Beth's Book Review

Katherine of Aragon: The True Queen by Alison Weir and Anne Boleyn: A King's Obsession by Alison Weir

Six Tudor Queens: Katherine of Aragon, The True Queen by Alison Weir (Ballentine Books, 2016)

Six Tudor Queens: Anne Boleyn, A King's Obsession by Alison Weir (Headline Pub. Group, 2017)

 

While having a wander through the largest Waterstones Book Store in London recently, I came across a new novel by Alison Weir, Anne Boleyn, A King's Obsession. A hardcover tome, I realized that if I bought it, toting this book on our vacation was going to be a chore---but one that was so worth the effort.

Sign Up for E-News

When inspecting the cover of the novel, it became obvious that Anne Boleyn: A King's Obsession was the second in Weir's latest writing endeavor; a novel about each of the wives of King Henry VIII, told from the point of view of the unfortunate ladies. Wow! It was like the 4th of July for me. (Actually, it was the 4th of July, come to think of it!)

I coveted this new treasure and sought out its mate, Katherine of Aragon, The True Queen. Alison Weir, a foremost scholar on the Tudor period, who has written scores of historical treatises on the turbulent and intriguing Renaissance in Britain, with her elegant prose and ability to tell this familiar story to her readership, is an extraordinary historical novelist. Both of these works enraptured me as I devoured each page and wished that they would never end.

Before discussing the novels, a word or two must be said about the importance of point of view in how a story is presented. As a Creative Writing teacher for over 30 years, instruction on the value of selecting the best point of view to use in telling a story was one of the starting points for my course each year. Whether one uses interior monologue, the epistolary method, first or third person narrative, point of view determines how the reader will respond to the characters. Alison Weir chose to write this series from the point of view of the wives themselves.

In reflecting on Katherine of Aragon, The True Queen, Weir states, “Writing the story from Katherine's point of view has enabled me to give a different and intimate psychological perspective on this indomitable, courageous, and principled woman.” (Katherine, p. 801) Weir goes on to explain that “In transporting the reader to that world, I have tried to show the past was indeed another country and that modern preoccupations with women's rights, feminism, and political correctness have no place in it. Katherine's situation, as a woman, and her willing subjection to Henry in all things except those that touched her conscience may seem shocking to us, but for her they were normal, right, and not to be questioned.” (Katherine p. 802)

Although Katherine of Aragon was in no way a feminist, she differed fundamentally with her husband on the major issue of their 25 year long marriage. Katherine tried to convince Henry that their only living child, a daughter named Mary, would be capable of succeeding him on the throne. Her argument was based largely on the stamina of her own mother, Queen Isabella of Spain, who had led her country in battle and directly ruled large provinces of Spain. Mary, Katherine argued, was intelligent and devout, and would be prepared to reign upon Henry's death. Had Katherine been able to get Henry to accept the ascension of his legitimate female child to the throne, both Katherine's future, as well as that of England, would have had a very different outcome.

By telling the story through Katherine's eyes, the reader feels the despair that this noble queen suffered, starting with Henry's early infidelities to his shocking decision to approve of his own divorce by turning his back on the papacy of Rome. Henry announced that he was the supreme leader of the Church of England, a decision that crushed Katherine because she believed that Henry had damned his immortal soul and announced to the world in doing so that their daughter, Mary, was not the legitimate heir to the British throne. She never wavered from her insistence that she was the lawful queen of England, even when Henry demanded that she return the crown jewels to him, or when he continued to reduce her circumstances from being attended by 300 loyal servants to a mere three devoted ladies at the end of her life.

By telling the story from Katherine's point of view, Weir achieves her goal of transporting the reader back to the Tudor period. We ride the waves of hope and cruel disappointments with Katherine. We taste the ocean of tears that she sheds with each new blow that Henry strikes in his efforts to obliterate her from his life. When the reader finishes the book, Katherine remains a force to be reckoned with in her faith and courage for what is not only moral, but true to her God.

Weir's portrait of Anne Boleyn is very cleverly done in the second book of the new series. Clearly, in Katherine of Aragon: The True Queen, Anne is the villain, who skillfully tears the affections of Henry from his beleaguered wife. So, how then does the author keep consistent with Katherine's view of Anne, and yet make Anne a sympathetic character in the second book of the series? Weir's explanation of how she approached the telling of Anne's story can be seen in the following statement, “In writing this novel from Anne's point of view, I have tried to reconcile conflicting views of her, and to portray her as a flawed but very human heroine, a woman of great ambition, idealism, and courage who found herself in an increasingly frightening situation.” (Anne, p.509)

In recent times Anne Boleyn has become a much more popular figure than she was during her own age. The British of the Tudor period never warmed to Anne and considered her a usurper of their beloved Katherine. Weir claims that it has become “fashionable” in the modern age to see Anne as a feminist heroine, a woman who spent her youth in the French court, which was far more progressive than Tudor England in courting an intellectual movement.

