LIVINGSTON, NJ — Three men from Newark were apprehended in Livingston and charged with eluding police, resisting arrest and possession of stolen property on Sunday in connection to a string of vehicle burglaries in West Orange, South Orange and Millburn, according to Livingston police.

After investigating a report of people attempting to enter cars on Silver Spring Road in Millburn, responding officers from the Millburn Police Department located a white Chevy Malibu and attempted to conduct a motor vehicle stop. When the driver refused to stop, Millburn officers began a pursuit that broke off in front of Saint Barnabas Medical Center on Old Short Hills Road in Livingston. 

Taking over the chase, Livingston Police Officers Todd Compesi and Anthony Trajer located the Malibu speeding westbound on E. Northfield Road. The officers then pursued the vehicle onto JFK Parkway and into the area of the Short Hills Mall, where the driver of the Malibu made a U-turn and began traveling back toward Livingston.

Sign Up for SOMA Newsletter
Our newsletter delivers the local news that you can trust.

While traveling west on South Orange Avenue into Florham Park, the vehicle made another U-Turn and headed back toward Livingston once again, according to police. The vehicle then turned onto the dead end of Peach Tree Hill, where officers watched as the vehicle struck a curb and became disabled. At this point, three men jumped out of the Malibu and fled on foot into the wetlands of the East Orange Water Reserve, according to police. 

The driver—identified as Antoine Lee, 27, of Newark—was captured within minutes while officers from Millburn, Florham Park, Essex County Sheriff K-9 and Chatham were called to assist Livingston police in establishing a perimeter and conducting an extensive search for the remaining suspects.

At approximately 7:45 a.m., Livingston Police Officers Dave Naylor, Kelli-Ann Mallek and Jessica Colucci took a second suspect into custody and identified him as Eric Fonseca, 26, of Newark. According to Livingston police, the third suspect—identified as Shatuwan McCall, 20, of Newark—later surrendered to Florham Park officers at the rear entrance to The Regency Club at the intersection of Regal Boulevard and Kennsington Lane in Livingston.

Inside the vehicle—which was found to have been rented in the name of a relative of Fonseca’s girlfriend—police discovered evidence linking the three men to burglaries in West Orange and South Orange.

According to West Orange police, there were at least seven incidents of burglaries from motor vehicles reported in the early hours of Sunday morning on Walker Road, Yale Terrace, Tremont Avenue and Rollinson Street. A Walker Road resident also reported a theft of a package coinciding with this string of burglaries, and an additional commercial burglary at Castillo Auto Repair at 36 South Valley Road was reported around the same time, according to West Orange police.

Lee and McCall were transported to the Essex County Jail, and Fonseca was released on a summons with a future court date.



VolunTEENs Honored

S.O. Offices Reclosed to Public

SHU's Powell to NBA

Board of Education Election Results

Columbia Football Ends on a Win

Winter Sports Pushed Back


Trans Awareness Day

SOMA Intersection Improvements

TAPinto SOMA is a free online newspaper serving the Townships of Maplewood and South Orange Village with no paywall. TAPinto SOMA is accredited by the New Jersey Press Association, and is a locally owned news organization serving the community.

Sign up for our FREE daily eNews and follow us on Facebook and Twitter.

Are you a business interested in reaching our audience? Contact Fred Smith at