Letters to the Editor

Public Statement by the Sparta Board of Education

7f4f5aaf169f27e44782_boe_14-15__3_.jpg
Credits: Jennifer Dericks
7f4f5aaf169f27e44782_boe_14-15__3_.jpg

On September 11 Brenda Beebe, a member of the Sparta BOE, wrote a letter to the editor published in the Sparta Independent entitled “Conducting business behind closed doors”.   This letter was presented under the caveat of being the opinions of Ms. Beebe and not that of the Sparta Board of Education.  This is an accurate and inaccurate statement.  It is accurate in that this was not the opinion of the Sparta Board of Education as that can only be done when the board majority votes to make such a statement.  We believe the statement to be inaccurate in that the opinions espoused in the letter are Ms. Beebe’s as a “Board Member” and not that of a private citizen.   It is our opinion that a private citizen would not be able to express opinions on the operation of the Sparta Board of Education nor explicitly infer that the Board is “conducting business behind closed doors”. 

 

This statement by the majority of the Sparta Board of Education is to clarify certain (but not all) of the assertions in the letter and to publicly refute Ms. Beebe’s allegations.  Issues that the Sparta Board of Education is of the opinion require a rebuttal are as follows:

Sign Up for E-News

 

1.The letter commences that “The importance of the email(s) discussed at the August 25 meeting should not be focused on one sentence rather than on the email as a whole.”  Ms. Beebe is correct and the discussion at the August 25 Board meeting did focus on the entire email.  The Board members did express their offense to the personal and professional attack in that one sentence from the email sent by Ms. Beebe and Ms. Yeomans which states  “Frankly, we are dumbfounded by the board’s willingness to shirk the important responsibility of goal setting and monitoring”.  Board members then did address the 6 points outlined as problematic in the e-mail related to the proposed goal.  The first 3 points stated that the State (NJ) did not provide disaggregated data.  These points were shown to be inaccurate as the information is available in the published NJ state score cards and has been since 2002 with the passage of the No Child Left Behind Act.  

Point 4 which states that the goal(s) “do not allow us to gauge our district’s improvement from one year to the next” is inaccurate.  The monitoring of performance will allow us to gauge improvement.  The measurement of the goal is to “benchmark” the Sparta school district to other comparable high performing school districts.  The purpose of selecting this goal (which is identical to the goal for the 2013/2014 school year adopted by the board in [October] 2013) is to measure our performance against these comparable districts and “eliminate” variations that would occur with the changes that were forthcoming from changing (1) curriculum to Common Core Standards, and (2) implementation of PARCC from NJ Ask. 

Point 5 stated that new reports make meaningful comparisons difficult from year to year with the assertion that this is a result of the state now annually assigning peer groups reducing the number of districts for comparison.  This is a true statement, however, all of the information is available from the state report card to make such an analysis.

Lastly, point 6 states that “These Goals do not provide a fixed target, nor do they define the amount of improvement necessary to attain the goal.”  Although this is an accurate statement , the rationale this year,  as it was last year, was to establish a measurable goal (benchmarking to other high performing school districts) by allowing an “apples to apples” comparison.  This then eliminates the vagaries that will occur with the change to Common Core and PARCC.  Assigning “fixed targets” would in fact be wholly meaningless as it would not be possible to dissect test scores to evaluate any change (positive or negative) to ascertain what is related to student performance and what is the resulted impact of the changes in curriculum and the test scoring format.

 

1.The statement that “I will not be drawn into responding to personal attacks” infers that board members attacked Ms. Beebe.  No board member attacked either Ms. Beebe’s or Ms. Yeomans’ personal or professional integrity.  Board members did respond on what they felt were attacks on their integrity because they disagreed with Ms. Beebe’s and Ms. Yeomans’ views and inaccurate assertions related to the deficiency of the board goals as discussed in Point (1).

