Sussex County Freeholders Move May Thwart Sparta's Departure from County Health Services

Credits: Jennifer Dericks
Credits: Jennifer Dericks

SPARTA, NJ - Sparta Township Council members were dealt a surprise at their last meeting on Tuesday, April 25 from the Sussex County Board of Chosen Freeholders.  In a press release distributed late  Tuesday, Freeholders announced they intended to restructure the county taxes, eliminating the Sussex County Health Tax, folding it into the general County Tax. 

The shuffling of budget categories appears to be an effort to thwart Sparta's withdrawal from the county health plan. 

The Sparta Township Council, township manager and others have been working on the initiative to withdraw from the Sussex County Health department for more than a year.  According to Sparta Township Manager William Close, Sparta had extended the deadline of the township’s withdrawal from the County Health Department to the end of May. 

Sign Up for E-News

"This action was confirmed with the new [Sussex] County Administrator to ensure that there was no interruption in service to the residents and businesses of the township," Close said.

"The township has made multiple attempts to get a meeting together with the county over the past seven weeks, but for whatever reason it never occurred," Close said. Sparta expected the freeholders to "gather information to present to the municipality" explaining the services Sparta received and the costs Sparta incurred.    

According to the freeholders’ statement they initially planned to eliminate the County Health Tax over two years.  They anticipated taking that extended time to implement the change that would incorporate the revenue as well as the expenses into the general County Tax Levy.  The state, however, required the change be done in one year, according to the freeholders. 

Therein lies the problem for Sparta. The change by the freeholders potentially eliminates the savings derived from withdrawing from the county health department.  Rather, if Sparta township went ahead with the planned divorce from the County Health Services, the taxpayers of Sparta would face additional taxes to cover the plan to reinstate an autonomous Sparta Health Services department. 

The county’s Introduced 2017 Budget "contemplated the partial dissolution of the Heath Tax accounting for mandated services... under the County Environmental Health Act."

The freeholders said they had been advised by the New Jersey State Division of Local Government Services that they would be required to make the change in one year, not two. What was anticipated to be dealt with in the 2017 and 2018 budgets was pushed ahead by the freeholders to take effect within a matter of days. 

The freeholders said the dissolution of the County Health Tax would "result in no net change to the tax payer as the general County Tax and the County Health Tax [previously] billed separately would now be billed as one."

Mayor Gil Gibbs presented a statement at the Freeholders Budget Hearing on April 26 on behalf of the Township Council.  He said the notification of abolishing the Health Tax was not in keeping with the notification sent by acting county administrator Ron Tappan dated March 17 that read, in part, in an effort to better serve all municipalities they would be isolating the cost of Title 26 services.

Gibbs said, “Now you are seeking to eliminate an identifiable, quantifiable budget expense item. This would further obscure how the health tax is being reported relative to the services received for each municipality.”

He wanted to know “what changed in the past four weeks that led to this significant change.”

Gibbs said Sparta had met with the freeholders to get an understanding of the health services costs so they could understand the options for their residents. 

“You are unilaterally changing the budget without meeting with Sparta or providing information previously requested,” to allow for a thoughtful decision.

Sparta had been working on a hybrid solution to provide health services according to the township Chief Financial Officer Sam Rome in a previous interview.  Some of the services were due to be contracted out while others were to be handled by Sparta employees.

Seeking to gain more oversight of the services, Sparta anticipated having better control of costs as well as the number and quality of services provided Rome explained. 

 “Sparta started looking at performance and the cost of health services,” Gibbs said. 

Gibbs asked to have the proposal tabled and have the freeholders meet with each municipality before the change is implemented.  “These actions seem to be preemptive in nature,” Gibbs said. He said this change “precludes accountability and competition,”

Deputy Mayor Josh Hertzberg commented at the end of the meeting.  He began by saying he took exception to a statement made by Freeholder Phil Crabb that Sparta’s resolution [to withdraw] was a shot across the bow.  “That’s not fair.”

Crabb said it was “an extraordinary action.”

Hertzberg said it was not extraordinary because Sparta was working with the county for two years.  “Frankly, the only reason we waited [to withdraw] was because Mr. Graham and Mrs. Petillo implored us to give them four weeks to present a proposal to get us to stay.  It’s been seven weeks,” and Sparta had not gotten the response promised. 

Graham said that was “not true that calls had been made to Manager Close and he was away and then there were other things.”  He went on to say he felt Sparta’s resolution was a good thing because it made them take a look at what was going on with the County Health Services.  He said he did not know and “would not have put up with it either.”

