Finalized Randolph Middle School Music Schedule Receives Criticism from Parents and Students


RANDOLPH, NJ - After announcing the final schedule for the Randolph Middle School program, the Board of Education and administration received more comments from parents and students. The new schedule moved strings and chorus rehearsals before school and band rehearsals after school.

Superintendent Jennifer Fano began the meeting by reminding the public why she considered changing the schedule.

“I was concerned with students being pulled from any subject area three times per week. So I wanted to look at if we could make a change and have a positive impact for the whole child, not just any one department,” Fano began.

Sign Up for E-News

Because of music classes taking place during the school day, students missed 40% of their physical education and health instruction, Fano explained. She also presented the middle school music schedule over the past 10 years, with after school sessions taking place from the 2007-2008 school year through 2012-2013. From years 2013-2015, the large music ensembles met during lunch, and 2015-2017 brought all music sessions into the regular schedule.

Visual/Performaing Arts Supervisor Frank Perrone presented the new music schedule during the June 20th meeting. The new schedule will allow for the music staff to team teach, and since no ensembles overlap, a student could enroll in all three options, Fano added.

However, rising 7th-grader Jason Goldner expressed his concerns about band rehearsal conflicting with his baseball, dance and religious school commitments.

“Music is very important to many kids, including me, and it is a class, so it should only be during the school hours,” Goldner said. “As a kid, I enjoy gym and I see the point of wellness education, but the schedule was working out fine in my opinion… You talk about educating the whole child, but you are depriving us of our music or our after-school activities, whichever one we choose.”

He mentioned that if music took place before school, he would not be able to participate because he would “have little time to sleep, and I wouldn’t be able to keep up my high grades.”

Parent Liz Clogher spoke of her son who plays trombone, but also participates in competitive swimming four days per week after school. She suggested students be able to audit the lesson during the day if unable to attend the after-school sessions.

“Right now my son is only being pulled out of gym twice a week… the health unit he participates in is one of four marking periods. What we’re talking about is in essence nine more days of health classes over a course of a year,” Clogher said. “In order to provide continuity for my son if I choose to have him withdraw, it will cost me $5400 a year to provide 150 minutes of music instruction [per week] on our own.”

Marie Mechanick, whose daughter plays viola and sings in the chorus, mentioned that her daughter does not wish to double this year “because it requires her to get up early on two consecutive days on Thursday and Friday, and she has an extracurricular activity on Thursday evening.”

“We have caused children to choose between continuing with our music program and their other after-school activities,” Mechanick continued. “After changing our school start times to encourage more sleep, we are now requiring the students to come to school early again and we have extended their day.”

The full middle school music program schedule can be found on the Randolph School District website.

TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Be Interested In

Sign Up for E-News


Road Resurfacing Work in Randolph for July 9 - 16

July 7, 2018

Below is a list of the streets for the upcoming resurfacing work. All roads will remain open for local traffic and emergency vehicles. Motorists should allow additional time for travel.

Street Name
Dates of Milling
Dates of Paving

Springhill Road - Forrest Road to #40

Musiker Avenue - Morey Lane to ...

Randolph Diner: Serving Up the Next Version of the Diner Experience

July 16, 2018

RANDOLPH, NJ- A diner, back in the early days of diners, typically referred to a restaurant that resembled a dining car on a train. Today, most diners still have a long counter and an array of booths lining the windows – much like the old railroad dining cars – but in many communities, the “diner” evolved into something more than a restaurant.

The diner became a ...

Upcoming Events


Thu, July 19, 9:00 AM

Brooklyn Bagel, Randolph

Coffee with a Cop

Community Calendar


Thu, July 19, 7:00 PM

Randolph Township Free Public Library, Randolph

Musical Monters

Community Calendar


Mon, July 23, 9:30 AM

Randolph Township Free Public Library, Randolph

Nursery Rhyme Time

Arts & Entertainment Community Calendar Health & Wellness Other

Catriona Lucus Selected to Play in 2018 National Lacrosse Academy  

July 16, 2018

RANDOLPH, NJ- Catriona Lucus, a rising freshman at Randolph High School has been named as a 2018 Maverik National Lacrosse All-Star and has been selected to attend the Maverik National Lacrosse Academy to be held July 16-19, 2018 in Frederica, Delaware at the DE Turf Sportsplex.

Catriona plays on the DEWLAX 2022 West club lacrosse team as well as being chosen to play with the DEWLAX ...

Geoffrey the Giraffe Moves In To New Brunswick Children's Hospital

July 12, 2018

NEW BRUNSWICK, NJ - Over a stretch of nearly 70 years, Geoffrey the Giraffe at Toys R Us stores was the symbol of happy times for generations of children, and now he may provide those same feelings for children coming to a hospital.

"From this day forward, Geoffrey stands tall in our lobby to encourage our smallest patients to smile when they enter our facilities," said John ...

Education: A Bedrock of Democracy, Civic Engagement and Economic Prosperity

July 6, 2018

More than 240 years ago, our nation’s founders envisioned a country where individuals could forge their own destinies and not be constrained by the circumstances of birth. The essential concept was that people could govern themselves and participate in democracy, or what Benjamin Franklin and others called “a great experiment.” The vision was bold and has flourished as the ...

Murphy Administration Takes Action to Help Smokers Quit

July 16, 2018

Eliminates Prior Approval for Medicaid Tobacco Cessation Medications; Counseling Options to be Expanded

July 16, 2018

(TRENTON) – The Murphy administration on Monday announced new steps to help New Jersey Medicaid recipients quit using tobacco by making it easier to receive tobacco cessation medications and counseling.

“Tobacco use is the leading preventable cause of death ...

Garden State Urology named a Center of Excellence by NAFC

Urology group recognized for exemplary care, dedication to patients

WHIPPANY, NJ – Garden State Urology, part of Atlantic Medical Group, was recently designated a Center of Excellence by the National Association for Continence.

Garden State Urology is a cooperative urology group that provides residents in northwestern New Jersey with a modern, integrated, comprehensive health care ...

Registration open for Randolph Hebrew with Early Bird Discount!

Entering its 17th year, Randolph Hebrew of Morris County has opened registration to new students for the upcoming school year that is set to begin on Sunday, September 16th.

Randolph Hebrew enjoys a well-earned reputation as a trend setter in creative Jewish education. It's well trained staff, cutting edge curriculum along with the teacher to student ration allows for individualized ...

Take the 2018 TAPinto Reader Survey

How often do you read TAPinto?  Have you downloaded the TAPinto APP?  These are a few of the questions for readers in our 2018 TAPinto Reader Survey.

We want to hear from you!

The survey will take less than five minutes to complete and will help TAPinto better serve you. 

Take the 2018 TAPinto Reader Survey.

Thank you.  We appreciate your support and ...

Atlantic Health System, MedExpress partner in 11 New Jersey Urgent Care Centers

Atlantic Health System, an integrated health care delivery system, and MedExpress, a neighborhood health care provider, are collaborating to coordinate care between MedExpress' 11 neighborhood medical centers in northern New Jersey and Atlantic Health System's extensive clinically integrated network of physicians, hospitals and other care sites.

The jointly owned centers will enable ...


AtlantiCast: Episode 18

On this week’s AtlantiCast, you’ll find out how accessing care at Atlantic Health System is now easier, more affordable and closer to home than ever, learn which item from the produce aisle could be the newest weapon against cancer, see what Atlantic Health System, the New York Times and Instagram all have in common and much more.