Superintendent Dennis Tobin's Response: Dept. of Education Commissioner Denies NJSIAA Football and Wrestling Changes



In a letter to NJSIAA Executive Director Steven Timko, dated Dec 28, Department of Education Commissioner David Hespe rejected two ballot initiatives approved by NJSIAA members earlier this month.  The proposed changes to high school football and wrestling would have separated public and non-public schools.

The ballots garnered wide approval from the member Athletic Directors and Principals at the Dec 7 NJSIAA annual business meeting.  The vote was 215-128 to create a non-public football conference and 216-121 to separate the state wrestling tournament.

Sparta School District Superinendent Dennis Tobin's response to Hespe's letter:

Sign Up for E-News

I would like to preface my comments/statement on two things.  First, none of my comments are targeted at any one parochial school, as this is a long standing state problem and not a local one.  Two, although they are my personal opinions and comments, they are based on forty years of experience as a former high school student-athlete, varsity basketball coach, building and district administrator, and father of three student-athletes. My opinions are also shared by the majority of high school coaches, athletic directors, and principals as evident by the most recent state vote on realigning the football and wrestling conferences for 2016-2017.

Although I respect Commissioner Hespe's ruling, as it is a big decision placed on one person that effects so many people in New Jersey athletics, I am disappointed he has chosen to overturn the vote made by a large majority of school administrators.  The NJDOE and NJSIAA have acknowledged that state athletic issues exists, most notably concerns related to competitive balance, but have failed to come up with a resolution to address this long standing problem.

The fact remains that public schools and non-public schools build their athletic programs in vastly different ways.  Public schools work closely with their township feeder programs and rely on developing student-athletes and high school programs within a township, while non-public schools have student-athletes participate in their programs from townships all over the state, and in some instances out-of-state and from other countries.  Some folks, including the media, like to use the phrase that private schools ‘attract’ student-athletes to their programs, which to some degree may be true. However, it is my belief and that of many others, that a large number of the so-called ‘blue chip athletes’ are recruited to play at certain parochial athletic programs.  Some of these athletes are housed with host families, as well as being provided assistance with school tuition and sometimes transportation.  Yes, I am very well aware of how to do all this within the established rules and guidelines.

Another major problem that exists in New Jersey high school athletics is student-athletes continuously transferring from one school to another, often not sitting out any time at their new school as per NJSIAA rules. This occurs because students simply change their legal residency by living with a relative or host family.  There have been some athletes who have played a fall sport at one school and another sport (winter or spring) at another school within the same school year without sitting out one game.  This happens more frequently then it should and the NJSIAA depends too much on public schools monitoring this issue rather than placing that responsibility with the state organization.

My personal issue with these long standing state athletic issues is that they have prevented public school programs and student-athletes from competing on a fair playing field for league championships and individual conference player recognition.  I will say this as a former coach in our district; if I were able to have a roster of our Sparta ‘blue chip’ players and surround them with a few other ‘blue chip’ players from other townships I would feel pretty confident that we would be a very successful program year in and year out. 

That being said, I would not trade my personal experience of working with parents, students, and athletes from one township for any of the other options. It is gratifying to develop community pride through successful student programs whether that be academic, athletics, music or the arts. My dissatisfaction with the progress in finding a solution for these issues does not in any way detract from the pride I feel for our Sparta athletic program.

I think most people will acknowledge that there are issues within the state regarding competitive balance among private and public school athletic programs.  It is time for developing and implementing a solution.


This monthly column will provide an opportunity for the Sparta School DIstrict's administrative staff to cover various educational topics and issues.  This news column will also be a useful tool in sharing information about decisions made by the school district as well as general educational matters.

The opinions expressed herein are the writer's alone, and do not reflect the opinions of or anyone who works for is not responsible for the accuracy of any of the information supplied by the writer.

TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Be Interested In

Sign Up for E-News


Sparta Police: No Seatbelt Stop Leads to Drug Arrest

July 21, 2018

SPARTA, NJ –A Newark man is facing drug charges after a traffic stop on Route 15 north.  On July 18 around 11:15 a.m. Cpl. Marc Rubino stopped a white Acura because the driver Ishmel Graham was not wearing his seatbelt according to police.

When the officer spoke with the 21-year-old Rubino smelled marijuana.  Graham told Rubino he had pot in the car police report.

When ...

Sparta Police: Wanted Man Gets Additional Charges

SPARTA, NJ -  A man from Hackettstown with an active warrant faces additional charges when officers stopped him because the registered owner of the car had a suspended license.  On July 2 around 2 a.m. Police Officer Ericks Finley stopped a car registered to Shanicqui Nelson on Route 15 police said.

The driver Shaun Reid, 36 was also found to have a suspended license and an ...

Sparta Police: Road Rage and Racing on Route 15 End in Arrest

SPARTA, NJ – A man from Plainfield was stopped for racing on Route 15, going 93 MPH in a 55 MPH zone.  Sparta Police Officer Erick Finley was able to stop one of  two cars racing on July 6 around 11:45 p.m. police said.

Driving a four door Chevy, Santos Vides-Guardado, 21, told Finley that he and the other driver had gotten into an argument that led to the two men racing each ...

Why Did Freeholders Reject Dr. Howard Burrell's Nomination to SCCC Trustee?

July 21, 2018


Outgoing Freeholder Director Jonathan Rose announced on Facebook that Howard Burrell was deemed “not acceptable” by the Sussex County freeholder board to serve as trustee of Sussex County Community College. 

Why did the freeholders decide that Dr. Burrell is “not acceptable?" After all, the freeholders’ own search committee nominated Dr. Burrell to ...

No Dog Beach on Lake Hopatcong?

Hello Editor, 
 I have spent considerable time trying to find somewhere on Lake Hopatcong to bring my dog for a swim.
What I have found is ridiculous - this lake has approximately 28 miles of shoreline and I found NO PLACE am allowed to bring him.  Am hoping you can make the public aware and maybe someone will know more than me and inform where dogs are allowed?
Many thanks for ...

Upcoming Events


Mon, July 23, 10:00 AM

Sparta Public Library, Sparta

Watercolor Workshop

Arts & Entertainment

Tue, July 24, 7:00 PM

Kinnelon Public Library, Kinnelon

Northern NJ Libertarian Party Monthly Meeting



Tue, July 24, 7:30 PM

Town Hall, Sparta

Sparta Township Council Meeting



Fri, July 27, 10:00 AM

Sparta Public Library, Sparta

Watercolor Workshop

Arts & Entertainment


Sat, July 28, 8:00 AM

Newton Moose Lodge, Fredon

Newton Moose Lodge Sunday Breakfasts

Food & Drink


Sat, July 28, 9:00 AM

Sparta Health and Wellness parking lot, Sparta

Sparta Farmers Market


Sat, July 28, 2:00 PM

Montville Animal Shelter, Montville

Summer Adoption Event at the Montville Animal ...

Home & Garden Other


Sat, August 4, 8:00 AM

Newton Moose Lodge, Fredon

Newton Moose Lodge Sunday Breakfasts

Food & Drink


Sat, August 4, 9:00 AM

Sparta Health and Wellness parking lot, Sparta

Sparta Farmers Market


Tue, August 7, 12:00 PM

MAYO Performing Arts Center, Morristown

The Power of Nine - Fine Art Exhibit by the ...

Arts & Entertainment

Newton High School FFA Students Dominate at State Convention

July 11, 2018

LONG BRANCH, NJ - The Newton FFA Chapter won several of their events at the 89th New Jersey State FFA Convention in May at Monmouth University. The students brought home several awards competing against the best in the state.

Freshman Kirk Avondoglio took first place in the state FFA Creed Public Speaking competition.  The event requires participants to recite the creed in front of a ...

