Law & Justice

Roxbury Gets to Argue Against Landfill's Return to Owner

Fenimore Landfill from the sky
Superior Court Judge Rosemary Ramsay
Roxbury Township Attorney Anthony Bucco

MORRISTOWN, NJ – Roxbury can intervene in a lawsuit that will determine whether the owner of the former Fenimore Landfill will regain control of the property, a judge ruled this week.

Superior Court Judge Rosemary Ramsay granted the township’s request to be part of the litigation, signing an order June 26, said Roxbury Township Attorney Anthony Bucco. The judge gave Bucco until July 31 to file a legal brief supporting the township’s position.

The property is now under the control of the state Department of Environmental Protection (DEP), which seized the land from its owner, Strategic Environmental Partners (SEP), in 2013. The seizure came after construction debris, dumped by SEP at the formerly dormant site, released clouds of noxious hydrogen sulfide that spread miles throughout Roxbury.

Sign Up for E-News

After taking control of the site, the DEP installed a cap on landfill and an odor mitigation system that is burning off the putrid gas generated when the waste, particularly wallboard particles, became wet.

SEP subsequently challenged the legality of the DEP seizure. It has so far been successful in this effort, convincing judges all the way up to the state Supreme Court that DEP Commissioner Bob Martin exceeded his authority when he had the DEP seize the property by issuing an “imminent threat” emergency decree.

The Supreme Court sent the case back to Superior Court for further consideration and it is here that Roxbury hopes to block a return of the land to SEP’s control.

“Obviously, SEP’s order to show cause was to get back the property,” said Bucco today. “SEP, in its lawsuit, is trying to get the court to require the state to turn the property back over to SEP, and obviously we are going to oppose that. Our brief will be all the reasons we think that shouldn’t occur and it’s a bad idea.”

Bucco said he will argue that SEP’s prior behavior should disqualify the company from having anything to do with the landfill. “I think they were a bad steward,” he said. “Their handling of the landfill before led to the conditions out there that were detrimental to the township. We don’t want to see that occur again.”

The state endorsed SEP’s plan to turn the former dump into a solar energy “farm,” a plan that involved leveling the site through the use of the recycled construction material. But Bucco contends the company failed to adhere to operational constraints. “They violated a number of their conditions in their agreement with the state to maintain the landfill,” he said.

The lawyer is confident SEP will not be allowed to regain control of the property. Ownership is another matter.

“SEP still owns the property, but the state has taken control over the landfill under that emergency order,” he said. “SEP still owns the underlying land. I think the DEP’s immediate goal is to close the landfill and address any of the ancillary issues that may come up as result of that closure like making sure the air is clean. We have also seen a little bit of an issue with groundwater recently and those two things are important.”

He said DEP’s “initial responsibility is to get those things under control.” What will happen in the future is unclear, he acknowledged.

“The long term plan as to how that property is maintained and owned will have to be discussed,” Bucco said. “We haven’t gotten any official determination from the DEP as to what the long range plans are … Normally, a public entity ends up taking responsibility because nobody one else will. It all depends. I don’t want to speculate as to what could occur there, but I’m pretty confident it won’t be a situation where SEP, in any way, shape or form, comes back and tries to resurrect what it did before.”

Bucco said he is pleased Roxbury will now have a say in the litigation. In seeking inclusion in the lawsuit, he argued the township and its residents – being the entities most directly impacted by the Fenimore mess – deserve a place at the litigation table.

“Obviously, we’re happy with the judge’s order,” said Bucco. “The mayor and council believe, as do I, that it’s important for the township’s voice to be heard in this case and we’re glad that the judge agrees and has given us a right to participate.”

TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Be Interested In

Sign Up for E-News

Roxbury

Upcoming Events

Carousel_image_751ce3691b8666120361_pie-966498_1920

Sat, November 18, 9:00 AM

Horseshoe Lake , Succasunna

Last Chance for Rotary Fruit and Pies!

Food & Drink

Carousel_image_aab41bb12dbd1b3272d4_2ca73a404171682cb018_no2

Sat, November 18, 9:00 AM

Roxbury Co. 2 Firehouse, Landing

Holiday Marketplace

Home & Garden

Carousel_image_4cb4b42517ef3770cefa_christmas-2017-768x614

Sat, November 18, 12:00 PM

Investor Bank Theater, Succasunna

The Christmas Chronicles, by JAM Theater Co.

Arts & Entertainment

Carousel_image_a67e853f910d6fc578a3_christmas-2017-768x614

Sat, November 18, 3:00 PM

Investor Bank Theater, Succasunna

The Christmas Chronicles by JAM Theater Co

Arts & Entertainment

Columns

Family Health

TrueBeam Offers New Options for Breast Cancer Patients

Atlantic Health System Cancer Care is now offering breast cancer patients treatments on the TrueBeam™ system.  Morristown Medical Center is one of four locations in New Jersey to offer this new radiotherapy system to patients.  

TrueBeam™ Radiotherapy System is an advanced image-guided radiation therapy (IGRT) system used to treat cancer with speed and ...

Sponsors of Roxbury's Best Journalism

Getting it Right From the Start; Roxbury Realtor Bob Idakaar

ROXBURY, NJ – Twenty years ago this month, Bob Idakaar experienced an unprofessional real estate agent. That’s when he decided to be a good one.

Idakaar, a lifelong Succasunna resident and TAPinto Roxbury sponsor, bought his fifth home in July 1997. A big event, one that could have been joyous, ended up being stressful and unenjoyable.

“I had a bad experience,” he ...

Letters to TAPinto Roxbury

Thank You Roxbury

November 9, 2017

It is not an easy task to put yourself out there and run for office. 

All four of the candidates who ran for Roxbury Township Board of Education had the best interests of our district and its students at heart, and all four of us brought a unique perspective to the table.

Roxbury would have “won” regardless of who prevailed in Tuesday's election.

Bearing that in ...

I Am Voting For Heather Champagne for Roxbury School Board

Today I will be voting for Heather McMurchie Champagne for Roxbury NOW.

Why? Because she is the best candidate for the position, in my opinion.

She has been involved in the community, not just at the school level. She understands what changes need to be made to best benefit the schools and most importantly our children.

Having a child in our schools, Heather is able to see first hand the ...

Press Releases

Atlantic Health's Dr. Bernard Maria Recognized with Most Prestigious Child Neurology Honor

November 17, 2017

MORRISTOWN, NJ – Dr. Bernard Maria, director of the Division of Child Neurology and Developmental Medicine at Goryeb Children's Hospital, part of Atlantic Health System, has been recognized with the 2018 Hower Award, the highest recognition from the Child Neurology Society.

This prestigious award is given yearly to one member of the Child Neurology Society who is highly regarded by ...

JCP&L Completes Inspections and Maintenance Prior to Winter Weather

MORRISTOWN, NJ - In preparation for winter, Jersey Central Power & Light (JCP&L), a subsidiary of FirstEnergy Corp. (NYSE: FE), is completing inspections and conducting equipment maintenance on weather-sensitive equipment across its service area.  

Winter’s cold temperatures can produce increased demand for electricity, and heavy snow and wind have the potential to cause ...