Letters to the Editor

Proof requested - Proof provided


Citizens of Scotch Plains:

During my12 years serving on our Board of Education, I have never publicly discussed either a board or council election and have struggled with the decision to do so this year.  What has swayed me to speak out is that this is not based on an individual, but rather a political party’s activity.

As you may be aware, I have accused a political party of endorsing a BOE candidate in this year’s election. There have been public denials and claims that I’m uninformed and biased. I am biased, but that bias is towards ANY political party endorsing a BOE candidate.

Sign Up for E-News

In regards to my being uninformed, I provide to you the following:

1.  Attached are the petitions filed by each Polhamus candidate for BOE seats. (Mr. Polhamus withdrew soon after the ballot positions were established and his wife received the first position). As can be seen on each petition, the signatures are in the exact order as they would be if passed around the table. In fact, they were signed at a Republican Party Committee meeting. Each signature, with the exception of the adult child of the Polhamus's is either a Republican Committee person or an associate Committee person. The signatures include the Party chair and a current councilman who is seeking re-election. 

2.  Included in these 12 signatures are ten who are either members of the Tea Party, or their spouses. The reason why I point this out is related to the following letter.

3. Below is a link to a website created by Mr. Polhamus. While it is currently active, it includes the announcement that his group has officially merged with the Union County Tea Party, so I do not know how much longer it will remain active.

4. This link originally directed one to a letter titled “One of Our Own”.  It is a Party supporter’s perspective on candidate’s night and provides a reference point of the philosophy of the candidate and her supporters. A careful read of the letter will confirm cuts to the school budget will come if and when these party-backed candidates gain a majority. The cuts will be achievable because they will bring “sharpened pencils.”

Curiously, when their letter was pasted onto Facebook, it was removed from the Polhamus website within hours. While elected officials do not always make popular decisions, we always make them by the light of day, regardless if we are talking to “our own” or not.

As I have previously stated, this issue is larger than one party. In fact, while it is a faction of the Republican Party, including a current councilman supporting this candidate, a sitting Democrat Councilwomen did not hesitate to post a comment on Facebook deriding this behavior and connecting it to the current council election. If that is not enough proof that both parties are willing to use our school elections, and ultimately our children’s education for political gain, I don’t know what is.

Last year, the top vote getter received 1,200 votes. Grassroots will only defeat an organized party if every parent and person concerned about our school district comes out and votes.  Talk to people and share this information so that voters are fully informed when making a decision. Many are still unaware of what is quietly happening with this election.

I apologize for the length but ask that you read the below letter from someone who requests his name be withheld.


Trip Whitehouse

Below is the text of the letter. I also urge you to visit their site www.concernedcitizensofunioncounty.com/blog/one-of-our-own.

One of Our Own


One of our members is running for the Board of Education in Scotch Plains.  Good for her!  Michelle Polhamus felt this was a chance for her to do something for the town and its residents.  

At the candidates night earlier this week, she got quite an unfair hearing.  Many in the crowd seemed to have come prepared to not approve of her.  In fact, the long knives were clearly out for her.

Many in the audience -- and many in town apparently -- think that she has been endorsed by the Republican Party.  The evidence that the Board chairman, Trip Whitehouse, cites for this is that the town party committee chairman happened to mention several months ago, once, in a private email to members of the committee, that he supports her.  The local committee itself did not endorse her, nor was it ever asked to do so.  (I think the complaining ill-informed members of the public think the committee is run Soviet style; that the chairman makes all the decisions.  I suspect that may be the way the Other Party does things. The Republican Party at least in Scotch Plains actually takes votes.  I suspect that is a shocking revelation for the Others.)  The committee did not ever raise funds for her, nor did it pay for any literature or lawn signs for her.  (She has not put up any signs, unlike the other challenger running who has signs up all over town, including on public property.)  No one on the committee has gone knocking on doors for her, nor have any of the party political candidates or politicians held 'meet and greets' for her (again, unlike for the other challenger the last time he ran).

Michelle's candidacy has so threatened the Board chairman that he recently published a second letter to the editor on this topic, and in this one he endorsed the other challenger and the incumbent for the two positions on the ballot!  That is interesting.  The Board Chairman publicly endorses candidates in the election?  I think that was completely inappropriate.  

Michelle had the gall (being sarcastic here) to suggest that perhaps the Board ought to try to have a flat budget next year.  She was immediately challenged for that by a former BOE member, who said something like "How could you accomplish that since the teachers are guaranteed raises?"  On the face of it, is was a fair question.  Michelle's response was that many people in town do not get raises every year and can't continue to afford ever increasing property taxes.  She might have raised the point that the Board, by agreeing to teacher contracts with automatic raises, must have decided at the time of agreeing to them that they would raise taxes (or cut other expenses) in order to pay for those raises.  What Michelle was really challenging, it seems to me, was the Board's decision, implicitly made when it agreed to guaranteed raises, to continue to raise property taxes in order to pay for the raises.  

