Law & Justice

Jury Finds Pit Bull Owner Responsible, Landlord Negligent in 2015 Attack on South Plainfield Woman, Dog at Spring Lake Park

Yogi, on a walk to the park with his owner Katie Stilo, on May 3, 2015, just minutes prior to the attack. Credits: Katie Stilo
Katie Stilo and her dog, Yogi. Credits: Katie Stilo

SOUTH PLAINFIELD, NJ –  A jury in Middlesex County Court earlier this month ruled in favor of the South Plainfield resident attacked by a dog at Spring Lake Park nearly three years ago. According to plaintiff Katie Stilo, both the property owner and the owner of the dog were found to be negligent in the 2015 attack on her and her dog.

On the afternoon of May 3, 2015, Katie Stilo, looking to take advantage of the nice weather and get some exercise, left their home off South Plainfield Avenue and headed to Spring Lake Park. Crossing Maple Avenue, Stilo and her dog Yogi, a 25-pound Shiba Inu, entered the county park near the PAL, but they didn't make it very far before being attacked by a female pit-bull-boxer mix that broke through the fence of an adjacent property.

According to Stilo, now 24, while still on the pedestrian path directly next to the park’s Maple Avenue entrance sign, she heard a woman to her right scream ‘no.’ “I looked up and saw a large dog was charging at us. By the time I could react, the dog was already attacking Yogi,” said Stilo. “In self-defense, because he couldn't do anything, I tried to push the pit-bull to the ground and then it came after me, tackled me to the ground, and bit me in the neck.”

Sign Up for E-News

Yogi, she said, ran off and into traffic onto Maple Avenue. Managing to break free of the aggressive canine, Stilo then went after her dog.

“The pit-bull chased us for about a block to Joan Street and I was in the middle of Maple Avenue bleeding from the neck, my dog nowhere to be found,” said Stilo, adding that with the help of a stranger – whose name she never knew – Yogi was found but he, too, was injured, his back left leg bitten and bleeding.

Stilo was taken by ambulance to JFK Medical Center where she underwent treatment for bite marks and injuries to her hands, legs and throat, close to her carotid artery. In addition to rabies and tetanus shots, she also underwent a cat-scan and received a number of stitches in her neck.

Yogi also needed immediate medical condition and was taken to Plainfield Animal Hospital. “He also received multiple shots and stitches to his back left leg because the muscle was nearly ripped off,” said Stilo.

About a week after the incident, Stilo reattained a lawyer and, over the weeks and months that followed, she went to countless doctors, including a therapist to help deal with anxiety and nightmares. She also ended up having back surgery due to an injury associated with the attack and lost over six months of work.

“It was a very treacherous two and a half years,” she said.

On a local level, she appeared in South Plainfield court at a vicious dog hearing but the judge ruled the dog was not dangerous. “The dog had previously attacked another dog prior to me being attacked and shortly after my incident it broke through and jumped out a window of the home and attacked a man’s dog. The man was pushing his young child in a stroller at the time of this attack,” said Stilo, telling TAPinto South Plainfield that she also wrote letters to the mayor, council, and chief of police. “If the town had properly handled the situation and took it in a serious manner that attack could have been prevented. It seemed the town didn't take this seriously.”

In June 2015, Stilo moved forward with a lawsuit against the landlord and the tenant/dog owner and, on Jan. 9, a jury in New Brunswick ruled in her favor. In the judgment, the court found the owner of the dog 80-percent responsible in the attack and the landlord/homeowner 20-percent negligent (for failing to maintain the property).

According to Stilo, she has no idea whether or not the dog still resides at the premise and that the landlord had testified in the past that he did not know whether or not a dog or any other pets were at his property. On the day the judgment was rendered neither the dog owner nor the property owner showed up in court the day of the verdict; the only legal representative for the defendant, she said, was the attorney representing the landlord’s insurance company.

“The compensation was not at all fair based on the suffering me, Yogi and my family have gone through along with countless bills, lost wages, etc.” said Stilo, adding that she will have to try to collect whatever is available from the tenant and go through the homeowner’s insurance for the rest.

