Councilwoman Quinn's Incident Statement Against Former Manager David Troast; Part 2 of 2

December 13, 2013 at 3:46 PM

SPARTA, NJ - A Sparta Township Council member has said she felt “threatened” and feared for her safety because of the actions of the community’s township manager.  The story that began last August, regarding a verbal exchange between Councilwoman Christine Quinn and former Township Manager David Troast at a ribbon-cutting ceremony, continues to unfold. 

Troast's and Quinn's statements about the exchange in the restaurant did not differ substantially.  The difference comes in the perception of what was said.  Troast indicates in his statement that "she had no particular response or reaction" to his comments, while Quinn felt threatened enough to contact the police. Quinn, Troast, Mayor Gibbs and witness Mary Ann Ryan all gave statements to the police about the exchange.

The following day the council met in a previously scheduled, executive session. By the next Township Council meeting, Troast had tendered his resignation.

Sign Up for E-News

With Troast's resignation came requests from reporters at the Sparta Independent and New Jersey Herald for the Incident Report regarding Troast.  The township's attorney advised not to release the documents to the public, saying it was a personnel matter and was therefore excluded from the public's right to see. This denial of access led the New Jersey Herald and citizen Jesse Wolosky to file a civil complaint alleging a violation of New Jersey Open Public Records Act.  

Subsequent to that, former council member Michael Spekhardt filed ethics complaints against councilwomen Quinn and Molly Whilesmith.  His complaint alleges both "acted in their official capacity in a matter where she has a personal involvement that might reasonably be expected to impair her objectivity or independence of judgment.  Additionally, they attempted to use their official position to secure unwarranted privileges or advantages for themselves."

Spekhardt explained he is relying on information available to the public as a foundation for his complaint including articles in the New Jersey Herald, meeting minutes and court brief that had been posted on-line.  

The Civil Action Verified Complaint filed by the Herald against the Township of Sparta sought "access to public records relating to police incident reports regarding former Township Manager David Troast and related Voluntary Statements of Molly Whilesmith, Christine Quinn, Gil Gibbs, John Schon, Jerry Murphy and David Troast." Whilesmith, Schon and Murphy, however, had not made statements regarding this incident. 

Spekhardt also cites the Superior Court ruling of Dec. 6 as rationale supporting his complaint against Quinn and Whilesmith. Judge Weisenbeck ruled against Sparta last Friday, Dec. 6 ordering the police report to be released by the following Monday, Dec . 9.  Once the documents were released, it was apparent that Whilesmith had not made a statement, as had been conjectured by the Herald and others.

Spekhardt plans to follow through with the ethic complaints against both councilwomen, saying he would "simply like an outside agency to look at the matter to determine the appropriateness of their actions," regarding the separation of Troast from the township.  He questions how Quinn could be fearful and feel threatened by the former township manager on Aug 15 and then be objective in a discussion about his employment on Aug 16. 

The code of ethics pertaining to local goverment officers seems to be related to business dealings where there is a possible financial gain for the official.  The language of the code, taken on its own however, could seem to relate simply to matters of conduct.  The violations listed in the complaint fall under "NEW JERSEY STATUTES TITLE 40A:9-22.1 et seq. LOCAL GOVERNMENT ETHICS LAW; 40A:9-22.5 Provisions requiring compliance by local government officers, employees... subsections (c) (d)."

There have been no further actions from the Department of Community Affairs regarding the ethics complaint to date.

Quinn made the following statement;  "As a result of events which transpired on August 15, I submitted a voluntary statement to the Sparta Police Department. If history were to repeat itself, I would make the same decision.

It's unfortunate that this incident has drawn attention away from positive community events and services which happen every day within Sparta Township. It is my hope that, with the reports now public, we can return our focus and energies accordingly."

Troast did not have any comment, citing the restrictions of the separation agreement. 

Sgt. John Paul Beebe, public affairs officer speaking for the police department, said, "We are not a political agency.  Mrs. Quinn is a citizen who also happens to be Town Council member.  She did absolutely the right thing by coming to the police after feeling threatened.  While the situation did not rise to the level of a criminal charge, the compliant was a legitimate public safety concern.  Mrs. Quinn was advised, as are all citizens in a situation like this where the police have not observed the alleged offence, that she could sign a complaint at any time from one to three years, depending on the statute of limitations of the  offence being charged."

"Additionally, the investigation did find that there was a firearm on township property without the permission of the Chief of Police and this is a violation of township policy."

"Further, the police want to continue to urge citizens to report anything that appears to be a threat or threatening situation.  Public safety is the primary mission of the Sparta Police Department."

With the court ordered release of the police report many questions have been answered.  Several more, according to some involved, have been raised.  It is also apparent that the story will not conclude until the ethics complaints have been resolved.

This is the second in a two part article on this subject.  For the first part can be viewed at

TAP Into Another Town's News:

TAP Into Another Town's News:

Sign Up for E-News


Upcoming Events

Sun, August 28, 1:00 PM

Van Kirk Homestead Museum, Sparta

Barns of Sussex County NJ - Paintings by Wendy ...

