MILLBURN, NJ — A fully staged, reimagined, digitally captured production of Pete 'N' Keely continues Paper Mill Playhouse's 2020-2021 season. Pete ’n’ Keely is a musical comedy about a divorced singing duo who reunite for a television special in 1968, packed with jazzy standards, torch songs, comedic showpieces, and tender sentiment.

 Like the title characters, the show’s original cast and creative team reunites to reimagine the musical comedy they made a cult favorite 20 years ago Off-Broadway. George Dvorsky and Sally Mayes reprise their roles as Pete Bartel and Keely Stevens, and the show’s lyricist and original director, Mark Waldrop, known to Paper Mill audiences for his direction of Gypsy starring Betty Buckley, Little Shop of Horrors, and A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to the Forum, directs. Additionally, original creative collaborators James Hindman (Book) and Patrick Brady (Music) join Waldrop to bring this production of Pete ’n’ Keely to new life on the Paper Mill stage. 

While Paper Mill had hoped Pete ’n’ Keely would be the first production performed for a live audience since the pandemic shut down the theater last March, streaming to the small screen just might be the perfect format for this particular show—which was originally staged to simulate a live taping of a television special. 

Sign Up for SOMA Newsletter
Our newsletter delivers the local news that you can trust.

This time around, the filming will be real, and the result will be a filmed version of a staged production of a live taping—a delightful reimagining of the kitschy spoof that had New York critics singing its praises when it premiered Off-Broadway in 2000. “I am so excited to do Pete ’n’ Keely in this medium,” said director Mark Waldrop. “The beauty of this show is, it’s a television show. It’s got all the glamour and glitz of a live variety special in 1968. And I think we can really get the feel of it in a way that we couldn’t in the theater. This hybrid moment in time creates a lot of unique opportunities, and it’s very energizing. It’s theater in a new milieu.” 

Paper Mill Playhouse’s 2020–2021 season is proudly sponsored by Investors Bank. 


By James Hindman

Original Lyrics by Mark Waldrop

Original Music & Arrangements by Patrick Brady

Music Direction byJeffrey Lodin

Scenic Design byKelly James Tighe

Lighting Design by Charlie Morrison

Original Production Costume Design by Bob Mackie

Costume Design by Leon Dobkowski

Sound Design byMatt Kraus 

Hair and Wig Design byKaitlyn Adams

Production Stage Management by Andrea Cibelli

Video Production by Milliron Studios

Direction and Musical Staging by Mark Waldrop


George Dvorsky and Sally Mayes

Streaming April 17–May 1, 2021

Pete ’n’ Keely is available now as part of Paper Mill’s four-show streaming season for $275.

Visit for more information.


GEORGE DVORSKY (Pete Bartel) is thrilled to be back at Paper Mill after appearing here in My One and Only1776Jesus Christ SuperstarShenandoahAnything Goes with Chita Rivera, and She Loves Me. Broadway credits include the title role in The Scarlet PimpernelGentlemen Prefer Blondes, PassionMarilynAn American Fable, and The Best Little Whorehouse in Texas. National Tour: Chitty Chitty Bang Bang. Off Broadway: The FantasticksCloser Than EverPete ’n’ KeelyDames at SeaAnd the World Goes ’Round.  George starred in the NYC premiere of Rodgers and Hammerstein’s Cinderella as Prince Charming at Lincoln Center. On PBS he was featured in the Emmy-winning Passion: Live at Lincoln Center starring Patti LuPone, and he starred with Bea Arthur and the Boston Pops in Bernstein’s Broadway. His solo CDs are available on the Jay Records label.

SALLY MAYES (Keely Stevens) made her Broadway debut in Cy Coleman’s Welcome to theClub (Theatre World Award, Outer Critics Circle nomination). She earned Tony, Drama Desk, and Outer Critics Circle nominations for the revival of She Loves Me, and she appeared as Aunt Corene in Urban Cowboy(Drama Desk nomination), as Mae West in the national tour of Dirty Blonde, and in the revival of Steel Magnolias. Off Broadway: Closer Than Ever(Outer Critics Circle nomination), Das BarbecüPete ’n’ Keely (Drama Desk nomination), and more. Select film/television: Alpha HouseCity HallDouble ParkedBye Bye BirdieSex and the City. Cast recordings: Closer Than EverShe Loves MeBye Bye BirdieLost in Boston, many others; plus five solo albums. Sally’s nightclub appearances have garnered rave reviews from coast to coast as well as twelve MAC Award nominations and two Bistro Awards.

