Sports

Former Columbia H.S. Coach Fischetti Sues District, Claims 'Sham Investigation' Forced Him Out

Former Columbia High School Coach Joe Fischetti Sues South Orange Maplewood School District Credits: Joe Strupp

MAPLEWOOD, NJ - Two former Columbia High School (CHS) baseball coaches who were not rehired this past season following alleged bullying have filed a lawsuit against the district claiming they were wrongly dismissed and subjected to “sham investigations” and “false and defamatory” allegations.

Former CHS head baseball coach Joe Fischetti and assistant Matthew Becht were the subjects of several harassment, intimidation and bullying (HIB) complaints dating back to 2014.

Fischetti left CHS coaching ranks at the end of last summer when the school board chose not to rehire him for the 2017 season. He remains a tenured physical education teacher at CHS.

Sign Up for E-News

His departure ended a very lengthy and difficult time for the baseball program, which saw Fischetti accused of several instances of harassment, intimidation and bullying.

Those claims led to the hiring of an outside investigator in 2016 to look into the charges and the school board's decision to search for another coach for the 2017 season. One former student, David DeFranco, also filed a lawsuit against Fischetti, other coaches and the district claiming abusive treatment, which has yet to go to trial.

Last fall, CHS hired James Whalen, a physical education teacher at Valley View Middle School in Denville who had been an assistant baseball coach at West Essex High School in North Caldwell since 2002, to coach the Columbia varsity baseball team.

Fischetti, meanwhile, became an assistant coach at nearby Newark East Side High School while continuing to teach at CHS.

The lawsuit, filed June 30, names the entire South Orange Maplewood Board of Education, Superintendent John Ramos and Assistant Superintendent Kevin Walston as defendants. It also names Randy Nathan, the father of a former CHS baseball player who filed several HIB complaints against the coaches, as a defendant.

Citing 10 counts of alleged improper and illegal actions, the lawsuit accuses the defendants of violations of civil rights and equal protection, malicious prosecution, and tortious interference with economic advantage.

The lawsuit cites the first HIB complaint, filed by Nathan in 2014, claiming the coaches were never given proper written notification of the complaint by the district or their due process rights. 

It adds that Fischetti, who was named head baseball coach in 2013, was later exonerated by then-acting superintendent James Memoli. But when Ramos took over the district in August 2015 he reopened the issue and overturned Memoli’s previous decision.

The lawsuit contends this act by Ramos “trampled the due process rights of the plaintiffs.”

“The failure to follow the strict timelines set forth in the law allowed false and defamatory allegations against the plaintiffs to remain open and were not kept confidential,” the lawsuit states, later adding that “for well over two years” the Board of Education “recklessly and negligently permitted plaintiffs to have open HIB claims held over their heads in violation of HIB law without ever providing them with their rights or any type of process to clear their name. In doing so, they damaged their reputations and caused distress.”

The lawsuit goes after Nathan as well, stating he “disparaged and defamed” the coaches “via excessive social media posts and by circulating false information to third parties.”

Nathan declined comment, saying he was not able to at this time due to the pending legal case.

The complaint also claims that the district sent the coaches a letter in December 2016 stating that, ”all HIB allegations were unfounded.” Attorney Steven Farsiou, who represents the coaches, told this reporter in April about the letter, but declined to provide a copy of it.

When asked for a copy of the letter at that time, district officials would neither confirm or deny its existence, but added that if the letter did exist it could not be released due to it being part of a personnel matter.

Farsiou did not respond to requests for comment, while School Board president Elizabeth Baker declined comment, citing it as a pending legal matter.

The lawsuit, meanwhile, adds that the defendants have allegedly  “defamed and slandered the plaintiffs to third parties and have tortuously interfered with their paid coaching positions as well as other coaching opportunities.” It also claims they were “outwardly hostile toward the plaintiffs and very much wanted the plaintiffs terminated from their coaching position.”

The complaint seeks unspecified compensatory and punitive damages, as well as attorney fees.

TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Like

Sign Up for E-News

SOMA

Village Coffee Sign Tweaks Starbucks, Clarus Twitter Trails, and School Shuffles

When Starbucks coffee opened in the new Clarus development complex at the former Maplewod Village post office site, some wondered what effect it might have on Village Coffee, the longtime java spot just down the street.

Village Coffee owner Ketan Patel sees no big impact as of yet and a visit to the shop finds the same customer traffic as usual.

One addition, however, is a sign posted at ...

