Police & Fire

Maplewood Teen Sues Police Claiming Post-Fireworks Mistreatment, Racial Slurs


MAPLEWOOD, NJ - A Maplewood teen claiming he was wrongly pepper sprayed, physically abused and discriminated against by police following the 2016 fireworks has filed a federal lawsuit against the Township and former Police Chief Robert Cimino seeking damages for actions that allegedly included punching, kicking and the use of racial slurs.

Jason McDougall, now 18, was 16 years old the night of July 5, 2016, when he was among many African-American teens leaving Memorial Park after the festivities and ended up in scuffles with police.

The lawsuit filed September 8, by McDougall’s mother, Cynthia, on his behalf, alleges the teen was unfairly targeted by up to eight police officers and wrongly abused.

Sign Up for E-News

The suit states, in part:

At some point … Cimino determined that he was going to direct his officers to send black children who were leaving the fireworks display in mass, out of the town of Maplewood and into neighboring Irvington. He told his subordinate officers to ‘send them east’ toward Irvington … It was the clear intent of the Maplewood Police Department to herd the youths out of Maplewood and into Irvington without regard for their right to return to their homes and without regard for their safety. At no time did officers attempt to determine if any of the children lived in Maplewood nor did they make provisions for those who did.

The lawsuit specifies that McDougall was walking along Elmwood Avenue at one point seeking to go to his home on Troy Court, but police would not let him. It claims police “told him to get on the sidewalk and walk up Elmwood Avenue” and when he “tried to explain to the police officer that he lived” in another direction, one officer allegedly said, “get your nigger ass on the sidewalk.” 

The lawsuit alleges that McDougall then went toward a commotion at Elmwood and Boyden avenues, but did not get involved.

However, the complaint claims that he was attacked by police anyway, stating:

Suddenly and without warning, another police officer ran toward (McDougall) and struck him forcefully in the chest causing him to fall backward. As he fell to the ground, he was immediately surrounded by at least eight police officers. He was kicked repeatedly by the police officers and sprayed with a chemical capsicum type spray directly in his eyes, nose, mouth and ears.

The lawsuit claims police then used other slurs and profanity, allegedly stating: ”what now bitch?” and “get the fuck out of here.” McDougall also alleges he was denied water to help sooth his eyes and mouth from the pepper spray.

As he sought to walk further up the street, the lawsuit claims, police allegedly knocked McDougall down again, slammed his face into the ground and punched him once more.

The lawsuit names as defendants Cimino, former captain Joshua Cummis and three individual police officers. It seeks unspecified damages and legal fees.

Township officials declined to comment on the suit Wednesday, noting they had not yet been served. But a clerk at the Federal District Court in Newark confirmed the 30-page suit had been filed September 8.

Robert Tarver, attorney for the McDougalls, had initially announced plans for the suit in August.

He said this week that the video and audio of that night’s events, which were released several months ago, show clear evidence of wrongdoing against his client and others.

“The unique aspect of this case is that the wrongdoing is there indisputably for everyone to see and hear,” Tarver said Wednesday by phone. “The language and behavior are based upon race.”

The McDougall lawsuit is the latest Maplewood trouble related to the July 5, 2016 police misbehavior, which has already led to the ouster of Cimino, a lawsuit from Cummis claiming wrongful termination, and a report from an independent consultant stating police acted improperly and more training for such incidents is needed.

Hillard Heintze, the Chicago firm hired as part of the Township’s response to demands by many in the community that Cimino be dismissed in the wake of improper police abuse, released its report last week that found 11 “key findings” of police response problems that night. 

Some of the strongest objections from residents involved the police “herding” many youngsters toward the Irvington city line, including many who live in Maplewood.

Video and audio of those incidents, which followed that night’s fireworks display, were made public in late July 2017 after months of demands for them to be released.

The same week, the police also announced that six officers had been disciplined for their actions that night, including one who was suspended for 20 days. It is unclear if any of them were among those cited in McDougall’s lawsuit since their identities have not been revealed by police.