MARK WALDROP (Direction, Musical Staging, Original Lyrics) directed and contributed special material to Bette Midler’s Divine Miss Millennium Tour at venues like Madison Square Garden and the Mandalay Bay in Las Vegas. Broadway: Bea Arthur’s Tony-nominated one-woman show, Between Friends. Off Broadway: Howard Crabtree’s When Pigs Fly (Obie, Drama Desk, and Outer Critics Circle awards for best musical), Pete ’n’ KeelyNot That JewishMy DeahInventing AviTill Divorce Do Us PartNEWSicalCapitol Steps, and Cut Throat. Regionally, he’s directed many classic musicals at Seattle’s 5th Avenue, Maryland’s Olney Theater Center, St. Louis’s Muny, and Houston’s TUTS—and new works at St. Paul’s Ordway Center and Chicago’s Royal George. At Paper Mill he helmed Gypsystarring Betty Buckley, Little Shop of HorrorsA Funny Thing Happened on the Way to the Forum, and Romeo & Bernadette. In addition to directing many editions of the 92nd Street Y’s Lyrics & Lyricists series, he’s made a specialty of devising and directing acts for artists including Sutton Foster, Brooke Shields, Rebecca Luker, John Lloyd Young, and Edward Hibbert at 54 Below, Joe’s Pub, Feinstein’s, and the Lincoln Center American Songbook Series.  

JAMES HINDMAN (Book) is proud to return to Paper Mill Playhouse, where he performed in 1776and Jesus Christ Superstar. He is an award-winning playwright whose work has been produced extensively across the United States and in Europe. Off Broadway: Popcorn Falls directed by Christian Borle (named in the Top Twenty Theatrical Moments of 2018), Pete ’n’ Keely (Outer Critics Circle Award nomination, two Drama Desk nominations), The Audience (Drama Desk nomination), The Gorges MotelWhat Doesn’t Kill You (Oscar Wilde Award nomination). A Terrence McNally Award finalist, James has developed his plays at Transport Group, Vineyard, Second Stage, Lark, Goodspeed, Denver Center, Pittsburgh Public, and Long Wharf. He has been a featured artist at the Last Frontier Theatre Conference and has taught playwriting at Art Workshop International and the Barrow Group. His performing credits include: Broadway/Tours: Mary PoppinsThe Scarlet Pimpernel,1776City of AngelsA Grand Night for SingingOnce Upon a MattressFalsettosDancing at LughnasaCatsJoseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat; Off Broadway: Bat BoyA Man of No ImportanceMerrily We Roll AlongRoadsideThe Foreigner; Film/Television: The ReportOcean’s 8, Marvel’s Iron FistThe Americans, Steven Spielberg’s Public Morals (recurring), Madam SecretaryPerson of InterestHouse of CardsThe SopranosLaw & Order, and The Blacklist.

PATRICK BRADY (Original Music, Arrangements) has worked as a musical director, conductor, pianist, arranger, vocal coach, singer, and actor for almost four decades. His notable Broadway credits include serving as music director, conductor, and vocal arranger for The Producers—he also supervised two national tours, companies in London, Sydney, and Toronto, and the motion picture version—Young Frankenstein, and Fosse, among others. Brady made his New York debut in 1989 as musical director, vocal arranger, and pianist/singer for Maltby and Shire’s Off Broadway revue Closer Than Ever. Additional NYC credits include St. Louis Woman and Promises, Promises for Encores!; Hey, Love: The Music of Mary Rodgers at the Rainbow & Stars Club; and many appearances on the Lyrics and Lyricists series at the 92nd Street Y.  

JEFFREY LODIN (Music Directoris thrilled to be here at Paper Mill Playhouse with this exciting production and incredible cast. As music director and arranger: A Letter to Harvey Milk(Off Broadway), Liberty(Off Broadway), and others. As composer: The Pin-Up Girls(Casa Manana, 2019), Merrilee Mannerly(Playhouse on Park, 2019; coming to Off Broadway in fall 2021); PopcornFalls (Off Broadway, 2018); Top of the Heap (WBAI radio play, 2020); Disney’s Doug Live!(MGM, the first original book musical produced in Disney World’s history), Young Abe Lincoln (TheatreWorksUSA); and others. As pianist and conductor: Chita Rivera, Andy Gibb, others. Faculty: American Musical and Dramatic Academy (AMDA, NYC). Member: Dramatists Guild, BMI, AFM.

