Guest Column

Which is Best: Lump Sum or Pension Annuity?

e9164614a213f39c7296_Eve-Kaplan.jpg
e9164614a213f39c7296_Eve-Kaplan.jpg

Is a lump sum offer from an employer a better choice than a pension annuity for life? The former provides an immediate up-front amount (say $300,000), but the pension annuity gives you a stream of payments for life (example: $1,350 per month). A number of employers dangle a lump sum offer to employees in part to remove future liabilities from their balance sheets. It’s tempting for employees to select the lump sum as an obvious choice and forgo the pension stream.  But is it the right choice?  Like all decisions, the correct is “it depends.”

The right decision may come down to engaging a fee-only financial planner to consider the options within the context of your entire financial plan.   Here are some things to consider:

  1. Look at the whole picture. By plugging the 2 alternatives (and a range of projected investment return assumptions) into your financial plan, you can see the outcome if you and/or your spouse live to age 70, 80, 90 or 95 and beyond.
  2. Your current and projected cash flow needs in retirement. How much of your net worth is locked up in e.g. your home, and how much is liquid? What percentage of your liquid investments and cash savings are tax-deferred? How much of your potential cash needs in retirement will come from pension-type annuities (such as defined benefit or cash balance pension plans from an employer, existing annuities and/or Social Security)?  
  3. A net present value (NPV) analysis. Using various interest rates, this analysis discounts future pension cash flows and generates a “net present value” that can be compared with a lump sum alternative. Like any analysis working with projected variables (e.g. interest rates), various assumptions can tilt this analysis in favor of a lump sum or a pension annuity.
  4. How long will you live? If you’re married, how long will your spouse live? Unless you’re terminally ill, no one can answer this so a good analysis will assume you may live into your 90s (and possibly beyond). Like Social Security, there often is a cross over point when it clearly makes sense to take a pension vs. a lump sum – e.g. if you/your spouse live past the age of 82.  The biggest change to retirement – in recent decades – is the need to plan for longevity and the risk of outliving your assets.
  5. How important is it to you to leave an inheritance to heirs?
  6. What happens if I have a pension annuity and my employer defaults?  Pension liabilities are governed by federal regulations; an employer cannot “wriggle out” of them. If your employer is purchased by another company, it still must honor pension obligations. In the unlikely event your employer goes bankrupt, the PBCG – a federal agency – takes up your pension obligation but it may pay out less.
  7. How well protected are you from the ravages of inflation? A pension annuity typically does NOT inflate, but investing proceeds in a lump sum – and growing them effectively – can protect better against inflation over time. However, the onus is on your and/or your advisor to generate a decent return and none of us knows what the future holds for markets.

OK, it’s clear there are pros and cons to lump sum vs. pension annuity choices but can you guess which option I tend to prefer for my clients?? The answer is: pension annuity for the majority of my clients --  particularly variations of a 75% joint and survivor pension annuity if my client is married. This gives the surviving spouse 75% of the monthly benefit for the remainder of his/her life.  Even if pensions don’t inflate, the pension annuity may be a more secure and superior option to taking a lump sum.

Sign Up for E-News

My client base ranges from middle class to affluent and we work to balance various projected streams of income in retirement (including IRA Required Minimum Distributions) to cover future goals and unexpected contingencies. As always we work to minimize the very real risk of longevity.

A fiduciary (fee-only) financial planner will be able to determine the best choice for you, and disclose potential conflicts of interest. Even fee-only advisors like me DO have potential conflicts of interest. For example, one way fee-only advisors charge fees is to invoice clients on a percentage of the investment assets they manage. An advisor with a fiduciary obligation to put the needs of the client first will disclose potential conflicts of interest and he/she will lay out the analysis for a client. 

In sum, “look before you leap.”

The opinions expressed herein are the writer's alone, and do not reflect the opinions of TAPinto.net or anyone who works for TAPinto.net. TAPinto.net is not responsible for the accuracy of any of the information supplied by the writer. Click here to submit a Guest Column.

TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Be Interested In

Sign Up for E-News

Piscataway

Follwing Florida Massacre, EB Schools Add Armed Officers to Security

February 17, 2018

EAST BRUNSWICK, NJ - At a meeting Thursday night, the East Brunswick board of Education unanimously approved a resolution to engage the East Brunswick Police department to place armed police officers at each school building in the district throughout the entire school day.  In a report released by superintendent Victor Valeski yesterday, township officials asserted that the move would ...

