Green

If a Tree Falls in Maplewood... Who Should Pay?

48cbc84330cc74d0a51b_e6e59a42bb95d3ee75f2_861f158dd5317c909ec1_20180312_182658.jpg
Kathryn Carliner Credits: Joe Strupp
48cbc84330cc74d0a51b_e6e59a42bb95d3ee75f2_861f158dd5317c909ec1_20180312_182658.jpg

MAPLEWOOD, NJ - If a Maplewood Township tree’s limb falls on your car in a rain storm and causes hundreds of dollars in damage, does the Township pay for it?

Not always. Just ask Kathryn Carliner of Dunnell Road. 

Carliner, a five-year resident of the area, is disputing Town Hall’s rejection of her claim that a tree limb that crashed on to her Honda CRV’s hood last fall during a windy storm is the Township’s responsibility.

Sign Up for E-News

“That is what I am contesting, that is what I don’t think I should have to pay,” Carliner said in an interview.

At issue is the $750 portion of the repairs that Carliner’s auto insurance did not cover due to her high deductible. She contends the Township should pay because the limb that did the damage was from a tree that was on Township property.

That property is the berm, the strip of land that runs along the curb of most Township streets, often dividing it from a sidewalk.

In Carliner’s case, that portion of Dunnell where she parked her car on Oct. 29, 2017, has no sidewalk. But since the tree is right next to the curb it is considered Township property.

When Carliner filed a claim at Town Hall for the $750, the case was turned over to the Township’s insurance carrier, PMA Companies of Janesville, Wis. In a letter to Carliner, the insurance carrier agreed that the tree was on Township property.

But the same letter rejected the claim, stating that the Township “had no notice of the condition purported to have caused the incident and, thus, no legal responsibility for the incident.”

It later cited a state statute related to claims against public agencies, which states, in part:

A public entity shall be deemed to have constructive notice of a dangerous condition only if the plaintiff establishes that the condition had existed for such a period of time and was of such an obvious nature that the public entity, in the exercise of due care, should have discovered the condition and its dangerous character.

Carliner contends that there was no way to foreshadow the dangerous condition because it was not on her property, and it became dangerous during the severe storm.

“I’m not a tree expert, how would I know if it was vulnerable?” she said. “I think it’s ridiculous. It was not on my property.”

She later added, “This was a huge limb that was obviously knocked off because of the storm.”

But Township officials say the insurance rejection stands and they plan to take no additional action.

“There is nothing further to comment on,” Maplewood Township Administrator Joseph Manning said via email. “She made a claim and our insurance company denied it. The Township does not pay claims that our insurance company denies.”

Asked if the Township would seek to discuss the findings with the insurance carrier, Manning wrote, “No, there have been similar claims in the past and I am confident that the decision is sound.”

TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Be Interested In

Sign Up for E-News

SOMA

Maplewood Police Blotter - Man Arrested for Package Thefts

April 20, 2018

April 5 - Shoplifting; At approximately 3:15 p.m. officers responded to the Extra Supermarket on Irvington Ave on a reported shoplifter. Jean Legerme, age 21 of Newark was detained by security for attempting to leave the store without paying for several items. He was arrested, taken into custody and later released after being charged on a summons.

April 5 - Shoplifting; At ...

South Orange Police Blotter - Theft and Burglary Reported

South Orange Police Blotter as of April 19

Theft - An East Orange resident reported that on Tuesday, April 17, at approximately 9:20 a.m., actor(s) unknown stole some tools from a construction site on Valley Street. The stolen tools, valued at over $500.00 were a Makita brand drill set and electrical saw.

Burglary to Auto - An Irvington resident reported that on Thursday, April ...

41st Annual SOMA Interfaith Holocaust Service and March of Remembrance Held on Sunday

April 19, 2018

MAPLEWOOD AND SOUTH ORANGE, NJ - The 41st Annual SOMA Interfaith Holocaust Service and March of Remembrance was held on Sunday, April 15. The march assembled in Spiotta Park on Maplewood Avenue in Maplewood, and was called to order with the blowing of the shofar.

Local elected officials who attended included Maplewood Mayor Vic DeLuca, Maplewood Township Committee member Dean Dafis, and ...

Water Main Break on Baker Street in Maplewood Wednesday Morning

MAPLEWOOD, NJ - Shortly after 5 a.m. on Wednesday, Maplewood police reported receiving a call from a commuter on his way to work who noticed a small geyser of water in front of 34 Baker St., next to the driveway to the Maplewood Country Club. 

