Law & Justice

NJ Superior Court Denies Elevator Company’s Attempt to Overturn Judgment

4af46b4d80c21720ce8b_Laddey__clark_ryan.jpg
4af46b4d80c21720ce8b_Laddey__clark_ryan.jpg

NEWTON, NJ - The Honorable Edward V. Gannon, Judge of the Superior Court, has denied Schindler Elevator Corporation's attempt to over-turn the jury’s 2014 verdict in the case brought against the company by Richard and Sharon Tufaro.

"We could not be more pleased for the Tufaro family.  It has been more than ten years since Rich was permanently injured and unable to return to work as a master carpenter.  Judge Gannon's decision was well-reasoned and thorough," says Andrew Fraser, partner at Laddey, Clark & Ryan and attorney for the Tufaros.

In a twenty-five page decision issued by the Court on Tuesday, Judge Gannon stated, "Analyzing the case law provided, considering the testimony and this Court's own feel for the case, under the totality of the circumstances, the Court has determined that the jury award should not be remitted and there was no prejudice to Defendant [Schindler] to warrant a new trial."

Sign Up for E-News

Richard Tufaro, of Montague, suffered permanent spinal injuries as a result of an incident in an elevator while he was working at Headquarters Plaza in Morristown in August of 2005.  It was alleged that Schindler Elevator Corporation failed to properly maintain the elevator which malfunctioned and dropped approximately two floors with Tufaro inside.

"We have now tried this case twice and been successful twice.  It is time for Schindler to accept responsibility for the permanent damage caused by their negligence. The jury has spoken [twice] and the Court has spoken," adds Timothy Dinan, who assisted Fraser with both the 2012 and 2014 trials in this case.

This case first went to trial in 2012 in Morristown and resulted in a $3.75 million verdict in favor of Richard Tufaro and his wife, Sharon representing compensation for the Tufaros’ harms and losses resulting from Schindler's negligence. The verdict was over-turned by the Appellate Division in 2013 due to a technicality and set for re-trial in 2014.

The second Morristown jury awarded Richard and Sharon Tufaro $7.75 Million for their losses resulting from Schindler's negligence.  Schindler appealed the jury verdict and the Appellate Division declined to over-turn the verdict, but returned it to the trial judge for an in depth analysis of the verdict amount.

After accepting submissions from the attorneys for Schindler and the Tufaros and after a hearing on the issues on October 30, 2015, Judge Gannon filed his decision on January 10, 2016. The judgment against Schindler Corporation and in favor of the Tufaros is now about $10.6 Million because of the interest that has accrued since the time of the accident, according to Dinan.

"Our juries were generous in recognizing the seriousness of Rich's [Tufaro] injuries and the devastating impact on both his life and his wife's life.  We can only hope that this verdict can finally help make up for what has happened to their lives due to Schindler's failure to properly maintain its elevator," states Lauren Fraser, partner and trial consultant at Laddey, Clark & Ryan.

For more information visit: lcrlaw.com

 

TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Be Interested In

Sign Up for E-News

Sparta

Sparta Police: Drunk Brooklyn Man Asks Police to Shoot Him

May 20, 2018

SPARTA, NJ – A Brooklyn man was taken for observation when he asked police to shoot him after having crashed his car down an embankment on County Road 517 near the Sparta Middle School.  On May 17 around 2:06 a.m. Sparta Police Officers Brian Porter and Timothy Lynott found Joshua Lindland of Brooklyn asleep in the driver’s seat of a gray Audi against a tree, police ...

Sparta Police: Passengers Face Drug Charges in Traffic Stop

SPARTA, NJ – Two Wantage women face drug charges after the car they were in was stopped for a broken headlight on Route 15.  On May 5 around 2 p.m. Sparta Police Officer Ben Griffin pulled over Alex Torres, 22, driving a white Honda Accord with two passengers, police say.

The officer saw a metal marijuana grinder behind the driver’s seat.  The car and ...

JCP&L Latest Information, Free Ice and Water

SUSSEX COUNTY, NJ – As of 8:47 p.m. JCP&L is reporting 12,745 customers or 22.11 percent, are without power in Sussex County.  In Sparta 2749 or 32 percent remain in the dark.

JCP&L said they anticipate the “vast majority of the remaining customers to be restored to service by late Thursday.”

JCP&L customers without power can get ice and water ...

Glen Lake

May 27, 2018

Being that I was forced to pay 15k to join this beach, I expect there to be more sand real soon. I would also like a grill.  

Sparta Education Foundation Thanks Community for Dragon Boat Festival Success

Dear Editor,

The Sparta Education Foundation’s Fourth Annual Dragon Boat Festival drew thousands to the Lake Mohawk Boardwalk on Sunday, May 20.  From the sponsors, participants and schools to the many volunteers and cheering spectators, the Dragon Boat Festival was a true reflection of Sparta Pride.

Congratulations to the Dragon Boat Festival’s top three teams: First Place ...

