The police investigation of the murder was flawed since its inception, Mazraani claimed. He said pressure from higher-ups and the Rutgers community pushed detectives to target an “innocent local” who was incapable of killing McCaw, a former Rutgers student.

The investigation relied on the word of several “rats” who lived with Puskas on Plum Street, Mazraani said. He claimed some people tried to frame Puskas because he planned to inform police of a burglary ring with which they were involved.

“Folks, a foundation built by rats cannot withstand this storm,” Mazraani told the jury. “It just cannot.”

Meanwhile, the defense attorney said, police overlooked leads that could have nailed the killer. Other possible perpetrators included a man who was found in possession of McCaw’s cellphone, young men who were jealous of McCaw spending time with their girlfriends and individuals who were involved with drugs, Mazraani claimed.

He said police and prosecutors merely performed a “surface scratching” of these other leads and instead let their “narrative” decide the course of the investigation.

In her closing statement, Middlesex County Assistant Prosecutor Bina Desai decidedly disagreed with Mazraani’s portrayal of the murder investigation.

“This was not a rush to judgment like the defense would have you believe,” she said. “The evidence led to the defendant’s arrest, not the other way around.”

Detectives looked into other possible killers and scenarios, but Puskas emerged as the killer, Desai claimed.

Some of his roommates claimed to have heard someone, presumably Puskas, leave his home around the believed time of the murder, a claim cast into doubt by Mazraani.

Although some of the prosecution’s witnesses were not exactly upstanding citizens, they were the people who lived with and knew Puskas, she said.

The defense theorized that McCaw may have met up with other friends before being attacked. Desai noted that no one has come forward with such information.

“You’d also have to believe that the people he was drinking with were the ones that killed him,” she added.

The prosecution and the defense disagreed on the likely time of McCaw’s death and the route he took to get to Hartwell Street.

McCaw was killed after a night of partying at two Rutgers frat houses. From there, prosecutors believe he walked down Hamilton Street and encountered an enraged Puskas on or near Hartwell.

Desai portrayed Puskas as an enraged man who was upset after a divorce and a theft from his bank account. He walked the streets of New Brunswick that night, “seeking someone to hurt,” she claimed.

But the defense said Puskas was a sick, sad man dealing with his mother’s ailing health. He had already known about the thefts against him for weeks by the time McCaw was killed and was more prone to whining than battering people, Mazraani said.

Police have neither identified nor found the weapon used to murder McCaw. The defense said Puskas never saw it, while the prosecution claims he hid or destroyed it.

Many of McCaw’s family members have traveled from Tennessee to watch the trial unfold, wearing red-and-black clothing and Rutgers gear. Some held their faces as the two sides presented their closing statements, while others teared up.

For them—and the shocked Rutgers community—the jury’s looming verdict could offer a sense of closure.

Being found not guilty would end a years-long “nightmare” for Puskas, who was found guilty two years ago of a fatal hit-and-run crash.

TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Be Interested In

Sign Up for E-News


Follwing Florida Massacre, EB Schools Add Armed Officers to Security

February 17, 2018

EAST BRUNSWICK, NJ - At a meeting Thursday night, the East Brunswick board of Education unanimously approved a resolution to engage the East Brunswick Police department to place armed police officers at each school building in the district throughout the entire school day.  In a report released by superintendent Victor Valeski yesterday, township officials asserted that the move would ...


Christina C. Sweet (Diaz) 79 years, died Monday January 1, 2017 at Robert Wood Johnson University ...
Read more
- Nov 15, 2017
Phillip A. Petracca, also widely known as Filippo Neri in the Italian-American Radio and ...
Read more

New Brunswick/Middlesex County Reentry Site Opens

February 14, 2018

MIDDLESEX COUNTY, NJ - The New Jersey Reentry Corporation (NJRC), a nonprofit agency serving court-involved individuals, is pleased to announce the grand opening a new reentry site in Middlesex County on Tuesday, Feb. 20, 2018 at 11 a.m. The office is located at 57 Livingston Avenue, Unit 3, New Brunswick, N.J. 08901. Assembly Speaker Craig Coughlin will offer remarks and cut ...

Track and Field: Union Catholic's Boys and Girls Win 14 Events at Lawrenceville Invit.

LAWRENCEVILLE, NJ -- The Union Catholic boys and girls track and field teams racked up 14 victories and a bunch of personal best performances at Saturday's Lawrenceville Invitational at the Lavino Field House in Lawrenceville.

In the girls competition, UC's Khamil Evans continued her red hot junior season with a pair of sprint victories. Evans, who lives in Piscataway, ...

Rutgers to Host Exhibit of Sen. Frank Lautenberg Papers

NEW BRUNSWICK, NJ - Frank Lautenberg, New Jersey’s longest-serving U.S. senator, left an outsize imprint on state politics and national policy by the time he died while in office, in 2013.

His papers, now curated and maintained by the Rutgers University Libraries, encompass 2,250 boxes of hats, buttons, campaign stickers, vinyl records, paper documents and other artifacts that, laid end ...

Upcoming Events


Sat, February 17, 6:00 PM

South Plainfield

Holy Savior Academy Spaghetti Dinner

Food & Drink Giving Back

Mon, February 19

State Theatre New Jersey, New Brunswick

Mr. Popper's Penguins

Arts & Entertainment

Mon, February 19, 12:30 PM


Matinee Monday

Arts & Entertainment

Tue, February 20, 1:00 PM


Community Blood Drive

Health & Wellness

Sat, February 24, 2:00 PM

Edison High School Auditorium, Edison

Free community viewing of "BAG IT" - Award ...

Arts & Entertainment Green

Westfield Cops Search for Suspects After Overnight Carjacking at Scotchwood Diner

February 14, 2018

This story was updated at 12:30 p.m. Wednesday.

SCOTCH PLAINS/WESTFIELD, NJ — Police are still searching for the suspects who carjacked a vehicle in the parking lot of the Scotchwood Diner (1928 Route 22) in Scotch Plains around 12:30 a.m. Wednesday, according to the Scotch Plains and Westfield police departments.

Patrol units responded to a report of a carjacking at the ...

How to Talk with Kids About the Florida Shooting

February 15, 2018

Guest Column

The tragedy of the Florida school shooting is devastating leaving 17 killed and 15 injured. Our children can easily identify with what occurred yesterday. It will be the topic of conversation today in schools everywhere. School administrators are doing all they can to provide support and guidance. The shootings affect children, teachers, and school personnel. The ...

Let the Games Begin

I am truly awed by the Olympics.  Watching these superb young athletes on TV inspires me to renew my membership to the gym and pursue my lifelong dream of taking home the gold.  


The problem is that in my deluded head, I can see actually see myself standing atop the podium.  I am wrapped in a puffy designer ski coat with a huge piece of bling slung around my neck ...

The Best Way to Pay Your Child a Compliment

“Of course you’re good-looking.”  “You’re the best friend ever.”  “Who wouldn’t want you on their team?”  Is there a parent out there (including me) who hasn’t praised a child in order to make him or her feel better?  Sometimes it’s true, and sometimes we say it because we just can’t stand to see them ...

Very Hot Tea Increases Cancer Risk

Researchers in China studying the consumption of “burning” hot tea, alcohol, and smoking habits of greater than 450,000 people ages 30 –79 for more than nine years found a five time greater risk of esophageal cancer in those who engaged in all three of the behaviors and a two time greater risk in those who either smoked or drank alcohol and consumed burning hot tea as compared ...