In Weir's depiction of Anne, we do not see a woman hopelessly in love with the dynamic Henry as Katherine had been when she married the young Henry. Rather, Weir's Anne plays the game of courtly love, but secretly harbors passion for Sir William Norris through the years of her courtship and brief marriage. Anne's motivation to become queen in Weir's story is for the power that she will wield. And, for the six tedious years in which she fended off Henry's physical advances while he attempted to shed himself of Katherine, Anne questions whether the fight is actually worth it because she is not impassioned by Henry.

The power of Weir's writing hits full force in the final scene of the novel. It is certainly no spoiler to include this statement that Weir made regarding the depiction of Anne's execution. Weir states, “Writing the final scenes of Anne's life was a grueling experience that stayed with me for days, and in case anyone wonders about my portrayal of her actual beheading, I must point out that a judge, Sir John Spelman, who witnessed her execution, recorded seeing 'her lips moving and her eyes moving afterwards.'” Due to the fact that the reader does feel transported back to Tudor times, we take every step with Anne as she goes to her death. Just as Weir says she was haunted by writing about the death of Anne Boleyn, I could not stop thinking about the final scene for days after finishing the book.

Fortunately, there are four more books to look forward to in Weir's series on the six wives of Henry VIII. Although the first two queens, Katherine and Anne, surely are the most famous of Henry's ladies, Weir begins setting up for the third queen, Jane Seymour, by introducing her as a background character, seen by Katherine and Anne as a mousey little thing in their courts. Like all of Weir's fans around the world, I anticipate that through her rigorous study of letters and documents of the time, we will get an intimate look at the mother of Henry's only legitimate son. For those who never tire of returning to Tudor England, I can guarantee that Weir's new series will bring you great reading pleasure.


 

Beth Moroney, former English teacher and administrator in the Edison Public School District, specialized in teaching Creative Writing and Journalism. Recently Moroney published Significant Anniversaries of Holocaust/Genocide Education and Human/Civil Rights, available through the New Jersey Commission on the Holocaust. A passionate reader, Moroney is known for recommending literature to students, teachers, parents, and the general public for over forty years. Moroney can be contacted at trackdak19@hotmail.com.

The opinions expressed herein are the writer's alone, and do not reflect the opinions of TAPinto.net or anyone who works for TAPinto.net. TAPinto.net is not responsible for the accuracy of any of the information supplied by the writer.

TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Be Interested In

Sign Up for E-News

South Plainfield

The Athlete of the Week: Shaun Boffard Boys’ Bowling

The South Plainfield Boys’ Bowling Team continues from their success of last season.  Coming off a Blue Division Title, and having many bowlers returning, The South Plainfield Boys’ Bowling Team has high standards for the season.  The team started off the year by defeating South River 4-0 on Friday, December 1, 2017.  The Tigers then traveled up to Bergen Catholic High ...

Obituaries

South Plainfield – Nina “Antonina” Basilone (DiPasquale) passed away unexpectedly ...
Read more

Letters to the Editor

Letter to the Editor from Mayor's Wellness Committee

December 14, 2017

Letter To The Editor:

South Plainfield Mayor Matt Anesh and the Mayor's Wellness Committee hosted the 2nd annual Anti Drug and Alcohol Conference at the South Plainfield Senior Center on December 5, 2017.  "Dr. " Nick Sottiriou and I began contacting a panel of guest speakers, who would be able to inform the residents and guests about various ...

Community Happenings

Santa Paws is Making a Stop at the Southside Dog Park

December 12, 2017

Are you in need of a Christmas card photo with your fur baby this year? Well, the Southside Dog Park has just the ticket for you! Join us for photos with Santa, and mingle with other dogs.  Bring your camera this Saturday, December 16th from 10 am to 11 am at the Southside Dog Park located on New Market Avenue.

Student council Luncheon for SP Senior Citizens

December 16, 2017

The South Plainfield Senior Center Senior Citizens were treated to a Concert hosted by the South Plainfield High School Musical Arts students and full course dinner hosted by Sodexo Food Service and the South Plainfield High School Student Council and advisor Anthony Encinas.  The Holiday Concert and Dinner Event has been hosted for the past 15 years, with the addition of two ...

Holy Savior Academy Presents The Best Christmas Pageant Ever

December 10, 2017

SOUTH PLAINFIELD, NJ  -  Holy Savior Academy in South Plainfield presented their fall production of Barbara Robinson’s classic story, The Best Christmas Pageant Ever, on December 1st.  The cast and crew featured 65 performers from the school’s Drama Club from third through eighth grades.

