Middlesex County News

New Brunswick Man Sentenced to 40 Years for Murdering Former RU Student

Timothy Puskas enters the courtroom on Friday, Jan. 6.
Billy McCaw Credits: Facebook
Credits: Anik Chadha/Facebook

NEW BRUNSWICK, NJ — The man convicted of killing a popular former Rutgers student named Billy McCaw has been sentenced to 40 years in prison.

State Superior Court Judge Dennis Nieves handed down the sentence today to Timothy Puskas, a New Brunswick resident, before a crowd that spilled into the hallway. Following the news, some began to shed tears as they left the courtroom, while others engaged in long, tight hugs.

For McCaw’s loved ones—many of whom lobbied for Puskas to get life in prison—the sentencing represented an emotional end to just one chapter in a tragic story.

Sign Up for E-News

“We’ll continue to move forward in Billy’s name and memory,” his father, Bob McCaw, said after today’s court proceedings. “It’s a continuing journey, but we’re grateful to have this part of it over.”

Puskas’s 40-year sentence is slated to run consecutive to a seven-year sentence he received after pleading guilty in 2015 to a fatal hit-and-run crash. He must serve 85 percent of the sentence before he is eligible for parole, according to the Middlesex County Prosecutor's Office.

Puskas, 41, might remain in prison until he is nearly 90 years old.

A jury convicted him in January of murder and several related charges. In doing so, the jury found that Puskas bludgeoned McCaw, then a 22-year-old Kean University, with a tool and left him for dead in a snow-covered Hartwell Street backyard in February 2014.

McCaw was killed after a night of party-hopping around Rutgers University. His death deeply upset his social circle and the Rutgers community at large, sparking a candlelight vigil and calls for greater off-campus protections.

Middlesex County prosecutors built their case on the idea that Puskas was outraged and unstable. He was, prosecutors alleged, out for blood.

Puskas has maintained his innocence and may appeal the decision. He didn’t address the court or McCaw’s family today, opting to remain silent, as he was for much of the trial.

Prior to announcing the prison sentence, Nieves acknowledged that the months-long, emotionally-draining trial began to “wear” on him. He extended his sympathies toward McCaw’s family, adding that he was glad they didn’t need to see the graphic photos of the young man’s body that were presented throughout the proceedings.

Those photos showed a gruesome scene in which blood soaked through the snow. McCaw’s face had been badly beaten.

The judge also acknowledged that McCaw’s supporters might be unhappy with his decision to not put Puskas behind bars for life. But McCaw’s father later said his family was “not dissatisfied” with the sentence.

“Nobody has the right to take somebody else’s life,” Nieves said prior to the sentencing. “Nobody.”

Many in McCaw’s family have chosen to try to forgive Puskas the murder. But that doesn’t make the loss of McCaw any less difficult, they said.

“Timothy Puskas has sentenced us to a lifetime of pain,” McCaw’s mom, Mary, said in court today, according to NJ.com.

Even so, the McCaw family has organized fundraising efforts to honor their son’s name and memory. This past Christmas, they used some of that money to buy gifts for the children of Leonel Lopez Hernandez, the 26-year-old New Brunswick resident killed in Puskas’s 2012 hit and run.

Puskas was free on bail for that offense when he killed McCaw.

TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Be Interested In

Sign Up for E-News

South Plainfield

The Athlete of the Week Luke Niemeyer Wrestling

The South Plainfield Wrestling Team sent six wrestlers to compete in the New Jersey Individual State Wrestling Championships, March 2nd-4th.  Thirty-two wrestlers throughout the state qualified for each weight class.  South Plainfield placed two out of the six qualifiers in the State of New Jersey.  Junior 195 pounder Luke Niemeyer became a state place winner for the first time in ...

The Athlete of the Week Joe Heilmann Wrestling

The South Plainfield Wrestling Team finished its terrific season this past weekend at the New Jersey Individual State Wrestling Championships.  The top four wrestlers from the Region Tournament in Union had the opportunity to wrestle in Atlantic City for an individual state title.  The Tigers placed two out of their six qualifiers in the State of New Jersey, Senior 126 pounder Joe ...

Pre-Ticket Sale for Holy Savior Academy’s 4th Annual Spring Splendor Tricky Tray

Holy Savior Academy is hosting its Spring Splendor Tricky Tray Saturday, April 21, 2018 at the school.  Doors open at 6:00 p.m.

Tickets are limited and will be sold at Holy Savior Academy, 149 South Plainfield Avenue, South Plainfield on Wednesday, March 21, 2018 from 2 p.m. to 4 p.m. (cash or checks)

BYOB and food- Admission $ 25 per ...


Robert Corcia, 52, of Cresco, died Tuesday, March 13, 2018 at Lehigh Valley Pocono ...
Read more

Letters to the Editor

Letter from the Chapman Family

March 14, 2018

Dear Editor -


“Hey Dad, today in school the police officer played volleyball with us, it was fun.”


“My son came home from school today and told me that the police officer played football with them at recess”.


“I heard that one of the police officers sat down and ate lunch in the cafeteria with the children today. They loved ...

