Sports

Former Columbia H.S. Coach Fischetti Sues District, Claims 'Sham Investigation' Forced Him Out

Former Columbia High School Coach Joe Fischetti Sues South Orange Maplewood School District Credits: Joe Strupp

MAPLEWOOD, NJ - Two former Columbia High School (CHS) baseball coaches who were not rehired this past season following alleged bullying have filed a lawsuit against the district claiming they were wrongly dismissed and subjected to “sham investigations” and “false and defamatory” allegations.

Former CHS head baseball coach Joe Fischetti and assistant Matthew Becht were the subjects of several harassment, intimidation and bullying (HIB) complaints dating back to 2014.

Fischetti left CHS coaching ranks at the end of last summer when the school board chose not to rehire him for the 2017 season. He remains a tenured physical education teacher at CHS.

Sign Up for E-News

His departure ended a very lengthy and difficult time for the baseball program, which saw Fischetti accused of several instances of harassment, intimidation and bullying.

Those claims led to the hiring of an outside investigator in 2016 to look into the charges and the school board's decision to search for another coach for the 2017 season. One former student, David DeFranco, also filed a lawsuit against Fischetti, other coaches and the district claiming abusive treatment, which has yet to go to trial.

Last fall, CHS hired James Whalen, a physical education teacher at Valley View Middle School in Denville who had been an assistant baseball coach at West Essex High School in North Caldwell since 2002, to coach the Columbia varsity baseball team.

Fischetti, meanwhile, became an assistant coach at nearby Newark East Side High School while continuing to teach at CHS.

The lawsuit, filed June 30, names the entire South Orange Maplewood Board of Education, Superintendent John Ramos and Assistant Superintendent Kevin Walston as defendants. It also names Randy Nathan, the father of a former CHS baseball player who filed several HIB complaints against the coaches, as a defendant.

Citing 10 counts of alleged improper and illegal actions, the lawsuit accuses the defendants of violations of civil rights and equal protection, malicious prosecution, and tortious interference with economic advantage.

The lawsuit cites the first HIB complaint, filed by Nathan in 2014, claiming the coaches were never given proper written notification of the complaint by the district or their due process rights. 

It adds that Fischetti, who was named head baseball coach in 2013, was later exonerated by then-acting superintendent James Memoli. But when Ramos took over the district in August 2015 he reopened the issue and overturned Memoli’s previous decision.

The lawsuit contends this act by Ramos “trampled the due process rights of the plaintiffs.”

“The failure to follow the strict timelines set forth in the law allowed false and defamatory allegations against the plaintiffs to remain open and were not kept confidential,” the lawsuit states, later adding that “for well over two years” the Board of Education “recklessly and negligently permitted plaintiffs to have open HIB claims held over their heads in violation of HIB law without ever providing them with their rights or any type of process to clear their name. In doing so, they damaged their reputations and caused distress.”

The lawsuit goes after Nathan as well, stating he “disparaged and defamed” the coaches “via excessive social media posts and by circulating false information to third parties.”

Nathan declined comment, saying he was not able to at this time due to the pending legal case.

The complaint also claims that the district sent the coaches a letter in December 2016 stating that, ”all HIB allegations were unfounded.” Attorney Steven Farsiou, who represents the coaches, told this reporter in April about the letter, but declined to provide a copy of it.

When asked for a copy of the letter at that time, district officials would neither confirm or deny its existence, but added that if the letter did exist it could not be released due to it being part of a personnel matter.

Farsiou did not respond to requests for comment, while School Board president Elizabeth Baker declined comment, citing it as a pending legal matter.

The lawsuit, meanwhile, adds that the defendants have allegedly  “defamed and slandered the plaintiffs to third parties and have tortuously interfered with their paid coaching positions as well as other coaching opportunities.” It also claims they were “outwardly hostile toward the plaintiffs and very much wanted the plaintiffs terminated from their coaching position.”

The complaint seeks unspecified compensatory and punitive damages, as well as attorney fees.

TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Like

Sign Up for E-News

SOMA

Maplewood Town Hall Newspaper Thief Sparks Warning

A thief has been victimizing Maplewood Town Hall.

No, not some burglar breaking in at night to steal tax payments, or an armed gunman ripping off town workers at gunpoint.

We’re talking about a newspaper poacher who’s been making a habit of walking off with the Township’s copy of The Star-Ledger.

Such illegal activity prompted a sign to be placed prominently in ...

South Orange Police Blotter - Two Arrests for Burglary

August 15, 2017

South Orange Police Blotter as of August 15

Burglary to Auto - A Clark St resident reported that between 7 p.m., Monday, August 14, and 10 a.m., Tuesday, August 15, actor(s) unknown entered her unlocked vehicle, which was parked in her driveway and rummaged through the interior. Nothing appears to be missing at this time.

Burglary to Auto - A Milligan Pl resident reported that between ...

South Orange Police Blotter - Multiple Burglaries Reported

The South Orange Police Blotter as of August 9

Adult Arrest - Burglary - Joe Carr, a 22 year old Newark resident, was arrested on Sunday, July 30, at approximately 2:26 a.m. for burglary. Officers responded to a call from a Kingman Rd resident for a burglary in progress and upon arrival arrested Carr, who had been subdued by the homeowner, without further incident. Officers transported ...

Two More Weeks of Moonlit Movies in South Orange

August 22, 2017

SOUTH ORANGE, NJ - There are two more weeks of Moonlit Movies planned in August as part of South Orange Summer Nights.

