Lack of Roxbury Lawyer Review Jeopardizes Horseshoe Lake Kayak Rental Idea


ROXBURY, NJ – With weekend temperatures expected to reach almost 90 degrees, the weather should be perfect for a kayak or canoe trip around Horseshoe Lake in Succasunna.

A proposal that would allow Ramsey Outdoor to rent canoes, kayaks and paddleboards at the township owned park seemed to be on course for approval last month. Ramsey told the township it wanted to begin the rentals on May weekends.

But nobody at town hall sent the paperwork to the township attorney for review and now Ramsey officials doubt they will have enough time to provide the rentals this summer.

Sign Up for E-News

"The problem is it's getting very late to try to put a program together," Ramsey Outdoor President Stuart Levine said today. "We have to go out and purchase boats and hire people and train staff."

A resolution awarding a contract to Ramsey for the rentals was on the agenda at the May 23 township council meeting. An approval there might have enabled the company, which has a store in Roxbury Mall, to be renting the equipment by Memorial Day.

However, at the meeting, the resolution was tabled at the request of Roxbury Councilman Fred Hall after Roxbury Township Attorney Anthony Bucco said he needed to review the contract and other paperwork. Although Ramsey signed those papers May 3, nobody sent them to the township attorney.

“I don’t feel comfortable right now moving forward until Tony has a chance to look at it,” Hall said at the meeting.

In the interview today, Hall said the matter was stalled because “Tony Bucco had not had a chance to review it,” adding the township “can’t move forward until such time as our attorney has reviewed the terms and conditions” of the contract.

“There has to be a contract put in place between us and Ramsey specifying the terms between us and them,” Hall said. Those terms would include “service levels, what’s going to be their hours of operation, where are they going to store the boats and other details, he said. “All this has to be stipulated in some sort of memorandum of understanding,” Hall said. “We have to have an agreement.”

Contacted today, Bucco said he'd still not received the papers to review. But then, in the middle of the interview, the documents arrived in an email he received on his phone, he said.

Unfortunately, for Ramsey - and anyone hoping to rent a watercraft on Horseshoe Lake anytime soon - Bucco said he received the papers too late to have the matter included on the agenda of the June 13 council meeting. The council meets every two weeks, meaning the rental plan - if given a legal OK by Bucco - likely won't see a vote until June 27.

That's probably too late for Ramsey to move forward this year.

"The point is  it's very tough to react once summers here," Levine said. "We told them we are going to buy all new boats and all new equipment for this. It's getting very late in the season. That's our main problem. You only have so many weeks and so many weekends. It does present a bit of a problem ... If they tell us June 27, I don’t think we could be up and running until the middle of July at that point."

On May 3, Ramsey approved a notarized “Concession Agreement” that was provided by the township. A “contract” was mentioned in a May 16 interoffice memo from Roxbury Township Purchasing Agent Valerie Wyble to former Roxbury Township Manager Christopher Raths.

In that memo, Wyble told Raths the request for proposals (RFP) issued by the township – to which Ramsey responded – “included a contract which was prepared by the township attorney.” Wyble also said “insurance requirements were approved and reviewed by the township’s risk manager.”

In the May 3 response to Roxbury’s RFP, Ramsey detailed many aspects of the boat rental operation, noting it currently runs a similar program at the Franklin Lakes Nature Preserve. The company said it wanted to begin renting watercraft on weekends in May “and daily from approximately the first week of June through Labor Day.”

Ramsey said it would provide eight to 10 kayaks, canoes and stand-up paddleboards, charging $20 per hour and $10 for every extra hour. The company offered to donate to the township either $1,000 worth of merchandise or gift cards “to be used for whatever fundraiser or events the town would like.”

It also offered to participate in lake and trail cleanup projects, offer a “free paddle day” and demonstrate an “ability and willingness to work closely with the township on any other events or programs during the year.”

Bucco said the rental plan might have been an unanticipated victim of confusion at town hall due to Rath's retirement on May 31. He was replaced by new Roxbury Township Manager John Shepherd who, contacted today, said he knew nothing about the Horseshoe Lake rental proposal.

