Springfield Parents Complain That Administrators, Board Not Answering Their Questions, Complaints About ‘Looping' System in Elementary Schools

Board of Education Credits: Chip Dickson

SPRINGFIELD, NJ—Two township mothers complained to the township’s board of education on Monday that the practice of looping in the district’s elementary schools may force their children to be exposed to possible bullying. They also claimed that school officials were rude to them and insulted them when they inquired about the practice.

Board members, in the meantime, said that scheduling is within the purview of administrators and they would not interfere with this administrative responsibility by setting a board policy regulating looping.

Looping, in education, refers to the practice of a teacher remaining with the same group of students for more than one school year. For example, a teacher who teaches a third grade class and then goes on to teach the same students, the following year, for the fourth grade.

Sign Up for E-News

Prior to opening the floor to public discussion, board president Robin Cornelison said the school body was aware of the concerns within the community, but urged the speakers not to make disparaging statements about staff members, not to refer to individual students and not to engage in debate with those on the podium.

Parent Samantha Kestin said that, while she did not wish to disturb the policy in place for the current school year, it was felt the district “was kind of all over the place where the rules are” and the response to parents raising questions about the practice “has been strong and upsetting and not really okay.”

Kestin added that, if a parent had a question, whether about whether their child was learning properly or about “remaining another year with children who make them cry every day” they shouldn't be placed in a position where placements can’t be changed or “nobody wants to help or figure out a way to help.”

She also said there was a “fine line between bullying and subtle bullying, and children should not be exposed even to subtle bullying.

Parent Sylvia Caggiano complained that, when she made her feelings on looping known, school administrators called her a liar and yelled at her.

Caggiano added that the rules of civility laid down to the public at board meetings should also apply to school officials in their dealings with residents.

She also questioned why Superintendent of Schools Michael A. Davino had refused to meet with parents to address their concerns and why he seemed to have an attitude that it was up to the administration to set the rules and no one should question their decisions.

Caggiano also said Davino’s answer that placement decisions were made “after careful consideration” and were “sound educational decisions” also meant that his decisions could not be questioned.

She added the superintendent did not respond to any of the specific points raised in many emails addressed to him on the situation.

She also called the decision to loop her child’s class “an unmitigated disaster.”

The school board’s attorney replied that Caggiano’s questions that were appropriate had been answered.

She added that decisions made by the administration were in the best interest of the schools and students and the board was not condoning disrespectful behavior from any member of the staff.

The attorney repeated that looping related to scheduling, it was an administrative policy and it was not within the board’s responsibilities to deal with it.






TAP Into Another Town's News:

You May Also Be Interested In

Sign Up for E-News


After 47 Years of Operation, Jade Isle Set to Close Its Doors in Scotch Plains

February 17, 2018

SCOTCH PLAINS, NJ — The iconic Jade Isle Restaurant located at the corner of Terrill Road and Second Street in Scotch Plains will close its doors forever after its last day on  Feb. 18. A phone call to the restaurant on Saturday confirmed that the Jade Isle's long history would come to an end Sunday.

Jade Isle has served a menu of traditional Chinese and Polynesian dishes and ...

Keep Our Local Governments as Clean as Possible

February 14, 2018

Dear Editor:


I read with interest in a local newspaper regarding the Union county democrat party political infighting for their “county chair” selection. There were 2 letters juxtaposed, each one listing supporters of either Senator Scutari or Fanwood Mayor Mahr, who are the two main people vying for the “boss” position.


Although I am a ...

Bob Hugin Announces GOP Candidacy for the U.S. Senate at Springfield Elks Club

February 13, 2018

SPRINGFIELD, NJ – The Elks Club in Springfield on Tuesday was the setting for Bob Hugin of Summit to announce his candidacy as a Republican for the U.S. Senate seat currently held by Democrat Bob Menendez.

The former CEO and Chairman of Celegene, Hugin resigned from the company on February 5 as executive chairman.  The crowd of over 100 was largely enthusiastic party ...

Sixteen at-risk youth celebrate one year of stability and new beginning

February 15, 2018

Young people living within New Jersey's child welfare system face daunting odds – often moving from foster family to group home to support program yet never finding their place, sometimes traveling with their belongings in a plastic garbage bag.

"The analogy is not lost on them," said Tanya Johnson, senior assistant executive director, youth services, at the nonprofit ...

Upcoming Events

Tue, February 20, 6:00 PM

UCEDC, Cranford

Next Level Business Planning

Business & Finance

Wed, February 21, 4:00 PM

Union Public Library, Union

ShopRite Kids Cuisine

Education Food & Drink

Wed, February 21, 6:00 PM

Vauxhall Library, Vauxhall

Club Teen: Painting Class

Arts & Entertainment Education