Scotch Plains Settles on Its "Fair Share" Affordable Housing Number

Bob Renaud Credits: John Mooney
Michael Mistretta Credits: John Mooney
Development at Parker Gardens location would include a new ballfield. Credits: John Mooney
Amberg property
North Ave. plot Credits: John Mooney
Downtown Redevelopment District Credits: John Mooney
Jerusalem Ave. near Scotch Hills Country Club Credits: John Mooney
Deputy Mayor Llewellyn Jones Credits: John Mooney
Mayor Al Smith believes affordable housing advocates aren't concerned with the impact of new housing units on the existing infrastructure or the impact on the school system. Credits: John Mooney

SCOTCH PLAINS, NJ -- Revealing a number that seems to please no one locally, Mayor Al Smith and the Scotch Plains Council announced on Tuesday that the Township has settled on a figure of 598 units for its state-mandated affordable housing obligation.

"Scotch Plains was among 300 municipalities that filed petitions. Not all of them are compliant for one reason or another," Mayor Smith explained. "The municipality has been involved since July 2015 in forming a housing ordinance and fair share plan, negotiating with developers, and dealing with special master (court-appointed planner) who oversees the development (of affordable housing)."

The housing units would be built at several different locations, including land that currently belongs to Bowcraft (200 units; 35 affordable) on Route 22, Parker Gardens (228 units; 34 affordable) on Terrill Road, Amberg Perennial Farm & Garden (125 units; 19 affordable) on Lamberts Mill Road, and parcels of land in the downtown redevelopment district, on North Avenue, and near Jerusalem Road.

Sign Up for E-News

Planner Michael Mistretta of Harbor Consultants, and Scotch Plains's affordable-housing attorney, Bob Renaud, walked the council and members of the audience through a detailed presentation that illustrated the locations and the number of units scheduled to be at each site. They explained that the 598 figure actually represents a 30 percent reduction in the number originally proposed as the township's obligation:854.

Mr. Renaud said that the "fair share" housing numbers come from formulas that take into account overall population, low-income population, the size of the town, and residents’ incomes and added that they "have no relation to reality.”

If the agreement, scheduled to be officially signed on Feb. 16, remains unchanged, more than 3,000 total new housing units will be developed in order for affordable-housing units to comprise 15 percent. To put that into perspective: Scotch Plains currently has 8,795 total housing units, according to the U.S. Census Bureau

At the meeting, Mayor Smith said that the township’s zoning ordinances would have to be revised to allow for multi-family housing units to be built on streets on which they currently are not allowed. Meanwhile, the mayor said he would speaking with state legislators in Trenton about solutions that would yield “more logical, more realistic” affordable housing numbers.  

In a phone interview with TAPintoSPF, Deputy Mayor Llewellyn Jones, who has been working on this issue for years, said: "The number of units we are settling on has been crammed down our throats through a totally asinine process contrived by the New Jersey State Supreme Court."

Jones says that the housing numbers were "created by a special interest group out of Cherry Hill that clearly has no understanding of our township."  

"I'm confident that we did the best we could given the situation," Jones said. "I'm optimistic for redevelopment in our downtown that will be beneficial to property owners and residents at large, but at the same time disappointed with other zoning changes that will infringe on residential areas."

Jones and Mayor Smith believe that the alternative of going to trial would have cost millions of dollars and risked far worse outcomes.

"I believe there is a need of affordable housing," Mayor Smith said at the meeting. "But at the end of the day, we are committed to implementing this agreement as best we can but will continue to seek better numbers."

The mayor said that the courts and the Fair Share Housing Center, which champions the building of affordable units, can "come in and tell us to build," but they don't care about the need for new infrastructure and the impact on the school system, which he says is near capacity.

"We will work to comply with the terms of the settlement and push as aggressively as possible for specific outcomes to protect the value of existing Scotch Plains property owners," Jones said. "Hopefully market forces and terms of the settlement will dictate that much of the overdevelopment remains theoretical and not tangible." is Scotch Plains-Fanwood’s only free daily paper. Sign up for our daily eNews and follow us on Facebook and twitter @SPF_TAP. Download the free TAPinto App for iPhone or Android.

TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Be Interested In

Sign Up for E-News

Scotch Plains/Fanwood

Update: Health Authorities Still Investigating Flu Death of Elizabeth Schoolgirl

February 19, 2018

ELIZABETH, NJ - The New Jersey Department of Health is continuing to investigate the cause of the passing of elementary school student Daniela Genaro after it was confirmed that the student had been diagnosed with influenza. Officials said it "presently remains unclear whether or not the virus was the primary contributing factor to the child's passing."

In a second letter ...

The Missing Moses

A seemingly dubious distinction belongs to this week’s Parshah, Tetzaveh (Exodus 27:20–30:10). It is the only reading in the Torah — from the first Parshah of the book of Exodus (in which he is born) until the end of the book of Numbers — where the name of Moses is not mentioned. Tetzaveh’s opening words are V’atah ...

Congratulations to UCDC Chairman Nick Scutari

February 23, 2018

Dear Editor:

First, congratulations to Chairman Nick Scutari. I look forward to working alongside him as 1st Vice Chair of the Union County Democratic Committee. 

For the last three weeks, this campaign for UCDC Chair displayed the power we have and the voice we share. You are the leaders, citizens and activists who are helping shape our future. What you do in your hometowns and ...

Being Alone on Valentine’s Day

February 13, 2018

Valentine’s Day is a day filled with Hallmark cards, chocolate covered strawberries, red roses and special dining.  It’s a day to express our love and affection to those close to us.  Some of us have expectations that this day will be blissful, we may even receive that diamond ring that represents engagement or marriage.

Valentine’s Day can be a wonderful time if ...

Poems Are Wanted for Fanwood Carriage House Poetry Prize

February 23, 2018

FANWOOD, NJ – The Carriage House Poetry Series and the Fanwood Shade Tree Commission are sponsoring the 2018 Carriage House Poetry Prize with a first prize of $300 plus publication of the winning poem in the autumn edition of Tiferet Journal.

Poets are invited to enter one or two poems – 40 lines or less each. There is a $5.00 entry fee for each contestant. Poems must be previously ...

Upcoming Events


Sun, February 25, 10:00 AM

Camp Riverbend, Warren

Camp Riverbend Open House

Arts & Entertainment


Wed, February 28, 1:00 PM

Mountainside Borough Hall (Recreation Room), Mountainside

Hearts for Hope; Create a moment of joy to those ...

Giving Back