On Aug. 1, 2017, the Township Committee (TC) called for Cimino to resign, held a unanimous vote of no confidence in him, and placed him and former police captain Joshua Cummis on paid leave.

The same night the TC appointed Acting Capt. Jimmy DeVaul as the new acting police chief, along with Lieutenant Albert Sally as a new acting captain.

Cummis has since retired and the Township this week approved an agreement with Cimino for him to remain on paid leave until the end of 2017 and then receive payments of nearly $280,000 during the next year.

Cummis, meanwhile, has filed his own lawsuit seeking damages for alleged wrongful termination.

Township officials announced last month that they would begin a national search for a new police chief.

Related articles

Maplewood Township Committee Passes Resolution Finalizing Settlement with Police Chief

Consultant’s Report Finds “Inappropriate Tactics” During Post-Fireworks Police Response; Chief Cited For “Counterproductive Effort”

Suspended Maplewood Police Captain’s Lawsuit Claims No Due Process

New Acting Chief and Acting Captain of Maplewood Police Department

Amidst Protests, Maplewood Officials Call for Immediate Resignation of Police Chief

6 Maplewood Police Officers Disciplined for July 5, 2016 Incidents

Maplewood Police Release Reports from July 5, 2016: Unruly Crowds, Pepper Spray Use, Attacks on Police

TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Be Interested In

Sign Up for E-News


Spring is (Almost) Here

Get ready for farmers markets and outdoor events, spring is bound to come at some point! To help you get ready Sadie's has lots of new spring products including this great Market Tote by Feed- the purchase of this cute everyday bag will donate 50 school meals. While stopping in for this tote check out some of the other great spring items just in. Don't forget the charity of the month is ...

Feeling Lucky

Shop of the morning to you! It’s that time of year when everyone’s color is green! Stop by Sadie's to get your St. Patty’s shirt before the big day. While your here and feeling lucky check out our latest Spring styles for Men and Women. You may make your friends green with envy.

Horoscope: Have a birthday between 3/13 and 3/24? If you stumble into a ...


AtlantiCast: Episode 13

On this episode of AtlantiCast, new clinical studies in the fields of cardiology and immunotherapy, national and statewide recognitions for Atlantic Health System medical centers and the inaugural AtlantiCast Collab Challenge!


South Orange Police Blotter - Adult Arrests for Shoplifting and DWI Reported

March 16, 2018

South Orange Police Blotter as of March 16

Adult Arrest/Shoplifting - William Minitee, a 45 year old Irvington resident was arrested on Thursday, March 8, at approximately 12:40 p.m. for shoplifting. Security officers at the Stop & Shop on Valley Street observed Minitee conceal several items on his person and then flee the store without paying for the items. Officers stopped a subject ...

Maplewood Police Blotter - Home Burglary, Burglary at DeHart Community Center Reported

March 4 - Burglary; At approximately 1:20 a.m., officers observed a male removing several items from inside DeHart Community Center. The male was identified as 22 year old Joe Carr of Irvington. He was arrested and charged with burglary.

March 6 - Burglary; At approximately 11:30 a.m., officers responded to a home on Broadview Avenue on a report of a ...

Maplewood Senior Center Holds Grand Opening on St. Patrick's Day

March 21, 2018

MAPLEWOOD, NJ - The Maplewood Senior Center has been open on Burnett Avenue for several months and this past Saturday, Maplewood Township officials, many seniors and community members held a grand opening celebration with a ribbon cutting officially dedicating the center.

As Saturday was the St. Patrick's Day holiday, the Senior Center celebration included green bagels ...

Maplewood to Hold Spring Egg Hunt on Sunday, March 25

MAPLEWOOD, NJ - Hop on down to Maplewood's Spring Egg Hunt! Maplewood will hold its 34th annual hunt on Sunday, March 25, from noon to 2 p.m. in Memorial Park.

