Law & Justice

Westfield Watcher House - Defense Attorney Believes Lawsuit Will Ultimately Be Dismissed

A motion to dismiss the entirety of the lawsuit filed over Westfield’s “Watcher" house was rejected on Thursday by a Superior Court judge. Credits: John Mooney

ELIZABETH, N J— A motion to dismiss the entirety of the lawsuit filed over Westfield’s “Watcher" house was rejected on Thursday by a Superior Court judge, as confirmed by former owners’ defense attorney, Richard Kaplow. However, several counts against them, and Caldwell Banker, were dismissed, he said.

“Based on the comments of the court, I believe ultimately after some discovery the entirety of the case will be dismissed,” Kaplow said. “I don’t think the case has any merit and I don't think it should have been filed in the first place.”

The current owners of the house, who bought it for $1.3 million in 2014, have claimed that disturbing letters signed “The Watcher” are preventing them from being able to sell the Dutch Colonial on Boulevard, which they never moved into. They are suing on the grounds that the former owners did disclose to them the creepy letters prior to closing. 

Sign Up for E-News

The case, and the house, have received national and international media attention since the lawsuit was filed last summer.

According to Kaplow, the former owners did receive one anonymous letter prior to the sale, but that that is no legal basis for a lawsuit. 

“There is case law in New Jersey that says there is no duty to disclose something like the single letter my clients received prior to the closing,” Kaplow said. “There is no duty, and there is therefore no merit for the case.”

Calls made by TAP into Westfield to Lee Levitt, the attorney for the plaintiffs, and to attorney Louis Chiafullo, representing Caldwell Banker, were not immediately returned.

TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Be Interested In

Sign Up for E-News

Scotch Plains/Fanwood

New Ice Rink Gets Green Light from Westfield Town Council

May 23, 2018

WESTFIELD, NJ — A standing room-only crowd cheered and booed Tuesday night after the town council, with a 6-3 vote, passed a resolution granting Mayor Shelley Brindle the authority to negotiate a lease agreement with Arena Realty Partners for a temporary ice rink at Gumbert Park this winter.

Brindle made her case for testing out the public-private partnership.

“I don’t ...

Capitalist or Communist?

Karl Marx may have been the pioneer, but many other Jews were also involved in the struggle for communism, particularly in the early days of the Russian revolution. Personally, I don’t think that we have any apologies to make for this phenomenon. Having suffered unbearably under successive oppressive regimes, many of those political activists genuinely thought communism would be better ...

The Facts About Vaping

May 13, 2018

Dear Editor:

The recent public discussion about vaping and “Juuling” that occurred at our high school really opened the eyes of a lot of parents who may have been clueless about what their kids are doing to themselves. There is a lot of conflicting and confusing information available online, on YouTube and social media about the so-called benefits of vaping vs. smoking ...

Softball: Peralta's Walk-Off Homer Gives Union Catholic a Dramatic 2-1 Win Over DePaul in State Tournament

May 24, 2018

SCOTCH PLAINS, NJ -- Gianna Peralta belted a walk-off homer over the center-field fence to lead off the bottom of the eighth inning to give third-seeded Union Catholic a 2-1 victory over DePaul in the quarterfinal round of the NJSIAA North Jersey, Non-Public A Tournament on Wednesday in Scotch Plains. 

Peralta, a freshman, drove in both runs for the Vikings, ...