Arts & Entertainment

VIDEO: Plainfield City Council Meeting Includes History of Library Artwork

Credits: Jennifer Popper
Albert Bierstadt, "Autumn in the Sierras" Credits: City of Plainfield
Albert Bierstadt, "The Landing of Columbus" Credits: City of Plainfield
Credits: Jennifer Popper
Credits: Jennifer Popper
Credits: Lisa Giannascoli
Mayor Adrian O. Mapp Credits: Jennifer Popper
Mayor Adrian O. Mapp and Anne Robinson Credits: Jennifer Popper

PLAINFIELD, NJ - Monday night's Plainfield City Council meeting began with Mayor Adrian O. Mapp presenting proclamations to the Queen City Academy's Bimbola Olaleye (3-5 ) and Desirae Hemans (6-8) MLK essay contest winners. 

Mapp then honored and acknowledged Anne Robinson, a past President, Plainfield Library Board of Trustees, for her work as she plans to leave Plainfield and move south.


Robinson then took the microphone, and said that she wanted to educate the City Council and the public about the artwork that was sold by the Plainfield Public Library, and the issues they faced along the way as the City of Plainfield considers the fate of the Albert Bierstadt paintings.

Sign Up for E-News

She stated that in January 2007, the library received a request from the Art Institute of Chicago to exhibit one of its paintings; this request necessitated an appraisal.

Both Robinson and at that time Library Director Joe Da Rold found standing water in the vault where the artwork was stored, and it was clear a new storage place was needed.

They also learned that there would be a huge increase in insurance premiums, and there would be a need for more security to hold multi-million dollar pieces of artwork in the library.  The library was already spending $25K per year on hard coverage, and this increase would more than double.  Plus, they spent $26K on a security surveillance system.

The library's insurer, AIG, informed the library they would also need three concentric rings of security.  This would include locked doors/cabinets, and video cameras, but what would the third be?  In museums, they have full-time guards, but the library couldn't afford that.

The artwork was too valuable to keep at the library, and they couldn't keep it in a water-soaked vault at the bank; they also couldn't afford the increase in the insurance premiums. They looked at storage facilities, and talked to other banks, but no one would take the pieces.  And no museum would take them unless the pieces were given on permanent loan.

There had been lengthy discussions; what was the difference between giving the artwork to museums on permanent loan versus not having the paintings at all?  No one sees them because the library can't afford to show them.  What was the responsibility to the donor who gave the library the paintings?  Could the library sell them, and if yes, how would it be done? 

The library researched the donors, interviewed Sotheby's and Christie's, and deliberated at board meetings for months.

Finally, over a year later in June 2008, the library's representatives voted unanimously to sell a Winslow Homer oil painting, a marble bust of George Washington, a green marble sculpture of Grecian wrestlers, and a coin and currency collection given to the library in 1886.

The library hired a lawyer to represent them, and make sure they were doing everything by the book, resulting in an eight-page opinion letter in October 2008.  The letter covered the wills of the man who gave the library the Winslow Homer, as well as the will of his mother, and all of the references from the board of trustee meetings regarding gifts.

The library entered into an advantageous agreement with Sotheby's that allowed both Winslow Homer paintings to be restored, and original copies to be made and put on display at the library for all to enjoy, at Sotheby's expense.

When the time came for the auction, several public figures criticized the library representatives, and they were investigated by the Attorney General.

Then, on December 2, 2008, Robinson learned that the City of Plainfield and the State of New Jersey would not stop the auction, and the sale proceeded the next morning.

Robinson notes that the history she shared was just about the selling; the more most important part was that whatever money was received from the sale of these assets would be protected and only used for projects that added permanent value to the library.  It couldn't be squandered, or used for staff salary.

In July 2008, the Plainfield Public Library had created the Heritage Fund, which has helped pay for the Children's Room at the library, and fifteen new public-use computers.  It led to the creation of a permanently searchable database of blueprints, and current plans include ADA-compliant bathrooms on the lower level. 

The Morgan Stanley-managed fund started at $2.3 million with the sale of the artwork, and to date, $606K has been spent.  The value of the fund is $2.4 million today.

Robinson believes she and her colleagues acted responsibly, and in the interest of the public.

She then brought her point to the City of Plainfield's challenge with the Bierstadt paintings.  She posed the question of what the city would do if there were a fire and the paintings were destroyed.  Being self-insured, the city would have no way to replace them.  Robinson also noted that the city hardly has three concentric rings of security around the paintings.

UPDATED: Mayor Adrian O. Mapp Unveils Plans for Commission to Review Plainfield Promise

She said, "wouldn't it be more responsible to put a reproduction on the wall?"

As the city considers the sale, she noted, officials must also consider the trust the public has placed in them.  "This sale could give the city a rare opportunity to do something incredible." 

She noted that the city would be under far more scrutiny from the public, but the principals are the same, and that five to ten years from now, many lives could be changed.  She ended by asking if the paintings remain on the wall, how will city officials make Plainfield a better place consider current budget constraints.


Other topics included a vote on final passage of towing penalties for taxis not licensed in Plainfield. 

TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Be Interested In

Sign Up for E-News


Upcoming Events


Thu, March 22, 3:45 PM


Bookbinding for Beginners

Arts & Entertainment


Thu, March 22, 4:00 PM

Hannah Atkins Community Center, Plainfield

Homework Helper


Holy Savior Academy Storm Varsity Basketball News

The Holy Savior Academy Storm Varsity basketball team concluded a very successful season by capturing two championships over the weekend.  The Storm continued the basketball program’s winning ways when the team captured the school’s fourth consecutive Diocese of Metuchen CYM Varsity White Division Championship on its home court on Saturday evening.  The team then secured the ...