All events take place on Floods Hill in Meadowland Park. Event organizers encourage concert-goers to arrive early and to pick out a spot on the lawn.

The Moonlit Movies schedule is as follows:

WED., AUGUST 23 - Pitch Perfect 

WED., AUGUST 30 - ...

Community Attends Eclipse Viewing Party at the South Orange Public Library

SOUTH ORANGE, NJ - The South Orange Public Library hosted an Eclipse Viewing Party both inside the library and outside on Monday afternoon, August 21. 

Many people were inside the library watching the live-stream of the official NASA feed as the eclipse traveled across the country, while others experienced the eclipse first-hand on the lawn on the south side of and behind the ...

Upcoming Events

Thu, September 7, 4:30 PM

New Jersey Youth Symphony Music Center, New Providence

NJIO Invites Musicians to Open House Rehearsals ...

Arts & Entertainment

Carousel_image_a949ec124654eea4c9de_7socialfacebook600x250-tomrushlivingstontaylor

Sat, September 16, 8:00 PM

South Orange Performing Arts Center, South Orange

Tom Rush and Livingston Taylor at SOPAC

Arts & Entertainment

Carousel_image_a78b03d752f64c81a9eb_ymca_golf_outing

Mon, September 18, 8:30 AM

Montclair Golf Club, West Orange

Metropolitan YMCA of the Oranges' 23rd Annual ...

Giving Back Health & Wellness

Carousel_image_beee068d568e613eeef7_millburn_photo

Tue, September 19, 7:00 PM

Millburn Free Public Library, Millburn

Millburn Library Presents Genealogy 101 with Jake ...

Arts & Entertainment Education

Turtle Back Zoo-vies to Show Indiana Jones and The Temple of Doom Wednesday, August 16

August 14, 2017

WEST ORANGE, NJ -  Turtle Back Zoo's annual "Zoo-vies" continue this Wednesday, August 16 with 'Indiana Jones and The Temple of Doom.'

On Wednesdays and Thursdays during the months of July and August, Turtle Back will have Family Nights with extended evening hours to 8:30 p.m., with the last admission to the Zoo at 8 p.m. 

On Wednesday ...

East Orange Mourns the Death of Rev. Dr. Leora Liggins, East Orange Resident, Founder and Pastor of Christ Resurrection Missionary Baptist Church

EAST ORANGE, NJ - Rev. Dr. Leora Liggins was the Founder and Pastor of Christ Resurrection Missionary Baptist Church in East Orange and active member of the East Orange Clergy until her demise. 

Rev. Liggins ministerial career began in 1994 when she was licensed to preach and joined the staff at Imani Baptist Church in East Orange, and she was ordained in 2000 by the late Rev. Moses ...

Cinemark Theater and 2 Anchors Receive Approvals to Replace Route 22 Sears

August 18, 2017

WATCHUNG, NJ — Plans for a theater and two of the stores in the new shopping center that will replace Sears and Sears Auto Center on Route 22 and Terrill Road received approvals at Tuesday night's Watchung Planning Board Meeting. The next meeting, where final approval on the cinema is expected, is scheduled for Sept.19.

HomeSense and Sierra Trading Post are the ...

Before Trump Broke Up Biz Council, Johnson & Johnson CEO Resigned

NEW BRUNSWICK, NJ — The head of Johnson & Johnson decided to step down from President Donald Trump's Manufacturing Council on Wednesday, prior to its disbandment, according to the company.

Alex Gorsky, chairman and CEO of the New Brunswick-based Johnson & Johnson, announced his exit in a statement, following reports published yesterday, Aug. 15., which said he planned to ...

Last Minute Ideas to Entertain the Family this Weekend

August 17, 2017

After last week’s dreary weekend, we are all looking forward to the nicer weather this coming Saturday and Sunday. Avoid the crowds at the shore and instead opt to attend one of the following family-friendly activities in the North Jersey area. Most of the events are free or inexpensive—ideal for those trying to save money after a jam-packed summer.

Canal Day Musical and Craft ...

Weekly Specials at Ashley Marketplace & Cafe - August 18 to August 24

August 19, 2017

Shop Ashley Marketplace & Cafe for your everyday needs!

This week's specials are:

The Greek Gods Greek Yogurt 24oz  $3.99
Talenti Gelato-Sorbetto 16oz $4.99
Salmon Steaks $8.99lb (Freeman’s Fish)
Grilled Lemon Chicken $5.99lb (Prepared Foods)
La Croix Sparkling Water 12pk $5.99
Black Angus T-Bone Steak $9.98lb (Meat)
Musette Limonades 25.4oz ...

Millburn Library Presents Genealogy 101 with Jake Garfinkle on Sept. 19

The Millburn Free Public Library is pleased to present Genealogy 101 with Jake Garfinkle on Tuesday, September 19 at 7pm.

Have you ever wondered where you came from? Who your ancestors were and what they were like? Have you started to research your past but not quite sure what to do? If you are lucky, perhaps you already have some of your family history from your parents or grandparents. Local ...

New Jersey American Water Performing Work in the Academy Heights Neighborhood

Over the next few weeks, residents can expect to regularly see New Jersey American Water crews performing work in the Academy Heights neighborhood. In anticipation of the upcoming repaving and roadway improvement work planned by the Village on Academy Street between Massel Terrace and the Maplewood border, crews will be exercising, repairing and replacing water valves and replacing fire hydrants.