According to Maplewood police, they requested assistance from New Jersey American Water to shut off the water, but as of 7:10 a.m., ...

Upcoming Events

Mon, April 23, 7:00 PM

First Congregational Church, Guild Room, Montclair

A Healthier New Jersey: The Murphy Administration ...

Government Health & Wellness

Tue, April 24, 6:00 PM

The Venetian , Garfield

Prepared For Life Dinner with Captain Mark Kelly

Other

Tue, April 24, 7:00 PM

Millburn Free Public Library, Millburn

Lenore Raphael Presents Ellington and More at ...

Arts & Entertainment

Carousel_image_0e6824bc1f15389361ec_medicaid_ramsey

Tue, April 24, 7:00 PM

South Mountain YMCA-Civic House, Maplewood

Medicaid Q & A - Hosted by Adamson Ramsey Homes

Health & Wellness Real Estate

Academy Heights Residents: No More Valley Street Development Until Master Plan Approved

April 22, 2018

This past Thursday, April 19th, the South Orange Development Committee considered a presentation from developers regarding the All Star Motors site on Valley Street between 3rd and 4th. The proposal is for a 61 unit dormitory/boarding house for college students, with 175 beds and limited parking on a lot that is partially zoned for two-family residential. About 20 Academy Heights neighbors ...

Essex County Announces Partnership with Nine Local Charitable Organizations

April 20, 2018

WEST ORANGE, NJ – Essex County will participating in nine special partnerships to increase awareness about and help raise funds for the American Cancer Society, American Heart Association, the Arc of Essex County, the New Jersey Children Alliance, Stop for Nikhil, The Valerie Fund, the Arthritis Foundation, the Saint Barnabas Medical Center's Neonatal Intensive Care Unit and ...

Kiburi Tucker Sentenced to 38 Months in Federal Prison

NEWARK, NJ - Kiburi Tucker, a longtime friend of Newark Mayor Ras Baraka and the business partner of a Newark woman who admitted to tax evasion last year, was sentenced today to more than three years in prison for wire fraud and tax evasion, federal authorities announced. 

Kiburi D. Tucker, 43, of Newark, pleaded guilty in November before Chief U.S. District Judge Jose L. Linares after ...

Amazon Works to End Stigma of “Free and Reduced” Meals at School

April 21, 2018

FLORENCE, NJ – There is a widely unknown problem in schools all over America: a stigma among many children who are eligible for free or reduced lunch.

Rather than face the peer pressure of receiving breakfast or lunch through this federal program, many choose to remain hungry.

To help eliminate the practice, Amazon has partnered with Share our Strength’s “No Kid ...

Endangered Bog Turtle Plods Through Senate Towards Official Designation as State Reptile

TRENTON, NJ - The endangered bog turtle is one step closer to being designated New Jersey's official state reptile, following State Senate approval of legislation sponsored by Senator Kip Bateman (R-Somerset, Mercer, Middlesex, Hunterdon) and inspired by students from Princeton.

Riverside Elementary School Students Kyle Grzmala and Hayah Mian, and their teacher Mark Eastburn, joined ...

Medicaid Q & A - Hosted by Adamson Ramsey Homes

April 23, 2018

Hosted by Susie Adamson and Bonnie Ramsey, Hearth Realty Group & Bethany Joseph, LSW, MPH, Elder Care Consultant

Please join us for the next installment in the SOMA Series on Tuesday, April 24, from 7 p.m. to 9 p.m. at the South Mountain YMCA Civic House at 124 Dunnell Road in Maplewood.

Confused about Medicaid? You're not alone!

Allison Busch Vogel has been practicing Elder ...

Class Act Performing Arts Studio presents "Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street" at SOPAC

Class Act Performing Arts Studio’s senior Musical Theatre Company members will perform “Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street” Thursday, May 10th , 2018 through Sunday, May 13th, 2018 at the South Orange Performing Arts Center.

Set in 19th-century London, this thrilling musical tells the story of barber Benjamin Barker, now known by his alias, Sweeney Todd, and his ...

Author Visit: Peter Golden at Millburn Library

The Millburn Free Public Library is pleased to welcome acclaimed journalist, novelist, and historian Peter Golden on Wednesday, May 2, 2018, at 7:00pm, to discuss his new book, Nothing is Forgotten.

Featuring Peter Golden’s signature “vivid characters and strong storytelling” (The Washington Post), Nothing Is Forgotten changes our understanding of the ...