Both men admitted things had gotten better with regard to health services in Sparta.  Hertzberg said it had gotten better because of the potential competition.  “The free market allowed for you to say we better get a better product.”

“If you had gotten back to us with the information it would have been better,” than the notification of the budget change. It would have allowed Sparta to make a choice and not be forced to stay, Hertzberg said. 

There was additional back and forth about the timing of the county’s announcement of the “single tier” tax system.  They also discussed the lack of adequate communication having led to a misunderstanding of the services that were in fact being delivered. 

Petillo said, “You can still leave.” 

Graham said, “Even if you’re all in [the county health services] we know what the numbers are now.” 

"We have reached out to the County Administrator looking to schedule another meeting between representatives of the Freeholder Board and the Council to discuss the situation, including the new proposal and anticipate it occurring within the next 10 days," Close said. "Hopefully, this discussion will provide the information necessary for the Council to make a decision on whether to remain with the County as its health services provider or choose another provider."

The video of Sussex County Freeholder April 26 meeting: Gibbs’ comments begin at 29:54, Hertzberg’s comments begin at 2:20:00


TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Be Interested In

Sign Up for E-News


Sparta Police: Speeding Stop Ends with Lost Driver Charged with DWI

June 22, 2018

SPARTA. NJ – A Newark man who thought he was heading to Atlantic City only won a trip to the Sparta Police Department headquarters after being stopped for speeding.  On June 18 around 3 a.m. Cpl. Kurt Morris stopped Manuel Pinheiro, 48, for driving 84 MPH in a 55 MPH zone on Route 15 south, police said.

When Morris spoke with Pinheiro the officer smelled alcohol coming from the ...

Sparta Police: Byram Woman's Broken Light Ends in Drug Charges

SPARTA, NJ – A Byram woman is facing drug charges having been stopped for a broken headlight on White Lake Road.  On June 15 Abigail Carkhuff, 22, was pulled over by Police Officer Brian Porter around 10:40 p.m. police report.

When Porter spoke with Carkhuff the officer smelled marijuana in the car.  A search of the grey Ford Escape turned up a ziplock bag of marijuana and a ...

Sparta Police: Speeding Stop Nets Drug Charges for Two Brooklyn Men

SPARTA, NJ – Two men from Brooklyn, New York stopped for speeding are facing drug charges.  On June 16 around 11 a.m. Sparta Police Officer Thomas Herd pulled over a grey Toyota Rav4 driven by David Mai, 20 going 95 MPH in a 55 MPH zone, police said.

When Herd spoke with the Mai, the officer smelled marijuana in the car. Mai said he had pot in his backpack.  Sparta Police ...

Sparta High School Time Capsule

June 20, 2018

To the editor: 

For this year’s AP project in our English class, we have put together a 2018 Sparta High School time capsule to be opened in 25 years. The capsule, likely to be buried next to the garden behind the school, will contain student testimonies, memes, and other relics of our time. Hopefully with this project we hope to preserve our unique experience of teenage ...

The Power of Positive Engagement

To the Editor:

I wanted to share this letter from Laurie Beacham, Media Director for NJ 11th for Change, about the notable increase in voter turnout and citizens deciding to run in the recent primary election:

"The 11th Congressional District has a lot to be proud of. In the June 5th primaries, voter turnout climbed from almost 33,000 in 2014 to over 86,000. Democratic ...

Upcoming Events


Sat, June 23, 9:00 AM

Sparta Health and Wellness parking lot, Sparta

Sparta Farmers Market

Sat, June 23, 10:00 AM

CASA of Morris and Sussex Counties, Morristown

CASA Information Session

Sat, June 23, 10:00 AM

Vasa Park, Hackettstown

Midsommar at Vasa Park

Arts & Entertainment

Sun, June 24, 1:00 PM

Van Kirk Homestead Museum, Sparta

Life Along the Wallkil River



Mon, June 25, 5:30 PM

Mohawk Avenue School, Sparta

Sparta Board of Education Meeting UPDATED



Sat, June 30, 9:00 AM

Sparta Health and Wellness parking lot, Sparta

Sparta Farmers Market


Sat, July 7, 9:00 AM

Sparta Health and Wellness parking lot, Sparta

Sparta Farmers Market


Sun, July 8, 1:00 PM

Van Kirk Homestead Museum, Sparta

Sussex County Views: The Art of Toni Chaplin

Home & Garden


Sun, July 8, 1:00 PM

Van Kirk Homestead Museum, Sparta

Sussex County Views: The Art of Toni Chaplin

Arts & Entertainment

Sussex Stags Football Team to Hold Fourth Annual Golf Outing

June 16, 2018

NEWTON, NJ—The Sussex County Stags will be holding their fourth annual gold outing on Saturday June 23.