The Board Chairman, in his letter to the editor, made the case that the teacher raises next year would cost at least $1.6MM and in order to have a flat budget there would have to be cuts in that amount in other areas.  He suggested they could fire 25 teachers to make up that $1.6MM.  That's a ridiculous number of teachers, of course, because simple math (the old-fashioned style, not the new math) tells me that $1.6MM divided by 25 is on the order of $64,000 a teacher. I know for a fact that there are a whole lot of teachers whose salary and benefits cost the District a lot more than $64,000 a year. I suspect they could let 10 teachers go and get pretty close to three-quarters of the $1.6MM number.  But I don't have all the financial details to firm that guess up.  The chairman put forth that instead of firing teachers (which of course raises that dreaded specter of increased class size (the big canard of education)) the BOE could cut all sports and extracurricular activities as well as cut maintenance etc. The chairman seems to think that members of the public cannot keep two thoughts in their heads at the same time. How about this Mr. Chairman - why not let a some teachers and aides go and at the same time sharpen your pencil and cut some expenses to get to the $1.6MM number?  Who knows, maybe if the teachers were faced with cuts in their numbers they might agree to forego some or all of their raises.  Oh the unions would howl and I am not sure they really believe in collectivism when things don't go their way like they do when the money flows freely.

Anyway, my real point was to thanks Michelle for putting herself out there which takes a lot of guts and to bemoan the horrible treatment Michelle had to endure during the candidates night.  An example of the sandbagging:  the moderator actually publicly admitted on stage that she had been instructed by the BOE chairman, Mr. Whitehouse, to mention that Michelle had been endorsed by the Republican Party.  

So it was pretty clear who was playing games here, and it wasn't Michelle.  The education establishment in town is horrified that someone who actually understands that the BOE taxes us far more than the town (and even more than Union County), someone who understands that the education establishment is quite happy with the manifest unfairness of the state funding formula for state aid to school districts, someone who might want to stop the ever increasing tax increases which are incredibly burdensome to seniors, families on fixed incomes and the children of those families, might actually get onto the Board of Ed. 

Name Withheld For the Time Being 

The opinions expressed herein are the writer's alone, and do not reflect the opinions of TAPinto.net or anyone who works for TAPinto.net. TAPinto.net is not responsible for the accuracy of any of the information supplied by the writer. Click here to submit a Letter to the Editor.

TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Be Interested In

Sign Up for E-News

Scotch Plains/Fanwood

Westfield Family Continues ‘Summer of Kindness’ with Infant Clothing Drive

July 12, 2018

WESTFIELD, NJ — Westfield mom and teacher Sara Liptack is continuing her family’s “Summer of Kindess” with an infant clothing for Furniture Assist, an organization in Springfield that helps formerly homeless people, veterans, the elderly, fire victims, refugees and people fleeing domestic violence.

“I said, ‘What’s the one thing you really ...

It's Not What You Are Eating, It's What's Eating You


Emotional eating can be described as episodes of binge-eating, grazing and/or eating when not hungry to soothe feelings. Emotional eaters have a pattern of eating to cope with stress, emotional conflicts and problems of daily life.

Emotional eating is eating for reasons other than hunger. Instead of physical symptoms initiating the eating, ...

What Is Your Bottom Line?

This week's Parshah (Torah reading) is the Parshah of Pinchas the Zealot: the courageous young priest who stood up against idolatry and immorality and, in the end, saved Israel from a devastating plague.

While Pinchas' radical response made him a hero worthy of having a Torah section named after him, we wouldn't necessarily suggest to our children ...

State-Imposed Affordable Housing Requirements Will Lead to Overdevelopment in Scotch Plains

July 17, 2018

Dear Editor:

There will be a public hearing in Trenton concerning the affordable housing process on Wednesday, July 25, 2018 from 10:00 a.m. to 3:00 p.m. at the State House Annex (131-137 W State St, Trenton, NJ 08608) in Committee Room 16 on the 4th floor.

This hearing is hosted by the Assembly Housing and Community Development Committee, and the Committee will receive ...

When to Dial 911: Scotch Plains Rescue Squad Tip of the Month

July 10, 2018

There are many times you should call 911. If you or someone around you is in true medical distress, such as experiencing difficulty breathing, chest pains, bleeding, possible stroke, or any other serious health issues, then 911 should be called as soon as possible. If there are wires down, fire, a crime in progress, or other dangerous conditions to people or property, call 911 ...

Caring Contact Volunteer Listener Training Fall 2018

July 18, 2018

WESTFIELD, NJ -- Have you ever been told you are a good listener? Do you have a yearning to really make a difference? Become a Caring and Crisis Hotline Listener.

You could save a life.

Volunteers receive 52 hours of comprehensive training in active listening, Mental Health First Aid and Applied Suicide Intervention Skills Training.  You also are supported by ...

Upcoming Events


Mon, July 23, 8:00 PM

Scotch Plains Public Library, Scotch Plains

View the Night Sky at the Scotch Plains Public ...

Arts & Entertainment Education


Wed, July 25, 6:00 PM

JCC of Central NJ, Scotch Plains

The JCC’s Barracudas Swim Team Meet the Coaches ...



Wed, July 25, 7:00 PM


Downtown Westfield 5K & Pizza Extravaganza