Marshall School Recognizes Hispanic Heritage Month

October 18, 2017

It is Hispanic Heritage Month and at Marshall Elementary School Mr. Martínez’s 2nd grade class honored the histories, cultures and contributions of famous individuals whose ancestors or they themselves came from Spain, Mexico, the Caribbean and Central and South America.

Hispanic Heritage Month is observed in the United States from September 15th through October 15th. These ...

Know Your Neighbor

For Desi, Cam, and Lily 

I am Puerto Rican. 

But, I have light skin and two blonde boys. I grew up in Upstate New York and now live in New Jersey, and have a very fortunate life. I am not the Puerto Rican portrait you might imagine.

During a college interview I was asked about my heritage and experiences with adversity.  I said then and can say to this day, ...

Supporting Diverse Learners: Statement from School Board Candidate Donna Smith

October 8, 2017

Supporting Diverse Learners

Our School District faces many challenges in serving diverse learners appropriately, but the Board has a duty to make sure it happens.

I believe there are three key ways that the Board can use its oversight to ensure that the needs of our diverse learners are met:

1. Implement Rigorous Monitoring of Special Education and Gifted & Talented Policies and ...

Statement on Common Sense Gun Laws by Vic DeLuca, Candidate for Re-Election to the Maplewood Township Committee.

After the Orlando nightclub massacre in June 2016, hundreds of SOMA people rallied in South Orange saying enough is enough and that we need Congressional action for common sense gun laws. What we got from Washington was cowardice.

Since that deadly June day, some 480 days ago, we've had 521 mass shootings in this country. And our elected leaders are telling us now is not the time to talk ...

Maplewood Police Blotter - 7 Thefts from Autos and 2 Vehicle Thefts Reported

October 16, 2017

October 10 - Shoplifting; At approximately 3:30 p.m. Wawa reported that a male left the building with several items without paying. Responding officers were able to locate the male a short distance away. The male, 51 year old Gregory Singleton of Union was arrested for shoplifting as well as an outstanding warrant.

October 10 - Malicious Damage; Sometime during the ...

South Orange Police Blotter - Seven Arrests Reported

South Orange Police Blotter as of October 6

Adult Arrest - Shoplifting - Henry Vance, a 31 year old Dover resident was arrested on Monday, September 25, at approximately 1:51 p.m. for shoplifting. Security officials at the Stop & Shop on Valley St. observed a subject place several items into a backpack and then leave the store without paying for them.  Security officials ...

'Gems of South Orange' Historical Home Tour Takes Visitors Back in Time

October 18, 2017

SOUTH ORANGE, NJ - The "Gems of South Orange" Historical House Tour on Saturday, October 14, gave visitors the chance to visit homes from a variety of time periods as they went inside eight homes built in four different centuries.

At each of the homes, a historic car was on display as well. Cars ranged from a '61 Coupe De Ville to a '84 Rolls-Royce. One of the cars ...

'Strut Your Mutt' Parade in South Mountain Dog Park on Saturday, Oct. 21

MAPLEWOOD, NJ -  This Saturday, October 21, is Strut Your Mutt, the annual Essex County Canine Halloween Costume Parade and Contest.

Two parades are planned, one at 2 p.m. in the afternoon (with registration at 1:15 p.m.) at the Essex County South Mountain Dog Park on Crest Drive in Maplewood/Millburn, and one at 10 a.m. in the morning (with registration at 9:15 a.m.) at ...

Upcoming Events

Carousel_image_24dfebf016d155f25e1b_ryan_roa_postcard_front_lo_res

Wed, October 18, 10:30 AM

Seton Hall University, South Orange

Ryan Roa - It's Complicated

Arts & Entertainment

Wed, October 18, 12:00 PM

Temple Sharey Tefilo-Israel, South Orange

The Purposes and Rhythms of Jewish Living

Education Religions And Spirituality

Carousel_image_9304b2eaebf77d58fa5a_october_workshop_tai_chi_2017

Wed, October 18, 7:00 PM

South Orange Chiropractic Center, South Orange

Tai Chi with Sifu Richard Mullen

Education Health & Wellness

Wed, October 18, 7:30 PM

Central Presbyterian Church Auditorium , Summit

Free Community Forum: Ecology & Economy Can NJ ...

Education Green

Donna Smith for BOE - one of hardest working members of our Board

October 16, 2017

I’m pleased to endorse Donna Smith for a second term of the Board of Education.

Donna has been involved with our public schools since 1998, first as a PTA mom and as a BOE member since 2015. Throughout her years of service, Donna has been an advocate for all children to have options and choices over their academic careers, in terms of subject matter and finding the course environment ...

