SP-F Tea Party Hosts Forum for Town Council Candidates

Al Smith, a member of the Scotch Plains-Fanwood Tea Party, moderates the discussion. Credits: Tom Fortunato
Scotch Plains Republican township council candidate Ed Saridaki speaks, as Republican mayoral candidate Mary DePaola looks on. Credits: Tom Fortunato
Fanwood incumbent Republican Mike Szuch speaks, surrounded by Democratic candidates Dan Levine (left) and Jack Molenaar (left). Republican incumbent Bob Manduca is on the far left. Credits: Tom Fortunato
Scotch Plains mayoral candidate Kevin Glover takes the mic. Even though Mr. Glover is a Democrat, he is described as "a fiscal conservative" and is well liked by members of The Scotch Plains-Fanwood Tea Party. Credits: Tom Fortunato
The row of the candidates, with Bob Manduca speaking. Credits: Tom Fortunato
Mary DePaola speaks, flanked by Democratic council candidate Colleen Gialanella and Republican council candidate Ed Saridaki. Credits: Tom Fortunato

 

SCOTCH PLAINS—on Tuesday evening, the Scotch Plains-Fanwood Tea Party sponsored and organized an open forum for Scotch Plains and Fanwood town council candidates to let residents get to know who they are, answer questions from residents, and debate each other.

From Scotch Plains, incumbent township council members Kevin Glover and Mary DePaola attended, both of whom are running for mayor in November. Also from Scotch Plains were political newcomers Colleen Gialanella, a Democrat, and Ed Saridaki, a Republican, whom are running for council.

Sign Up for E-News

On the Fanwood side were incumbent Republican council members Bob Manduca and Mike Szuch, along with their Democratic challengers Dan Levine and Jack Molenaar. Mr. Molenaar had previously served on the borough council from 2004 to 2006, running alongside Mayor Colleen Mahr. “We started our first terms together,” Mr. Molenaar added.

The most discussed topic at the meeting was the sharing of services between the two municipalities, specifically the police force. All four candidates on the Scotch Plains side were in favor of sharing services with Fanwood.

Kevin Glover described shared services as “when you get to dance with your partner before you marry them.”

“Let’s not go too quickly into the dark,” Mr. Glover explained, “[we] better make sure we have safety on the street, let’s have verified auditable savings, and if for whatever reason if we’re not to work, let’s have the ability to opt out.”

“The problem is, Kevin and I actually agree on a lot of this stuff,” Mary DePaola added.

On the Fanwood side however, the attitude towards shared services was different. While most of the candidates favored the idea in general, they were more cautious. Councilman Bob Manduca in particular stood out as being very opposed to the merger and he expressed a lot of skepticism that sharing services with Scotch Plains would in fact save any money at all.

“Look at the people who are pushing shared services: ‘stop, don’t think, just do a shared service,’” Mr. Manduca warned, “it’s the Democratic headed legislature, it’s the head of our county, it’s people who look at us the same way Colonel Sanders looked at the chickens.”

Mr. Manduca stressed that since Scotch Plains uses the “civil service” rules for its police force while Fanwood doesn’t, and for these two police departments to be successfully merged and save any money at all would require use of the special laws in Governor Christie’s “tool-kit” which was passed last year.

“One of the key things that causes caution where I’m concerned,” Mr. Manduca explained, “You can talk to the people at the Eagleton School at Rutgers University School of Government, they say that what is called the ‘tool-kit’ is going to be litigated. It will take years.”

“Let’s assume theoretically that we merged our police departments,” Mr. Manduca continued, “8 years from now, an unelected judge can say ‘wait a second, that tool-kit wasn’t legal.’ And [Fanwood] could wind up with all the responsibilities and all the back-salaries [of Scotch Plains]… it could wind up costing [Fanwood] millions.”

Frank Festa, a member of the Scotch Plains-Fanwood Tea Party, asked the candidates whether they prefer their town to be managed by a hired manager, or by the council and a “strong mayor.”

