Real Estate

Proposed Plainfield Vet Home Design Meets Opposition

Andre Yates Credits: Bernice Paglia
Credits: Bernice Paglia
Plans of the proposed addition Credits: Bernice Paglia

10/2/17 UPDATE:  The Plainfield Zoning Board will hear Vets Home proposal on Oct. 4th.

PLAINFIELD, NJ - Plainfield preservationists found little to like in a proposed addition to a Central Avenue mansion Tuesday, giving the owner and his architect a month to revise the plans.

Owner Andre Yates intends to create 25 apartments for veterans at the former nursing home known as Abbott Manor, but  Historic Preservation Commission members, residents of the Van Wyck Brooks Historic District and others objected to the design. A resident who spoke in favor of the project, Bruce Butts, is on the Yates House for Military Veterans' board of directors.

Sign Up for E-News

After two hours of discussion, the HPC agreed to carry the matter to its Oct. 24 meeting, making an Oct. 4 scheduled Zoning Board of Adjustment appearance by Yates moot. Until the HPC issues a "certificate of appropriateness" on the design, the Zoning Board cannot act on the proposed use. Meanwhile architect William Doran asked for help in altering the design, which a committee of the HPC may consider.

About 40 attendees waited through three other hearings for the Yates case, which began with attorney Steven C. Rother asking HPC Chairman William Michelson to recuse himself, based on their mutual participation in a decade-old clash over the same property.

"You and I have a long history with each other," Rother said, adding it was "not necessarily good for either of us."

MORE:  Bill Michelson's summary from the Van Wyck Brooks District Association web site

"We feel that your impartiality might be in question and it's best that you step aside,"  Rother said.

Michelson said Rother had a right to raise the issue, but after discussion of how an HPC approval had to precede any other action, the case proceeded Tuesday.

Yates began his testimony with descriptions of other properties he has renovated in historic districts and promised complete repair of the structure at 810 Central Avenue, but HPC commissioners noted he got approval five years ago for roof repairs at the mansion and never did the work. Yates countered by saying he was denied a building permit in June 2015, but Michelson said it was the first he heard of it.

Doran said a two-story 1950s addition to the mansion will remain and that Yates wanted to add a third floor. Commissioner John Favazzo led HPC comments by calling the third floor "highly inappropriate" and other board members, which Michelson said included "two planners, two lawyers and three architects," further criticized the design. Doran said the aim was to make the addition "totally different" from the original structure, but after Michelson said the board always gives free advice, Doran said, "We should have gotten some of that before we came here."

Among other comments from commissioners, Sandy Gurshman said, "The addition is a horror," and Larry Quirk called proposed changes "extremely out of character" with the original structure.

Comments from the public echoed the commissioners' disdain for the design and faulted Yates for not contacting the district association. Each of Plainfield's six residential historic districts has an association which is charged with upholding preservation interests, but Arne Aakre, president of the Van Wyck Brooks Historic District association, said Yates never contacted him.

Resident Gerry Heydt said the addition resembled a "factory building dormitory" and April Stefel advised studying archived photos of the mansion at the Plainfield Public Library.

"I want to see what's there and what you're going to replace," she said.

Former Plainfield Zoning Officer Ron Johnson called the design "kind of a slap in the face" to the district and said the audience included "people from all over the city who are very involved in historic districts."

The meeting ended with a final caution from Quirk, who said, "Tell us exactly what you are going to do" at the next one, which is 7:30 p.m. on Tuesday, Oct. 24 in City Hall Library, 515 Watchung Ave. 

The building's use as a veterans' home will be decided by the Zoning Board of Adjustment at a future date, pending issuance of HPC approval. 

MORE:  Plainfield's Yates House Seeks Approvals for Expansion

TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Be Interested In

Sign Up for E-News


You Meet the Most Amazing People on the Trail

The weather cooperated this weekend, so I went for more than one hike. After all, there are only just over fifty days before my walk to Maine commences, so why not.

This Saturday, some friends dragged me away from housecleaning (thank you!) for a quick jaunt through Watchung Reservation.  While we were there, we ran into two individuals from Westfield; the cosplayers introduced themselves ...

Go Take a Walk

Friday, March 30 was Take a Walk in the Park Day, so I did.  I really didn't have an excuse to not do so; the sun was shining, I had the day off, and I had no plans for the rest of the day.  So after a session with Abbe, my trainer at LifeTime Fitness, I made the short trip to Lake Surprise in Watchung Reservation. 

As I made my way around the lake, it was easy to see how ...

Upcoming Events


Thu, April 26, 4:00 PM

Hannah Atkins Community Center, Plainfield

Homework Helper



Thu, April 26, 6:00 PM

Plainfield Public Library, Plainfield

The Crucial Keys to Home Ownership

Home & Garden

Holy Savior Academy Excels in the Arts - Annual Spring Musical, Art Show to Take Place in May

SOUTH PLAINFIELD, NJ – The students and staff at Holy Savior Academy, a pre-K3 through eighth grade AdvancedED accredited Middlebrook Deanery Catholic School located in South Plainfield, have been busy gearing up for two widely anticipated spring events. In May, the drama club will present its 4th annual Spring Spectacular Musical and a school wide art show will also take ...