An email from the Maplewood Recreation Department states to "please arrive promptly at noon with a basket or bag to make sure you don’t miss anything."

At last year's event, hundreds of kids ...

Upcoming Events

Fri, March 23, 7:00 PM

Bow Tie South Orange Cinemas, South Orange

18th Annual New Jersey Jewish Film Festival

Arts & Entertainment Religions And Spirituality


Fri, March 23, 7:00 PM

Par 440 Restaurant & Lounge, Short Hills

The Extra Rich In Class Dinner Show with E.R.I.C.

Arts & Entertainment Food & Drink


Fri, March 23, 7:00 PM

Par 440 Restaurant & Lounge, Short Hills

The Extra Rich In Class Dinner Show with E.R.I.C.

Arts & Entertainment Food & Drink

Fri, March 23, 8:00 PM

Burgdorff Center for the Performing Arts, Maplewood

Strollers Present John Patrick Shanley's "Doubt"

Arts & Entertainment

Hundreds Cheer on Marchers and Bands at 67th West Orange St. Patrick’s Day Parade

March 19, 2018

WEST ORANGE, NJ – Even a week’s delay caused by a massive snowstorm couldn’t dampen the spirits of the large crowd of spectators who cheered on the marchers and bands who participated in West Orange’s 67th annual St. Patrick’s Day Parade on Sunday.

Wending their way up Main Street were more than 25 bands, including marching bands from northern New Jersey high ...

Members of Brick City Brims Charged for Alleged Roles in Drug Trafficking Organization

NEWARK, NJ – Six members of the Brick City Brims set of the Bloods street gang were arrested last week for their alleged roles in a major drug trafficking organization that dealt heroin in and around Newark.

Tyrone Brown, 34, Lamarr Burwell, 22, and Miles McCloud, 37, all of Newark, and Martin Pettiford, 23, of Irvington, are each charged with one count of conspiracy to ...

Renovation Complete, Winberie's Restaurant Reopens

March 22, 2018

SUMMIT, NJ - After a more than two months-long renovation -- an initiative which focused on updating the entire dining room, revamping the floor plan, and expanding the bar -- Winberie’s Restaurant & Bar has reopened in Summit.

The restaurant had been closed since New Year's Eve.

“Our guests will immediately see the physical changes we’ve made ...

Commemoration of Jay Kielwasser, Union Animal Control Officer

UNION, NJ – A commemoration of the late Jay Kielwasser's work as Union’s Animal Control Officer took place at Wednesday evening’s Board of Health meeting.

Board President Jackie Carter said Kielwasser, who passed away in April, was the first Animal Control officer appointed by the Board of Health. 

“You really don’t know how someone ...

Maplewood, South Orange Students to Join March for Our Lives: Rallies on Saturday at Maplewood and South Orange Train Stations

March 23, 2018

Student organizers from Maplewood and South Orange have come together with community leaders and SOMA Action in Maplewood and South Orange to rally in support of gun violence prevention on Saturday, March 24. The rallies are part of the worldwide March for Our Lives movement.

“We stand with and support victims of gun violence and mass shootings. We hope by speaking out and ...

Staff, Members at Metro YMCA’s 7 Branches Raise $788K In First Six Weeks of Annual Campaign

In just six weeks, staff and members at the seven Metropolitan YMCA of the Oranges branches raised 70 percent of the organization’s $1,125,000 annual campaign goal.

“This achievement is a testament to our staff and members’ commitment to their communities through our mission of promoting healthy living, youth development and social responsibility,” Metropolitan YMCA of ...

Check Out BCB Community Bank's High Rate CDs

Get the most out of your savings with BCB Community Bank's high rate CD.

Check out BCB's 18-month CD interest rate of 1.76%.  Invest early and watch your money soar.  For more information, just visit or call your local BCB branch today in Union, Maplewood or South Orange:

Union Branch

2000 Morris Avenue
Union, NJ 07083

Maplewood Branch

156 ...