Council Approves Use of Eminent Domain in Scotch Plains Downtown Redevelopment in 3-2 Vote Along Party Lines

Councilwoman Rose Checchio Credits: Sean Conklin
Councilman John Del Sordi Credits: Sean Conklin
Deputy Mayor Llewellyn Jones Credits: Sean Conklin
Mayor Al Smith Credits: John Mooney

SCOTCH PLAINS, NJ – Following a contentious 20-minute discussion, the Township Council approved a resolution that would allow eminent domain in a 3 1/2 block radius in downtown Scotch Plains in a 3-2 party line vote on Tuesday evening at the Scotch Plains Municipal Building.

The resolution designates the right of the local government to potentially reassess private property for public use in the form of payment or compensation of fair market value, if necessary, as part of the downtown redevelopment process. Township leaders have stepped up redevelopment plans in recent months due to the ongoing COAH affordable housing litigation. Surrounding municipalities in Union County, including Fanwood, have undergone affordable housing litigation, which is being driven by the Fair Share Housing Center and enforced by the Supreme Court of the State of New Jersey.

The debated vote comes less than a week after the Downtown Redevelopment Committee’s second meeting, which evaluated the pros and cons, according to Scotch Plains Mayor Al Smith and Deputy Mayor Llewellyn Jones, both members of the newly-formed group. The counsel of the committee advised the governing body to include eminent domain on the plan as a "tool in their toolbox." Several local property owners are on the committee including Joe Mortarulo, managing partner of Darby Road on Park Ave.

Sign Up for E-News

“This is not an easy decision for me,” said Mayor Al Smith, who is chairman of the Downtown Redevelopment Committee. “We’ve got a new factor in this: Fair Share Housing There’s a lot of decisions that we have to make on behalf of our residents as their representatives. The last thing I want is somebody telling me what to do with or around my property.”

“An entire plan could potentially collapse because one property owner doesn’t want to sell their property,” Smith continued. “The court could then come in and dictate where they are going to build the property in the last place you want to be in Scotch Plains.”

Councilwoman Rose Checchio and Councilman John Del Sordi both voted no on the resolution.  

“I want to see the Downtown Redevelopment move forward, but I just have a hard time (voting for this) because I would like to hear from the property owners first,” said Checchio, who added that she understands there are incentives and other positive takeaways. “I can’t vote yes on this until I have a better understanding how property owners in Scotch Plains feel about this.”

“If I lived on one of these streets around here, I wouldn’t want somebody having that ‘tool in their toolbox’ to dictate to me what they (decide to do) with my property for fair market value,” explained an impassioned Del Sordi. “Not while I’m ever up here will I support eminent domain and dictate to these people what they should do with their properties.”

He acknowledged the good work that the Scotch Plains Redevelopment Committee was doing and was encouraged with the progress that has been made.

Deputy Mayor Llewellyn Jones, who is also vice-chairman of the Scotch Plains Downtown Redevelopment Committee, refuted the claim that the public was left in the dark.

“I don’t think it should be a surprise to anybody that we’re talking about Downtown Redevelopment,” suggested Jones, who admitted that he was originally against the concept of eminent domain in Scotch Plains a couple years ago.

He added that two things have changed – the ongoing affordable housing litigation and the advice of the counsel.

“We have to keep in mind our responsibility to the entirety of the town,” Jones explained. “(Scotch Plains) is under pressure to undergo redevelopment and that’s being forced upon us by the Supreme Court of the State of New Jersey as we continue to negotiate hard in the town’s best interest.”

There are currently no immediate plans of enforcing eminent domain and in the event that issue arises, it is a lengthy process that involves both the council and Planning Board. The entire council was in agreement that it is something they would not like to see happen.  

The Downtown Redevelopment Committee will host its next meeting on Wednesday, June 14 at 6:30 p.m. at Town Hall and the public is invited to attend. is Scotch Plains-Fanwood’s only free daily paper. Sign up for our daily eNews and follow us on Facebook and twitter @SPF_TAP. Download the free TAPinto App for iPhone or Android.

TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Be Interested In

Sign Up for E-News

Scotch Plains/Fanwood

New Ice Rink Gets Green Light from Westfield Town Council

May 23, 2018

WESTFIELD, NJ — A standing room-only crowd cheered and booed Tuesday night after the town council, with a 6-3 vote, passed a resolution granting Mayor Shelley Brindle the authority to negotiate a lease agreement with Arena Realty Partners for a temporary ice rink at Gumbert Park this winter.

Brindle made her case for testing out the public-private partnership.

“I don’t ...

Capitalist or Communist?

Karl Marx may have been the pioneer, but many other Jews were also involved in the struggle for communism, particularly in the early days of the Russian revolution. Personally, I don’t think that we have any apologies to make for this phenomenon. Having suffered unbearably under successive oppressive regimes, many of those political activists genuinely thought communism would be better ...

The Facts About Vaping

May 13, 2018

Dear Editor:

The recent public discussion about vaping and “Juuling” that occurred at our high school really opened the eyes of a lot of parents who may have been clueless about what their kids are doing to themselves. There is a lot of conflicting and confusing information available online, on YouTube and social media about the so-called benefits of vaping vs. smoking ...

Softball: Peralta's Walk-Off Homer Gives Union Catholic a Dramatic 2-1 Win Over DePaul in State Tournament

May 24, 2018

SCOTCH PLAINS, NJ -- Gianna Peralta belted a walk-off homer over the center-field fence to lead off the bottom of the eighth inning to give third-seeded Union Catholic a 2-1 victory over DePaul in the quarterfinal round of the NJSIAA North Jersey, Non-Public A Tournament on Wednesday in Scotch Plains. 

Peralta, a freshman, drove in both runs for the Vikings, ...