“I think the kids did a fantastic job,” said Eva Tripodi, Enrichment ...

Bishop James Checchio visited Holy Savior Academy

Bishop James Checchio visited Holy Savior Academy on Tuesday November 28th.  Bishop Checchio was the main celebrant of the school mass held at The Church of the Sacred Heart.  This Mass also coincided with the 8th Grade Ring Ceremony.

Bishop Checchio spoke to the students, families and friends in attendance about “Thanking God first.”  He also spoke directly to the ...

High School Concert for Seniors

December 16, 2017

What a treat South Plainfield seniors enjoyed last Wednesday at the high school. The music students performed a special concert for us consisting of the Jazz Band, Chamber Choir, String Quartet, Symphony Orchestra and Band. This was followed by a luncheon served to us by the nicest, friendliest students. Thank you students and music department.

Press Release – Residential Burglary

South Plainfield Police responded to a residential burglary which occurred on Wednesday, December 6th, 2017, shortly before 1:00 PM to a home on Woodland Ave.  Access was gained to the home and electronic items and jewelry were stolen.
A witness saw two black men 20's-30's dressed in all black, both wearing black hoods one carrying a large black duffel bag with red trim walking ...

Middle School National Honor Society Help to Decorate Senior Center

The Middle School Junior National Honor Society was instrumental in hanging all the beautiful decorations at the senior center.   The students set aside 3 afternoons to complete the task.

 Donna Tierney is the advisor of this amazing group of students.    The teachers took the time to walk students after school to the Senior center and supervise their ...

Columns

A Winter Saturday in South Plainfield

Dear Residents:

There is no better job than being Mayor of my hometown of South Plainfield. Last Saturday, was one of those days. I sit back and say how thankful I am, to you the residents and the town I call home.

The morning started off with breakfast with the Mayor at the South Plainfield Senior Center. I am glad I had my coffee because everyone was wide awake. There ...

Victoria and Albert: A Royal Love Affair by Daisy Goodwin and Sara Sheridan

Victoria and Albert: A Royal Love Affair by Daisy Goodwin and Sara Sheridan (St. Martin's Press, 2017)

Several months ago I reviewed the magnificent compendium Hamilton: The Revolution by Lin Manuel Miranda. This charming edition is a must for anyone who is planning to see the Hamilton in order to become familiarized with the libretto and prepare him/herself for an extra-ordinary ...

Bookmarks

Come join us at the library for Monday Night Movies!  On December 18 at 6:30 PM, we will be showing a new romantic comedy starring Reese Witherspoon, Michael Sheen, Candice Bergen, and Nat Wolff.  Witherspoon plays a single mother who allows three young men to move into her house; let the antics ensue.   If you cannot make it to our Monday night showing, it will also be shown ...

TAPinto Featured Franchisee: Westfield's Jackie Lieberman

This week's feature will focus on TAPintoWestfield franchisee, Jackie Lieberman. Find out what makes TAPintoWestfield.net different than the competition, what she did before coming onto TAPinto.net and how an inexperienced sales person became one of TAPinto's most successful franchisee's. 

 

When did you join TAPinto.net?:

I started as a freelance reporter in 2011 ...

The Thought that Counts

The other day I was talking to our cat . . .  

Hmmm.  It says here that dogs are smarter than cats.

What are you reading, Mad Magazine?

No seriously, this article in the Times claims that a scientific study conducted at Vanderbilt University recently discovered that dogs have twice as many neurons as cats in the analytic part of their brains.

Yeah, but they only use a ...

Johnny Four Fingers Week #15 NFL Picks

CALABASH, NC – The Four Finger man went 3-2 last week. I won three out of my four dogs, but lost Cincinnati. My Baltimore was good. I picked the Ravens losing by one point. I think the smell of pork roll is helping my picks. Here are my picks for week #15.

WEEK #15 NFL PICKS

Tennessee +1 ½ Over San Francisco – The 49ers are much better than their record shows, and this ...

Suburban Woman’s Club Rings in the Holidays!

The Suburban Woman's Club of South Plainfield began celebrating the holiday season on December 3rd with its annual Theater Party at the Historical Edison Valley Playhouse.  At a sold-out performance, the audience was treated to “You’re A Good Man, Charlie Brown,” a delightful and heartwarming musical.

Continuing with the holiday spirit, the Club donated to ...

Press Releases

ESCNJ Prepares Students For Independent Living

December 14, 2017

PISCATAWAY--While discussing Community-based Instruction (CBI) on the Educational Services Commission of New Jersey’s (ESCNJ) Better Together podcast, first year South River Public Schools Superintendent Sylvia Zircher remarked on the organizations value in “teaching you how to fish,” when it comes to operating educational programs.

 Ms. Zircher, a first year ESCNJ Board ...