Palm Sunday to Easter Worship at CAPC

March 22, 2018

You are invited to join us as we journey to the Cross and beyond. Crescent Avenue Presbyterian Church, 716 Watchung Avenue, Plainfield, invites you to a series of worship services (each unique in its theme). We begin our journey through Holy Week with a Children led Triumph Tour beginning at 9:30 am Palm Sunday, March 25, in our Guild Room. Worship follows starting in the Chapel at 10:30 am ...


March 17, 2018

WASHINGTON, D.C., March 16, 2018 – Despite her rhetoric, U.S. Rep. Bonnie Watson Coleman, D-12, failed Wednesday to deliver on her promise to make schools safer for our children.

The two-term congressperson was one of only 10 representatives that voted “nay” Wednesday afternoon on the STOP School Violence Act of 2018.

The bill passed the U.S. House of Representatives on a ...

Retro Fitness in Manahawkin Calls Stafford Police to Remove Man for Praying for Another Member

March 21, 2018

STAFFORD, NJ - Retro Fitness club member and Long Beach Township resident Craig Fasler was escorted by a member of the Stafford Township Police Department out of the gym because an employee accused him of sharing his faith in public. 

TAPinto Stafford-LBI was contacted by a Stafford Township resident about the incident that took place on Wednesday, March 21 around ...

La tienda de comestibles Canela de Plainfield acogerá el evento de la tienda Healthy Corner

March 19, 2018

PLAINFIELD, NJ - EZ Ride y la ciudad de Plainfield se han asociado una vez más con Canela Grocery and Deli para organizar un evento gratuito para los residentes que ofrece muestras gratis de bocadillos saludables, cupones, una rifa saludable de canastas e información nutricional. Atlantic Health también estará en el evento con una unidad móvil para proporcionar ...

Celebrando el Mes de la Historia de la Mujer

PLAINFIELD, NJ - Estimados Plainfield,

Yo fui criado por dos mujeres poderosas e generosas, y me pasaron principios y valores que me han guiado durante mi vida entera. Mi mama persiguió la oportunidad y busco una manera de proveer para su familia. Ella dejo la isla de Barbados para poder trabajar en los hogares de los Estados Unidos, creando e allanando un camino para que sus hijos lo ...

Innovador Plainfield

Estimados Plainfield,


El crecimiento requiere evolución, la evolución implica cambio, y el cambio conduce a la innovación. Plainfield está evolucionando. Nos estamos adaptando para cumplir con los requisitos del renacimiento que está formando el futuro. No podemos esperar cambio positivo y sostenible si continuamos con el mismo ritmo de las ...

'Trying' explores age, youth and points of history in poignant production

‘Trying’ explores youth, age and points of history in poignant production

By Liz Keill

NEW BRUNSWICK, NJ – The George Street Playhouse presents an engrossing, two-character play based on the real life of Francis Biddle, former Attorney General.

Biddle, a Harvard educated lawyer, served under Franklin Roosevelt and later Harry Truman during the Nuremberg Tribunal. His ...

In Cold Blood by Truman Capote

In Cold Blood by Truman Capote (Random House, 1965)


In Cold Blood is, quite simply, the grand-daddy of true crime writing, dubbed by Capote, himself, as the first non-fiction novel (although Norman Mailer argued the point when he published The Executioner's Song in 1979.) The conditions under which I read In Cold Blood for the first time were pretty weird, which was another ...

Ian Hockley Visits New Jersey to Introduce Program to Empower Youth

This week I am taking a departure from book reviewing to share an important program that has been introduced to New Jersey this week by Mr. Ian Hockley, founder of the Dylan's Wings of Change Foundation. On December 14, 2012, Hockley's five year old son, an autistic child named Dylan, was gunned down in his classroom in the Sandy Hook Elementary School shooting. Dylan, a shy and adorable ...

Lilli DeJong by Janet Benton

Lilli De Jong by Janet Benton (Doubleday, 2017)


“It's said that every woman's painful labor is God's punishment. Eve ate an apple, and God pours wrath on every mother. So the Bible tells it.” (p.320)

The story of Eve and the serpent in the Garden of Eden, which is the Biblical explanation for the extreme pains of childbirth, casts women in the role of ...

Prayers the Devil Answers by Sharyn McCrumb

Prayers the Devil Answers by Sharyn McCrumb (Altria, 2015)


Years later, after the tragedy, someone remembered the Dumb Supper and what had happened there. That was the cause of it, they said, because the ritual wasn't a game after all. It really was magic, but magic has rules, and she broke them. Even when they call it a 'senseless tragedy,' people always try to find a ...

Super Carb Diet by Bob Harper

Super Carb Diet by Bob Harper with Danny Pellegrino (St. Martin's Press, 2017)

It's hard to go on a serious diet, one on which you expect to be successful and maintain a loss. Fortunately, in his new book Super Carb Diet, Bob Harper has given the weight watching world a sensible new diet plan to help achieve a healthy weight.

Harper, host of NBC's popular show The Biggest Loser, ...

Two Nights by Kathy Reichs

Two Nights by Kathy Reichs (Bantom,2017)

How does a writer of a beloved series like Harry Potter or Temperance Brennan break out of their readers' expectations and try something new? For J.K. Rowlings it was the novels penned under the pseudonym Robert Galbraith; books about a maimed and very flawed private detective with the unlikely name of Cormoran Strike. For Kathy Reichs, it is the ...