Hall said he remains enthused about the idea, despite the delay. “I think this will be a nice offering for the residents of Roxbury Township,” he said. But at this point, it might have to wait until next summer, according to Levine.

"I certainly don’t want to seem ungracious in any way shape or form," he said. "We’re still excited to work with the town and optimistic that if they say 'yes,' we believe they are going to be happy with the product we put out on the water. It will be a win-win for the town and the people."


TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Be Interested In

Sign Up for E-News


Upcoming Events


Sun, June 24, 1:00 PM

Mary Axelson, Succasunna

Open House Sunday 6/24 and 6/30

Real Estate


Sun, June 24, 4:00 PM

Investors Bank Theater, Succasunna

Austin McMahon Presents Joe Davidian

Arts & Entertainment


Wed, June 27, 7:00 PM

Roxbury Rec Center, Succasunna

SPECIAL MEETING of the Roxbury Mount Arlington ...

Education Government



AtlantiCast Episode 17

On this week’s AtlantiCast, it’s National Men’s Health Month, so check out important health tips for you or the men in your life, learn about groundbreaking research into breast cancer treatment that could mean an end to chemotherapy for some patients, meet a local sports hero who’s living his baseball dreams thanks to Goryeb Children’s Hospital and much ...

Letters to TAPinto Roxbury

Necessary Discussion and Debate of Addressing School Violence

June 10, 2018

Dear Editor,

As of late, due to most disturbing acts of violence against children in our schools, there is much vigorous debate regarding gun control and protection of our children and grand-children.

Much of the debate is based on emotion rather than reasoned thought.

I think that exploration in three areas needs to be more thoroughly discussed and debated. The first is ...

Necessary Discussion and Debate of Addressing School Violence

Dear Editor,

As of late, due to most disturbing acts of violence against children in our schools, there is much vigorous debate regarding gun control and protection of our children and grand-children.

Much of the debate is based on emotion rather than reasoned thought.

I think that exploration in three areas needs to be more thoroughly discussed and debated. The first is ...

Student from Roxbury Makes UConn Dean's List

June 21, 2018

STORRS, CT - Jamie Katzenberger of Kenvil made the spring semester dean's list at the University of Connecticut, said the school.

At the end of each semester the dean of each school and college names to the Dean’s List those students who (1) were registered for at least 12 credits calculable for grade points, (2) received no grade below “C”, including the actual ...

Two Students from Roxbury Make Springfield College Dean's List

SPRINGFIELD, MA -- Two students from Succasunna qualified for the spring semester dean's list at Springfield College. Criteria for selection to the dean's list requires that the student must have a minimum semester grade point average of 3.5 for the semester.

The students:

Mackenzie Miller, who is studying Health Science/Pre-physician Assistant.

Megan Schneider, ...

22 From Roxbury Area Make U of Delaware Dean's List

NEWARK, DE - The following Roxburyuarea students have been named to the University of Delaware Dean's List for the Spring 2018 semester:

Samantha Aquino of Flanders 

Olivia Boon of Ledgewood 

Christopher Bouvier of Flanders 

Alyssa Cartier of Flanders 

Juliette Castro of Landing 

Brennan Chuprinko of Flanders 

Ryan Decker of ...

Press Releases

County Chamber Statement about Proposed State Tax Increases

June 20, 2018

MORRISTOWN, NJ - Paul Boudreau, president of the Morris County Chamber of Commerce, today issued the following statement on the budget negotiations in Trenton:

“Individuals and businesses are shouldering a significant tax burden already in our state. Raising taxes sends a signal to our employers and future investors that New Jersey will remain uncompetitive for decades to ...

JCP&L Completes Inspections and Projects Prior to Summer Season to Help Enhance Customer Service Reliability

Jersey Central Power & Light (JCP&L) has completed inspections and projects across its 13-county service area to enhance customer reliability in preparation for the summer season.  The work included upgrading transmission and substation equipment, upgrading circuits and trimming trees along power lines. 

Helicopter patrols are completing inspections on more than 780 ...