Arts & Entertainment

Sun, August 28, 1:00 PM

Van Kirk Homestead Museum, Sparta

Summer Arts at the Museum - Jazz with Rio Clemente

Arts & Entertainment

Sun, September 4, 7:30 AM

V5 Cycles, Flemington

Avery's Hope Century Ride

Giving Back Health & Wellness

Trump and the American Auto Industry

August 19, 2016

I worked via government in the Auto Industry.  In the 1970s, I was one of many state workers, who worked at the Ford Plant in Mahwah, in its closing days, and that closed plant has still left a legacy of pollution that has impacted many in Northern Bergen County. In the other two plants, I worked with my colleague Peter Nozza, an unusual asset for government and industry,  and his ...

Elizabeth Man Flashes False ID, Faces Multiple Charges

August 23, 2016

SPARTA, NJ – An Elizabeth resident faces charges after falsely identifying himself as an Essex County Constable.  On August 21, just after noon, Juan Genao, 26, was pulled over by Sparta Police Officer Tom Snyder for “several equipment violations,” according to police.

While stopped on Tomahawk Trail, Genao showed Snyder a gold badge with a “poorly constructed ID ...

Sparta Police: Jefferson Man Crashes into Telephone Pole, Faces Several Charges

SPARTA, NJ - A Jefferson man faces multiple charges after crashing his car into a telephone pole.  Sparta police officers were called to the scene of the one car accident at 397 Main Street at 2:45 p.m.  on August 18.

They found Chase Wainstein, 21 of Jefferson, still in his car a 2013 Toyota Camry.  Cpl. Scott Elig spoke with Wainstein after he got out of his car and suspected ...

Route 15 Closed After 7 p.m. Friday, For Several Hours

Sparta, NJ—At approximately 7 p.m. on Friday, August 19, Rt. 15 was closed at mile marker 14, due to an accident that occurred earlier in the day, according to police.

A dump truck rolled into a pond needed to be removed. A detour was be set up diverting traffic around the area police reported..

According to Sparta Police, Route 15 northbound traffic had to be ...

Sparta Police: Driver and Passenger Charged in Route 15 Crash Involving Pregnant Woman

SPARTA, NJ - Charges have been filed in the accident that occurred on Route 15 on July 19 that led to injuries, including a pregnant woman.  Sparta police announced they have "issues charges against Joshua Buttacavole and the passenger of his vehicle Nicholas Baya."

The Lodi residents were in a 2005 Chevy that crossed from the northbound lane , rolled over in the grassy median ...

Sparta Police: Head-On Collision Leads to DWI Charges

SPARTA, NJ - A Connecticut man was taken into custody following a head on collision early on Sunday morning.  Sparta police responded to the accident on Green Road around 4 a.m. to find a 2007 Saab had crossed into the opposite lane  and crashed into a delivery truck, according to police.

Sparta Cpl Kurt Morris spoke with the driver of the Saab, Zachary Watson, 26, of Norwalk, CT.

Sparta Police: Newton Man Faces Charges After Causing 2 Accidents in Two Towns

SPARTA, NJ – A Newton man faces charges following two car accidents in two different towns.  On August 9 at 6:53 p.m. Sparta police went to Route 15 after being told by Jefferson Township police a work truck had been in an accident and fled the scene, police report.

Sparta police were also notified of another accident on Route 15 on the Sparta Junction.  When Sparta police got ...

Newton Habitat for Humanity Gets a New Home

July 26, 2016

NEWTON, NJ - Newton Habitat for Humanity will soon have a new home of its own.  The non-profit organization received the deed to a foreclosed property on Mount View Road from Wells Fargo. 

The dwelling on the property will be demolished and replaced with a pole barn.  The building will be 40' x 50' by Shirk from Pennsylvania.  The new facility will have 1400 square ...

Florham Park Resident Colin Skeele Arrested for Producing and Distributing Child Pornography

August 10, 2016

FLORHAM PARK, NJ- A Florham Park man was arrested for two counts of production of child pornography, one count of enticement of a minor to engage in criminal sexual activity and one count of distribution of child pornography.

According to the New Jersey Department of Justice, Colin Skeele was arrested by agents of the US Immigration and Customs Enforcement’s Homeland ...

Do you drive drowsy? Drowsy driving may cause up to 1 in 5 fatal accidents.

A report released last week from the Governors Highway Safety Association (an organization of state and territorial highway safety offices) estimates that up to 20% of fatal traffic accidents result from drowsy driving. The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) has added drowsy driving to its definition of impaired driving along with drunk, drugged and distracted ...

August Message from Sparta Superintendent Dennis Tobin

Welcome to this month’s edition of the Sparta School District Spotlight. The Sparta School District is pleased to provide this monthly article as another means of communication with our community. As we approach the start of the school year, we, in the Sparta Schools, hope that you have had an enjoyable, relaxing summer.

During the summer months, we have been busy preparing for the ...