Help Right a Wrong. Critical Employee Being Let Go in South Orange

August 26, 2013 at 8:02 AM

During my time of the Board of Trustees, one of my proudest accomplishments was helping to hire our new Village Clerk, Robin Kline.  Coming to South Orange, Robin had big shoes to fill from her predecessors, Lynn Cuccinello and Marj Smith, both of whom served the Village well for many years.  However, after just a short period of time, it was quickly apparent that Robin Kline was "the real deal".  She not only spoke about organization, transparency, efficiency, customer service, ethics, hard work and professionalism - she lived it - every single day.  The amount of information she processed, including meeting minutes, ordinances, resolutions, legal notices, OPRA requests, correspondence, liquor licenses, elections, licenses and permits, just to name a few, was staggering.  However, she kept on top of all of it, followed through on everything and never let a ball drop.  She did all this while simultaneously maintaining a positive attitude towards customer service to everyone who entered Village Hall, and handling all requests with grace and professionalism.

So, it was all the more stunning when the Board of Trustees (which includes the Village President) posted a job opening for the Village Clerk's job on the Village website on August 19 and issued a statement on August 20 stating that "the Village Clerk’s appointment and service to the Village will end on September 30, 2013."

The statement went on to say that "The Board has expressed a fundamental opposition to tenure and is exploring its options at this time". However, there are a few keys facts that make this statement baffling, at best, and possibly illegal, at worst:

Sign Up for E-News

•               A Municipal Clerk is granted tenure after FIVE years of continuous employment.  Robin Kline was hired in 2010 and her initial three year term ended on August 1, 2013.  A reappointment NOW would not provide tenure until 2015.  Robin could EASILY be reappointed now, while the Board of Trustees simultaneously works with the State Legislature to reform tenure over the next two years.

•               The State statute provides that the "clock resets" after a 60 vacancy in the position.  So, Robin COULD take a 60-day leave of absence and then be reappointed, which would start the five year clock back to the beginning, giving the Board of Trustees five years to work with the State Legislature to reform tenure.

•               The Board of Trustees statement that they have a "a fundamental opposition to tenure" was never discussed publicly.  Similarly, there was no resolution voted on which stated this opinion. (Certainly not during the six years I served on the Board nor over the past 3 months after my term ended.)  Yet, the statement says that "the Village Clerk’s appointment and service to the Village will end on September 30, 2013".   In essence, the Board of Trustee took action in Executive Session, which is in violation of the Open Public Meeting Act.

•               The declaration of a "fundamental opposition to tenure" will likely decrease the pool of qualified applicants who apply for the position to replace Robin.  After all, who would apply for a job with the knowledge that they too will be let go in 3 years, regardless of their performance?

As word has gotten out about this, residents, former colleagues, former Board members and respected members of the community have rallied around Robin on Maplewood Online and via an online petition that is being circulated:

http://www.ipetitions.com/petition/robinkline/

Through this dialog, many constructive suggestions were made which would allow the Village to retain an indispensable employee, while simultaneously addressing the stated "fundamental opposition to tenure".

For the sake of fairness, please sign the petition and contact the Board of Trustees directly (BoardofTrustees@southorange.org) to express your disappointment in this decision and request that they reconsider and immediately reappoint Robin Kline as Village Clerk.

 

The opinions expressed herein are the writer's alone, and do not reflect the opinions of TAPinto.net or anyone who works for TAPinto.net. TAPinto.net is not responsible for the accuracy of any of the information supplied by the writer. Click here to submit a Letter to the Editor.

TAP Into Another Town's News:

TAP Into Another Town's News:

Sign Up for E-News

SOMA

New Field Usage Fees in Maplewood

August 23, 2016

As some of you are well aware of by now, a new township ordinance has been passed stating that there will be a new "Field usage fee" for all activities taking place in DeHart, Maplecrest, Memorial, and Borden fields. 