 

2. The third paragraph of the letter is wholly contradictory.  The first statement is that “The annual goal setting session was held on July 14 was facilitated by NJSBA field service representative.”  This is correct and it is the same process used in the prior year.  The field rep from NJSBA did facilitate the meeting by providing all board members their self-evaluations and commentary on both the district and the board performance thus identifying the “common issues” expressed by the individual board members. 

The next four hours were spent discussing these issues, scribing all of the raised items and finally reducing the number of issues to a manageable number.  The recommendation was to have 3-5 goals for both the district and the board. 

The statement that Ms. Beebe made when she said “These goals were not drafted, developed or discussed by the BOE, yet the BOE was asked to approve them” contradicts her statement when she admitted that the goal setting session was facilitated.  The facilitator wrote the board members’ input on the poster paper at the easel.  He was simply scripting the ideas of the board and after the July 14 meeting we received the “formal” written document from the facilitator who compiled the information.

 

3.In the third paragraph of Ms. Beebe’s letter, she references an e-mail sent out to the board of education members by the administration on Aug. 20 suggesting that the first two goals be changed.  This is not a totally accurate statement.  The academic goals of increasing student achievement were not changed.

Since the board was having difficulty in determining how to measure the two academic goals, our professionals made a recommendation of using the PARCC assessment in comparison to our peer/comparable school districts.  Ms. Beebe fails to provide the context in which the administration proposed modifications to these two goals.

At the August 18 work session of the board of education, concerns were raised that the goals, as summarized by the NJSBA rep, failed to disaggregate between general education and special education students and the issues related to using common assessments as the benchmark.

Discussion ensued by board members at this meeting, including the fact that at the July 14 goal setting meeting, the board could and should consider whether to have one or two goals disaggregating general education and special education students.  After discussion, and consensus by the board majority,  the administration did send out a suggested modification regarding the assessment and measurement of the goals.

Also stated in the third paragraph of the letter, Ms. Beebe said “One of my concerns is that the proposed goals fail to monitor student achievement for all students leaving out grades K-2 and 12.  I was unable to even bring this up for discussion because the goals discussion was shut down and we were told to vote.”  This statement is inaccurate as Ms. Beebe did raise this and replies were given that this has always been the case as under NJ ASK (or its successor PARCC), these grades are not tested.

  

4. In the last paragraph Ms. Beebe stated “…it helps to facilitate discussion by notifying board members beforehand of questions and concerns for them to consider…”  Purportedly this is in reference to the e-mail sent by both Ms. Beebe and Ms.Yeomans at 11:01 a.m. on the 25 August, the day of the board meeting for discussion at the board meeting beginning at 6:30 that evening.  There was not sufficient time for the board members to review and analyze the e-mail before the board meeting.

 

5.     Additionally, the administrators who are required participants in the discussion were not privy to this e-mail, thereby denying them the ability to adequately prepare to address the concerns of both Ms. Beebe and Ms. Yeomans.  It is the opinion of the board majority that this is disingenuous and was not designed to allow board members time to properly digest issues that were raised at the August 18 work session.  If this was the case, there was an entire week prior in which this e-mail could have been sent.   

6.     In the last sentence, Ms. Beebe states “In my opinion, I feel conducting business behind closed doors undermines the integrity of the BOE with the public.”  The only conclusion that a reasonable person/board member can reach is that Ms. Beebe is accusing all board members (or an undisclosed subset therein) of conducting board business in violation of the Open Public Meetings Act.  She provides no evidence or examples that this has or is occurring.  It is counterproductive for Ms. Beebe to make such statements which allege misconduct, and impugns other board members’ personal and professional integrity, simply because she disagrees with the decision of the majority of the board.  All board member comments, including those from Ms. Beebe are always considered before final decisions are made on any issues by the board.

 

 

This statement has been read, discussed and will be voted on by the Sparta Board of Education at the September 22, 2014 BOE meeting.

Editor’s note: The letter was read, discussed and approved.

 

 

The opinions expressed herein are the writer's alone, and do not reflect the opinions of TAPinto.net or anyone who works for TAPinto.net. TAPinto.net is not responsible for the accuracy of any of the information supplied by the writer. Click here to submit a Letter to the Editor.

TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Be Interested In

Sign Up for E-News

Sparta

Sparta Police: Drunk Brooklyn Man Asks Police to Shoot Him

May 20, 2018

SPARTA, NJ – A Brooklyn man was taken for observation when he asked police to shoot him after having crashed his car down an embankment on County Road 517 near the Sparta Middle School.  On May 17 around 2:06 a.m. Sparta Police Officers Brian Porter and Timothy Lynott found Joshua Lindland of Brooklyn asleep in the driver’s seat of a gray Audi against a tree, police ...

Sparta Police: Passengers Face Drug Charges in Traffic Stop

SPARTA, NJ – Two Wantage women face drug charges after the car they were in was stopped for a broken headlight on Route 15.  On May 5 around 2 p.m. Sparta Police Officer Ben Griffin pulled over Alex Torres, 22, driving a white Honda Accord with two passengers, police say.

The officer saw a metal marijuana grinder behind the driver’s seat.  The car and ...

JCP&L Latest Information, Free Ice and Water

SUSSEX COUNTY, NJ – As of 8:47 p.m. JCP&L is reporting 12,745 customers or 22.11 percent, are without power in Sussex County.  In Sparta 2749 or 32 percent remain in the dark.

JCP&L said they anticipate the “vast majority of the remaining customers to be restored to service by late Thursday.”

JCP&L customers without power can get ice and water ...

Republican Party Values

May 21, 2018

Campaigns are interesting things.

Throughout the process, my opponents' supporters have labeled me a "political prostitute", "pimping" a message as a "spokesperson". I've been in a public meeting when referred to as a "lackey" who 
"belongs in a cage like the animal you are".

It's been said directly to me by a ...

Ethical Or Political Stunt

On May 9th Sussex County Freeholder Director Jonathon Rose announced formation of the Sussex County Transparency Committee. A committee established to monitor the ethics of County politicians.  

Alarming is what was left out of this announcement. Besides naming the dynamic duo Lazzaro and Graham, two other names show cause for curiosity. Jonathon never acknowledged, nor did he ...

Upcoming Events

Carousel_image_fd1cdb2a28e320db4cdd_img_7405

Thu, May 24, 6:00 PM

Sparta High School Media Center, Sparta

Sparta High School Art Gala

Arts & Entertainment

Carousel_image_6f4ecc7e007a7b295623_farmers_market

Sat, May 26, 9:00 AM

Sparta Health and Wellness parking lot, Sparta

Sparta Farmers Market

Carousel_image_eda4582229827b1fe4f5_img_7405

Sat, May 26, 11:00 AM

Sparta High School Media Center, Sparta

Sparta High School Art Gala

Arts & Entertainment

Sun, May 27, 1:00 PM

Van Kirk Homestead Museum, Sparta

Life Along the Wallkil River

Education

Carousel_image_6f4ecc7e007a7b295623_farmers_market

Sat, June 2, 9:00 AM

Sparta Health and Wellness parking lot, Sparta

Sparta Farmers Market

Carousel_image_6f4ecc7e007a7b295623_farmers_market

Sat, June 9, 9:00 AM

Sparta Health and Wellness parking lot, Sparta

Sparta Farmers Market

Sun, June 10, 1:00 PM

Van Kirk Homestead Museum, Sparta

Life Along the Wallkil River

Education

Carousel_image_6f4ecc7e007a7b295623_farmers_market

Sat, June 16, 9:00 AM

Sparta Health and Wellness parking lot, Sparta

Sparta Farmers Market

Thu, June 21, 2:00 PM

Van Kirk Homestead Museum, Sparta

Summer Afternoon Garden Soiree

Home & Garden

Carousel_image_6f4ecc7e007a7b295623_farmers_market

Sat, June 23, 9:00 AM

Sparta Health and Wellness parking lot, Sparta

Sparta Farmers Market

Newton's Petition to Move Election Certified, Tabled to May 30 by Council

May 15, 2018

NEWTON, NJ—The petition to move elections from May to November was certified by the clerk and presented to the Newton Town Council at the meeting on Monday night.  The petition has been circulating since April and was a point of controversy in the recent council election campaigns.