EPA Selects Camden, NJ to Receive $400,000 in Brownfield Grants to Revitalize Blighted Properties, Promote Economic Redevelopment

April 25, 2018

New York, NY - Camden was among 144 communities selected for Brownfields Environmental Assessment, Revolving Loan Fund, and Cleanup grants. The two grants totaling $400,000 will provide the community with funding to assess, clean up, and redevelop underutilized properties while protecting public health and the environment. A total of $54.3 million will be provided to brownfields sites ...

Politics IS Government in Union County

April 22, 2018

After Bruce Patrson of Garwood was stopped from speaking at the Union County freeholder meeting of March 22 regarding the politics behind refusing to give the party line to a sitting freeholder I thought this brazen suppression of free speech could not go unanswered. A the the April 19 meeting I answered with these comments.

After ten years of following government in Union County I conclude ...

Fallen Officer Identified. ‘A Sad Day for Paterson’ as Police Officer Loses Life in Car Accident

April 23, 2018

UPDATE- Several sources familiar with Sunday’s tragic accident have identified the fallen officer as Tamby Yagan, a 13-year veteran of the Paterson Police Department.

PATERSON, NJ- On what Paterson Superior Officers Association President Mason Maher called “a sad day for Paterson” a city police officer lost his life on Sunday after being involved in a motor vehicle ...

Blood Drive en Plainfield High School el viernes

April 12, 2018

PLAINFIELD, NJ - Un esfuerzo de sangre se llevará a cabo el viernes en Plainfield High School en asociación con la Cruz Roja Americana.

¿Alguna vez se ha preguntado qué le sucede a la pinta de sangre que dona?

Según la Cruz Roja, la donación se almacena en refrigeradores helados hasta que se transporta a un centro de la Cruz Roja y se escanea en una ...

Springtime Advice from Rapps Pharmacy

April 17, 2018

It may not feel like spring, but that spring weather is right around the corner and so is allergy season!  Here is some friendly advice from Rapps Pharmacy, your neighborhood pharmacy:

Combating the Allergy Season

As seasons change and pollen counts rise, more and more people clash with the aggravating symptoms of seasonal allergies. Beginning in February and lasting into early summer, ...

Featured Business: NJ Printing & Embroidery LLC

Featured Business: NJ Printing & Embroidery LLC

Nestled in the heart of Plainfield is NJ Printing & Embroidery, a family-owned business providing digital screen printing and embroidery for custom shirts, caps and other items.

The company also offers custom printed business cards, fliers, banners and storefront vinyls, and can provide expert graphic art design upon request.

Eric ...

'The Sting' shimmers and shakes at Paper Mill

‘The Sting ‘slithers and shakes at Paper Mill Playhouse


MILLBURN, NJ – In a premiere production of “The Sting,” Harry Connick Jr. commands the Paper Mill Playhouse stage in Millburn.

Based on the sensational Paul Newman/Robert Redford film in 1973, the 1930s plot centers on a con game and gambling, sometimes on a train between New York and ...

Retro Review: Johnny Got His Gun by Dalton Trumbo

Retro Review: Johnny Got His Gun by Dalton Trumbo (Citadel Press, 1970)


How does a reviewer do justice to a book called “the great American novel”? I first read Johnny Got His Gun during the Viet Nam war, when young people, nationwide, were protesting fighting in a war that was a senseless waste of life; a war in which the United States had no business participating.

The Truth About My Reading

The Truth About My Reading

I didn't get my Composition and Literature teacher at Montclair State College at all. A crusty old man with a dour disposition, Mr. Smith always seemed angry and rude. He appropriately intimidated freshmen, even me, an English major, who found this common core course beneath my dignity. Frankly, as a graduate of Highland Park High School, and a survivor of Mrs.

The German Girl

The German Girl by Armando Lucas Correa (Washington Square Press, 2016)

For each of the twelve million victims murdered during World War II there is a gutwrenching story to be told. I have read hundreds of memoirs, biographies, plays, and novels that recount the stories of the martyrs; some are exceptional, some are fair. The German Girl by Armando Lucas Correa, an award-winning journalist, ...

The Skin Collector

The Skin Collector by Jeffery Deaver (Grand Central, 2014)

Jack the Ripper. The Boston Strangler. The Texas Watchtower Killer. The Zodiac Killer. The Angel of Death. The Butcher. BTK. The police and the press have a long history of dubbing serial killers with names that catch the attention of the public, usually having the effect of instilling greater fear and selling more print media so that ...

Queen Mary and the Cruiser

Queen Mary and the Cruiser by David A. Thomas and Patrick Holmes (Naval Institute Press, 1997)

“Had the forenoon watch and after eating went out onto the fo'c'sle. Just arrived at the top of the ladder by the PO's heads when the wave hit me---waist high---and knocked me over. Looking astern---through the bulkhead door which was open, saw the stern of a ship sticking up out of ...

In Cold Blood by Truman Capote

In Cold Blood by Truman Capote (Random House, 1965)


In Cold Blood is, quite simply, the grand-daddy of true crime writing, dubbed by Capote, himself, as the first non-fiction novel (although Norman Mailer argued the point when he published The Executioner's Song in 1979.) The conditions under which I read In Cold Blood for the first time were pretty weird, which was another ...