These new fees will go to future repairs, renovations and maintenance to our parks and fields. For Maplewood and South Orange residents, in addition to any current ...

Weekly Specials at Ashley Marketplace & Cafe - August 22 to August 28

Shop Ashley Marketplace & Cafe for your every day needs!

This week's specials are:

Boar’s Head Salsalito Turkey $9.99 lb (Deli)
Ciuti Extra Virgin Olive Oil  $7.99
Total Fage Yogurts 35.3 oz. $6.29
Earthbound Farm Organic Salads 2/ $6.00
Pete & Gerry’s Organic Medium Eggs $2.99

See all specials here.

Ashley Marketplace and Cafe is open 7 ...

South Orange Launches Humane Program to Reduce Feral Cat Population

On June 27, 2016, the Board of Health in South Orange enacted an Ordinance to address the growing feral cat population in the Township.

For years, the Township and many other municipalities in NJ have tried unsuccessfully to combat feral cat overpopulation by trapping and removing cats. Village President Sheena Collum and the Board of Health have decided it’s time to try something ...

Obituary: Jeanette M. Estoye, Age 37, of Maplewood

August 17, 2016

Jeanette Manning Estoye, loving wife, mother, sister, and friend, 37, of Maplewood died suddenly on August 14, 2016. 

Born in Voorhees, Camden County on Jan. 14, 1979, and raised in Audubon, NJ, Jeanette lived in Maplewood for the past 7 years. She was a beautiful, independent woman with an adventurous spirit. She earned her BFA in Graphic Design from Winthrop University in South ...

Obituary: Jeremy Craig Mathews of South Orange

Jeremy Craig Mathews, 44, of South Orange, NJ died suddenly on Friday, August 12, 2016 in Rio De Janiero, Brazil. 

Born in Chester, PA, on Nov. 5, 1971, Jeremy had lived in metropolitan New York for 21 years with the last four being in South Orange, NJ. He graduated from Temple University in 1994 with a BA in Journalism. He was SVP, Group Partner, Integrated Investment for Universal ...

Obituary for Dave Curtin, Age 58, Former Columbia High School Coach and Athletic Director

The following was posted to the South Orange-Maplewood Education Association's Facebook page on Aug. 11:

It is with deepest sorrow that we inform you of the passing of Dave Curtin. He was a P.E. teacher and the former Athletic Director at Columbia High School. Dave recently turned 58 years old last week. Dave was a devoted husband, father of three and a grandfather of two. He also taught ...

South Orange Police Blotter - August 24

August 24, 2016

South Orange Police Blotter as of August 24

Burglary to dwelling - A Stanley Rd. resident stated that sometime between 2 p.m. and 6 p.m. on Sunday August 21, an unknown actor(s) had gained entry into his residence by prying open a side entrance door. Once entry was gained the actor(s) removed a purple Dell laptop computer and a Trinity tablet. The Detective Bureau is investigating the ...

South Orange Police Blotter - Credit Cards Stolen at South Orange Pool

South Orange Police Blotter as of August 22

Theft of credit cards - A South Orange resident stated that sometime between 1 p.m. and 4:30 p.m. on August 20, an unknown actor had removed credit cards from her purse while she was at the town pool. The actor(s) had used several of the stolen credit cards to make purchases. The Detective Bureau is investigating the incident.

DWI/arrest - Nnamdi ...

Maplewood Police Blotter - Several Thefts; Report of Suspicious Person/Vehicle

August 16 - Bicycle Theft; Between 6 p.m. and 9 p.m. a bicyle left on the lawn of a North Terr. residence was stolen.

August 18- Bicycle Theft; During the overnight hours a bicycle was stolen from an unsecured garage on Hudson Ave.

August 17 - Motor Vehicle Theft; At approximately 4 a.m., a Chevy pickup truck was stolen from a business on Springfield ...

