Agreement on "Lynch Report" Ends Two Weeks of Angst in Peapack-Gladstone


PEAPACK AND GLADSTONE NJ - The Peapack-Gladtone Police Committee has settled two weeks of turmoil in the twin borough.  The Committee has resolved to put the Lynch Report "in abeyance", and has made some changes to the staffing of the department and to the scheduling of the officers, according to an announcement made at tonight's borough council meeting.

The terms of the police committee's agreement must be approved by the P.B.A. and the entire borough council before they become binding.

Police Chief Gregory Skinner made a public statement on behalf of the Police Committee:

Sign Up for E-News

"I am pleased to report that the Police Committee met twice this past week and have come to an agreement on the staffing of the Department. The Committee, composed of myself, Chairman Mark Corigliano, Councilman Bill Simpson and advisor Councilman Anthony Suriano worked together to address concerns regarding the Department’s utilization of manpower. This statement is being made on behalf of the entire Committee.

Because the agreement requires acceptance by the PBA and subsequent acceptance by the full Council, the details of the arrangement cannot be disclosed at this time. However, I can say that the agreement provides for i) greater supervisory coverage; ii) greater police officer presence during the hours of 6:30AM to 8:00PM and 1:00AM to 2:00AM each weekday and iii) potential reduction in overtime costs. These objectives are being met at no additional cost.

The Police Committee works well together and we aspire to continue to work cooperatively in the best interests of the Borough, its residents and the Police Department and its personnel."

Two Weeks of Angst

The committee's proposed settlement comes in the wake of nearly two weeks of angst in this bedroom community of just over 2,450 people.  There were heated - and on one occasion profane - exchanges on a local social media site, some of which were removed by the site's mediator.  There was a Jib-Jab video spoofing the mayor and some members of the borough council to the tune of Devo's "Whip It", which appeared on social media, then disappeared after vocal objections from a member of the borough council.

There was another letter from Farm Cottage Road resident and former councilman John Sweeney to the editor of the local newspaper, and a resulting cover article in that same paper.  The article pitted some residents against the mayor and borough council.

And there was the return of the "We support our police" lawn signs, most heavily concentrated along Pottersville Road near the residence of Mayor William Muller.

The surge of political activity was the result of a police staffing report obtained by the borough council to address public safety and staffing issues.  The report analyzed the staffing issues over about seven pages, then in the final three paragraphs dropped the Twin Borough version of the atomic bomb:  Consider eliminating the police department and contracting with Bedminster Township.

A quarter century ago, a previous mayor and borough council proposed a police department merger with Bernardsville.  The public did not take well to the proposal.  A citizens group was formed to oppose the merger.  There were confrontations between a borough councilman and a leader of the citizens group that resulted in the conviction of that councilman for harassment.  Eventually, the proposal was the subject of a non-binding referendum.  The proposal failed by a 4-1 margin.

The 2016 reaction was reminiscent of the 1991 reaction.

During the two weeks of frenetic political activity, the Police Committee met on two occasions, and hammered out the agreement on staffing.  The details of the agreement are not yet public.  P.B.A. Local 139, which represents the officers in the Peapack-Gladstone Police Department must first approve the agreement reached in the Police Committee.  The full Borough Council must also approve the agreement before it can take effect.

TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Be Interested In

Sign Up for E-News

Somerset Hills

Somerset County Preparing for Construction of Finderne Avenue Bridge, Beginning Feb. 20

February 18, 2018

BRIDGEWATER, NJ - The Finderne Avenue bridge, between Union Avenue and Foothill Road, will be under construction from Feb. 20 for about nine months, according to a release from Somerset County.

The bridge will be constructed in three separate stages, with one lane northbound and one lane southbound being maintained, aside from intermittent single-day closures as required. In addition, ...

Saint Peter's Fights Against Fatal Cardiac Arrests on the Playing Field

February 17, 2018

NEW BRUNSWICK, NJ - On a particular Tuesday evening, Jim Fisher stood in front of a group of coaches and doctors at the newly ​-​ renovated, start-of-the-art simulation center at Saint Peter’s University Hospital in New Brunswick.

Jim’s son, Sean, died in Aug ​just​ 2008, as a result of an undetected heart defect. He was just about to turn 13. The two and their family are ...

The Path to a House Majority Leads through the Somerset Hills

February 18, 2018

Genteel and bucolic, the Somerset Hills rarely provide a battleground for national races, in 2018 that appears to have changed.  This year, the road to a majority in the House of Representative leads through New Jersey.  The non-partisan Cook Report, one of the go-to sources for congressional race handicapping, says that five of New Jersey’s twelve seats are in ...

NJ Audubon: Teacher Naturalist Training

February 11, 2018

NJ Audubon: Teacher-Naturalist Training
NJA Scherman Hoffman Teacher-Naturalist Training Program

Do you enjoy the outdoors? Would you like to be involved in environmental education? We are offering the opportunity to join Scherman Hoffman's environmental education team. As a Teacher-Naturalist, you would teach environmental education programs in an outdoor setting to school and scout ...

Orza: Get the Board of Health Story Right

February 3, 2018

Editor's Note:  This letter, originally addressed to the editor of the Bernardsville News, was sent to TAPinto Somerset Hills for publication.


Sometimes your paper just doesn’t get the news right.  Your story on the recent activities of the Bernardsville Board of Health proves the point.    Contrary to your reporting, Mike Monica and ...

Upcoming Events

Mon, February 19, 9:00 AM

The Center for Contemporary Art , Bedminster,

Dan Bischoff: Critic As Artist

Mon, February 19, 9:00 AM

The Center for Contemporary Art, Bedminster

Keepers of the Chroma: An Exhibition Regarding ...

Arts & Entertainment

Tue, February 20, 9:00 AM

The Center for Contemporary Art , Bedminster,

Dan Bischoff: Critic As Artist