All medical and emotional issues aside, Stilo said all she ever wanted – and is still waiting for – is an apology. “I just wanted them to apologize and be up front and own up to responsibility…and I never got that,” she said.

Stilo continued, “Imagine how you would feel. It was horrible. I was just trying to walk my dog in the park and I almost bled out and died from it.”

TAPinto South Plainfield is South Plainfield’s only free daily paper. Sign up to get all the news as it happens at and follow us on Facebook at and on Twitter at @SoplainfieldTAP.

TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Be Interested In

Sign Up for E-News

South Plainfield


Chief Michael J. Cleary, Sr. 66, of South Plainfield, died suddenly on July 14, 2018. Born and ...
Read more

Letters to the Editor

Carly Kensey Graduates from ECU

July 13, 2018

GREENVILLE, NC -- Carly Kensey of South Plainfield graduated with a BA-Psychology from East Carolina University during spring commencement exercises May 4 in Dowdy-Ficklen Stadium.

The fireworks capped off a new format for ECU's 109th spring commencement ceremony, which was held in the evening for the first time.

The keynote speaker for commencement was Linda McMahon, administrator of ...

Community Happenings

Adult “crafternoon” at the South Plainfield Public Library

July 15, 2018

Crafting isn't just for kids anymore!  Come to the South Plainfield Library on Saturday July 28 at 2pm for a fun filled “crafternon” for adults with crafter Patricia Dahl.  Crafters will be decorating a wine bottle. We will supply all the materials, just come and enjoy! If you have a glue gun at home, if you could bring it to the craft program.  Registration is ...

Frist Baptist Church of South Plainfield to Host Annual Vacation Bible School

July 17, 2018

SOUTH PLAINFIELD, NJ - First Baptist Church of South Plainfield will be holding their annual Vacation Bible School program the week of August 6-10 from 6:30 to 8:30 PM. This free VBS program is open to children entering Kindergarten through entering 6th grade. Children will participate in this exciting experience learning how God is faithful and keeps His promises through Bible stories, songs, ...

South Plainfield Police Hiring Per-Diem Dispatchers

The South Plainfield Police Department is accepting applications for Per-Diem Police Dispatcher.  The following are the minimum requirements for applicants:

Must be at least 18 years of age
Must have a High School diploma or GED
Must be certified in 9-1-1, EMD and CPR
Must pass a background check and a computerized Dispatch test
Must be able to multi-task while using Police, ...


Lucia, Lucia by Adriani Trigiani

Lucia, Lucia by Adriana Trigiani (Ballentine Books, 2003)


If a summer romance novel is what you are craving to read as you sit by the pool or beach, Adriana Trigiani's Lucia, Lucia is a perfect choice. Set in 1950 New York City, the novel is about a young woman, Lucia Sartori, who is determined to have a career and be able to support herself, an unusual choice for a girl who was ...


Come join us Monday, July 23 at 6:30 PM for Monday Night Movies.  This week’s selection stars Donald Sutherland and Helen Mirren, and it follows their characters as they journey across the country in a RV, rekindling their passion for life and their romance.  It is rated R.  If you cannot make it to the Monday night showing, there is a second screening on Wednesday, July 25 ...

Press Releases

Criminal charges brought in South Plainfield fatal motorcycle crash

July 17, 2018

Middlesex County Prosecutor Andrew C. Carey announced today that a driver has been charged in the motorcycle fatality in which a passenger was killed in South Plainfield on July 4, 2018.

Ruddy Custodio, 30, of Piscataway, the operator of the motorcycle, was charged on July 16, 2018 with vehicular homicide in the second degree caused by driving while under the influence of alcohol and ...

5 Simple Ways to Save Water this Summer

According to the L.A. Times, the average American uses an estimated 98 gallons of water EACH day.  

Here are five simple ways you can save water, to help you conserve water this summer and take some pressure off of your drains.

1. Unless you are using it, turn the faucet off. How many of us still leave the water running while we shave or brush our teeth?According to ...