The Argument in Favor of Restoring a Full Time Librarian

August 18, 2016

The argument in favor of restoring a full time librarian to South Orange Middle School (SOMS) can be made convincingly with facts. There is very real data showing the positive impact of a full time librarian. The financial resources that would go towards a dance teacher could easily be redirected to a librarian. 

And while these logical arguments are important, the experiences of ...

Middle School Librarians Should Be Restored for the 2016-17 School Year

It has come to our attention that yesterday the district was interviewing for a middle school dance teacher, a position that has not been in the middle schools for at least ten years. How can the school district be stating to us and others that they can not reverse the decision to cut the middle school librarian position due to a "difficult budget cycle," while at the same time ...

Open Houses - Aug. 27 and Aug. 28

The West Orange Alternative

People pay a premium to live in South Orange and Maplewood to have an easy commute into the city. What some people considering this area may not realize is that you can live in West Orange and still have easy access to the trains.

 

Did you know that West Orange offers free Jitney service to the South Orange and Orange train stations? So if ...

Some Like it Hot

“Oh boy!” exclaimed my husband. “There’s a hot sauce shop in town!”

We were away antiquing for the weekend in a quaint village populated by Bed and Breakfasts, art galleries, and apparently, a hot sauce shop. For my husband, this was like discovering that someone had bought you a lottery ticket and you won… if the lottery prize was a fireball that would ...

Going for Brass

I get all teary-eyed watching the Olympics on TV.  You  know, the human drama, the sacrifice, the dedication, the thrill of competition, the athletic lip sync murmur to the national anthem on the podium.  

 

This year I discovered that there are many other Olympic champions besides the usual cadre of spring-wound gymnastic pixies and ferociously wedged, hairless swimmers ...

Ionesco’s ‘Exit the King’ Makes for Powerful Drama at New Jersey Shakespeare Theatre

MADISON, NJ – There’s dying and then there’s dying in long, drawn-out agony. Well, if you’ve been king for 400 years, you won’t disappear quietly. No doubt King Berenger thinks he’s immortal and, like many of us today, lingers long after he’s of any use to himself or others.

The king on "Exit The King" is ravenously alive early on, still ...

Essex County Officials Dedicate Search and Rescue Dog Statue at Eagle Rock September 11th Memorial

August 24, 2016

WEST ORANGE, NJ – A four-foot-tall “Search and Rescue Dog” Statue has been added to the Essex County Eagle Rock September 11th Memorial in West Orange to commemorate the role that dogs had in the search and recovery efforts at the World Trade Center and Pentagon after the 9/11 attacks.

Essex County Executive Joseph DiVincenzo, Jr. joined New Jersey Attorney General ...

TAP Visits Essex County Airport to Celebrate National Aviation Day

FAIRFIELD, NJ – In honor of National Aviation Day, the TAP into West Essex office staff took a field trip on Friday to the local runway at Essex County Airport, located at 27 Wright Way in Fairfield.

Upon arrival, Jessica Parkes, co-owner of TAPintoWestEssex.net, and Conor McCloskey, TAP marketing consultant, were greeted by Tom Gomez, manager of the airport’s governing body, the ...

A New York State of Mind in Clark, New Jersey

August 21, 2016

CLARK, NJ – You may be right! I may be crazy! But “we didn’t start the fire.”  Swing by Oak Ridge Park on Wednesday night, Aug. 24, as Union County finishes off its 2016 Summer Arts Festival concert series with New York State of Mind, a Billy Joel tribute band.

“We wrap up another exciting summer of entertainment in our parks with a fabulous performance ...

Union Resdent Killed in Newark Bus Crash

UNION, NJ - Acting Essex County Prosecutor Carolyn A. Murray and Newark Public Safety Director Anthony Ambrose announced today that the Newark Police Department and the Essex County Prosecutor’s Office are investigating a fatal bus crash that resulted in the death of a NJ TRANSIT bus driver and one passenger. 

Shortly after 6 a.m. today, Aug. 19, a NJ TRANSIT bus -- the 59 ...