Arrival time is 11:30 a.m. at the Minebrook Golf Club located at 500 Schooleys Mountain Road in Hackettstown. Golfing will begin at 1 p.m. and tickets can be purchased online at

Tickets are $125 per person and include the following: golfing, the cart, an all you ...

Update: Police Break Up Fight Involving 40-50 People at Bridgewater Commons Mall

June 15, 2018

BRIDGEWATER, NJ — No injuries have been reported in an incident that shut down Bridgewater Commons Mall Thursday evening after a fight involving a crowd of 40-50 people.

Police are still investigating unconfirmed reports of shots being fired, according to the Somerset County Prosecutor's Office.

The mall is closed for the evening as the investigation continues.

Somerset County ...

5 Home-Related To-Do’s Before Leaving On Vacation

With school out and the summer sun shining down, thoughts turn to summer vacation trips.  Team Nest Builder offers these 5 home-related tips to follow to avoid everything from minor inconveniences to major headaches upon your return:

Pause Your Post & Paper

Piled up mail and newspapers act like a “rob me” sign!  Avoid tipping off strangers to your absence by ...

Why Buying a Home is Better Than Renting

People often ask if now is a good time to buy a home in New Jersey, but nobody ever asks whether or not it’s a good time to rent. Regardless, Team Nest Builder wants to make certain that everyone understands that now is NOT a good time to rent.

The Census Bureau recently released their 2018 first quarter median rent numbers. This graph from their report shows rent increases from 1988 ...

5 Fab Father's Day Happenings in Sussex & Morris Counties

Father’s Day hits this Sunday--what do YOU have planned? Team Nest Builder offers a slew of Father’s Day fun in Morris and Sussex County. Read on and surprise Dad with cool activities! (Be sure to check if registration is required prior to showing up!)

Alstede Farms' Father's Day Brunch – Chester

From 9am-noon, take a scenic hayride to a brunch buffet that offers ...

Don't Miss Sunday's OPEN HOUSE for 4BR Sparta Mountain Beauty

Perched handsomely on an acre in the beautiful SpartaMountain community, 28 Waters Edgeoffers a 4BR 2.5 Bathroom home with space and style. Come see for yourself this Sunday, June 17th, from 1-3pm at our OPEN HOUSE!

Located in the prestigious Sparta Mountain Reserve, this large, beautiful center hall colonial with open floor plan has a nice, level play yard with direct ...

Days on The Housing Market Drops to New Low

According to recently released data from the National Association of Realtors (NAR), the median number of days that a home spent on the market hit a new low of 26 days in April, as 57% of homes remained on the market for under a month.

NAR’s Chief Economist, Lawrence Yun, opined,

“What is available for sale is going under contract at a rapid pace. Since NAR began tracking this ...

Pass It Along Triathlon

Tri-something new this July and sign up for the Pass It Along Triathlon!

The 9th annual Pass It Along Triathlon will take place on Saturday, July 28, 2018, at the Lake Mohawk Country Club. This triathlon features two USAT-certified courses - Olympic and Sprint. This triathlon has become a Sparta tradition and everyone is welcome to attend to cheer on athletes and be a part of the ...


AtlantiCast Episode 17

On this week’s AtlantiCast, it’s National Men’s Health Month, so check out important health tips for you or the men in your life, learn about groundbreaking research into breast cancer treatment that could mean an end to chemotherapy for some patients, meet a local sports hero who’s living his baseball dreams thanks to Goryeb Children’s Hospital and much ...

June 13 Sussex County Board of Chosen Freeholders meeting

NEWTON, NJ - The June 13 Sussex County Board of Chosen Freeholders meeting video.


Susan G. Komen North Jersey Increases Program Funding by 15% for 2018-2019 and Awards 13 Grants to 11 Local Community Non-Profit Organizations

June 22, 2018

Susan G. Komen North Jersey Increases Program Funding by 15% for 2018-2019

and Awards 13 Grants to 11 Local Community Non-Profit Organizations

June 21, 2018  – Susan G. Komen North Jersey announced that it will award a total of 13 grants to 11 local community non-profit organizations in its nine-county service area for 2018-2019, with an increase in total program funding at 15% ...