Somers Neighbors Oppose Development of ‘Oddball’ House


SOMERS, N.Y. – Twenty-two weeks after giving the planning board an earful over adding another house on Green Briar’s Driftwood Drive, would-be neighbors returned last week to say “no way.”

As a detached single-family home, the residents argue, the proposed structure would clash aesthetically with their attached townhouse units, standing out, one of them said, like “one orange on a street of apples.” In addition, the owners contended at an April 12 public hearing, building that outlier would depress the value of their townhomes and pose a potential environmental hazard for nearby wetlands.

At issue is a proposal by Greenbriar Somers Corp. and 2-4-36 Green LLC to build a single-family, standalone house at the entrance to Driftwood Drive.

Sign Up for E-News

Scaled-back from earlier, more-ambitious plans so it conforms with state wetland restrictions, the proposed house would be smaller than neighboring residences, lack the basement they enjoy and contain fewer bedrooms and square feet. Its third of an acre lot, sloping sharply down to Greenbriar Brook, would be fenced, unlike the property of the attached units.

“We’re asking for less-intensive use of the land,” Susan Shapiro, who owns the property, told the board. “Normally, in most communities, people would be quite happy to have less-intensive use of the land.”

But Robert Gaudioso, an attorney representing the Driftwood Drive residents, said “this smaller, oddball unit” would adversely impact the property values of other homes on the street, part of the sprawling Green Briar housing complex.

A 300-acre cluster development with some 230 homes, Green Briar has been offering groupings of single-family and townhouse-style accommodations since the early 1980s.

Last week’s planning board meeting, first of the spring, resumed a public hearing that began last fall and was postponed, in a series of adjournments, four times over the winter. About three-dozen people crowded town hall, filling seats up front and standing room space in the rear.

Amy Horowitz, one of eight Driftwood Drive residents who followed Gaudioso to the microphone, said she prefers the earlier plans calling for attached townhomes on two lots. “I want them to build what they said they were going to build,” she told the board. But wetland concerns forced the developers to scale back their plans. “So, now,” she said, “they want to merge the two lots together and build one orange on a street of apples.”

Another Driftwood Drive resident assailed the proposed location. “Go take a look at where they want to put this building,” Joe Starace suggested. “If you look at the area they’re talking about, in person, you’ll think, ‘How the hell can you put a house over there, a house that’s going to be contradictory to everything on the street?’ It will have an impact on our property values; it will have an impact aesthetically.”

At the initial public hearing last Nov. 9, George Semmens, vice president of the Greenbriar Homeowners Association, said that while the HOA board did not oppose construction of two attached townhomes on two lots, it disagreed with the proposal for a single-family residence.

But the applicant’s engineer, Joseph Buschynski, advised the board that after the lots were created in 1987, the state’s Department of Environmental Conservation declared Greenbriar Brook to be a wetland, subject, along with the two lots, to environmental regulation. To meet mitigation requirements, he said, the developers combined the lots and chose to build one unit—the single-family house.

“That’s not our issue,” said Horowitz, a title insurance executive. “The issue is this is the way it was presented to the state and the attorney general. This is the way it should stay. I don’t believe this late in the game you can change the game plan.”

HOA attorney Gaudioso called the proposed construction “a one-off” and said, “This does not fit in with the character of this community. As a single-family residence on Driftwood Drive, it’s the first building that you will see when you pull in... It’ll be an odd duck, so to speak.”

An appraiser’s report prepared for the HOA, Gaudioso said, “documented that this smaller, oddball unit will have an adverse impact on the property values of the other units…on Driftwood Drive.”

Shapiro, the property’s would-be developer, rejected contentions that the single-family home would depress those property values. Referring to comparables, the real estate measure of similar properties’ characteristics, Shapiro said, “They just have to look at the comps: one home is this size with a basement; one home is this size without a basement. . . . It’s not the same home; it’s not going to affect your property values.”

Shapiro said of the residents’ opposition, “It’s really unreasonable that they’re trying to prevent us from using the land… All we’re asking for is a less-intensive use because the state regulations have changed.”

The planning board took no action last week and tentatively scheduled renewed discussions in June.

TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Be Interested In

Sign Up for E-News


The Feline Night Stalker

Shades of the late Darren McGavin! If you liked the ‘70s horror shows on TV, you knew him as Kolchak, crime reporter, in the series “The Night Stalker.”

It seems that I have a night stalker living with me. My kitty, Bonnie, had her 18th birthday in April and I’ve noticed some subtle changes in her behavior. Up until that time, Bonnie would sleep on my bed at night. She ...

Hitting the road, Part II

Welcome back to our little trip across these great United States. We left off somewhere on Route 90, heading out of Cleveland.

So glad to have you following along, and frankly, if you’re following I’m just glad you’re not the cops. On the way to Chicago I found myself driving 70 miles an hour, which made the police quite angry, since the speed limit was 75. 

When ...

Sabotaged by the DMV

After living in Manhattan for the last few years, my grandson, Chris, and my wonderful grand-daughter-in-law, Silvia, have decided to move back to his hometown of Westfield, N.J. Silvia has just returned from a four-day visit with her parents in Hong Kong and they are bunking with my daughter, Lisa, while preparing their new home. Because they now have a daily commute to the city, I decided to ...

Do it badly!

Anything worth doing is worth doing badly, at least to start. 

As a recovering perfectionist, I have learned to get started on a project even if I don’t have all the pieces together. Sometimes just puttering, tinkering or moving the parts around will help me sort out my brain enough to give me an idea of how to tackle a project.  

I can’t tell you how many times ...

What Kind of Sports Parent Are You?

Social media recently showered a lot of likes and love on a high school pitcher in Minnesota whose team was playing in a regional final that would send the winning team to the state championship game.

After the last batter of the game struck out, the pitcher did something unheard of. Rather than spontaneously join his teammates in an on-field celebration, as is customary, the pitcher ...

I Come from the Land Down Under

I know this is a family column, so I’m going to put this in as delicate terms as possible.

This morning I woke up and I knew, as sure as the sun shines over Bora Bora, that something was very, very wrong in that place in my body where the Bora Bora sun doesn’t shine.

It’s that place I used to refer to my daughter as her hoo-hoo. But it certainly wasn’t a happy ...

Upcoming Events


Thu, June 21, 6:00 PM

Yorktown Heights

2018 Kickball Registration is Open! Meet, Greet ...


Sun, June 24, 1:00 PM

Yorktown Heights




Tue, June 26, 1:00 PM

Yorktown Heights



Excited for Somers Block Party June 30

June 20, 2018

Hello Somers:

The Town is excited this year to partner with the Somers Lions Club, Somers Chamber of Commerce and Sebastian Capital to offer a new kind of Independence Day celebration, at a new location, starting a new tradition with the 2018 Somers Block Party on June 30.

The Block Party will take place at Sebastian Capital’s 1 Pepsi Way property (across from King Kone) with gates ...