 KELLY JAMES TIGHE (Scenic Design) is pleased to return to Paper Mill for his sixth project. Off Broadway/National Tours: Martin Luther on TrialThe Most Reluctant ConvertThe Great DivorceThe FantasticksAlmost HeavenMovin’ OutShear MadnessCats. Regional: Paper Mill Playhouse, Slow Burn Theatre Co., Finger Lakes Musical Theatre Festival, San Jose Rep, Laguna Playhouse, Center Rep, Arts Center of Coastal Carolina, Sacramento Theatre Company, Gateway Playhouse, Contra Costa Musical Theatre, Diablo Theatre, Ray of Light. Mr. Tighe’s theatrical work is published in the textbook Scene Design and Stage Lighting, and his work as an illustrator has been published in Mooseltoe: A Moose and a Dream. Awards: SF Bay Area Theatre Critics Circle, Drama-Logue, Shellie. Online portfolio:

 LEON DOBKOWSKI (Costume Design). Paper Mill Playhouse: Vanya and Sonia and Masha and SpikeMary PoppinsAnnieBeauty and the Beast. Past productions with The Muny (St. Louis Theater Circle Awards for Seussical and The Wiz), Weston Playhouse, Theatre Under the Stars, George Street Playhouse, Irish Repertory Theatre, Yale Repertory Theatre, Pittsburgh CLO, Music Theater Wichita, Engeman Theater, Blumenthal Performing Arts Center, Feld Entertainment’s Disney Live!, Maltz Jupiter Theatre, Asolo Repertory Theatre, Epic Theatre Ensemble, NYMF (Outstanding Costume Design, Claudio Quest), Cape May Stage, TheatreWorks Hartford (CT Critics Choice Award nomination, The Legend of Georgia McBride). MFA, Yale School of Drama., @MrLeonD

CHARLIE MORRISON (Lighting Design). Paper Mill: Some Enchanted Evening, Sing in a New Year!, Cinderella,Beauty and the BeastAnnieMary PoppinsWest Side StoryElf, GreaseThe Little MermaidCurtainsSmokey Joe’s Cafe, The Full MontyMeet Me in St.Louis, and Hello, Dolly!. National/International Tours: The Little MermaidHow the Grinch Stole ChristmasThe ProducersHello, Dolly!Chitty Chitty Bang BangMiss SaigonAidaMan of La ManchaGuys and DollsGroovalooMy Fair LadyThe King and I42nd StreetThe Who’s Tommy; and many others. Regional: Shakespeare Theatre Company (DC), Guthrie, Goodspeed, Seattle Rep, Dallas Summer Musicals, TUTS, 5th Avenue, Kansas City Starlight, Pittsburgh CLO, George Street Playhouse, PlayMakers Rep, Tulsa Opera, and more. Two Helen Hayes Awards (seven nominations). 

 MATT KRAUS (Sound Design). Broadway: Liza’s at the Palace…Kristin Chenoweth: My Love Letter to BroadwayKathy Griffin Wants a Tony. Off Broadway: Caucasian Chalk Circle50 Shades! The Musical ParodyForbidden BroadwayVoca People. Audio coordinator for remote shoots at The Tonight Show Starring Jimmy Fallon. Regional: Paper Mill Playhouse (Some Enchanted Evening, Sing in a New Year!, Cinderella,Chasing RainbowsBeauty and the BeastHoliday InnLend Me a TenorNewsies), St. Louis Rep, Cincinnati Playhouse, Walnut Street, and more. Matt has also played the Hollywood Bowl, Hampton Court Palace, Olympia in Paris, Sydney Opera House, Monte Carlo Sporting Club, and Vienna State Opera House. He won an Emmy for his work on Disney’s Broadway Hits at Royal Albert Hall

KAITLYN ADAMS (Hair, Wig & Makeup Designis thrilled and honored to be back at Paper Mill for her design debut (after Sister Act was postponed)! Previous PMP credits (as associate hair and makeup designer) include Beauty and the BeastAnnieMary PoppinsEver AfterMillion Dollar QuartetA Christmas StoryVanya and Sonia…, and Elf. Other recent design credits: Blues for an Alabama Sky (Keen Company). Starter Pistol (Delaware Rep), Certain Woman of an Age (Audible Theatre), Cinderella (Muny), Paint Your Wagon (Muny). Broadway (associate designer): Escape to Margaritaville, The Great CometTime and the ConwaysSweatThe Heidi Chronicles. CCM alum. Love to Mom, Iesa, and Leah!