Upcoming Events

Sun, May 27, 1:00 PM

Van Kirk Homestead Museum, Sparta

Life Along the Wallkil River

Education

Carousel_image_6f4ecc7e007a7b295623_farmers_market

Sat, June 2, 9:00 AM

Sparta Health and Wellness parking lot, Sparta

Sparta Farmers Market

Carousel_image_6f4ecc7e007a7b295623_farmers_market

Sat, June 9, 9:00 AM

Sparta Health and Wellness parking lot, Sparta

Sparta Farmers Market

Sun, June 10, 1:00 PM

Van Kirk Homestead Museum, Sparta

Life Along the Wallkil River

Education

Carousel_image_6f4ecc7e007a7b295623_farmers_market

Sat, June 16, 9:00 AM

Sparta Health and Wellness parking lot, Sparta

Sparta Farmers Market

Thu, June 21, 2:00 PM

Van Kirk Homestead Museum, Sparta

Summer Afternoon Garden Soiree

Home & Garden

Carousel_image_6f4ecc7e007a7b295623_farmers_market

Sat, June 23, 9:00 AM

Sparta Health and Wellness parking lot, Sparta

Sparta Farmers Market

Sun, June 24, 1:00 PM

Van Kirk Homestead Museum, Sparta

Life Along the Wallkil River

Education

Carousel_image_6f4ecc7e007a7b295623_farmers_market

Sat, June 30, 9:00 AM

Sparta Health and Wellness parking lot, Sparta

Sparta Farmers Market

Newton's Petition to Move Election Certified, Tabled to May 30 by Council

May 15, 2018

NEWTON, NJ—The petition to move elections from May to November was certified by the clerk and presented to the Newton Town Council at the meeting on Monday night.  The petition has been circulating since April and was a point of controversy in the recent council election campaigns.

According to the town attorney, the town clerk certified “369 valid signatures of qualified ...

Vehicular Homicide Charges for Driver of Paramus School Bus

May 25, 2018

MORRISTOWN, NJ - The driver of a school bus involved in a crash on Route 80 last week that killed two people faces two counts of second-degree vehicular homicide/death by auto, it was announced today.

The driver, Hudy Muldrow, 77, of Woodland Park, attempted to make an illegal U-Turn on the highway in an attempt to find his way to Waterloo Village, the planned destination of the bus that was ...

Sneak Peek! Highly Desirable Lake Mohawk 3BR

Longing to live the lake lifestyle? Today's your lucky day! Take a sneak peek at our newest home available in Sparta's highly desirable Lake Mohawk community, and get ready for our OPEN HOUSE Saturday, June 2nd from 1pm-3pm.

This 3 bedroom, 2 bath home at 137 Hillside Road, Sparta, features a wood burning insert in the living room fireplace, perfect ...

Why You Should Buy Your NJ Home Before Interest Rates Rise

Interest rates for a 30-year fixed rate mortgage climbed from 3.95% in the first week of January up to 4.61% last week, marking a 7-year high according to Freddie Mac. Many factors fueled the current pace of acceleration.  Sam Khater, Freddie Mac’s Chief Economist, opines:

“Healthy consumer spending and higher commodity prices spooked bond markets and led to higher mortgage ...

Is Your First Home Within Your Grasp Now?

 

Bottom Line


According to the US Census Bureau, ‘millennials’ are defined as 18-36-year-olds.


According to NAR’s latest Profile of Home Buyers & Sellers, the median age of all first-time home buyers is 32.


More and more ‘old millennials’ (25-36) now realize homeownership is within their grasp now!

Are YOU ready for ...

Find Your Dream Home During Our DOUBLE Open House Weekend!

The forecast for this weekend is rain, rain, and more rain---so why not spend your time touring your new home?  Team Nest Builder offers 2 wonderful Open Houses this weekend, PLUS a new listing for you to check out via video tour!

27 Hilltop Trail, Sparta

Step into your own fairytale with this Lake Mohawk, storybook-sweet 3-bedroom, 1.5-bathroom gem! Gather in front of the rustic ...

Help Feed Hungry Sussex County Families Through Foodstock

Did you realize food pantry shortages INCREASE during the summer months? Decreased donations and increased need due to the summer break from school lunch and breakfast programs leave many Sussex County families hungry.  

Enter Foodstock:  an annual spring countywide food drive started 15 years ago through the coordinated efforts of Pass it Along, United Way of Northern New Jersey, ...

AtlantiCast

AtlantiCast: Episode 15

On this week’s AtlantiCast, learn some important tips for controlling and avoiding diabetes from an Atlantic Health System expert, see how Atlantic Health is advancing cutting-edge research, hear what’s being done to keep health care environmentally friendly and much more!

 

Sussex County Board of Chosen Freeholders May 9 video

SUSSEX COUNTY, NJ - Video of the Sussex County Board of Chosen Freeholders May 9 meeting. 

 

Enrollment Begins June 2 For Lord Stirling's Summer Riding Lessons

May 26, 2018

BASKING RIDGE, N.J. — The Somerset County Park Commission will be conducting registration for summer horseback riding classes and other seasonal programs at Lord Stirling Stable, located at 256 South Maple Avenue in Basking Ridge, N.J.  

Lessons are offered to juniors (ages 9-17) and adults, and will accommodate first-time beginners through more advanced levels with jumping ...