MAPLEWOOD AND SOUTH ORANGE, NJ - Local bakeries are offering a variety of Thanksgiving pies, and ordering deadlines are coming soon, with the first one on Friday, Nov. 20.
187 Maplewood Avenue, Maplewood
Order deadline: Friday, Nov. 20; call 973-313-1133 to place order.
Full pie menu here, includes Pumpkin Pie ($24), Apple Pie ($25), and Modern Mince ($25). Also has list of gluten-free goodies.
1 South Orange Avenue, South Orange
Full pie menu here, includes Sweet Potato Pie ($7.99), Apple Pie ($7.99) and Strawberry Rhubarb ($12.99).
Cait & Abby
15 Sloan Street, South Orange
Call 973-763-2229 to place order.
Full pie menu here, offers fruit pies like apple and cherry (8" are $11.95 and 10" are $17.95) and pecan pie (8" are $15.95 and 10" are $21.95).
Cedar Ridge Cafe & Bakery
410 Ridgewood Road, Maplewood
Order deadline: Saturday, November 21; call 973-327-2286 to place order.
Pie menu: Maple Cream ($20), Pecan ($24), Pumpkin ($20) and Apple ($24).
Mara's Cafe and Bakery
9 W South Orange Avenue, South Orange
Order deadline: Wednesday, November 25, noon; place orders at store or by phone 973-762-8100. Also open on Thanksgiving Day from 7 a.m. to noon. Pie options include Pumpkin, Carrot, and Caramel Apple Cheesecake.
105 Main Street, Millburn
Order deadline: Monday, November 23, call 973-379-0740 to place order.
Full pie menu here, includes Pecan Pie ($24.95), Gluten Free Apple Pie ($34.95), and Pumpkin with a Gingersnap Crust ($24.95).
Did we miss a bakery? Email Anna at firstname.lastname@example.org.
For a list of restaurants open in South Orange and Maplewood on Thanksgiving, click here.
You May Also Be Interested In