US Junior Amateur: Chinn Earns Medalist and Top-seed honors, Misses Rain Delay, after Second Day of Stroke Play

July 18, 2018

Tuesday’s Second Round Scores, playoff participants (8 for 3 spots)

Wednesday’s Round of 64 matchups

SPRINGFIELD, NJ - Kelly Chinn of Great Falls, Va., continued his stellar play Tuesday morning and missed an afternoon four plus hour rain delay on arguably Baltusrol Golf Club’s toughest layout, the Lower Course.

After shooting a five under 66 on the Upper Course Monday, ...


July 22, 2018


Our rescue group needs more foster families, would you like to help us?

 Furever Home Dog Rescue needs foster homes!  As a shelterless rescue, we don’t have a building where our dogs are housed until they get adopted.  We are lucky enough to have loving foster families who open their hearts and homes to our dogs until they are placed. However, ...

What You Need to Know About the Mortgage Process


Many buyers are purchasing a home with a down payment as little as 3%.

You may already qualify for a loan, even if you don’t have perfect credit.

Take advantage of the knowledge of your local professionals who are there to help you determine how much you can afford.  This means call Team Nest Builder’s Lynn Garafola at 973-222-3777 ...

You DO NOT Need 20% Down to Buy Your Home NOW!

The Aspiring Home Buyers Profile from the National Association of Realtors (NAR) found that the American public is still somewhat confused about what’s required to qualify for a home mortgage loan in today’s housing market. The results of the survey show the main reason non-homeowners do not own their own homes is because they believe that they cannot afford them.

This brings us to ...

Get Rid of Your E-Waste This Saturday in Sussex County

Team Nest Builder knows it’s easy for e-waste---tv sets, printers, laptops, etc.--to pile up. Here’s your opportunity to rid yourself of it in Sussex County! It’s the Sussex County Municipal Utilities Authority E-Waste Collection Event! The scoop:


Saturday, July 21st


7 am - 2 pm


Up to 5 Units per vehicle at no charge.  Scale charges for ...

4 Top Tips for Kitchen Remodels

Getting ready to remodel your New Jersey home's kitchen? Team Nest Builder shares these top 4 tips for maintaining your sanity (and budget)!

Expect the Unexpected

Even the best-laid plans go awry during a kitchen remodel--be prepared!  Add a 10% cushion to your finanical plan for problems that may arise. In case something happens, this could save your time and budget.

Make A ...

Get Out and Garden During FREE Open Gates Weekend

Team Nest Builder wants you to discover the beauty and diversity of Morris County’s Community Gardens through the people, plants, and planting techniques that make gardens thrive. It's Morris County Community Garden FREE Open Gates Weekend!

Tour the many gardens, discover how to start one in your town, and learn more about growing your own food. Enjoy food tastings and demonstrations ...

Be a Triathlon Volunteer!

Summertime is here and upon us Sparta residents, bringing a variety of exciting events to our area. Well, Pass It Along is BACK with the 9th Annual Triathlon at Lake Mohawk Country Club, located in Sparta, on Saturday, July 28, 2018!

This athletic event draws in several hundred people, both participants and spectators, to Lake Mohawk. Volunteers are needed to assist with the event in ...


AtlantiCast: Episode 18

On this week’s AtlantiCast, you’ll find out how accessing care at Atlantic Health System is now easier, more affordable and closer to home than ever, learn which item from the produce aisle could be the newest weapon against cancer, see what Atlantic Health System, the New York Times and Instagram all have in common and much more.



The Sussex County Freeholders July 11 meeting video

NEWTON, NJ - The Sussex County Freeholders July 11 meeting video


Register for Fall Flag Football

July 22, 2018

Registration is open for Sparta Spartan Youth Football flag football now through August 1.

They are offering co-ed teams kindergarten through grade 12.  

5 vs 5 Co-Ed flag football kindergarten through grade 8

Recreational high school program that is "make your own team" with a customizable schedule.  All games are played at ...