Government

South Plainfield Borough Advances Affordable Housing Plan

Under the borough's new affordable housing plan mandated by the court, 1111 Durham Avenue will have to used for residential housing.
1111 Durham Avenue

SOUTH PLAINFIELD, NJ – The South Plainfield Borough Council, at a Jan. 23 meeting and under legal obligation from the Superior Court, unanimously authorized the approval of a proposed settlement agreement that will include the former Motorola property at 1111 Durham Avenue into its affordable housing plan. The settlement agreement is scheduled to be approved at the Feb. 6 council meeting.  

The 5-0 council vote – Councilman Robert Bengivenga, Jr. recused himself – was rendered just days after the New Jersey Supreme Court ruled that municipalities throughout the state must meet constitutional obligations and provide a fair share of low and moderate income housing options.

“No one is saying we do not believe there should be affordable housing throughout the state and throughout South Plainfield. It is the manner in which we, as a municipality, are being forced to do things,” said Mayor Matt Anesh during the meeting.

Sign Up for E-News

Earlier this month, the state Superior Court unanimously ruled that municipalities must meet affordable housing needs left unaddressed between 1999 and 2015, stating that during this 16-year period, the Council on Affordable Housing (COAH) failed to meet housing quotas for towns. Under the ruling, a total of 200,000 units are needed statewide, through rehab, conversion or new construction, by 2025.

“We hold that towns are constitutionally obligated to provide a realistic opportunity for their fair share of affordable housing for low- and moderate-income households formed during the gap period and presently existing in New Jersey,” stated Justice Jaynee LaVecchia in the court’s unanimous 32-page decision.

Housing advocates such as the Fair Share Housing Center, feel the court ruling is ‘a victory for lower-income and minority families across New Jersey.’ “This ruling means that thousands of lower-income and minority families will be given the opportunity to live in safe neighborhoods, send their children to good schools, and work at jobs where they live instead of traveling hours commuting each day …” stated Colandus “Kelly” Francis, chairman of the Fair Share Housing Center’s Board of Directors and vice president of the Camden County Branch of the NAACP.

According to Anesh, the borough’s problem is not with having to provide affordable housing, but rather the way in which the town is being forced to do so.

“This isn’t something the town is taking lightly. I fundamentally disagree - not with providing affordable housing in South Plainfield but with the method the courts or the Council on Affordable Housing is mandating how we do it,” said Anesh.

The mayor stated that South Plainfield previously opposed residential development of the Durham Avenue property and, after multiple commercial parties expressed interest in the site, the borough did not include the property in its affordable housing plan, seeking a ‘Vacant Land Adjustment’ in meeting the affordable housing requirements.

Anesh said that South Plainfield was aggressively working to bring other commercial tenants to the site, but Motorola owner M&M Realty objected to the municipality’s plan. With the objection, M&M Realty was able to intervene in the affordable housing plan the borough was submitting to the court.

Special Court Master Betsy McKenzie, appointed to oversee the litigation, spoke at the Jan. 23 meeting. McKenzie stated that although the borough had been fully compliant in terms of meeting its previous affordable housing obligations, Durham Avenue must be included.

“The borough is legally obligated to include that site in the plan once it was know that it was available…” said McKenzie. “When you have a developer proposing inclusionary development and you are seeking a ‘Vacant Land Adjustment’ – and you had no choice but to do so in South Plainfield – you have no choice but to deal with that developer…”  

As it currently stands, a combination of condos and townhouses totaling a combined 410 units, with 20 percent designated as affordable housing, can be built on 27-acres at 1111 Durham Avenue; the approved amount is a negotiated decrease. The developer was proposing nearly 750 units for the site.

“We’ve spent a great deal of time negotiating with the two developers to try to maximize the percentage of affordable housing, which ultimately reduces the development on those properties as necessary to meet the town’s obligations,” said Steven Kunzman, the attorney handling the borough’s affordable housing plan.

According to McKenzie, had the borough taken the issue to court rather than agree to the settlement option, it would have, ‘ultimately ended up in a lawsuit trying to stand its ground.’ “The only way that a town can avoid having an interveners site in the plan is if they can meet the full obligation in some other way… you don't have that luxury because you are a town that is largely developed,” she said.

