Should Fenimore Air Monitor Spikes Warrant Emergency Alerts?

A Google Earth image of the former Fenimore Landfill showing the cap installed by the state Department of Environmental Protection to help stop odors. Credits: Google Earth

ROXBURY, NJ – Air monitors near the closed Fenimore Landfill recently reported concentrations of hydrogen sulfide way above the levels that are supposed to spark emergency alerts by the township, but no alerts were issued.

The township, last year, agreed to immediately warn residents via its emergency notification system when the 60-minute average levels of the putrid gas exceed 100 parts per billion (ppb). However, the alerts did not take place even though air monitors recently reported hydrogen sulfide (H2S) levels as high as 12,000 ppb.

“What’s been happening is we’re getting these spikes on the monitors … and they (the township) should be sending out an alert, as per their protocol, but they are not doing that,” said Bob Schultz, president the Roxbury Environmental Action Coalition (REACT) citizen group. He said the alerts are supposed to go out over the emergency alert system to which residents can subscribe.

Sign Up for E-News

However, a spokesman for the state Department of Environmental Protection (DEP) said reports of skyrocketing H2S from the monitors were  likelycaused by temporary equipment glitches, possibly the result of frigid temperatures, not by real escapes of gas from the closed dump.

"There have been no emissions of the types REACT talks about," said DEP Spokesman Larry Ragonese. "There have been cold weather malfunctions in the township's monitoring equipment and their consultant is trying to make sure it doesn't occur again."

Ragonese, stressing he can't speak on behalf of the town, said "common sense" should determine when emergency alerts are issued, especially when it comes to devices that sometimes experience glitches. "The town doesn't want to send people running and scurrying needlessly ... and causing angst when there's no need for it," he said. 

In an email sent to Roxbury Township Manager Christopher Raths on Jan. 14, REACT member Bill Morrow complained about the situation, citing readings at “ROX 6,” an air monitor on Lazarus Drive.

“Can you please explain why no alerts were sent out despite extremely high readings on ROX 6?” he asked. “My wife and daughter are home today, and when levels are high, they are instructed to turn on our air purifiers and shut the heat off to minimize toxic gas in our attic space from entering the house.”

Morrow pointed to an October 2014 letter from the township to the Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry (ATSDR), a branch of the federal Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), in which Roxbury spelled out its plan for dealing with high H2S readings. In the letter, Raths said Roxbury would issue the alerts if the 60-minute average of H2S exceeds 100 ppb and it would also open the township “respite centers” (where people can go to escape the smell) if the centers were closed.

“Why is the alert system not being used as currently defined?” asked Morrow. “This is more than several times now in the past few weeks that no alerts have been sent out, when they should have, according to township protocols.”

Raths would only say yesterday that he is investigating the matter. "We have our experts viewing the data and we anticipate a response as early as week's end," said the manager. "As to the condition of the landfill, when we have more information, we will get it out to the public. We've been fortunate that, when these incidents occur, the DEP provides an assessment of what is going on at the site itself."

Mayor Jim Rilee said the township is currently "reviewing the protocls and assessing the situation with the professionals." The mayor pointed out the township reaches out to experts when there are spikes "to see if there are any odors of gas at the time of the spike."

Schultz said he can understand a reluctance to issue emergency alerts if the monitor results were caused by a malfunction. However, he said town officials should "err on the side of caution" instead of choosing to delay. "What if it was a real spike and they delay it three hours?" he asked. "By then, somebody could be overcome with gas ... They put all these protocols in place and now they are not following them."


TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Be Interested In

Sign Up for E-News


Upcoming Events

Tue, February 27, 11:00 AM

Roxbury Public Library, Succasunna

Roxbury Area Preschool Fair



Thu, March 1, 6:30 PM

Roxbury Public Library, Succasunna

Celtic Harp Concert

Arts & Entertainment


Sat, March 3, 8:00 AM

Redeemer Lutheran Church, Succasunna

Boy Scout Troop 159 Pancake Breakfast

Food & Drink


Sat, March 10, 7:30 PM

Investors Bank Theater, Succasunna

Charlie Zahm

Arts & Entertainment



AtlantiCast: Episode 12

On this week’s episode of AtlantiCast, decade of excellence makes headlines, as Atlantic Health’s place on Fortune Magazine’s 100 Best Companies to Work For List leads off the newest episode of AtlantiCast. Also on this week’s show, check out the newest “hybrid” operating room at Morristown Medical Center and find out how Atlantic Health is helping local ...

Sponsors of Roxbury's Best Journalism

Getting it Right From the Start; Roxbury Realtor Bob Idakaar

ROXBURY, NJ – Twenty years ago this month, Bob Idakaar experienced an unprofessional real estate agent. That’s when he decided to be a good one.

Idakaar, a lifelong Succasunna resident and TAPinto Roxbury sponsor, bought his fifth home in July 1997. A big event, one that could have been joyous, ended up being stressful and unenjoyable.

“I had a bad experience,” he ...

Roxbury Diner: Homespun Hospitality Through Thick and Thin

ROXBURY, NJ – Roxbury was being buried in snow March 14 and most businesses were closed. Not Roxbury Diner.

Roxbury Diner isn’t like most businesses.For co-owner Jimmy Dontas, a snowstorm – even a blizzard – isn’t a reason to suspend operations. Instead, it’s a call to action.