According to the town attorney, the town clerk certified “369 valid signatures of qualified ...

10-Year Old Boy Battling Cancer Receives Generous Donation From Randolph Hockey Family

May 20, 2018

RANDOLPH, NJ- While the inter-town hockey battles on the ice between Randolph and Roxbury are fierce at every age level, when it comes to real life battles off the ice there is no hesitation to offer help to their neighbor.

Such is the case with a recent gesture of unity and support from the Randolph Varsity hockey team, when they came together to deliver good wishes and ...

Why You Should Buy Your NJ Home Before Interest Rates Rise

Interest rates for a 30-year fixed rate mortgage climbed from 3.95% in the first week of January up to 4.61% last week, marking a 7-year high according to Freddie Mac. Many factors fueled the current pace of acceleration.  Sam Khater, Freddie Mac’s Chief Economist, opines:

“Healthy consumer spending and higher commodity prices spooked bond markets and led to higher mortgage ...

Is Your First Home Within Your Grasp Now?

 

Bottom Line


According to the US Census Bureau, ‘millennials’ are defined as 18-36-year-olds.


According to NAR’s latest Profile of Home Buyers & Sellers, the median age of all first-time home buyers is 32.


More and more ‘old millennials’ (25-36) now realize homeownership is within their grasp now!

Are YOU ready for ...

Find Your Dream Home During Our DOUBLE Open House Weekend!

The forecast for this weekend is rain, rain, and more rain---so why not spend your time touring your new home?  Team Nest Builder offers 2 wonderful Open Houses this weekend, PLUS a new listing for you to check out via video tour!

27 Hilltop Trail, Sparta

Step into your own fairytale with this Lake Mohawk, storybook-sweet 3-bedroom, 1.5-bathroom gem! Gather in front of the rustic ...

Help Feed Hungry Sussex County Families Through Foodstock

Did you realize food pantry shortages INCREASE during the summer months? Decreased donations and increased need due to the summer break from school lunch and breakfast programs leave many Sussex County families hungry.  

Enter Foodstock:  an annual spring countywide food drive started 15 years ago through the coordinated efforts of Pass it Along, United Way of Northern New Jersey, ...

3 Tips for Making Your Home-Ownership Dream a Reality

 

Here's Highlights:


Setting up an automatic savings plan that saves a small amount of every check = one of the best ways to save without thinking much about it.


Living within a budget right now helps you save money for down payments while also paying down other debts holding you back.  What are you willing to cut back on to make your dreams of homeownership ...

AtlantiCast

AtlantiCast: Episode 15

On this week’s AtlantiCast, learn some important tips for controlling and avoiding diabetes from an Atlantic Health System expert, see how Atlantic Health is advancing cutting-edge research, hear what’s being done to keep health care environmentally friendly and much more!

 

Sussex County Board of Chosen Freeholders May 9 video

SUSSEX COUNTY, NJ - Video of the Sussex County Board of Chosen Freeholders May 9 meeting. 

 

SURVIVING A STROKE: Quick Medical Response Gives Mom Her Life Back

Carotid artery dissection. It’s one of the most common causes of stroke in younger adults.

And while you might not associate the word “stroke” with younger patients, the condition – if not treated immediately – could lead to paralysis and even death.

Lindsey Singh can attest to the importance of immediacy. The 31-year-old mother of two from Flanders experienced ...

Newton Town Pool Registration is Open

May 23, 2018

NEWTON, NJ – Memberships are available for the Newton Town Pool for the 2018 summer season. 

The Newton Town Pool has two water slides, a fully enclosed kiddie pool with walk-in entry, a grass picnic area, a picnic pavilion, lounge chairs, large pool umbrellas, snack stand, updated change rooms and an ADA lift.

The pool will be open June 25 through August 26.  Open swim ...