In addition to the former Motorola property, the development of the Harris Steel site at New Brunswick Avenue and Tyler Place is also included in the plan. That site was approved to be in the plan back in 2009.

According to the borough’s planner Stan Slachetka, South Plainfield has implemented and followed through many of its affordable housing plan obligations over the years. “Fundamentally, the plan you have in place is the plan that you have been implementing for a better part of a decade and, in some case, for over a decade,” said Slachetka.

Among them include rehabilitation of existing dwellings occupied by low- or moderate-income households that were below code and in need of modernization. Additionally, the borough has also fully satisfied its ‘prior round’ obligations through the establishment of completed projects such as Highland Manors, several group homes that address special needs obligations, and at other locations, including existing senior citizen housing and rental units. However, said Slachetka, the borough’s plan must now work to address an obligation to ‘prospective need.’

“That is the obligation now and which will continue through 2025 and that prospective need is being addressed in part through a couple of projects already in your plan,” he said, referencing the Celebrations construction, the Harris Steel property site - which has been in the plan for several years – and now, the Durham Avenue site.

Although municipalities such as South Plainfield can appeal the Superior Court ruling, doing so would be a lengthy and costly legal battle that, in the end, could result in more housing units being mandated.

Frustrated, Anesh blasted the process and the court’s decision.

“There is nothing we can do to prevent housing on 1111 Durham or prevent housing at the Harris Steel site. We can put up a big show, take it to court, spend $250,000 of our money that ultimately could go to improving our roads, our parks, or to public safety… and fight a case we know we will not win,” said Anesh, noting that in the end, the borough could ‘end up with more units, the same, or a little less’ but nothing that would prevent housing on Durham altogether.

“It is legally obligated to be included in the plan,” Anesh said. “We have a decision to make, like it or not, and that decision has to be the one that is best for the borough. The choice of this governing body isn’t a choice anyone wants to make [but] … there is no decision other than to settle.”

Council President Derryck White, chair of the borough’s Economic Development Committee, added, “To minimize impact on the borough – whether it be legally or in terms of infrastructure – this is the decision we are faced with. It is not a decision we want or one we are taking lightly. We, as a governing body, tried as best we could to minimize the impact on the community because we didn't want to put ourselves in a position where, moving forward, we would have more dire consequences.”

Realizing residents will have questions and concerns, Anesh said the intent of the borough is to ‘share information and facts as they become available; and to make the borough’s ‘professional experts available’ at upcoming council meetings and other venues. An electronic version of the affordable housing plan, once officially adopted, will be posted on the borough’s website.

“We intend to fully make what is going to happen in the new plan transparent as can be,” said Anesh. “I also encourage our professionals and our governing body to make themselves available and hold a town hall where the details can be provided and residents can ask the questions that they want.”

The South Plainfield Borough Council is expected to approve the affordable housing plan at the Feb. 6 meeting. 

TAPinto South Plainfield is South Plainfield’s only free daily paper. Sign up to get all the news as it happens at www.TAPinto.net/enews and follow us on Facebook at https://www.facebook.com/SouthPlainfieldTAP/ and on Twitter at @SoplainfieldTAP.

TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Like

Sign Up for E-News

South Plainfield

Obituaries

South Plainfield – Louis V. Gambacort, Jr., 71, died Sunday August 13, 2017 at Robert Wood ...
Read more
South Plainfield – Ruth McArthur, 87, died Monday, August 14, 2017 after a lengthy ...
Read more

Letters to the Editor

Letter to the Editor from Chief James Parker

August 8, 2017

Dear Residents,

Last week the Borough held its fourth annual National Night Out, and I must say it was the best. An event like this can only work by having plenty of volunteers and community support.  Thankfully, we had both.

The South Plainfield Police Department received hundreds of donations from citizens and businesses to be used towards the National Night Out event. Volunteers put ...

South Plainfield High School Graduate Angelica Smith Earns Dean's Award at Colgate University

August 13, 2017

HAMILTON, NY -- Colgate University Class of 2017 member Angelica Smith, from South Plainfield, NJ (07080), has earned the spring 2017 Dean's Award for academic excellence.