ANDREA CIBELLI (Production Stage Manager). Paper Mill: World premieres of A Bronx TaleThe Bandstand, and Honeymoon in Vegas, as well as Some Enchanted EveningSing in a New Year!, Rodgers + Hammerstein’s Cinderella, Beauty and the Beast, West Side StoryThe Sound of MusicThoroughly Modern Millie, Smokey Joe’s CafeThe Full MontySteel MagnoliasSeven Brides for Seven BrothersNutcracker, and New Voices2013–2019. Broadway: A Bronx TaleHead Over HeelsHoneymoon in Vegas. Tours: West Side StorySpring Awakening. International: West Side Story(Japan), Race for Love(China). Regional: Dreamgirls(TOTS), The Little Mermaid(DSM). Other credits include Monkey: Journey to the WestThe Mile-Long Opera, Jazz at Lincoln Center, Princeton University Dance Department, and Lincoln Center Festival. 

 MILLIRON STUDIOS (Video Production) is a production and post-production media house based in New York City. Dedicated to “Helping Creatives Create,” Milliron Studios believes that no matter what the obstacle, be it financial, institutional, or even viral, it is ever our duty to support and lift the arts. 


Paper Mill Playhouse Streaming Season Includes  


Created by Larry Gallagher

Choreographed by Jennifer Werner

Directed by Casey Hushion

Cast TBA

Streaming June 12-26, 2021, delivered virtually from the Paper Mill stage.

Big hairdos and even bigger voices command the stage in this tuneful tribute to women who rock—the girl groups that made their mark on the music of the ’60s. Featuring such hits as “My Boyfriend’s Back,” “Son of a Preacher Man,” and “(You Make Me Feel Like) A Natural Woman,” Beehivechronicles the dramatic transformations of a volatile decade, told from the perspective of six young women who live through it.  



Directed by Mark S. Hoebee 


Kathryn Allison, Kate Baldwin, Natalie Cortez, John Treacy Egan, Dion Simmons Grier, Rob McClure, Kyle Taylor Parker, Mamie Parris, Hayley Podschun, Nicholas Rodriguez, Graham Rowat, Christopher Sieber, Elena Shaddow, Rema Webb 

A streaming encore now scheduled for June 12-26, 2021, delivered Virtually from the Paper Mill stage 

Paper Mill Playhouse’s popular summertime outdoor Brookside Cabaret comes inside and onto the Paper Mill stage for a very special concert presentation! Over a dozen popular Paper Mill performers, directed by Producing Artistic Director Mark S. Hoebee, sing a unique selection of seasonal favorites just in time to ring in the new year. 


Music by Richard Rodgers

Lyrics by Oscar Hammerstein II

Concept by Jeffrey B. Moss

For Jerry Kravat Entertainment Services Inc.

Directed byMark S. Hoebee

 Starring Belinda Allyn, Ashley Blanchet, Donna English, Nicholas Rodriguez, Billy Harrigan Tighe 

A streaming encore now scheduled for June 12-26, 2021, delivered virtually from the Paper Mill stage.

This stunning collection of Rodgers and Hammerstein’s most beloved compositions will shine the spotlight on five magnificent Paper Mill singers in a glorious parade of hits from CarouselSouth PacificThe King and IOklahoma!, The Sound of Music, and more. Paper Mill’s own Mark S. Hoebee directs.

Pete ’n’ Keelycan be purchased as part of Paper Mill’s streaming season, available now for $275. Visit and sign up for all we have to offer.Audiences will enjoy Pete ’n’ Keely now, Beehive from June 12 through June 26 and, at that time also be given access to an encore streaming period for Sing in a New Year!and Some Enchanted Evening

Program and artists are subject to change.

PAPER MILL PLAYHOUSE, recipient of the 2016 Regional Theatre Tony Award, is a nationally renowned, not-for-profit theater under the direction of Mark S. Hoebee (Producing Artistic Director) and Michael Stotts (Managing Director). A beloved NJ arts institution since 1938, Paper Mill creates and produces groundbreaking new musicals and reimagined classics. Several productions have gone on to Broadway and launched national tours, including Disney’s NewsiesLes MisérablesHoneymoon in VegasA Bronx Tale, and Bandstand. The theater is also the home of an award-winning center for musical theater education and artist training, with outreach programs that impact thousands of students each year. As one of the nation’s premier musical theaters, Paper Mill fosters a creative environment to advance the art form, educate students, develop future theater lovers, nurture inclusion, and provide access for all. Paper Mill Playhouse programs are made possible, in part, by funds from the New Jersey State Council on the Arts, a partner agency of the National Endowment for the Arts. Paper Mill Playhouse is a member of the National Alliance for Musical Theatre, the Council of Stock Theatres, and the New Jersey Theatre Alliance.