Community Happenings

A Tribute to our Veterans - An Evening with Jim Barone

March 15, 2018

The South Plainfield Elks Motorcycle Committee in conjunction with the Veteran's Committee is hosting an evening with Jim Barone, who is an Elvis impersonator, on April 28th, 2018. Doors open at 7:00pm and the Show starts at 8:00pm.   Tickets are $30.00 which includes the show and finger foods.  Tickets are limited please contact Brian Csobar 908-756-9425 or SP Elks ...

Grandparents Day at Riley School

March 18, 2018

Pictures of Grandparents Day at Riley School submitted by Debbie Boyle

Pre-Ticket Sale for Holy Savior Academy’s 4th Annual Spring Splendor Tricky Tray

March 17, 2018

Holy Savior Academy is hosting its Spring Splendor Tricky Tray Saturday, April 21, 2018 at the school.  Doors open at 6:00 p.m.

Tickets are limited and will be sold at Holy Savior Academy, 149 South Plainfield Avenue, South Plainfield on Wednesday, March 21, 2018 from 2 p.m. to 4 p.m. (cash or checks)

BYOB and food- Admission $ 25 per ...

Eggert Volleyball Fundraiser a huge success.

March 12, 2018

SOUTH PLAINFIELD, NJ - On Sunday March 11th South Plainfield current and former residents came out in force to support the Eggert Family and stand up against cancer.  The Volleyball fundraiser was a great success and would not have happened without all of the great support from the community.  Once again South Plainfield showed that we are a tight knit community who looks out for each ...

Upcoming Events


Wed, March 21, 2:00 PM

South Plainfield

Holy Savior Academy's 4th Annual Spring Splendor ...


Sun, March 25, 1:00 PM

South Plainfield

Annual Easter Egg Hunt

Thu, March 29, 7:30 PM

Wesley United Methodist Church, South Plainfield

Holy Thursday Communion Service at Wesley United ...

Religions And Spirituality

Fri, March 30, 3:00 PM

Wesley United Methodist Church, South Plainfield

Good Friday Prayer Vigil at Wesley United ...

Religions And Spirituality

Sat, April 7, 9:00 AM

Wesley United Methodist Church, South Plainfield

Rummage Sale at Wesley United Methodist Church

Arts & Entertainment Other Religions And Spirituality


Fri, April 13, 7:00 PM


SPRO Victory Dinner Honoring Councilwoman ...


Diegnan Bill To Secure At-Risk Nonprofits Becomes Law

SOUTH PLAINFIELD, NJ -Legislation sponsored by Senator Patrick J. Diegnan to provide state grants to increase security at New Jersey’s nonprofit organizations deemed high-risk targets of threats, attacks, and other violent acts was recently signed into law.

“We know that individuals, with great animus, are looking to endanger our friends and neighbors for who they are, what they ...

Saturday Debris Cleanup Operations

The Department of Public Works will have three separate crews performing tree and branch removal tomorrow March 17th.  All branches and twigs should be brought to the curb. Cleanup efforts will not be completed tomorrow. This will be an on-going effort to remove all debris from the Borough. Additionally, the yard waste site will be operating on summer hours which are 8:00am – ...

In Cold Blood by Truman Capote

In Cold Blood by Truman Capote (Random House, 1965)


In Cold Blood is, quite simply, the grand-daddy of true crime writing, dubbed by Capote, himself, as the first non-fiction novel (although Norman Mailer argued the point when he published The Executioner's Song in 1979.) The conditions under which I read In Cold Blood for the first time were pretty weird, which was another ...


Did you miss a movie that you wanted to see in the theaters and don’t want to pay to rent it or for the DVD? Come to “Monday Night Movies” at the library.  It’s all the fun of a movie theater but none of the cost.  We are showing brand new releases every Monday night and we will be providing popcorn for all who attend. This week’s movie stars Margot Robbie ...

2018 Keystone Community St Patrick's Lunch

The South Plainfield Knights of Columbus Council 6203 held their annual Keystone Special Citizens Community Lunch at the Holy Savior Academy on March 10th. Every Month Father John Alvarado from Sacred Heart Church holds a special Mass for the Mentally Challenged residents from the Keystone Community as well as other residents from Middlesex County.  This month’s theme was St ...

If You Want to Experience the Awkwardness of Race Relations, Look No Further Than Sunday Morning

In a country that is more racially divided than ever, our churches reflect the divide on Sunday morning. In America, we miss the mark on integrating the faces and lives of many races and ethnicities into our Christian communities.

LifeWay conducted a survey of 994 churchgoers who attend religious services more frequently than just holidays. They also surveyed 1,000 Protestant senior pastors of ...

Press Releases

Join the Kennedy School for “A Night at the Casino”

March 19, 2018

The John F. Kennedy Elementary School’s PTSO is hosting their 4th Annual “A Night at the Casino” on Saturday, April 14th at 6:30 p.m.

Thanks to the generous donations from local businesses, the PTSO is transforming the American Legion Chaumont Post #243 into a casino complete with Black Jack, Roulette, Craps, and Poker.  Tickets for this adult evening of fun and ...