The Dean's Award at Colgate is awarded to students with a 3.3 or higher term average.

Colgate University is a highly selective residential liberal arts institution distinguished by its commitment to global ...

Community Happenings

Class of 2007 Reunion

August 8, 2017

Who: The Class of 2007, spouses, significant others and little ones!

Where: Forest Lodge 11 Reinman Rd. Warren, NJ

When: September 3rd 2017 11:30am-5pm

Why: Because Why Not It’s Been 10 years!

How Much: Adult ticket prices will be $70, but for a limited time there will be an early pay discount of $65 through January 31st.

What’s in the Box?: Forest ...

Starts Sunday in East Brunswick: 79th Annual Middlesex County Fair

August 6, 2017

EAST BRUNSWICK,  NJ - The 79th annual Middlesex County Fair will be held from August 7th-13th at 655 Cranbury Rd, East Brunswick. The fair runs from 5-11 p.m. Monday-Friday, 11 a.m.-11 p.m. on Saturday, and 11 a.m.- 10 p.m. on Sunday.

The fair is a fun time for all ages with a multitude of rides, entertainment, games, and much more! The entertainment includes The Pork Chop Review animal ...

Senior Trips

Back by popular demand!     South Plainfield Senior Center Presents

Grounds For Sculpture  On Wednesday, September 27

Bus leaves the senior center at 9:30   - return is 3:00 p.m. apprx.

$60.00 p/p  includes admission,  lunch and transportation

Must sign up at the center 908-754-1047

Upcoming Events

Carousel_image_0973e2eeda44cc8965d7_monarch

Sun, August 20, 2:00 PM

Indian Queen Tavern - East Jersey Old Town Village, Piscataway

“Magnificent Monarch” Migration

Carousel_image_9019bc6acfc5a9f45da1_img_2362

Sun, August 20, 2:00 PM

Middlesex

Open House 12 Douglass Lane Middlesex NJ

Real Estate

Carousel_image_81048bab64a7b83f1107_summer_concert_series

Thu, August 24, 7:00 PM

Columbus Park Extension Gazebo, Piscataway

Piscataway Summer Concert Series

Arts & Entertainment

Carousel_image_e8a7fb140f62da6337da_6f42f654de38b1770eda_pasta_for_joey_flyer

Fri, August 25, 5:30 PM

Dunellen Defender Fire Company #1, Dunellen

Pasta Dinner for Joey

Giving Back Police & Fire

Carousel_image_7fa9ce48c8441506de7f_summer_concert_series

Thu, August 31, 7:00 PM

Columbus Park Extension Gazebo, Piscataway

Piscataway Summer Concert Series

Arts & Entertainment

Carousel_image_dbd5215c11b04ffadc95_food_truck

Sat, September 9, 11:00 AM

South Plainfield

South Plainfield Rescue Squad First Annual Food ...

Columns

In a Dark, Dark Wood by Ruth Ware

In a Dark, Dark Wood by Ruth Ware (Scout Press, 2015)

Think Hitchcock. Think old-fashioned psychological thriller. Think good writing. If you have read and loved The Woman in Cabin 10, Ware's most recent novel, you will enjoy her first publication, In a Dark, Dark Wood.

Leonora Shaw, a crime writer, awakens, bruised and befuddled in a hospital bed. Frightened and confused, Nora tries ...

Bookmarks

ECLIPSE UPDATE: On August 21 there will be an eclipse of the sun.  It will be partially visible in South Plainfield from 1:22 pm until 4:01 pm.  NEVER look at the sun directly.  For instructions on safe methods of view, click here  ; more information can be found here.

-------------------

You know summer is drawing to a close when books checked out won't be due until ...

Press Releases

Traffic Safety Service, LLC Now Offers The World’s Only Speed Dependent Crash Attenuators

August 16, 2017

The Smart Cushion Innovations Crash Cushion (Model SCI100GM) is creating a stir in the traffic safety industry. The SCI100GM is revolutionary as it is the only one of its kind: a speed dependent crash cushion that adjusts it’s stopping force based on the speed and weight of the crashing vehicle, and does not reach maximum stopping force unless the colliding vehicle is traveling at the ...