To many in town, Roxbury Diner – a TAPinto Roxbury sponsor – is ...

It Began With Filling Your Tank; Now They Fix Your Grandson’s Car

When we drive east on Route 10 through Roxbury, many of us might remember a Shell station at the Randolph border next to the golf range. It was in that station that Nancy and Peyton Knight began their long history of auto repair in the township.

That was 1983 and soon the Knights’ business grew and expanded. The humble gas station gradually morphed into a state-of-the-art ...

Orthopedic Urgent Care in Roxbury - Open Late and on Weekends

ROXBURY, NJ – It’s a pleasant Sunday morning, you’re playing volleyball in the back yard with the kids and – forgetting you’re not 17 anymore – you jump up to smack that ball.

Instead of feeling the satisfaction of an unanswered spike, you feel the stinging pain of a wounded ankle.

The only good thing about this scenario is that you live in Roxbury. That ...

Love of His Hometown Drives Roxbury Realtor Ted Miller II

ROXBURY, N.J. – Most local real estate agents can tell you what houses are for sale in Roxbury. Ted Miller can probably tell you what was there before the houses were built. 

Miller, a TAPinto Roxbury sponsor, grew up in the township and has watched it change from bucolic to bustling. The son of a local Realtor, ...

Three Sons at His Side, John Klein Makes Plumbing a Family Affair

ROXBURY, N.J. - Running water and a warm house during winter months are some of the most important amenities we enjoy -- and often take for granted -- in our homes.

With John Klein Plumbing & Heating, a TAPinto Roxbury sponsor, residents of Roxbury (and beyond) have a father-and-sons company they count on for reliable plumbing and heating services to keep the ...

Letters to TAPinto Roxbury

Roxbury Library Blood Drive Will Help 111 People

January 31, 2018

Dear Editor,

On Jan. 17, the Roxbury Public Library held its first American Red Cross blood drive. Despite snow and less than ideal driving conditions, dozens of area residents showed up to donate blood, nearly doubling the Red Cross' quota for the day! 

The drive was held in honor of local resident, Matt Adonis. Having a blood rive in his honor was a lovely way to bring awareness ...

Two From Roxbury Area Make Loyola Dean's List

February 22, 2018

BALTIMORE, MD -- Two students from the Roxbury area made the Loyola University fall 2017 Dean's List.

In order to qualify for the Dean's List at Loyola, a student must achieve a minimum QPA of at least 3.500 for the term, provided that, in the term they have successfully completed courses totaling a minimum of 15 credits.

The following local students have achieved this ...

Three from Roxbury Area Make James Madison Dean's List

HARRISONBURG, VA -- James Madison University is pleased to announce the following students made the dean's list for the fall 2017 semester:

Jordan Israel Taylor of Flanders .

Nicolette Thorkildsen of Flanders .

Olivia J Viparina of Ledgewood .

Students who earn dean's list honors must carry at least 12 graded credit hours and earn a GPA of between 3.5 and 3.899.

Totaro Makes Hofstra Dean's List

HEMPSTEAD, NY -- Julia Totaro of Mt. Arlington excelled during the Fall 2017 semester, achieving a GPA of at least 3.5 to earn a spot on the Hofstra University Dean's List.

Roxbury Area Students Named to the Marist College Dean's List

POUGHKEEPSIE, NY -- The following local students have been named to the Marist College Dean's List for the Fall 2017 semester:

Mariah Christian of Flanders is a member of the Class of 2018 and is majoring in Communication.

Jenna Ficula of Flanders is a member of the Class of 2019 and is majoring in Computer Science.

Erika Hofgesang of Kenvil, is a member of the Class of ...

Roxbury Area Students Make Clemson Lists

CLEMSON, SC - Kristin Elizabeth Agosta of Flanders has been named to the President's List at Clemson University for the fall 2017 semester and three other area students were named to the Dean's List.

Agosta is majoring in Accounting.

To be named to the President's List, a student must achieve a 4.0 (all As) grade-point average.

The three Roxbury ...

Roxbury Area Students Make Seton Hall Dean's List

SOUTH ORANGE, NJ -- Nineteen Seton Hall University students from the Roxbury area qualified for the Fall 2017 dean's list, according to the university. The students are:

Siddharth Bector of Flanders 

Nicholas Czipo of Wharton 

Gabriella DePiano of Ledgewood

Darrelle Dilangalen of Succasunna

Katherine Dolan of Flanders 

Kimberly Gong of Kenvil

Edward Guenzel ...

Press Releases

Assistance Programs Available for JCP&L Customers to Help with Winter Heating Bills

February 13, 2018

MORRISTOWN,NJ - As the cold weather continues, financial assistance programs are available for Jersey Central Power & Light (JCP&L) customers who need help with winter heating bills.

Assistance to qualifying JCP&L customers is available through the Lifeline, Universal Service Fund (USF), Weatherization, Payment Assistance for Gas and Electric (PAGE) and New Jersey SHARES ... Named Partner of the Year by NJ News Commons

NEW PROVIDENCE, NJ - has been named Partner of the Year by NJ News Commons, a network of more than 230 news organizations across New Jersey.  The award goes to a journalist or news organization that showed overall excellence in their work for 2017.    

Joe Amditis, Associate Director of the Center for Cooperative Media, said TAPinto won the award ...