Donna Smith - a fierce, consistent, commitment to improving the educational experience of all of our students.

Donna Smith stands out in the crowded field of BOE candidates. She has a long and continuous history of service to SOMA schools. She knows our past and has a vision for our future. Donna is level-headed, reasonable, practical, thoughtful, and hard-working. Most importantly, Donna has demonstrated a fierce, consistent, commitment to improving the educational experience of all of our ...

Family Health

Second Opinion on Breast Cancer Program Offers Peace of Mind

A breast cancer diagnosis can change a person’s life. And during such devastating news, the sheer amount of information regarding treatment and follow-up care can quickly become overwhelming. However, patients are not alone in this fight. Atlantic Health System’s Breast Cancer Second Opinion Program at Carol G. Simon Cancer Center, Overlook Medical Center, is helping provide peace of ...

Christie, Booker, and Baraka Show Strong Support for Newark to be Next Amazon HQ

October 17, 2017

NEWARK, NJ - A bipartisan trinity of New Jersey politico firepower assembled in downtown Newark to shoot the first salvo needed to score a major economic triumph for New Jersey's largest city: the construction in Newark of the new corporate headquarters for Amazon, the world's largest online retailer.  

All three of the prime politicians in place inside Rutgers Business ...

Former President Obama to Visit Newark to Campaign for Murphy

NEWARK, NJ - Former U.S. President Barack Obama is scheduled to roll into downtown Newark on Thursday to campaign for the Democratic New Jersey gubernatorial candidate Phil Murphy as the battle to run New Jersey heats up in the race's final weeks. 

Obama's appearance in New Jersey's largest city less than three weeks before the Nov. 7 election on behalf of ...

Enjoy Union County History Tour, “Four Centuries in a Weekend” Oct. 21 and Oct. 22

October 18, 2017

UNION COUNTY, NJ – History fans of all ages can enjoy Union County’s annual civic heritage event, “Four Centuries in a Weekend: A Journey through Union County’s History”; Saturday, Oct. 21, 10:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m. and Sunday, Oct. 22, noon to 5:00 p.m.

Sponsored by the Union County Board of Chosen Freeholders with the participation of staff and volunteers at ...

Atlantic Health's #AskHer Campaign Promotes Annual Mammograms During Breast Cancer Awareness Month

MORRISTOWN, NJ - In addition to asking the women in your life what's for dinner? Can you drop me at practice? Or how was your day? Ask her...... Have you scheduled your mammogram?

In 2017, 252,710 new cases of invasive breast cancer are expected to be diagnosed in women in the United States, according to Atlantic Health System. During Breast Cancer Awareness Month,  the ...

Mahopac’s Frank Lloyd Wright House Back on the Market

October 12, 2017

MAHOPAC, NY — If you have about $15 million to spare, you can own the Frank Lloyd Wright-inspired home, which comes with its own island, on Lake Mahopac.

The iconic home, once rumored to have been purchased by Angelina Jolie and Brad Pitt (those rumors were false), is back on the market with a selling price of $14,920,000.

The sale is being handled by high-end real estate brokers ...

Woolley Home Solutions: Heating Oil New Customer Offer

October 18, 2017

Woolley Home Solutions Heating Oil New Customer Offer

Get a $0.50/gal Off Your 1st Heating Oil Delivery, and $0.10/gal off for the Next 2 Years When You Switch to Woolley Home Solutions!*

For more information, click here or call Woolley Home Solutions now at 973-762-7400.

So many reasons to switch to Woolley Home Solutions for ...

Maplewood Garden Club Presents “From Flowers to Fragrances”

Get an insider’s look at the perfume industry on Monday, November 6, 2017, at 7:30 p.m. at Maplewood Memorial Library, 51 Baker Street, Maplewood, when the Maplewood Garden Club presents “From Flowers to Fragrance.”

Speaker Bruno Leyssene was born into the fragrance business and has worked in the USA for almost twenty years as a senior perfumer for ...

'A Republic if You Can Keep it': How to Fight for American Values in the Age of Trump

South Orange-Maplewood Action (SOMA Action) and Blue Wave NJ to Co-Host Town Hall Discussion with Civil Rights Activist and Attorney Norman Siegel

Representatives from Local NJ Activist Groups Join SOMA Action and Blue Wave NJ to Share Ideas and Strategize about How to Defend the Rule of Law in the Trump Era

On October 18, SOMA Action and Blue Wave, NJ will host a town hall meeting with ...