Fanwood is incorporated as a borough and thus is governed under the borough form of government in accordance with the Borough Acts of 1878, 1897 and 1987. Fanwood is managed only by its council and mayor. Scotch Plains, however, is governed under the “Council-Manager Form” in accordance with the Faulkner Act and therefore most of Scotch Plains’ decisions are made by an independent manager hired by the council, not an elected official.

Each candidate, regardless of whether they were from Scotch Plains or Fanwood, defended their own town’s form of governance.

“I think for the most part the average citizen doesn’t really care what form of government we are as long as we do a good job and save money,” answered Mr. Molenaar, who then added: “I’ve always been in favor of the benevolent dictator form of government. Napoleon did a good job when he redeveloped Paris… I don’t know if that’s an option in New Jersey, but maybe it’s something we could look into.”

“We’ve got no problem with people stepping up and being very active in the management of the community,” Mr. Manduca answered, “I wouldn’t perceive changing it. You don’t get any lower than zero, either, in administrative costs.”

Mr. Sardacki, on the Scotch Plains side, supported having a manager: “I’m a firm believer of using expertise. If you have community members that have the expertise to manage an entity the size of Scotch Plains, then by all means come forward and do it for nothing.”

“It’s the council’s responsibility to make sure [the hired manager] does a good job of running [the township],” Mr. Sardacki added, “in the same way, it keeps the council from micro-managing… The council, unless they are a certified municipal manager, don’t know how to do it, but they do know what needs to be done and what the taxpayers want to have done.”

TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Like

Sign Up for E-News

Scotch Plains/Fanwood

Debate Over Bike Trails in Watchung Reservation Continue at Union County Freeholders Meeting

April 22, 2017

ELIZABETH, NJ — Debate about the possible addition of trails for mountain biking in Watchung Reservation continued at Thursday night’s Union County Freeholders meeting. The county had asked for input regarding the trails in February, which sparked an outpouring of people into the subsequent board meetings.

A resolution regarding mountain biking had appeared on the agenda for ...

Feelin' Hot, Hot, Hot

The real estate market is heating up! Homes are selling quickly in the entry-level price points and things are moving in the luxury market as well. According to NJ real estate valuation expert Jeff Otteau, "For the first time in a decade, we're seeing an increase in demand for houses in the $1M to $2.5M price range ... this is a significant change."

Multiple ...

Paramedic Unit Now Stationed at the Scotch Plains Rescue Squad

The Scotch Plains Rescue Squad is pleased to announce that advanced medical care for our community and surrounding towns is now closer than ever. Since December 2016, paramedics from JFK Medical Center have being stationed at our building on Bartle Avenue.

The rescue squad provides BLS care (Basic Life Support) by Emergency Medical Technicians. This includes everything from the stabilization ...

Election Sloganeering

April 23, 2017

Dear Editor:

November seems like a long way off, but is it possible to at least hear more substantive ideas instead of recycling campaign rhetoric?

Presenting a litany of a city's or state's problems (and virtues) without offering any real solutions, improvements or original ideas is somewhat embarrassing. "Keep our schools great." What does that mean?

"We need to ...

American Sign Language Interpreter at Scotch Plains Public Library Program

April 28, 2017

The Scotch Plains Public Library is pleased to announce that they will have an American Sign Language interpreter at a program for the first time. On Sunday, April 30 at 1pm, the Library will host a panel discussion as part of its Voices from the Margins series. In Survival, Remembrance, and Rebuilding, Survivors of the Holocaust and the Rwandan genocide, and a descendant of Armenian survivors, ...

Upcoming Events

Carousel_image_7a446abe7f0bf0b7cac5_y

Sat, April 29, 7:00 AM

Westfield Area YMCA, Westfield

Fitness 'Fun' Raiser

Health & Wellness

Carousel_image_4244135d9adae5526321_stem_day0417

Sat, April 29, 9:00 AM

Mother Seton High School, Clark

Free STEM Day at Mother Seton for Girls in 6th, ...

Carousel_image_7c55d267c3ad6cae79c4_scotch_plains_library_5-1-16

Sat, April 29, 10:00 AM

Scotch Plains Public Library, Scotch Plains

Practice ACT Testing at the Scotch Plains Public ...

Education