Obituaries

Christina C. Sweet (Diaz) 79 years, died Monday January 1, 2017 at Robert Wood Johnson University ...
Read more
- Nov 15, 2017
Phillip A. Petracca, also widely known as Filippo Neri in the Italian-American Radio and ...
Read more

Wreath Laying for Local Vietnam Hero Lost 50 Years Ago Today Held in Piscataway

February 18, 2018

Childhood friends of Soldier & Family Join Mayor Brian C. Wahler, Township Councilmembers, RU Army ROTC Cadets, Local American Legion & Lake Nelson Residents Today at Park Named After Veteran

PISCATAWAY, NJ – On Feb. 18th, the 50th anniversary of the passing of Jeffrey R. Byrne, a Piscataway-raised 19-year-old who died serving in Vietnam, childhood friends of him and his family ...

South Plainfield Middle School Student Council Thanks Supporters

The South Plainfield Middle School Student Council would like to express our thanks for the support of local businesses and organizations in our fundraising efforts.  A spaghetti dinner was hosted by the South Plainfield Elks Lodge #2298 on January 13th.  Mrs. Sharon Reuter and members of her Youth Committee and kitchen crew provided dinner for family, friends and staff of South ...

Rutgers to Host Exhibit of Sen. Frank Lautenberg Papers

NEW BRUNSWICK, NJ - Frank Lautenberg, New Jersey’s longest-serving U.S. senator, left an outsize imprint on state politics and national policy by the time he died while in office, in 2013.

His papers, now curated and maintained by the Rutgers University Libraries, encompass 2,250 boxes of hats, buttons, campaign stickers, vinyl records, paper documents and other artifacts that, laid end ...

Upcoming Events

Mon, February 19

State Theatre New Jersey, New Brunswick

Mr. Popper's Penguins

Arts & Entertainment

Mon, February 19, 12:30 PM

PISCATAWAY

Matinee Monday

Arts & Entertainment

Tue, February 20, 1:00 PM

Piscataway

Community Blood Drive

Health & Wellness

Sat, February 24, 2:00 PM

Edison High School Auditorium, Edison

Free community viewing of "BAG IT" - Award ...

Arts & Entertainment Green

Sun, February 25, 1:00 PM

St. David's Episcopal Church, Cranbury

Organizing for the 2018 Mid-terms: Elections, ...

Education Giving Back Government

Westfield Cops Search for Suspects After Overnight Carjacking at Scotchwood Diner

February 14, 2018

This story was updated at 12:30 p.m. Wednesday.

SCOTCH PLAINS/WESTFIELD, NJ — Police are still searching for the suspects who carjacked a vehicle in the parking lot of the Scotchwood Diner (1928 Route 22) in Scotch Plains around 12:30 a.m. Wednesday, according to the Scotch Plains and Westfield police departments.

Patrol units responded to a report of a carjacking at the ...

How to Talk with Kids About the Florida Shooting

February 15, 2018

Guest Column

The tragedy of the Florida school shooting is devastating leaving 17 killed and 15 injured. Our children can easily identify with what occurred yesterday. It will be the topic of conversation today in schools everywhere. School administrators are doing all they can to provide support and guidance. The shootings affect children, teachers, and school personnel. The ...

Let the Games Begin

I am truly awed by the Olympics.  Watching these superb young athletes on TV inspires me to renew my membership to the gym and pursue my lifelong dream of taking home the gold.  

 

The problem is that in my deluded head, I can see actually see myself standing atop the podium.  I am wrapped in a puffy designer ski coat with a huge piece of bling slung around my neck ...

The Best Way to Pay Your Child a Compliment

“Of course you’re good-looking.”  “You’re the best friend ever.”  “Who wouldn’t want you on their team?”  Is there a parent out there (including me) who hasn’t praised a child in order to make him or her feel better?  Sometimes it’s true, and sometimes we say it because we just can’t stand to see them ...

Very Hot Tea Increases Cancer Risk

Researchers in China studying the consumption of “burning” hot tea, alcohol, and smoking habits of greater than 450,000 people ages 30 –79 for more than nine years found a five time greater risk of esophageal cancer in those who engaged in all three of the behaviors and a two time greater risk in those who either smoked or drank alcohol and consumed burning hot tea as compared ...